Pinned Tweet
Winner of the 1000 person 'All-Time Best Managers' league on LiveFPL this season.
Now it's time for football to come home.
4
27
4,680
My England World Cup Squad
No - Foden, Palmer, Eze, Gibbs-White
Yes - Toney, Maguire, Trent, Garner
Rough rationale - If we're using Tuchels 4-2-3-1 as a base, and trying to optimise around Kane, then I think this is the best way to build.
Kane needs space when he drops deeper and the best way to ensure this is to have more disciplined nominal wide players to stretch the pitch. (Saka, Gordon). He needs pace around him and runs in behind. (Gordon, Rashford, Madueke).
When we want to encourage this dropping we can only have one '10' on the pitch or they will be too crowded.
When he drops and sprays the ball out wide, and said fast players then cross the ball, we need to have a presence in the box still and Bellingham and Rogers have the best physical profiles of the 10s to dovetail with him here.
As a sub, Toney is the most similar profile to Kane that we have and although its our biggest drop off, I think it makes sense to take him on the basis of resting Kane at the end of games if we can whilst still keeping the same structure. He's also good at penalties.
Rice and Anderson can both play '6' and '8' and they are the top 2 for both roles. If one were to get injured Mainoo and Wharton are progressors of the ball but in different ways. Mainoo can carry (good v high press), Wharton passes (good v low block). If both Rice and Anderson were injured though, I wouldn't be comfortable playing them together. I think Garner would be the backup to one of them in more of an enforcer type role.
With Whites injury I think Trent should go as the backup to James, Livramento should go as the backup for both fullback positions. Maguire should come for his heading ability in both boxes. Coming on for the last 20 minutes both when we need to defend or we need to score, hes really valuable here.
GW34: Free hit ramble
Rank: 10
Last week I played my bench boost in a very template way, as just being on bench boost was the differential I needed to push higher up given the teams around me.
It's a good situation to be in, however in terms of what to do it became pretty complex.
First has a similar team to me, 44 extra points and an extra chip that I don't have (triple captain) so if we are to be realistic you've got to say its unlikely. Infact, all 9 teams above me were also on bench boost last week (so all very similar teams).
Now, I could just play very solidly from now on and coast in this position. I'm top of the elite 1k league ('the top 1000 managers of all time'), and were I a content creator I would be top of that league too. I could coast because I can pretty much guarantee every other player in the top 10 of the elite 1000 league will captain Fernandes. Going Salah if I was only in this league would be reckless. But, at the end of it all, you don't get here very often, so I think I am obligated to still try.
Taking risk at the extremes in rank has asymmetric payoffs. Lets say TC is worth 8 points so I'm down 52. If I gain 50 on those around me, I move up to 2nd for a gain of 8 places. If I have the same risk go the other way equally (so -50 points to those around me), I drop to 200th so 190 places.
For people who play for the highest average rank across seasons (most content creators, most 'who is the best manager' review systems) its obviously a bad idea to take those risks. But I believe that view is too simplistic.
To me the difference between 1st and 2nd is worth more than between 24387 and 24388, even though its still a single place.
So the way I approach the problem is to think of it like a poker tournament, where there are 'prizes' that are heavily weighted to the top of the rankings. This is how you can justify taking choices that would seem 'irrational' to those chasing the best average rank. You are optimising for a different payoff to them.
I have actively sabotaged my standings in various best manager rankings multiple times. For example when I was top of the 3 year rankings, I was taking picks to cover the choices of the teams behind me rather than the picks I really thought were best which dropped my average ranking a bit, but I became more highly correlated with them (and so ended on top). When I was top of the massive data rankings on fplreview, it wasn't because I'm "so much better at optimisation / analytics" than @sertalpbilal , @FPL_Spaceman , @FF_Trout ' etc that people have said before, (I'm not at all, they are all great - at best I would get to the same result they do with way more time spent), its just that I took a hard, slightly less-optimal line on purpose to differentiate myself and over time the model moved towards my picks.
Now, I'm going to say to start, that I dislike my FH team quite strongly. If I was at a middling rank and able to choose freely, I would likely have ended on a 451 or 541, but my job instead became, work out what the average free hit will be (assuming the 9 above me will do this), and then work out where I can deviate / go against it.
Given the fixtures and who had things to play for, I think a triple up on ARS / LIV / TOT was at least the guide. I think Virgil / Gabriel were required, but beyond this:
Predicted thought process --> My thought process
Best captain: Fernandes --> So I go Salah
Best goalkeeper: Raya --> Try to have more ARS attack instead (Havertz / Eze / Rice)
Safe Liverpool minutes: Gakpo / Szobo / Wirtz --> Take the risk with Isak
Best of the rest: WHU DEF --> Go EVE attack (Ndiaye)
So yeah, I would have tinkered more (I basically ran out of time), and the whole team does feel a bit off for me, but I think this is just the part of me that is hard to quiet (knowing that in all likelihood I've made my position worse when I didn't have to) but I hope at least I've been able to explain my reasoning as to why I've done it.
Best of luck to you all this week
GW28: 89
Rank: 16
Fernandes was a clear captain for me this week as I also own Mbeumo (so I'm already betting on MUN to do well). If I had Semenyo instead I would have gone for Haaland. Timber over Andersen was for the same reason (a bet on ARS DEF).
I had 2 FTs and £2.8m ITB. That money was originally intended as an Enzo to Wirtz upgrade, but with his injury, I needed a new plan. There were a lot of other MIDs available but after looking at my team for a while I decided I was more worried about bench depth with the quick fixtures. Guiu *doesnt* blank in GW31, but he might as well considering he doesnt get onto the pitch.
As such, I decided to use the money ITB to upgrade Guiu to Ekiteke, which allowed to me to get a piece of the LIV attack like before, but also getting that deeper bench. Enabling this was Enzo to Stach (exact money). I had no intention of playing Stach this week v MCI, but thought that he was a decent cheap playing option after this week until WC time. My first bench then became Andersen and I was happy with this as he had higher xpts than Timber anyway.
For this coming gameweek I have 3 flagged players so only having 1 FT is not great, but this depth of bench is at least saving me a bit. If Rice is ruled out I will be looking to move him on for someone who plays in GW31. If hes ok, I'll try to roll the transfer and sell him GW31 to have a full playing 11. I'm not considering a Haaland to Salah switch as I don't have the free transfers for it.
Just say no outfield players allowed in 6 yard box before taking for set pieces. Keepers should be able to jump.
GW11: 52
Rank: 68
I had a few close decisions this week. Dubravka v Vicario in goal. Saka v Haaland for captaincy.
I solved the goalkeeping one by choosing the one who wasn't facing one of my attacking players (mentioned in a previous GW review)
The captaincy one can bring me to a deeper discussion.
I said in one of my responses to questions last week that I was likely to captain Saka, but that I thought Haaland was the slightly better choice.
So there are 2 questions:
1) Why did I change? (addressed here)
2) Why would I ever captain someone who I don't believe to be the best choice? (I'll cover this next GW)
The main takeaway / tldr is that close decisions don't matter (they are controlled by luck), but by the time the deadline came along, it was no longer as close.
We speak of FPL being a game that is a mixture of skill and luck. The skill portion is what do we do before the GW starts. How do we set our team up? And 90% of this skill benefit is going to be in the obvious things. Spending your money, playing your chips at the right time, picking players from good teams that start, replacing injured players, not taking lots of -4 hits, captaining your best player each week*. You can critique yourself based on these choices.
The luck aspect is then, what actual outcomes occur. This is never something to be upset / angry at yourself about. You're a team manager, not a player controller.
So we can't control what happens here, but we *can* control how much we are subjected to it, based on how different our team is from the next person. To win FPL / any game with a large player pool we want to be heavily subjected to luck to avoid being stuck in the crowd.
So to really simplify, Saka and Haaland had equal expected points earlier in the week, and this was giving an opportunity to have more risk / more 'luck' v the field when they would mostly be Haaland (c). However, by the time the deadline came around the EV difference was about 0.5 (which doubles to 1 when captained), and I deemed this to be too much of an EV / 'skill' sacrifice just for the sake of being different. (I will cover this in much more detail next GW).
Looking forwards with 2FT, Vicario remains an issue and I can now add Reijnders to that given his consecutive benchings. There are always possibilities of injuries during the international breaks so I won't make any early moves. Assuming injuries don't happen, I'm likely to try to maximise the value in my starting 11, and that would mean a goalkeeping transfer. I'm most likely to go to Petrovic, but Verbruggen or even Alisson if confirmed fit are options.
GW10: 79
Rank: 254
I wanted to bring in a 3rd ARS player this week and the obvious choice was a defensive one (I already had Saka and Gabriel). Players in my team that I wanted to move on here were Vicario (GK) and Pedro Porro (DEF).
TOT have been outperforming their expected data this season, their attack is in reality weak, unable to progress the ball through a midfield of Bentancur and Palhinha as they struggle to pass forwards. This hurts both in terms of attacking returns (for Porro), and defensive returns (clean sheets for both).
My original plan was to do the GK move as the cheapest route, but with Raya now up to £5.8 he was the same price as Calafiori, with Timber being £0.3 more (Saliba wasn't considered due to lack of attacking threat).
When we think about chasing upside (as we want to if we want very high ranks), with GKs we have saves and penalty saves, and with DEFs we have attacking returns and DEFCON. With a bad TOT attack, this hurts the upside of Porro more than it does Vicario so I decided on the DEF change.
On predicted points sites, Calafiori is (by far) the lowest rated in the ARS DEF, as his minutes are judged to be less secure. However, as long as hes starting and getting 60+ to reach the clean sheet points, this is ok. This can even be an advantage as he can lock in a clean sheet before being subbed and a goal against occurring. Where this would be bad is for any player we hope to get DEFCON points (doesn't apply here).
Given I no longer care about the minutes beyond 60 with this, the way I then compare them is to equalise their minutes to give me a realistic output of their attacking threat when both on the pitch. Once I do this, Calafiori has a small lead.
The real question is whether either he or Timber will be dropped at some point. How important are they to the first team this season? There are 2 ways to answer this.
The first, for people who actually like football, is to listen to people like nitter.cf/GrationHarvey who has done multiple youtube videos on their setup this season (they are both important).
The other way is to just pick them because they are currently starting and assume this will continue, only changing your view once you're proved wrong.
As a poker analogy, if I know that a player is going to mostly call all my bets, I should keep betting with all my good hands, and I should never bluff. If I know that they mostly fold when I bet, I should keep betting (bluffing) with all my weak hands. We should only stop this when we have proof that they have changed their strategy. We would say that by not doing this, you are leaving money on the table.
Or in football terms, if you have a corner routine that is working, it is *by far* the best strategy to use this *exact same routine every single time* until you see proof the opponent has adjusted. You already know it works. It annoys me when teams change their corner routine after scoring from the last one because most opponents will not make immediate adjustments (they have trained their defensive setup a certain way all week), and its only once they adjust this that the relative weakness in their setup will move elsewhere.
Given all this, I decided on Calafiori. However, if he and Timber had been exactly equal, how would I then choose? It would be, 1 - Who is cheapest? (so better value), 2 - What is the ownership? (I'd then choose the lower owned as the differential points are more valuable to me when upside chasing). In both cases Calafiori comes out on top here.
GW9: 49
Rank: 175
With the Gabriel doubt and Andersen continuing injury my 4th defender was likely to come into play. This was Konsa with the next 2 fixtures being MCI and LIV. As such I transferred him out to someone I could play for the next few weeks in Keane.
At the same time I moved out Kudus (who would now be playing against my new defender) for Enzo so I have a player across Chelsea's good fixtures.
The bench order I think is instructive. Porro, Reijnders, Mateta and Guiu (if you upped his minutes) all had roughly the same EV and I needed to play two.
Because I had Vicario in goal, Porro made sense to double up. Because I was captaining Haaland, Reijnders made sense to link up with him.
As I was starting Gabriel and he was the most likely to miss out, the ARS DEF could be weaker, and so in this scenario, Mateta coming on would work well. Guiu was then second bench.
If it had been a Saka injury worry instead of Gabriel, I would have had Guiu ahead of Mateta (who would be facing Gabriel).
This ordering isn't strictly the best EV wise (it's all equal there), but I think it maximised my skew to positive and negative which is what we want when we are aiming for high ranks rather than middling ones. In poker we would call it 'polarising your range' (where if you are betting you do it with just your best cards (to extract value) and worst hands (to bluff when you have no value), but I'm sure there is a better maths term to use that I'm forgetting.
The FPL page is slow to update so my screenshots are from fplgameweek today
7
57
23,693
GW8: 81 points
Rank: 112
With just the 1FT, I held onto 2x TOT DEF this week, delaying the decision of my 3rd ARS.
3 x TOT, Konsa and Andersen if injured long term are what I see as the issues in my team going forwards.
GW7: 78 points
Rank: 240
3/3 FTs:
Williams --> Gabriel
Anderson --> Semenyo
Salah --> Saka
Forests good fixtures came to an end last week so now was the time to move them on. I watched LIV midweek and Salah was confirmed as the sacrifice to free the funds.
Because of this, Saka was always going to come in for me ahead of Gyokeres (as I was removing 2 MIDs) and Mateta in any case isn't a priority sell.
GW6: 70 points
Rank: 207
My main decision was Andersen v Mateta. They were about equal EV. I lent towards DC over Pens. There was also the tiny factor of a Mateta blank slightly increasing my chances of a Salah CS point.
2
14
3,927
GW5: Dorgu --> Senesi
I've changed my plan a bit here. As part of justifying my WC3, it left me £0.1m in the bank and with Senesi likely rising tonight, I want to move off of a player I'm mostly benching for a player I want to hold long term before I'm priced out.
I was going to next play Dorgu (v SUN) in GW7, but Senesi can play then (v FUL) so the only downside is the free transfer opportunity cost.
This means I will bench both Porro and Reijnders this week rather than decide between them.
Some would say I should play one over Konsa given the AVL form, but I must play him v SUN having chosen him on WC.
Given I'm no longer starting Porro, I have the option to play Dubravka over Vicario (as I'm no longer playing into the double DEF), but I'm going to stick with Vicario for the - I have NFO players v Dubravka - reason I mentioned in my last post.
1
25
7,082
GW4: 75 points
Saved the free transfer this week, will likely do the same next unless there is injury news. I'm not worried about any of my players for now.
For next week, Dubravka is predicted more points than Vicario, and Reijnders more than Porro. They are both close. I'm likely to go against those choices and play the double TOT DEF.
This is mainly because I will be playing 2 NFO players (Anderson and Williams) and the small chance of an attacking return from either would be against Dubravka.
Once I decide I'm playing Vicario, the Porro double up is attractive as it lets me skew my risk (i.e. I can doubly benefit / lose out from a TOT clean sheet).
You can make the argument the Reijnders / Haaland double up does the same thing, but its lower probability. A DEF double up is almost always binary (i.e. clean sheet comes in or doesn't), whereas Haaland will often score or assist without Reijnders contributing)
24
5,182
GW3: 52 points
The injuries to Saka and Palmer hurt my early WC3 by becoming non-options and I ended up with a team that's going to have to try to tread-water a bit until it builds up some transfers.
Because some people will ask, - my non-WC team would have outscored this by 15 points (with the lucky triple Leeds clean sheet coming through v NEW). It would also have been well setup for a WC4, and able to go more heavily into LIV & ARS now that their game is out of the way, so a more favourable position overall.
A lot of people get emotional about FPL (or elsewhere) about things like this (or points players score). You have to try to let it go to minimise the downside. You can only control your own reaction to the situations you find yourself in. The real masters of this will be able to ride the highs fully whilst brushing off the lows. I'll do a separate post on this at some point when I have a bad week.
But yeah, for me, having already confirmed the WC and then having the injuries happen, I think I played it as well as I could.
A big part of Dorgus inclusion was for GW3 so it was disappointing he didn't play. He was 100% to play in the predicted lineups and I'm not going to pretend I'd know better than them so I don't regret the choice.
My team isn't *bad*, but its going to be slightly worse than most non-WC teams for the time being as it can't orient itself around a future WC or FH, and its still some transfers away those long term players I wanted.
It's still been a great start otherwise and I'd take the points I have now over having the 3 chips available.
4
41
5,299
GW3: Wildcard
This was tricky. I activated immediately after the start of GW2 as having lost 0.1 on Paqueta, Fullkrug was falling that night. I also moved some players in to try and catch price rises.
I wasnt concerned about playing the WC before international break / transfer window closing as I would be moving to fully guaranteed players who wouldn't be sold or displaced from the team.
But then both Palmer and Saka (the main pieces of my planned wildcard) got injured. Had I not made transfers and activated already, I would have cancelled it.
The main question now was, do I redistribute the planned Saka / Palmer money (that was in one of Haaland / Salah before) or not (so I can do the same plan later)
I think the most sensible way to redistribute would have been to take out Haaland, and bring in 3 of Gyokeres / Mateta / Pedro / Wood and plan to play them every week.
But if I cant have the midfield I want, then I want Haaland in GW6 and it would be hard to get him back for that (I've already used my FH). Gyokeres has poor fixtures for now, Pedro is a rotation risk with Delap, Woods fixtures are mixed.
There is also the idea that I've gained 0.1 on Haaland and by keeping him I have a chance to get another rise before selling down the line.
As such, I kept him, and spread the money around in defence instead (instead of having 4.0s like Esteve or Rodon) on the bench (I have already used BB).
I kept Kudus and Reijnders in midfield for the same price rise reasons. Georginio was sold due to injury (and value loss), Ekiteke and Gakpo I couldn't consider keeping with the Isak transfer possibility.
Palmer and Saka will now have to wait until GW7 (after Haalands GW6), by which time I will hopefully have some transfers to use.
14
2,645




























