As a 9 year old I would ride my bike miles from home across busy streets and along the bayous in Houston. It was like a bike highway for kids and you could go anywhere. Nobody even asked any questions when you got home.
1
27
I was writing about AI for Development when I realized I needed to lay the groundwork first. Why is development so bad at thinking through AI impacts? Because it mostly happens inside firms, which they weren't built to engage with. c0unterfactual.substack.com/…
14
Saying things like a trillion IQ is really just such stupid sales pitch nonsense. There are certainly natural limits to intelligence, IQ is a human measure that won’t even really apply to machines in key dimensions.
Sam Altman says he'd rather have a trillion slightly superhuman AIs join society than one AI with a trillion IQ
"I would much rather intuitively have a trillion AIs of slightly superhuman intelligence join society than one AI of 1 trillion IQ join society"
"I do think the properties of swarms match a lot of the properties of the resilience of society, or the robustness of society"
"For all of the deep flaws of society, it is unbelievably robust. And this would not happen without a lot of people keeping each other in check"
"There are a lot of people who may have a different opinion about how it should be used. But this is the one that I think is right"
1
40
A world where AI shops employed anyone who took a philosophy of science class would know things like this and not delude itself that AI is anywhere near fixing it.
Dreams of AI ending aging and of AI killing everyone through a purely in-silico-designed pandemic both rely on this fallacy.
It's understated here how much we lack ground truth data about what's happening inside of cells, or sensors to get that data. A single cell contains billions of protein molecules, across at least thousands of types, and at least trillions of interactions per second.
Think we solved protein folding? We've made enormous progress predicting static protein structures. But these proteins constantly change their conformation and interact with one another, often in ways we can't observe or model accurately.
Our best sensors capture a miniscule fraction of the activity in a living cell, orders of magnitude short of what's happening.
We actually lack the ability to perceive what's going on that would be required to build such a bottoms up simulation.
Let alone to scale this up to an organism or a global population.
We know we have an expanding universe not because of breakthroughs in theory or computation - but because Edwin Hubble got new data by looking through the Hooker telescope. Possibly the greatest mind, Einstein, was wrong in his model of the universe because he lacked the right instrument to bring him the right data.
That's where we are in biology. Our sensors are still so crude. No amount of pure computation or AI can build a perfect model.
We need an instrument revolution in biology, not just a computational or intelligence revolution. AI can generate hypotheses, but without sufficient ground truth data, we can't know whether our simulations are modeling reality.
1
56
It amazes me how hard it is for people to believe that we just won’t let the worst outcomes of AI doom happen. Game theory taught me that equilibriums nobody wants are not stable. Humans use power to oppose things they hate. It’s as reliable as gravity.
1
1
28
An under appreciated part of the AI bubble is how much loss there is translating genuine innovation into commercial viability. Most innovation is economically useless. Building a business around it is much harder than the discovery.
I’m really curious how big the market will actually be for true “frontier” intelligence.
What does it say, for example, that there are brilliant physics PhDs for whom a tenure-track position at Calgary A&M is actually a good career outcome?
21
My lastest piece: Wild Partisans of Flesh and Blood: On Meaning and Misery in an Age of AI. c0unterfactual.substack.com/…
21
Im begging people who think like this to have some self respect for our species. There is a categorical firewall to the nature of human beings that should stop you well before you get here.
Replying to @undeservingfut
As the video illustrates (did you watch it?) we know they are both evolved to predict their environment, and both using loosely similar structures, and both able to "learn" the same things.
That should at least give you pause and make you even 0.1% uncertain.
24
One thing AI should absolutely do for us is allow us to test our ideas outside of areas of our own deep expertise just to see what we might be ignorant of. This slide would have raised several red flags from any AI model.
This is a slide from Terence Tao's 'Math 2.0' public lecture yesterday evening at Caltech. I am highly confident that, if the cure actually worked, almost any Stage 4 cancer patient would tell you that human comprehension of its mechanism is completely irrelevant to them.
27
The AI Math news just highlights for me how many impacts on humans this tech is going to have that nobody building it has even given a moments thought. The socio-economic impacts will be so vast and nobody is preparing for that in any meaningful way.
1
27
This makes me think the AI Founders thing @coeff_giving is doing needs to add a Political Economy of Post Scarcity Institute (PEPSI lol) to its list of projects. That I might be interested in founding!
13
Why does the world do development backwards? Development institutions started with backwards assumptions about how development happens and have never really changed course. c0unterfactual.substack.com/…
13
Today I wrote about the closure of the Aspen Network of Development Entrepreneurs, which I led for 3 years and worked at for 9. There is much left to do in advancing this work that has the potential to lift many millions out of poverty: linkedin.com/posts/devin-che…
1
60
If anybody knows @JustinSandefur tell him to read my Launchpad Fund EOI on this subject. I've used GiveWell's template to model BDS services using real data and and a thorough review of academic findings and it could plausibly be a 10x+ cash level intervention.
13
Ohtani Day is going to be so much worse than Bobby Bonilla Day.
Exclusive @TheAthletic: Shohei Ohtani will defer $68 million per year of his $70 million annual salary over the course of his 10-year, $700 million deal with the Dodgers, allowing the team to keep spending, according to a person briefed on the terms.
theathletic.com/5129506/2023…
289
People who didn’t live through the 1970s and never actively studied it in an academic course can’t really understand how individual actors didn’t unilaterally write world history by their personal volition.
Critics and sycophants of Henry Kissinger are both overstating his individual personal responsibility for things that happened in the 1970s.
197

















