Sarah Karlin-Smith (@SarahKarlin) profile picture

Research Director at Public Citizen's Access to Medicines program. Former journalist covering intersection of pharma, health policy & politics.

Washington, DC
Joined May 2009
Photo by Sarah Karlin-Smith (@SarahKarlin)Photo by Sarah Karlin-Smith (@SarahKarlin)Photo by Sarah Karlin-Smith (@SarahKarlin)Photo by Sarah Karlin-Smith (@SarahKarlin)Photo by Sarah Karlin-Smith (@SarahKarlin)Photo by Sarah Karlin-Smith (@SarahKarlin)Photo by Sarah Karlin-Smith (@SarahKarlin)Photo by Sarah Karlin-Smith (@SarahKarlin)Photo by Sarah Karlin-Smith (@SarahKarlin)
Sarah Karlin-Smith retweeted
Big (if not eventually overturned)...
4
10
974
Sarah Karlin-Smith retweeted
How can patients give informed consent for a treatment if the telehealth platform & clinician is financially incentivized to prescribe these products of unknown quality, safety, & efficacy? When has a "trust me, bro" policy ever worked for the public jamanetwork.com/journals/jam…
2
4
1
10
2,378
Sarah Karlin-Smith retweeted
The fact that being good at picking fights despite almost always being wrong is a pathway to a million plus dollars annually but folks say when teachers make over $100,000 a year that it’s a very very generous salary for a teacher is truly a statement.
Replying to @JHWeissmann
Anyway, I wrote and deleted a longer version of this, but I think the reason Matt is successful is that — to paraphrase AJ Liebling — he is faster than anyone better at picking a fight, and better at picking a fight than anyone faster.
1
1
1
7
3,684
Sarah Karlin-Smith retweeted
Hims & Hers acquired its own peptide manufacturing facility in 2025 & is now celebrating this policy allowing unproven peptides as its latest cash grab. As we found in our secret shopper study, there'll be little to no prescriber oversight to protect patients & prevent harms.
$HIMS 🚨 HHS INTERIM ENFORCEMENT PEPTIDE POLICY "The Secretary of HHS [RFK Jr.] has determined that this limited enforcement-discretion policy will discourage the continued, widespread use of certain research-use-only peptides supplied by foreign manufacturers that pose a safety risk to US patients. By allowing limited compounding of the substances addressed in this guidance under appropriate safeguards, the policy provides patients with a more controlled alternative." "Based on the available evidence, including the recommendations of a recent Pharmacy Compounding Advisory Committee, the Secretary has determined that the policy advances patient choice and freedom while appropriately protecting patient safety." "Until a peptide bulk drug substance is addressed in a final rule as being included or not included on the 503A bulks list, HHS does not intend to take action against a State-licensed pharmacy, Federal facility, or licensed physician compounding a drug product using a peptide bulk drug substance that is not a component of an FDA-approved drug product, the subject of an applicable USP or NF monograph, or on the 503A bulks list codified at 21 CFR 216.23(a), when all of the following circumstances are present:" 1. 503A Interim Access List: BPC-157, TB-500, MOTS-c, KPV, Semax, or Epitalon 2. Peptide Identity: The peptide must meet the identity specifications and administration-route limitations in Appendix B 3. Characterization & Testing: The substance must come from an FDA-registered facility and have a valid Certificate of Analysis (COA) confirming identity, purity, potency, and contaminant testing 4. Manufacturer Requirements: The original manufacturer must be FDA-registered, comply with CGMP requirements, and be identified on the COA. Intermediaries must validate suppliers 5. Reporting Requirements: Compounders must report products compounded, serious adverse events, and product quality issues to FDA and relevant states. Reporting instructions must appear on product labeling 6. Product Labeling: Labels must state: “This is a compounded drug product. Not for resale.” 7. Single Active Ingredient: Each compounded product may contain only one peptide API from Appendix A. No peptide combinations. 8. Oral Bioavailability: Oral formulations require documentation demonstrating adequate human bioavailability. 9. Drug Delivery Devices: Only FDA 510(k)-cleared syringes may be packaged with or contain the compounded drug. 10. Compliance With Existing Law: Products must satisfy other applicable FD&C Act requirements, including sanitary compounding conditions and valid patient-specific prescriptions.
4
4
1
9
3,324
Basically our entire system for reviewing and approving drugs was blown up because the current Health Secretary and his buddies like these products.
1
12
30
2,202
If "significant interest in use" governed FDA decision making all the time we'd have a much different array of available medical products on the market and I'm not sure we'd be better off...
Replying to @AlecGaffney
The key take-away, as expected:
2
1
10
1,396
Sarah Karlin-Smith retweeted
The key take-away, as expected:
3
3
3
11
5,898
Sarah Karlin-Smith retweeted
Imagine landing your first big journalism job, still teaching adult dance classes to make rent, and then seeing your story splashed across the pages of a newspaper you revered, with no credit. And when you ask about it, nothing. It continues to shape the way I view this industry.
3
3
37
1,935
Sarah Karlin-Smith retweeted
THis. Is. Not. Normal.
Both CNN and Politico were barred from travel pool duty on Air Force One today. Axios is sending notes from the "secondary" pool seat. Here's the relevant note that just went out to subscribers:
6
19
3,048
Sarah Karlin-Smith retweeted
I really think everyone needs to pay attention to this cordinated campaign to delegimatize Muslim Americans - not just as citizens but as humans. These increasingly hysterical attacks are a prelude to Republicans bringing us to a very, very dark place after the election.
RFK: "There's five hundred million Arabs in the world. And yet they don't produce science. They don't win the Novel Prize. They don't win the Fields Prize. They don't win the Wolf Prize. They don't produce literature."
3,042
2,786
173
11,798
373,431
Sarah Karlin-Smith retweeted
SCOOP: Afghans in immigration detention across the country are being told there is a plan to deport them to Pakistan. Advocates fear those removed, which could include families of US allies, would be in life-threatening danger. news.bloomberglaw.com/us-law…
1
67
6
78
8,722
This seems in some ways like its more about Europe holding drugs to a higher standard than MFN. "Roche said its plans reflected recent EMA guidance encouraging more comprehensive clinical evidence upfront."
2
1
5
1,376
Also I think important to think about the flip side of what happens in the U.S. Cancer drugs get quicker approvals (often on surrogate endpoints) and then people are charged huge pricetags before we know if drug extends/improves lives. Why do Americans accept this as status quo?
1
1
1
425
Europe says, you want a better price point, show us the data. America just hands over the money. Who's getting the better deal here?
1
1
268
Sarah Karlin-Smith retweeted
Requiring compounders to report adverse events for peptides where there is no evidence of efficacy, safety, and quality is basically putting a bandaid on a bullet hole. Here are the many reasons why this is an awful idea that will fail to protect patients:
New: Top officials at HHS and FDA have been working to balance Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s push to expand access to buzzy peptides with safety concerns raised by agency scientists. A peek behind the curtain with new details on the path ahead w/ the dream team @rileyraygriffin @g0ingmad @nyahphengsitthy 🎁: bloomberg.com/news/articles/…
1
2
2
7
1,650
Sarah Karlin-Smith retweeted
Always remember what MLK said about the greatest threat to peace being the white moderate. The complete moral depravity from Yglesias here isn't just infuriating, it's heartbreakingly sad. And the depravity gets worse when @mehdirhasan presses him about Gaza.
52
115
31
922
77,571
Sarah Karlin-Smith retweeted
DC ATEs only fine if you are >11 mph over speed limit. In a residential area, that means going 36 in a 25. Getting hit by a car going 36 mph has ~2x the force and ~3x the likelihood of death. My wife and I have never received a moving violation - it really isn’t that hard!
Rarely disagree w MY on safety issues but DC machine-guns people with $100 tickets for minor violations that put nobody in danger. It’s ridiculous and a lot of people just ignore the tickets.
5
14
135
3,402
The issue here is there are always risks with products like peptides. If you don’t know the benefits you can’t properly weigh benefit-risk trade offs.
New: Top officials at HHS and FDA have been working to balance Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s push to expand access to buzzy peptides with safety concerns raised by agency scientists. A peek behind the curtain with new details on the path ahead w/ the dream team @rileyraygriffin @g0ingmad @nyahphengsitthy 🎁: bloomberg.com/news/articles/…
1
2
5
796
Plus there is a difference between data you can collect in a trial & data collected from real world use in trying to determine causality. Then there are the quality and manufacturing issues in this less regulated space, and the whole issue of undermining drug approval process.
2
275
Only 1 in 5 large employers cover GLP-1s for weight loss. 9% of employers are using international prescription drug purchasing services.
Worker premiums for family health insurance are up 9%. The total average premium is $28,303. The average deductible is $1,955. It's no wonder people are worried about health care costs.
2
3
8
812