Pinned Tweet
ICYMI: article on Covenant Theology
What Does Same in Substance but Different in Administration Mean?
"Understanding the proper meaning of the Reformed formula helps us to see that the modern notion of what is now called โadministrative republicationโ is incoherent"
Link below
The Marrow controversy is often caricatured as good guys vs bad guys with Hadow being the leader of the bad guys, theologically speaking.
However, James Buchanan writes:
"We are not warranted, indeed, to say that Principal Hadow, and those who concurred with him in
Did The Marrow contain certain Antinomian errors?
James Buchanan:
"...we shall only say, that a book which is held even by its admirers to require explanatory or apologetic notes, may be fairly presumed to contain some unguarded expressions, which might be understood in
Although Ball is willing to use the phrase "Do this and live" in reference to the CW, he doesn't engage in eisegesis and read the CW into texts where it doesn't belong.
Ball has long been one of my favorites.
See the link below for an short article on Do This and Live:
๐๐จ๐ก๐ง ๐๐๐ฅ๐ฅ ๐จ๐ง ๐ฐ๐ก๐ฒ โ๐๐จ ๐ญ๐ก๐ข๐ฌ ๐๐ง๐ ๐ฅ๐ข๐ฏ๐โ ๐๐ง๐ โ๐๐ก๐ ๐๐จ๐๐ซ๐ฌ ๐จ๐ ๐ญ๐ก๐ ๐๐๐ฐ ๐๐ซ๐ ๐ฃ๐ฎ๐ฌ๐ญ๐ข๐๐ข๐๐โ ๐๐ซ๐ ๐ญ๐จ ๐๐ ๐ซ๐๐๐ ๐๐ฌ ๐๐จ๐ฌ๐ฉ๐๐ฅ, ๐ง๐จ๐ญ ๐๐๐ฐ
Below I will post the full excerpt which may be found from his influential magnum opus โA Treatise of the Covenant of Graceโ (forthcoming print by @BerithPress), which shaped the distinct, Westminsterian covenant theology. Some key takeaways (full text attached below):
- The Mosaic Covenant being gracious, unlike the covenant of works, admits and allows of imperfect, sincere obedience. As such โDo this and liveโ is an evangelical principle for the covenanted Israel, not legal โ โWe may soundly gather, that the Law as it was given to Israel, doth admit and allow of sincere and unpartiall obedience, though it be imperfect and answer not to that exactnesse which is required. These words, โDoe this and live,โ must not be interpreted, as if they did promise life upon a condition of perfect obedience, and for works done in such exactnesse as is required: but they must be expounded Evangelicallyโ
- The same applies to the writing of St. Paul. The doers of the Law being justified is not preaching of Law strictly, but of the Gospel such that we can and must do it โ โAnd in like manner that of the Apostle, โThe doers of the Law are justified,โ may be expounded Evangelically, not of them that fulfill the Law, which should be justified by their works, but of them that soundly obey, who are justified of grace by faith, not for their worksโ
- Those covenanted in the covenant of grace have a moderated standard since God deals with them not strictly but paternally โ โto them that be in Covenant the Law was given with such moderation, that sincere obedience was accepted of them, though attended with many imperfections, as is cleare by that of the Psalmistโ
- Israel themselves when covenanting with God did not understand themselves to be agreeing to exactly and strictly fulfill the law (for this is impossible and would be a non-starter) โ โAnd when [Israel] promised, and bound themselves by Oath to walk in all the Statutes, Judgements, and Ordinances of the Lord, or of the Law of Moses, they did neither pervert the sense of the Law, nor promise punctually to fulfill the Law in every jot and title. Therefore they understood the tenour of the Law as it was given unto them, to admit of upright, unfained and true obedience, the imperfection that cleaveth unto their best works being graciously
pardoned.โ
"we cannot be saved from sin while we still desire and intend to continue to sin. If we are to escape God's wrath and curse, we must turn from our sins to God."
J.G. Vos
Kline:
"The works principle in the Mosaic order was confined to the typological sphere...Even individuals who were elect in terms of eternal salvation would be cut off from that temporal, typological realm as the penalty for various serious infractions of the law."
By contrast, according to Klinean "republication," the law's principle of works applied to all Israel, regenerate and unregenerate alike.
Hence, it can't be republication of the covenant of works. It must be something else.
191
"But a justified Christian who is assured of his salvation in Christ Jesus ought also to have a healthy fear of the warnings against apostasy and thus final damnation."
From the 3rd article I wrote for MTP back in the day: Sanctification by Faith in the Threatenings
Link below:
1
11
466
Tip of the day:
Don't rip Scripture out of context so that you can use it to put believers under the covenant of works.
6
269
โthey [believers] are also confident that their acts of obedience, although they are immature and still not perfect, do not displease their benevolent Father, but are acceptable to him in his love.โ
-Synopsis Purioris
12
415
So, apparently you shouldn't "expand" the term "antinomianism." That is a sign of nomism.
But what is it a sign of if you expand the term "neonomianism," which you must do to pin that label on people like Piper?
1
29
803
If you want to know what Neonomianism is historically, then see here:
placefortruth.org/neonomianiโฆ
1
2
243
By contrast, according to Klinean "republication," the law's principle of works applied to all Israel, regenerate and unregenerate alike.
Hence, it can't be republication of the covenant of works. It must be something else.
True.
And Klinean republication isnโt a form of republication for the simple reason that it doesnโt republish the covenant of works.
1
9
615
Interesting observation from Francis Beattie:
What is the relationship between faith and repentance according to the Westminster Standards?
Here is something to consider:
1. Faith and repentance are both defined as a saving grace wrought in the heart of a sinner by the Holy Spirit and the word of God.
2
7
461
Matt Bustin is a great guy, and his pumpkin carvings are fantastic!
Pumpkin carving artist honours Dolly Parton with Jack-oโ-lantern portrait ctvnews.ca/atlantic/nova-scoโฆ
201












