Reshmi Dasgupta retweeted
Every time Rahul Gandhi and Priyanka Gandhi Vadra invoke their grandmother Indira Gandhi’s assassination, they should remember that theirs was not the only family to suffer.
Thousands of Hindus and Sikhs lost their lives in the violence that preceded and followed it.
They should also remember the soldiers who entered the Golden Temple with one hand tied behind their backs, conscious of the sanctity of this hallowed space, desecrated by the very Bhindranwale and his armed followers whom their grandmother’s political choices had helped create, and whom the soldiers were eventually sent in to confront.
Every time they speak of the trauma of their father Rajiv Gandhi’s assassination, they should spare a thought for the children who lost their fathers in the ill-fated IPKF mission in Sri Lanka, and for the families whose loved ones were killed in the suicide bombing that took his life.
They have spoken of forgiveness for the killers and conspirators.
But did they ever seek to understand the trauma of others who lost their loved ones?
Did their grief matter as much?
Did their children deserve the same acknowledgement?
The appropriation of grief, as though suffering were unique to their family, is deeply insensitive to the countless other families who continue to live with these losses.
And when that grief is repeatedly invoked as political capital, it becomes even harder to accept.
The Gandhi family was not the only one that paid a price. Surely, that too is worth remembering.
Reshmi Dasgupta retweeted
Replying to @Vasudha156
“Challenging social notions” from which perspective Italian or English, it’s their culture, I’m not saying that is bad but it’s not an Indian culture, it has never been. The form of deep love and healthy relationship expression are quite different in India, it’s mostly private than western kind of. So how can one culture challenge other cultures notions. Your assessment is purely reeks inferiority complex. Rahul can cherish as he is half Italian but not me, don’t know about you.
Reshmi Dasgupta retweeted
Replying to @Vasudha156
If he thinks it’s cool to talk about the private life of his visibly embarrassed mother on a public platform, then I can tell you, it isn’t.
It’s juvenile and gross.
Reshmi Dasgupta retweeted
Now, having watched anchors from @NDTV @CNNnews18 @TimesNow discuss Sonia Gandhi’s Belonging, here are a few takeaways.
1. There is at least one anchor on every channel’s panel who seems positively dazzled by the Gandhi family’s food, tastes, sensibilities and domestic anecdotes. Far too enamoured of the people to examine their politics.
2. Most struggle to explain away glaring omissions by taking refuge in that supposedly subtle distinction between a memoir and an autobiography.
These ‘political’ journalists seem to overlook one rather important fact: Sonia Gandhi was, for a decade, arguably the most powerful *extra-constitutional* authority in this country.
She presided over a government that was ostensibly a parliamentary democracy, while exercising enormous influence through an extra-constitutional body, the NAC. Power without direct accountability. Influence without constitutional responsibility.
She was not merely a bahu who found herself having to run a household in the aftermath of tragic circumstances.
She was a political actor who consciously assumed the reins of power, without holding constitutional office, and exercised extraordinary influence over the governance of a country of over a billion people.
The country’s future was, in many ways, treated as though it were hers to shape and dispense with.
3. To dismiss this book as her ‘prerogative’, reduce it to a simple narrative of a love story, family and personal experiences, is precisely the problem.
It is this very framing that helps explain how she could exercise such extraordinary power while remaining largely insulated from scrutiny.
Yes, the Gandhis occupy a unique space in our political landscape. But perhaps the more uncomfortable question is: why?
Is it because, even decades after Independence, we remain mentally shackled? Still colonised in our imagination? Still predisposed to treating one political family as royalty, whose private world deserves reverence rather than scrutiny?
And I think I now understand why panelists are allowed to overspeak and interrupt one another. Left to themselves, these anchors do exactly the same thing.
Reshmi Dasgupta retweeted
Vivek Oberoi finally speaking about how Salman Khan misbehaved with Aishwarya and how he tried to stand up for her, and in return he was left with nothing:
"Despite delivering hits & winning awards, a powerful lobby just took over, & I started getting calls from the underworld"
Reshmi Dasgupta retweeted
Actor Dalip Tahil just dropped a political truth bomb!
He takes the gloves off while discussing Sonia Gandhi!
Reshmi Dasgupta retweeted
I must thank @ARanganathan72 for flagging my sacking at the behest of a Lutyens clerk merely because I was not deferential to his boss. So this is how this and other near-sackings happened in my otherwise vanilla life.
It was an extremely distressing experience to get sacked in 1995 from The Pioneer where I was Associate Editor because the then Editor (economist Ashok Mitra famously described him as a ‘handout Editor’) needed to suck up to Sonia Gandhi. No less distressing was the reality of being left without a roof and phone (rented / owned by The Pioneer’s then owners, the Thapars) with a family in tow — we were literally out in streets with nowhere to go. All this happened after Vinod Mehta resigned in protest against pressure from Thapar House to be ‘nice’ to Sharad Pawar to whom the ‘Bombay Club’ was beholden.
That was not my first or last experience of running into trouble with Sonia Gandhi and her factotums. I had published a photograph of Rajiv and Sonia in The Statesman’s popular weekend section (The Saturday Statesman) which I edited, shot during their visit to Mizoram in 1986. Sonia was in a Lacoste tee and the couple looked remarkably striking. Those were still Camelot days of Prince Charming.
It was a measure of the then Government’s illicit and undeclared reach that they had access to The Saturday Statesman, which was printed in Kolkata and shipped to Delhi on Thursday-Friday, before its distribution on Saturday. HY Sharada Prasad, Press Advisor to Rajiv Gandhi, called CR Irani, MD of The Statesman, and rained fire and brimstone on him for daring to publish a ‘private photo of Madam.’
Sharada Prasad demanded that The Saturday Statesman with the Rajiv-Sonia photo should not be distributed and all copies must be destroyed. Irani, who was then struggling to get the rebuilding plans for The Statesman’s Delhi office at CP approved, worked out a deal that there would be an ‘apology’ in the main paper and The Saturday Statesman would be distributed. Irani asked me to draft the apology and run it in Saturday morning’s paper.
On that occasion Swapan, also at The Statesman, stood like a rock by me — I remain grateful to him. He also drafted the ‘apology’ for me — Swapan’s nib-breaking, tongue-twisting, brain-wracking English impressed Sharada Prasad but little did he realise it was actually a non-apology.
The story of my encounters with the Nehru Dynasty is one of several episodes. In 2012 the Sonia Gandhi-led UPA regime invoked the draconian anti-Freedom of Expression, anti-liberty, anti-Constitution Section 66A (drafted and implemented by Kapil Sibal with great fervour to prevent, prosecute and punish any criticism of Sonia Gandhi and silence all critical Speech in India) against me, instructing ISPs to block my Twitter handle. The handles of several other journalists and regime critics were also blocked.
The sinister charges against me, never registered formally but only informally conveyed, made me feel like Trotsky in Stalin’s court. Better counsel by way of domestic and global criticism of this attempt to choke voices prevailed and the block order was quietly buried after a hearing in a dark room with a single electric bulb hanging from the ceiling, very reminiscent of the interrogation chambers of Mussolini’s secret police OVRA.
I was later told the Gestapo-style hearing was the brainchild of then Home Secretary RK Singh whose fetid imagination had also birthed the hideous nomenclature ‘Saffron Terror’. He who later floated into NDA and has now floated out again.
@kushanmitra
Reshmi Dasgupta retweeted
Ajit Gulabchand made India's first Smart City Lavasa using his own money which included world class schools and hospitals for poor of the area
Lavasa was so advanced that it would rival any Western City
His only crime? Being a Hindutvadi and Allowing Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi to visit the under construction city in March 2012
The moment Modi visited, Sonia Gandhi gave directions to Jairam Ramesh and Medha Patkar to destroy Lavasa and Ajit Gulabchand
Medha Patkar started false rumours that Lavasa is drawing water from Pune and Jairam Ramesh who was environmental minister sent notices without reason to close the City construction
Today the city is a ghost town, Ajit Gulabchand incurred Billions of Dollars in loss and was forced to sell his company for 10 Lakh Rupees
Reshmi Dasgupta retweeted
No need for MEA to give any explanation. The Embassy was no doubt instructed to cancel her visa. It can’t act on its own.
The US cancels visa without informing the concerned person and gives no explanation.
Government grants Norwegian journalist Helle Lyng a visa to travel to Hyderabad, but Embassy tells her it is cancelled just as she heads to airport. If this is about her comments to PM and Secy(West) in Oslo in May, why was visa issued? And once issued, why cancel? Awaiting MEA explanation thehindu.com/news/national/n…
Reshmi Dasgupta retweeted
If there is one thing ‘Belonging’ has made clear, it is that India’s oldest and most powerful political family - the one that produced three prime ministers - is badly out of touch with the country as it exists today.
A memoir is, by definition, a person’s memories. We can accept that ‘Belonging’ is Sonia Gandhi’s memory of events, however selective or incomplete. The difficulty is that she is not an ordinary citizen. She is the matriarch of the Congress party’s first family. When she describes the Godhra incident as “disputed,” calls the abrogation of Article 370 the worst thing to happen to Kashmir, or suggests the RSS had a hand in the 1984 anti-Sikh riots, or completely omits the Bhopal gas tragedy, it has more to do with politics than her memories. Then. it becomes easier to understand why the party is where it is today.
Her memory lapse on the Bhopal gas disaster of December 2, 1985, is unusual. Between 15,000 and 25,000 people have died since that day from the long-term effects of MIC gas. Even if Arjun Singh played the main role in letting Warren Anderson leave the country, Rajiv Gandhi was Prime Minister. And I am willing to accept that an inexperienced Rajiv was played by his more experienced partymen. But didn’t he discuss it with her even once? And even if he didn’t, didn’t she have an opinion? Memory lapse?
And what about Bofors? Here too, we can accept that her late husband was cleared of receiving kickbacks. But somebody in her government or connected with the government did get the money. Surely, she knew. She forgot about Ottavio Quattrocchi?
Blaming the RSS and the BJP for every problem the country has faced is also difficult to accept. Ironically, her political career, after Rajiv’s unfortunate demise, runs virtually parallel to the BJP's rise. Acknowledging that record would, of course, turn the spotlight back on her own family and how it has run the Congress party.
Watching her children struggle in politics only reinforces the point: the apple does not fall far from the tree. Reading the book, it is clear that Sonia Gandhi’s view of events is essentially the same as theirs. So, if anyone bears responsibility for the present condition of the Congress and her children's political roles, it is she.
The memoir has factual errors, and they’ve already been highlighted on various social media platforms, so there’s no need for me to repeat them here.
Yes, the book does have some lovely vignettes of her life with Rajiv. How she met him, her love affair, her marriage, and her transition into Indira Gandhi’s daughter-in-law. The book also shows that Rajiv Gandhi was a basically decent guy who would have preferred a life away from his mother's profession but was drawn into it by circumstance. After that, Sonia Gandhi had a ringside view.
So, she can choose what she wants to remember, but public memory does not work that way.
Murasoli Maran’s wife,Mallika Maran is a Tamil #Brahmin
Kalanithi Maran’s wife, Kavery Maran is Kannada Brahmin.
Daya Nidhi Marand wife Priya Rangarajan Tamil Iyengar Kavya Maran's husband Anirudh Ravichander is a Tamil Brahmin.Iyengar. Preach against Brahmins but marry them
Finally @SoniaGandhi has admitted what we all knew: the idea of #PranabMukherjee as PM was abhorrent to her. And we know why. He would have not been a doormat like MMS.
'Pranab Mukherjee Shocked Me With Change At Top Suggestion': Sonia Gandhi
ndtv.com/india-news/sonia-ga…
Reshmi Dasgupta retweeted
Sonia Gandhi has discovered “great damage” to India. Curious how selectively her political memory works.
India does not need selective amnesia served alongside a memoir. If “great damage” is the standard you wish to apply, Sonia Gandhi, have the courage to apply it to your own political legacy as well.
Mrs Gandhi, many Indians remember the damage of decades of Congress governments - only in death tolls from terror attacks. They remember train compartments, crowded markets, places of worship and hotels transformed into scenes of terror.
And while we are discussing damage to public trust, perhaps your account of Congress’s years could also address Bofors and Ottavio Quattrocchi. And how Quattrocchi's Italian firm Snamprogetti was allowed to access classified government files on major defense deals before even Indian officials did!
Maybe it will refresh your memories @SoniaGandhi.
Reshmi Dasgupta retweeted
CNN reports on Jensen Huang and his extramarital affair partner Alice Huang...Note the language Financial Times uses: ‘romantic relationship’…
Reshmi Dasgupta retweeted
Listen to Tavleen Singh exposing Sonia Gandhi and the Lavasa smart city project, promoted by industrialist Ajit Gulabchand.
How many opportunities for India’s progress were lost during Congress regime And who was accountable?
Reshmi Dasgupta retweeted
Deepawali or Diwali can be celebrated for many reasons. In our home we celebrate three separate reasons during three days!
This map is a good collection of the main reason. I am sure some will disagree as we have too many reasons. But it gives you a high level picture.
Reshmi Dasgupta retweeted
Debates don’t win elections in India. Mock parliaments are for school & college kids to simulate Parliament - not for seasoned parliamentarians. The only thing that demonstrably wins elections in India is groundwork. Stop wasting your time on infantile inanities & start roughing it out on the ground instead of running abroad every week.
24 घंटे हो गए मोदी जी। मैंने आपको चैलेंज दिया है।
आप कहते हो कि opposition देशद्रोही है। किसी भी स्टेज पे आप जगह चुनिए, डिबेट कीजिए मेरे साथ।
देशद्रोही कौन है? विदेशी फोर्सेस का कनेक्शन किसका है? और किस प्रकार का कनेक्शन है? जल्दी से जल्दी कीजिए, डरिए मत।
दोनों मिलेंगे, मीडिया होगी, देश के युवा होंगे, टेबल होगी, एक साइड आप बैठोगे, एक साइड मैं बैठूंगा। जिसको आप जज बनाना चाहते हो, बना दो। मोहन भागवत जी को बिठा दो, चलो। और फिर डिबेट करते हैं।
सवाल उठेंगे फाइनेंशियल सिस्टम पर, फाइनेंशियल स्ट्रक्चर पर, US डील कैसे हुई, क्यों हुई, इतनी जल्दी क्यों हुई, सिर्फ आपने क्यों की, कैबिनेट को क्यों नहीं बताया, अडानी का केस बंद क्यों हुआ, Epstein - ऐसी बहुत सारी चीजें हैं जिसपे खुलकर डिस्कशन होगा।
आ जाइए, डरिए मत।
दूध का दूध, पानी का पानी कीजिए।
आप एलिगेशन लगाते हैं ना मेरे ऊपर, आ जाइए, सब साफ हो जाएगा।
बाकी चीजों पे आपने defamation केस लगा रखा है, शायद 45 defamation केस मेरे ऊपर हैं।
मगर इस डिबेट मामले पे, foreign कनेक्शन पे आप defamation नहीं लगा रहे हो। लगाइए ना, वहाँ भी डिस्कस करेंगे, खुल के। ये सब डिस्कस करते हैं, आइए।
हैप्पी दिवाली, मोदी जी।
It’s been 24 hours since I challenged you, Modi ji.
You say the Opposition is anti-national. Choose any stage, any venue, and debate me on this - Who is anti-national? Who has connections with foreign forces? And what is the nature of those connections?
Let’s do this as soon as possible. Daro mat!
We’ll both be there. The media will be there. The youth of this country will be there. There will be a table. You’ll sit on one side, I’ll sit on the other. You can appoint whoever you want as the judge. You can even make Mohan Bhagwat ji the judge.
There will be questions about the financial system, the financial structure, how the US deal happened, why it happened and why so quickly, why you made the deal alone and didn’t inform the Cabinet, why the Adani case was closed, Epstein - and many other issues. We’ll discuss all of them openly.
Let the truth come out. Let everything be crystal clear.
You make allegations against me, don’t you? Come forward. Everything will become clear.
You’ve filed defamation cases against me over other matters. I think there are around 45 defamation cases against me.
But on this issue of the debate, on the question of foreign connections, you haven’t filed a defamation case. Go ahead, file one. We’ll discuss that openly too.
Happy Diwali, Modi ji.
Reshmi Dasgupta retweeted
“Priests in temples rape women.”
~ Neha Bora.
I have always maintained that the more they speak, the better.
Hindus are so pathetically forgetful and forgiving that they need this daily shot of venom to stay awake.
Keeping the commie-jihadi ecosystem’s voice loud and free has been one of Modi’s finest political manoeuvres.



























