I've been watching my youtube competitors for a while now. There are certainly a 5 or 6 channels starting in my niche currently. All of them using exactly the same premise, some of them even exactly the same AI voices ...and few of them even copied each other topics.
This whole "demonetization wave" situation i starting to look more and more like a joke to me. Imagine you are a big company, raking millions of dollars and you decided to clean your platform from AI slop - hitting channels that are not an AI slop at all. Podcasts, animation studios, animation channels etc.
Job failed successfully? And now, with all those "free spots" you got another, new sloppy channels, inauthentic as hell, taking places while the rest of us fighting to get their channels back or even lost interest in this nonsensical fight.
With my channel youtube.com/@Otherplace1 I really tried to stand out, got demonetized anyway...and and after months of fighting with @TeamYouTube I finally gave up. Only a few days left till i can re-apply again...but guess what..I can't because I don't have a 10 mil views needed to do it. :) Every day I'm watching those numbers go down. And probably, I will never make it back, because I just don't pop out videos like mine on daily basis. We will see...but this whole situation is making me really frustrated and kinda sad. When you pour your life into something (literally I spend hours after work creating those videos) and then its gone overnight without any reasons, It can break a person :)
Mejra retweeted
I finally got my monetization back after 47 days.
This thread explains exactly what happened,
how posting daily almost backfired on me and almost costed me $1,500 👇
After 58 days of trying to get my channel reviewed, I received another interesting email, completely shattering my hopes once again. I tried to make a meaningful content on this platform instead of spitting 5 low effort videos per day to make crazy money and I've been punished for it. I've spend more then a year to build my channel and it's gone like that overnight.
This is what youtube is considering inauthentic. Without any warning or time to fix whatever they want (I still don't know for sure) they decided to just demonetize all the channels around youtube.
My vid:
youtube.com/shorts/5a-u_yP3c…
My channel is verified, proved authentic by their other systems...already had a personality through my own animations, mascot and humor and its tied to a personal google account that is very old. Still demonetized... This is how they treat their partners. :)
@TeamYouTube @YouTubeCreators @YouTube
Hi @TeamYouTube, you publicly told me you would review my channel and get back to me as soon as possible, but then in DM you told me to disregard that message and go back to an email thread with Creator Support where they simply aren’t responding anymore.
After losing monetization on 3 channels, this is extremely stressful. Can someone please actually look into this instead of sending me in circles?
All those channels back in YPP makes me at least a little bit happy! Congrats to all. I'm still sitting on basically dead channel now while subscribers leaving in masses :( But there is a spark of hope for me. Maybe, my channel will be next @TeamYouTube ? <3
Mejra retweeted
Hello @TeamYouTube
My case [2-8928000040800] was closed, but the issue remains unresolved. Emails are no longer being answered. All of my videos are original, varied, and manually crafted using Adobe Illustrator. It's not repetitive/mass produced.
@YouTube
@YouTubeCreators
I was completely left in the dust :( After I tried to contact @TeamYouTube for more than a month, I got nothing more than copy pasted bot responses. I proved everything, showed my face, my voice, my processes...still ignored. My 148k channel is basically dying right now...that is a year and a half gone, overnight.
BTW my channel is verified - which means I also prove that I'm a human being, authentic and actually creating all this myself ...which is funny thing to say while looking at my channel, demonetized for being inauthentic. :)
Please @TeamYouTube , can I ask you to look at my channel and review my appeal to resolve this issue?
Channel: youtube.com/@Otherplace1
Day - I don't even know - from demonetization.
@TeamYouTube please, your systems made a mistake and flagged hours and hours of real human work. My channel is basically dead now, subscribers dropping ... but I still wanna continue doing what I love!
Review my channel properly...please.
Channel: youtube.com/@Otherplace1
Thanks!
@YouTubeCreators
Mejra retweeted
140 DAYS DEMONETIZED
Hi Team YouTube, here is my welcome video on YT. I am beyond human, my process is human, my writing is human, my research is human. The stories are human.
I am a mom, a chiropractor, a writer, and someone who is sharing stories in documentary form.
This needs a human review please.
@TeamYouTube @youtubecreators @youtube @nealmohan
Just a friendly reminder to @TeamYouTube to check my channel!
More than a month passed and I'm still demonetized which feels like a mistake :(
Please, only a few minutes of your time. Thank you!
youtube.com/@Otherplace1
Hello @TeamYouTube - over a month I've been demonetized by mistake, putting my whole channel I've worked hard in risk, as well as my whole life situation.
I really worked hard to provide my audience a meaningful experience on youtube providing a manually animated videos with original stories and facts. Your demonetization really stopped everything in place. I was one video away of being monetized and possibly providing my family a much needed additional income. You also forces me to show my face in public, even though I'm not comfortable of doing so.
As you can see on the attached video, my channel is really hand crafted and no AI on this planet can replicate what we create in software like Adobe After Effects. It's obvious that my content is not mass produced and its original. All I'm asking is a few minutes from someone in your review team (a human being).
Thank you @TeamYouTube @YouTubeCreators @YouTube @nealmohan
Mejra retweeted
Hey @TeamYouTube, I need a human eye here! 🚨
My 8-year-old educational channel was just demonetized.
100% Original: Years of handcrafted 2D animations, infographics, and motion graphics.
The majority of my videos were created long before generative AI even existed. Newer videos only use AI as a tool to enhance my art, the core work is entirely human.
Can we please get a manual review?
Hello @TeamYouTube @YouTubeCreators and @YouTube in general.
Over a month now, I've been trying to get a fair review of my channel - which is fully run by me, from the first line of each script to the last sound effect. I will show you the process in video attached. ⬇️
Instead of focusing on quality content and enjoyable animations, I have to scratch my head and cluelessly thinking about why my channel got demonetized.
Everything you see in my videos is original - originally designed voiceover that you can't hear anywhere else (now I'm even using my own voice), scripts that I'm writing myself, based on what worked for me in the past and animations that simply cannot be done on mass scale. (and I don't even have money for an animator, since my channel was not even monetized through ads!)
I would really appreciate it if a real human reviewer looked at my channel again, because I'm 100% sure I didn’t break any policies or rules. 💔
Thank you @TeamYouTube again and have a better day than me! :)
Congrats to recent re-monetized channels aswell!
@DanAnimation1 @real_Monumental @ridethetiamat @ppaniman36_08 and others!
Mejra retweeted
We are going to sue YouTube
But before we do, our lawyer is currently in the process of sending a letter to YouTube.
Over 2 weeks ago our channel youtube.com/@UnderSparked was falsely demonetized under the "inauthentic content" policy.
Demonetized doesn't mean no ads though, all it means is YouTube will still run ads on the videos. But they pocket all the revenue, essentially stripping all the revenue from us.
We don't claim to be the pinnacle of quality content standards, but the following things do cause us to scratch our heads in confusion
1. All of the bigger channels in the same niche as us are monetized with no issues
2. We literally voice act, edit, etc, all our own videos while 100s of AI storytelling channels are still monetized
3. YouTube is fine with running ads on the videos, pocketing all the revenue. We assume if YouTube had such a big problem with the content, why still serve it to your advertisers?
4. 100s of reaction channels still stay monetized
Some examples of bigger monetized channels that are in the same niche as us are:
rSlash: youtube.com/@rSlash
DarkFluff: youtube.com/@DarkFluff
Oz's Vault: youtube.com/channel/UCoJ1Anu…
We support these channels, the reason we are providing these channels as examples is to showcase how it feels like we're being targeted.
This has caused extreme distress for my team and I. Many of our livelihoods and families rely on this channel. Our community relies on the UnderSparked channel.
Many people support the UnderSparked channel because in a time of nonstop AI channels, we stepped up and used real voice actors to cater to that connection and community that viewers on YouTube crave.
We truly believe this demonetization was done in error, all we want is a real human specialist to help us fix the issue.
We're tired of constantly receiving only copy and pasted templated responses, constantly neglecting/dismissing our attempts at fixing the false demonetization.
We're kindly requesting for a representative from @TeamYouTube to help us fix this demonetization issue with our channel.
We don't want to send letters, or sue, or anything! We simply just want to go back to producing content for our community.
Dear @TeamYouTube @YouTubeCreators,
Since my channel was demonetized, my mental health has hit rock bottom. I’m afraid I won’t be able to make enough money to provide my little kid with what he needs. My whole life depends on this cha.....wait a second…
Do we really need to beg on our knees, make fools of ourselves, and belittle ourselves because your broken AI took away our passion, our meaningful jobs, and our hobbies?
Is this really how you want to treat your creators?
The same creators you praise so much in your posts and public messages?
The creators who are basically one of the main pillars of your business?
Let us create.
Let us grow on your platform, and in return we’ll provide meaningful and entertaining content.
Not all of us are AI slop farms, you know?
I don’t know… this whole thing feels absurd.
Please, can you help smaller creators too? We are basically left in dust now.
Our voices deserve to be heard as well.
Thank you.
@EUparliament @MovieTalkNOW1 @timdanilovhi @kaien @DevenSeenath @Meowbananacat @chrispavlovski @monumental @real_Monumental
Mejra retweeted
🚨YOUTUBE KILLED MY CHANNEL AND MY DREAM. @TeamYouTube
🗓️A month ago, my channel “Ray Docs” was growing faster than I could ever imagine. Videos were reaching 200K+ views in just a few hours. People were smiling, commenting, enjoying the content I spent countless hours creating with passion and care.
📉Now? My latest uploads can barely reach 500 views.
🙋🏼♂️Same creator. Same passion. And even more effort.
The difference is that after the demonetization for “inauthentic content,” I’ve been left completely lost inside a system with no clarity, no transparency, and no real guidance on what is supposedly wrong.
And that confusion slowly destroys your channel.
That’s the most painful part:
Not only did YouTube damage my channel… it damaged my dream project.
“Ray Docs” was never just a channel to me. It was my dream combination of two things I genuinely love:
WWE and content creation.
I know I’m not perfect. I know learning comes through mistakes and growth. That’s part of being a creator. But even then, this situation still feels deeply unfair because my content is 100% original, creatively directed, heavily edited, and built from scratch with real effort and passion.
I truly believe I created something new on this platform. A unique format.
And above all… I only ever wanted to make people smile.
That’s it.
To entertain people.
To bring joy to wrestling fans.
To create something exciting and different.
On top of all this, more than $3,000 of my earnings are currently frozen. According to YouTube’s policies, in around 20 days that money could be gone forever.
And that money was never just about me.
- It helps support my family.
- It helps support my life.
- And even my dog Maggie, who has been next to me through all of this.
It may sound silly to some people, but I genuinely can’t even enjoy buying her treats or little toys anymore because this entire situation has mentally and financially drained me.
🧠For the past month, my mental health has been destroyed.
I barely eat properly.
I can’t focus on my responsibilities.
I wake up stressed every day.
I’ve spent weeks trapped in emails, appeals, and automated responses that explain absolutely nothing.
And despite all this, I still want to stay on YouTube.
I still want to create.
I still want to contribute positively to this platform.
But creators cannot improve when there is no transparency.
Under the EU Digital Services Act (DSA), platforms like YouTube are supposed to provide meaningful explanations and transparent review processes.
Right now, that simply isn’t happening.
Please @TeamYouTube
I’m not asking for special treatment.
I’m just asking for: a real human review, a clear explanations
and a fair chance to keep building the project I love.
Don’t let automated systems destroy genuine creative projects and the people behind them.
Thank you for yout attention @TeamYouTube
Mejra retweeted
🚨 YouTube no longer wants to pay REAL creators.
These automated rejections don't just kill authorship—they kill ANY desire to create high-quality content. Knowing your videos won't even be looked at, and you'll just be automatically blocked, is soul-crushing.
To every creator thinking this won't affect you: you are going to be disappointed.
And if you think a "linked channel" rejection only happens for severe violations like copyright strikes or 18+ content—think again! My only "crime" was an old channel that got an "unoriginal content" label.
I did exactly what YouTube asked: I started a brand-new channel, changed my presentation completely, followed every strict rule, and put in maximum effort.
But it is NO LONGER ENOUGH. It's not enough to create from scratch, edit everything yourself, write your scripts, or show your face. Why? Because instead of evaluating your new hard work, the bot instantly rejects you just for a technical "link" to your past!
And don't even tell me to "just submit an appeal." The appeal system is completely broken. Appeals are reviewed exclusively by bots looking for predefined patterns in their scripts. Submitting an appeal guarantees absolutely NOTHING—it’s just a dead end. They don't look at human effort.
Hey @reneritchie, your job title is "Creator Liaison". But how can you be a bridge between creators and YouTube when YouTube has replaced the other side of the bridge with blind bots? If your role is to actually protect real human creators from automated nightmares, here is your chance. Prove that your job isn't just PR, and that a human can still review a channel.
If we stay silent, this will become the new normal. Today it's me trapped by an AdSense link, tomorrow your channel gets flagged by a bot, and you'll be screaming into the void. We need to raise our voices! Please RT! 🔄
I demand a REAL HUMAN to look at my face, listen to my voice, and review my channel. Break this automated loop!
Channel: youtube.com/channel/UCCqFzG7…
@nealmohan @TeamYouTube @YouTubeCreators
#YouTubeCreators #Demonetization #JusticeForCreators

























