Renzo Cucinotta (@Trenchap) header
Renzo Cucinotta (@Trenchap) profile picture

A Kraus Twitter sarebbe piaciuto. Forse.

Joined April 2013
Photo by Renzo Cucinotta (@Trenchap)Photo by Renzo Cucinotta (@Trenchap)Photo by Renzo Cucinotta (@Trenchap)Photo by Renzo Cucinotta (@Trenchap)Photo by Renzo Cucinotta (@Trenchap)Photo by Renzo Cucinotta (@Trenchap)Photo by Renzo Cucinotta (@Trenchap)Photo by Renzo Cucinotta (@Trenchap)Photo by Renzo Cucinotta (@Trenchap)Photo by Renzo Cucinotta (@Trenchap)
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
Veteran BBC journalist Stephen Sackur has called out the corporation’s “impartiality” on Gaza as unsustainable and one-sided. He highlighted how the BBC was ordered from the top to attach a terrorism label every single time it reported Palestinian death tolls from the Hamas-run health ministry. Yet when Israel officially denied bombing apartment blocks full of women and children, or striking a food kitchen and killing aid workers, the BBC never mentioned that Netanyahu is wanted by the International Criminal Court for war crimes. “BBC’s notion of impartiality is a difficult thing to sustain… it’s difficult for me to justify the BBC talking so rigorously about impartiality and then reporting that way.” “The BBC manual doesn’t talk about morality.” This is what “both-sides” journalism looks like when one side is an occupying power with an ICC arrest warrant and the other is under bombardment.
99
1,386
72
2,552
90,114
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
Even if you are pro-Ukraine, pro-EU, anti-Russia and you view these people as malignant Russian operatives... what is the EU fighting for here, exactly?
By my own count, if one includes these latest sanctions, the EU has now sanctioned 8 European citizens for speech: - 3 German citizens: Alina Lipp, Thomas Röper and Hüseyin Doğru - 3 French citizens: Xavier Moreau, Adrien Bocquet and Sylvain Afoua (aka Egountchi Behanzin) - 1 Lithuanian citizen: Ernest Mackevičius - 1 Irish citizen: Chay Bowes The sanctions include freezing these people's assets and making it a crime for anyone in the EU to pay them, hire them or even lend them a single euro. They also include a travel ban, which leads to some absurd situations: Doğru - based in Germany - was invited by some members of the EU parliament to Brussels to plead his case but he couldn't go due to the travel ban. As one of the MEPs who invited him - and made 40 phone calls to try, unsuccessfully, to get him cleared to come - put it: "It really was like something out of a Kafka novel" (berliner-zeitung.de/article/…). And, probably worst of all, all of this was decided without any charge, trial or court ruling - simply as a unilateral decision of government ministers. Yesterday's sanctions, for instance, were decided at the Foreign Affairs Council meeting of EU Foreign Ministers and were simply signed by Kaja Kallas alone on behalf of the Council (eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-cont…). Put it all together, and this violates at least half a dozen of what the EU keeps saying are the fundamental values and principles it supposedly fights for: 1) Separation of powers: here we have government ministers - members of the executive branch of their countries - acting as prosecutor, judge and jury 2) Presumption of innocence (Article 48 of the EU’s own Charter of Fundamental Rights): they’re punished without guilt ever being established, and without being given a chance to plead their case before the decision 3) Right to a fair trial (Article 47): there was no trial at all, let alone a fair one 4) Freedom of expression and of the media (Article 11): they were sanctioned - explicitly so - for what they said and published. For instance, in these latest sanctions, Chay Bowes was sanctioned for, among other things, the speech crime of "participat[ing] in the spreading of anti-Western and anti-Ukraine disinformation at the UN Security Council" (eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-cont…). Sanctioned in part for a speech at the UN, a forum that exists precisely so that clashing views on international matters can be heard, quite the message to send from the EU... 5) Freedom of movement (Article 45): they're under a travel ban 6) Right to work and to property (Articles 15 and 17): their assets are frozen and nobody may employ or pay them You can think whatever you want about these 8 people. But ask yourself this: even if you are pro-Ukraine, pro-EU, anti-Russia and you view these people as malignant Russian operatives... what is the EU fighting for here, exactly? This is more profound than you may think: we're speaking about the very foundation of modern European civilization, built on the very idea that political power alone cannot decide what is true. I'm not exaggerating. What we’re witnessing is a return to the pre-Enlightenment playbook, when monarchic or religious authorities defined the truth, deviations from it were called heresy, and heretics were excommunicated - cut off from the community, so that no one could trade with them, employ them or help them. In Europe's darkest times, heretics were even famously burned at the stake - like Joan of Arc or Giordano Bruno. It took literal centuries of religious wars and debates, and the likes of Voltaire, Kant and Mill, to replace it with a basic idea: that no single power, however legitimate, gets to be the final judge of what is true, and that you answer for your words only before a court, under laws written via a process separate from the power that does the accusation. You can find countless works of European literature on this very matter. Take Spinoza, excommunicated in 1656 by the Portuguese-Jewish community of Amsterdam, with a decree ordering that "no one should communicate with him" nor "accord him any favor". He went on to write the Theological-Political Treatise, one of the founding texts of the Enlightenment, with an entire chapter arguing that "in a free state every man may think what he likes, and say what he thinks." Or Mill, two centuries later in On Liberty, Chapter 2: "All silencing of discussion is an assumption of infallibility." Or Kafka’s The Trial, the story of a man accused by an authority nobody can quite locate, of something nobody will explain. How is what Europe is presently doing anything other than going back to that very system, under new appellations? The authority: government ministers. The heresy: "disinformation". The excommunication: assets frozen, banned from travelling and nobody may pay them, hire them or lend them a single euro. It’s basically Spinoza’s excommunication decree on EU letterhead, with a bit of Kafka sprinkled in given that the man invited to the European Parliament to contest his punishment couldn’t attend because of the very punishment he wanted to contest. You don’t have to like these 8 people, or even care about them, to see the problem. Heck, this system was developed precisely for the people nobody likes: consensual ideas never needed protecting. No, the real question here is this: do you want Europe to be the heir of Spinoza - or of Voltaire, or of Galileo, or of any of the countless Europeans who suffered or even died for thinking differently - or of their persecutors?
2
3
81
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
Take a look at what is being classed as ‘antisemitism’ 👇👇👇
Next week the Combat Antisemitism Movement (CAM) will be teaching Local Councillors how to prevent Antisemitism. I went through their Antisemtism weekly reports for the last 12 months to see what they consider Antisemitic, spoiler its supporting Palestine or protesting Israel.
11
90
3
219
3,169
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
Two genocides perpetrated, complicity in a third (in little more than a century), and German leaders still have the f**king audacity to lecture Palestinians.
Germany's Merkel criticizes Palestinians for "not confronting" Hamas: What surprises me is that we have heard very, very few people from the Gaza Strip critically confronting Hamas.
41
363
1
1,603
14,100
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
Quello che sta succedendo a Trieste è l’ultimo tassello di una lotta ai migranti e chi li aiuta. Lorena Fornasir che da anni cura le ferite di chi arriva dalla rotta balcanica è stata multata. Secondo disposizioni non si può aiutare il prossimo all’ora dello spritz
18
170
5
419
7,520
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
Arabia Saudita: Jawad Qureiris è stato messo a morte nel fine settimana, nonostante fosse minorenne al momento dei presunti reati. Era stato condannato a seguito di un processo palesemente ingiusto. Aveva denunciato di essere stato sottoposto a tortura per estorcergli una "confessione". No alla pena di morte!
Heartbreaking news from Saudi Arabia. Authorities executed Jawad Qureiris over the weekend, despite him being a child at the time of some of his alleged offences. He was convicted for "terrorist" crimes following a grossly unfair trial. He told a judge that his "confessions" were coerced under torture. The UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention previously found that the detentions of Jawad, Jalal Labbad, Abdullah al-Derazi, Hassan al-Faraj and Youssef al-Manasif, were arbitrary, and called for their release. All were members of the Shia minority and had participated in anti-government protests in the Eastern Province when they were minors. Jalal Labbad, Abdullah al-Darazi and Hassan al-Faraj have also been executed. Jawad's execution is yet another example of Saudi authorities reneging on their promise to end the use of the death penalty for ta'zir (discretionary) offences committed by people under the age of 18. Saudi authorities have long sought to silence dissent in Saudi Arabia's Eastern Province, including by repeatedly imposing death sentences on members of the Shia community. #EndDeathPenalty
3
26
1
42
1,052
I fratelli Cohen sono uno solo.
4
3
1
23
568
Il coraggio di questo giovane uomo.
Also, I didn't "accuse Israel of ethnic cleansing", I documented Israel committing ethnic cleansing. And that's why you want to revoke my citizenship, that's why you banned me from the West Bank, that's why you murdered hundreds of Palestinian journalists in Gaza, that's why you routinely jail and torture Palestinian journalists in the West Bank. For documenting your crimes.
1
2
6
181
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
Also, I didn't "accuse Israel of ethnic cleansing", I documented Israel committing ethnic cleansing. And that's why you want to revoke my citizenship, that's why you banned me from the West Bank, that's why you murdered hundreds of Palestinian journalists in Gaza, that's why you routinely jail and torture Palestinian journalists in the West Bank. For documenting your crimes.
Dozens of journalists are asking me for comment on the Israeli Minister of Diaspora Amichai Shikli demanding revocation of my citizenship. Here is my comment for all of you: Since Amichai Shikli is a Minister of Diaspora, I suggest that he immediately calls for instituting a Law of Return for the Palestinian refugees, living in the diaspora since 1948. And if that would result in overpopulation, we can revoke Amichai Shikli's citizenship to compensate, and put him on a plane straight to the Hague, together with his colleagues in the government.
125
2,466
42
6,464
68,164
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
I asked @savechildrenuk why it chose not to adopt the IHRA definition of antisemitism for its <800 employees. Its response: the UK already has equalities legislation, as well as employer guidance on racial and religious discrimination. This is a landmark moment. Here's why🧵 1/
32
382
17
1,062
38,655
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
However promising these images may be — and they really are — we should not forget that this is something Iranian women fought for over many years and achieved, not something that was granted to them by the government. It is true that we have seen a gradual weakening of the Islamic Republic's religious and ideological identity in favor of its security-oriented and pragmatic side. But the Islamic Republic still relies heavily on a minority of hardcore, ideologically committed supporters who feel increasingly uncomfortable with the gradual erosion of what they consider the foundational moral values of society. The government is struggling to balance the demands of this constituency against the risk of sparking new unrest by putting excessive pressure on the majority of the population. Moreover, tactical flexibility on the issue of hijab should not obscure the broader securitization of the state. One clear manifestation of this trend is the tightening of rules and regulations restricting contact with foreign media outlets, organizations, and individuals. The Iranian state is in a period of transition, and its eventual direction will depend heavily on the outcome of the war. But when it comes to political freedoms and civil society, the trajectory is toward more restrictions, not fewer.
Iran: A significant number of young women are walking around the streets of Tehran without headscarves.
59
11
303
73,333
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
During World War II, American aircraft bombed civilian neighborhoods in Germany, killing nearly half a million German civilians. Later, in defending these attacks, the United States justified the bombing of civilian populations as a means of breaking German society’s morale. Another argument used to justify such attacks was that the German people’s silence under Hitler amounted to approval of his policies, and that they therefore deserved to be punished. Yet many historians have challenged this reasoning. Not everyone who lived under Hitler was a Nazi, and not everyone who remained silent supported him. Still, that distinction did nothing to protect civilians from the bombs. And yesterday, former German Chancellor Angela Merkel revived this same line of reasoning while defending Israel’s policies toward civilians in Gaza, pointing to the lack of widespread public opposition to Hamas within Gaza in the context of her remarks about Israel’s war. And here is my question: What exactly is a civilian supposed to do to deserve protection? Must he take to the streets and confront an armed authority? Must he publicly declare his opposition in front of cameras? Must he prove to the world that he resisted hard enough before his death becomes worthy of condemnation? I am from Gaza, and I know that opposing Hamas is not an abstract political position. I know that expressing such opposition publicly can carry very real risks. I also know that Palestinians have criticized Hamas, both before and during the war. Some have even paid with their lives for doing so, even if their voices never reached Mrs. Merkel. But more importantly, I cannot understand why we should have to pass this test in the first place. A German child should never have had to prove that he opposed Hitler to avoid being killed beneath the rubble of his home. And a Palestinian child should not have to prove that his family opposed Hamas in order to deserve to live. We can discuss the responsibility of governments and armed groups. We can criticize them, condemn their actions, and demand that they be held accountable. But the moment we begin measuring civilians’ right to life by how much they resisted those who governed them, we cross a dangerous line: we stop holding those in power accountable and begin holding their victims responsible for the violence inflicted upon them. And what pains me most is hearing this reasoning, even by implication, from a German political figure who, of all people, should understand where the idea of treating an entire population as collectively guilty can lead. A civilian should not need a certificate of political good conduct to deserve protection from bombs.
107
390
31
1,078
40,498
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
Davide Carnevali ha scritto un pezzo bellissimo. In questi weekend di città in fiamme e negozi saccheggiati narrati come l’alba dell’apocalisse, un dubbio serpeggia tra il popolo radikalchic milanese: la rivoluzione non doveva essere un pranzo di gala? doppiozero.com/biljana-srblj…
1
2
19
1,096
Vicedirettrice del Foglio ante litteram.
Replying to @sowelleconomics
... and then Ayn Rand spent her later years surviving on state-funded social security and Medicare benefits (as was her right, of course, but not quite in line with her lifelong anti-redistributionist, 'fend for yourself' laissez-faire capitalist philosophy).
84
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
Greenwashing, ancora… anche a Madrid, nonostante quello che gli israeliani (l’esercito israeliano, e i coloni) compiono in Cisgiordania contro terra, umani, alberi. Ulivi come simbolo falso e fuorviante di pace, mentre è in corso il genocidio palestinese. Grazie @Publico
12
26
602
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
If I was writing an editorial about countries targeting journalism, i’d mention the country that has systematically killed more than 200 journalists. But the Guardian obviously knows better.
20
400
6
1,321
37,804
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
Rauti padre della patria. Fausto, Iaio e Valerio Verbano morti di nessuno. Volete davvero la pacificazione? Istituite una Commissione per la verità e la giustizia come in Sudafrica. Carla Verbano invitava gli assassini di suo figlio a farsi avanti: «Bussate ancora alla mia porta». E allora coraggio, camerati. Bussate. E rompete il silenzio. La destra apra l’album di famiglia: solo così finiranno gli anni Settanta editorialedomani.it/idee/cul…
118
331
8
1,219
19,464
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
“Under the cease-fire deal, Israel pledged to allow about 18,000 trucks into Gaza monthly, but IDF data obtained by Haaretz show that since March, the number has averaged about half that target.” “The IDF has destroyed nearly all of Gaza's food production capacity. The few remaining resources are either beyond the Israeli-controlled area, marked by the so-called Yellow Line, or otherwise inaccessible to the local population. According to UN estimates, only about 3 percent of the agricultural land cultivated before the war is currently being farmed, while the Strip is home to just 5 percent of its prewar livestock. The Israeli Navy also restricts fishing, and the volume of fish being caught has declined dramatically.”
27
401
34
421
12,540
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
Paragrafi che ben pochi millennial che si sono occupati di Medio Oriente in questi anni pensavano di poter leggere, un giorno: «Il sostegno incondizionato a Israele era un tempo condiviso nel Congresso tanto quanto la spilla della bandiera statunitense sul risvolto della giacca di un senatore, in gran parte grazie all'influenza bipartisan dell'American Israel Public Affairs Committee... L'era dell'ineguagliabile potere politico e dell'influenza dell'AIPAC è giunta al termine. Nonostante... la sua crescente marginalizzazione nella politica americana, il gruppo non solo non riconosce questo cambiamento, ma agisce come se Israele fosse popolare come lo era nel 1991, quando lo Stato ebraico godeva di un tasso di gradimento di quasi l'80% tra gli americani. Secondo un sondaggio di NBC News del 2026, solo il 32% degli elettori americani vede ora Israele in modo positivo; tra i democratici, tale cifra scende a solo il 13%. Inoltre, Israele ha perso persino molti ebrei americani. Secondo un sondaggio del Washington Post del 2025, il 61% degli ebrei americani ha dichiarato di ritenere che Israele abbia commesso crimini di guerra a Gaza e circa il 40% ritiene che Israele abbia commesso un genocidio. Un altro recente sondaggio ha rilevato che quasi la metà degli ebrei americani sotto i 35 anni ritiene che il conflitto israelo-palestinese debba essere risolto creando un unico stato binazionale, un'idea considerata marginale da quando lo studioso palestinese-americano Edward Said l'aveva sostenuta nel 1999». (@nytimes)
1
11
37
2,363
Renzo Cucinotta retweeted
An extremely important report about how the criminal enterprise known as the state of Israel has been fencing its stolen property in New York City. Please read and share.
For years, the City of New York has facilitated and protected the sale of occupied Palestinian land. With Mamdani in power, local pro-Palestinian activists wonder if the mayor will do anything to stop his own city from enabling land sale events. Read now: thekeymagazine.com/p/mayor-m…
35
646
10
1,679
20,302