Armand Sim (@armandsim) header
Armand Sim (@armandsim) profile picture

Development economist | @CornellDyson alumn

Melbourne
Joined June 2011
Photo by Armand Sim (@armandsim)Photo by Armand Sim (@armandsim)Photo by Armand Sim (@armandsim)Photo by Armand Sim (@armandsim)Photo by Armand Sim (@armandsim)Photo by Armand Sim (@armandsim)Photo by Armand Sim (@armandsim)Photo by Armand Sim (@armandsim)Photo by Armand Sim (@armandsim)Photo by Armand Sim (@armandsim)
Big news in development econ...
6
130
22
719
85,127
Armand Sim retweeted
Konten akun YT FEB UGM ini keren2. Tempo hari bahas legacy Adam Smith. Kali ini bedah buku Pak Sudarno Sumarto. Political Economy of Policy Reform in Indonesia | Sudarmo Sumarto youtu.be/onwP_p19MI0?si=zgmc… via @YouTube
3
47
2
177
43,634
Armand Sim retweeted
This article is full of wild facts. For example, Jakarta recently overtook Tokyo as the world's largest city but has 6 train lines and 250 miles of track vs Tokyo's 158 lines and 2,930 miles
In 2014, Jakarta was crowned the most congested city in the world. Ten years later, it was only the 24th most congested - despite *adding* ten million new residents. How? Transit, of course.
7
42
3,565
🚨Replication alert🚨 I'm pleased to announce that my replication of Moretti (2021) is now accepted as a comment at AER. I find ten issues in the paper. My comment focuses on two major problems; in the appendix, I document eight (relatively) minor problems. 1/
11
98
33
638
291,762
Armand Sim retweeted
Indonesia's finance chief attacked a Citi analyst for commenting on the country's budget deficit without having a PhD bloomberg.com/news/articles/…
32
141
38
791
182,003
Mungkin khalayak tidak kenal ekonom Dr Sudarno Sumarto (@SMERUInstitute) krn ybs dan lembaganya terlalu humble utk pamer. Beliau akan bicara di Mubyarto Public Policy Forum di @feb_ugm ttg pengentasan kemiskinan di Indonesia selama 20 tahun terakhir. ideas.repec.org/top/top.indo…
Save the date! Dr Sudarno Sumarto will reflect on two decades of welfare policy reform in Indonesia and the role of evidence-based policymaking at the 9th Mubyarto Public Policy Forum (MPPF). crawford.anu.edu.au/event/9t…
1
44
3
156
9,090
Tulis apa harapan kalian untuk Indonesia tercinta 🇲🇨 [Lagubaper]
223
3,364
134
11,162
189,133
Incorporating informative Bayesian priors into impact evaluation offers the ability to learn more from experiments. @leoiacovone, @economeager & @dmckenzie001 demonstrate how to do this in the context of a Colombian exporting experiment. econometricsociety.org/publi…
2
40
3
206
23,102
Armand Sim retweeted
Manchester United - 2006 to 2009
71
1,429
450
7,199
1,275,895
If you do one thing today, make sure you watch this.
3,156
26,422
7,827
92,870
8,297,168
Woof. Very sad to see. The MIT econ department has recommended that this paper be withdrawn...
This is the best paper written so far about the impact of AI on scientific discovery
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
There seem to be grave concerns about the integrity of the research. MIT announced that they "conducted an internal, confidential review and concluded that the paper should be withdrawn from public discourse." economics.mit.edu/news/assuring-… wsj.com/tech/ai/mit-sa…
24
98
35
671
389,197
You've heard of the studies where they give the same dataset/research question to a bunch of researchers and they tend to get different answers, right? Why is that? This new working paper shows that it has a lot to do with data cleaning. This is consistent with Gelman's "garden of forking paths" analogy. Small researcher coding decisions greatly influence results, often without being explicitly acknowledged.
23
341
24
1,681
211,348
Armand Sim retweeted
#GDRI_rep Update 7: Retraction! Our comment of "Parent–teacher meetings and student outcomes: Evidence from a developing country" has led to the paper being retracted. Our comment is accepted as is. Short 🧵
1
34
141
34,756
Big kudos to this team for doing the work of uncovering what looks like large-scale research malpractice. Some highlights in this thread.
After being alerted about possible misconduct, the I4R are reproducing published papers that use data from a specific NGO (GDRI). This thread releases the first 2 reports and provides more information about the work and responses/statements from authors journals and journals. 🧵
4
78
8
469
172,964
Armand Sim retweeted
After being alerted about possible misconduct, the I4R are reproducing published papers that use data from a specific NGO (GDRI). This thread releases the first 2 reports and provides more information about the work and responses/statements from authors journals and journals. 🧵
4
149
33
433
362,473
Armand Sim retweeted
Announcements Sunday 9PM ET / Monday 3AM CET / Monday 1PM Melbourne! See you all then #EconTwitter #EconSky
Economists: "Mom, can we camp outside the bookstore for the @I4Replication drop on Monday?" #EconTwitter (sorry not sorry for the repost)
4
1
19
7,198
Related to the forthcoming development research scandal, the fundamental problem (as in social psych) was this: THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS MAJOR CHANGES IN IMPORTANT THINGS FROM TINY INTERVENTIONS! *Every* paper making claims like this are wrong- you don't even need to read them.
12
24
11
231
75,766
A new malpractice scandal is brewing in development economics. We should ask: What is the role of co-authors who had access to all of the shady data (and more), were happy to claim "all authors contributed equally" when these were top publications, and now quietly disavow and distance. They may be completely innocent — victims of a colleague who fabricated data, and now caught in the collateral damage, losing publications and having a shadow cast on their legit work. It's hard to imagine how devastating it would feel to invest years in a project that was totally fraudulent. But can they *all* be *totally* innocent? If there are six authors on an RCT and the data is fabricated, can five of them be completely ignorant? Surely they were working with the data for months and months, and could have noticed the anomalies found by the I4R replicators? Maybe one was brought in for a specialized task like building a structural model— bad luck!! But 5 out of 6 authors on a paper? I don't know what information I4R plans to release, but I think we need a greater accounting than just one bad actor and everyone washes their hands and moves on. We should hear from the more than half dozen people involved, some on multiple projects. We should hear from the NGOs and firms that ran the surveys—if they exist. How could a thing like this happen? What questions should have been asked but weren't? What systems and practices would these researchers use to prevent it from happening to them again? Research fraud imperils the entire discipline, and it is surely more widespread than the egregious scandals which come to light. The fraudsters are not all as ham-fisted as Ariely/Gino "the fake data is in a different font in an Excel spreadsheet." And trust me, this is not the only research team in development economics churning out result after result that is too good to be true.
Abel: I am writing in my capacity as Chair of I4R. Last year, I was contacted by a researcher that alerted me of potential scientific misconduct in a set of papers all using data from a specific NGO.🧵
5
58
3
314
82,663
Indonesia's new wealth fund Danantara is not yet launched but it's already controversial. 325 trillion IDR from public spending cuts would be used by the fund, whose management cant be probed by BPK or KPK. In this economy? By this regime? 👀 sc.mp/c15zm?utm_source=twitt…
2
165
3
270
31,660