Dan Wrightman (@dwrightman) profile picture
Joined April 2011
Photo by Dan Wrightman (@dwrightman)Photo by Dan Wrightman (@dwrightman)Photo by Dan Wrightman (@dwrightman)Photo by Dan Wrightman (@dwrightman)Photo by Dan Wrightman (@dwrightman)Photo by Dan Wrightman (@dwrightman)Photo by Dan Wrightman (@dwrightman)Photo by Dan Wrightman (@dwrightman)Photo by Dan Wrightman (@dwrightman)Photo by Dan Wrightman (@dwrightman)
Dan Wrightman retweeted
In the words of Germany's Minister of Energy: "The phaseout of nuclear was a huge mistake, a huge mistake and we miss this energy." Yet many ideological voices in Canada still champion this policy path and insist we repeat history. By closing its nuclear plants, Germany lost 20 GW of 24/7 emissions-free generating capacity at affordable prices. That's nearly enough generating capacity to meet the average electricity demand of a country the size of Poland. Ontario can not afford to make that same mistake.
Germany is preparing to reactivate its coal-fired power plants as a gas shortage looms. Maybe blowing up one of its biggest coal-fired power plants last year wasn't such a great idea... The plant: - Was only 6 years old when it shut down - Cost €3 billion to build - Had 1,650 MW of generating capacity - Blowing it up cost another few million Germany is doing everything in its power to create a perpetual energy crisis.
19
25
2
108
6,100
Dan Wrightman retweeted
[Hydro Quebec] "says it is dealing with its four driest consecutive years since hydrological data began to be compiled in the 1940s." gas into "green" alchemy continues: ON imports to US exports theglobeandmail.com/business…
7
6
21
4,176
Dan Wrightman retweeted
After 17 years, is the contaminated well water in Chatham-Kent fixed? NO. And now, @ONenvironment and Ontario govt proposing to delete key environmental protections for "renewable" energy projects via #bill140. Just in time for an @IESO_Tweets RFP. "This is not sand": the story of Chatham-Kent contaminated water continues - Wind Concerns Ontario share.google/iVHK1e3lGAwJUpw…
3
6
132
Dan Wrightman retweeted
Note that the Sir Adam Beck generating station at Niagara Falls was built in 1922. It’s over 100 years old, and its concrete experiences far more stress than anything at Pickering.
Replying to @ScottLuft
the big ending is given to an anti-nuke kook, but no concrete structure lasts 90 years? I bravely live on a waterway controlled by older dams upstream and downstream I’m okay with scaremongering about invisible radiation, but must we frighten those around the CN Tower? 8/9
1
3
31
760
Dan Wrightman retweeted
Matthew McClearn has [another] good column on Darlington nuclear GS today those with a subscription can read on the Globe and Mail site. good, imo, to see OPG's performance questioned, but there are a few issues I’ll address. #1-ffs: the refurb period was 10 years - not 20 1/9
1
6
1
28
2,053
Dan Wrightman retweeted
What makes Darlington's SMR cost & schedule overruns particularly galling is Canada's failure to think strategically in the national interest. Rather than investing in CANDU, we have committed billions in public financing to pioneer GE Vernova Hitachi Nuclear Energy's American BWRX-300, potentially creating a formidable U.S. competitor to future Canadian reactor exports. With OPG acknowledging a cost overrun, Canada's financial exposure is growing. The BWRX-300 benefits from Canadian generosity in the form of cheap public financing, avoiding the punishing commercial capital costs that have bedevilled nuclear construction elsewhere, most notably Britain's Hinkley Point C. Ottawa has committed up to $2 billion through the Canada Growth Fund, Ontario's Building Ontario Fund another $1 billion in equity & the Canada Infrastructure Bank $970 million in low-interest financing. Eligible expenditures can also benefit from the federal 15 percent Clean Electricity Investment Tax Credit. Ontario ratepayers finance the remainder. Canada is deploying the full weight of its public balance sheets to overcome two of nuclear construction's greatest obstacles: the cost of capital & the financial risks of building first. Yet this extraordinary industrial policy support is helping establish a U.S. reactor design rather than strengthening our own. If the BWRX-300 succeeds, GVH will have a commercially demonstrated reactor to market globally. Canadian suppliers may win export contracts & OPG could benefit from its pioneering experience. Yet OPG has a much stronger stake in CANDU, inheriting Ontario Hydro's design expertise & intellectual property interests arising from its historic collaboration with AECL at its Darlington CANDU plant. With the BWRX-300, GVH retains control of the core IP & international reactor-sales franchise, while Canadian taxpayers & electricity customers shoulder the financial risk. OPG deserves credit for securing exceptionally high Canadian content in the BWRX-300. But achieving that localization comes at a cost, requiring domestic manufacturers to qualify new components & develop capabilities for an unfamiliar U.S. design. Meanwhile, Canada's $26 billion nuclear refurbishment program has already revitalized a domestic CANDU supply chain. An Enhanced CANDU 6 at Darlington, which I tirelessly advocated for since 2024, could have leveraged those investments while establishing a modern reference plant to strengthen Canadian exports. The benefits, from IP & engineering expertise to future reactor sales, would have accrued far more substantially to Canada. Few countries with an indigenous nuclear industry would be so cavalier about financing a potential competitor. From aviation & telecommunications to AI & now nuclear, Canada has repeatedly failed to champion its own advanced technologies & capture their economic value. As we face a large reactor technology selection pitting the U.S. AP1000 against CANDU, we can't repeat this own goal. @Sflecce @fordnation @timhodgsonmt @melaniejoly @MarkJCarney @FP_Champagne @DLeBlancNB @PBethlenfalvy @PierrePoilievre @MaritStiles @jamiewestndp @tedhsu @Rae_Matt
🤖 Made with AI
6
15
1
77
3,200
Dan Wrightman retweeted
OPG Acknowledges the West’s First SMR is Behind Schedule Ontario Power Generation has acknowledged that “DNNP Unit 1 is no longer expected to achieve the previously disclosed commercial operation date target of October 2030 or be completed within the previously disclosed estimated cost of $7.7 billion.” OPG explicitly identifies unfinished engineering by GE Vernova Hitachi as the primary contributing factor, going on to say... “This reflects GE Vernova Hitachi Nuclear Energy's ongoing engineering for its first-of-a-kind SMR, which has impacts on construction execution and supply chain performance.” Detailed engineering is falling behind construction, causing costly delays, rework and lost productivity. These pressures are compounded by the departure of several senior engineers at a critical stage of the project, when GVH’s already stretched resources are needed most. Meanwhile, GVH is pursuing an expanding portfolio of projects, including Clinch River in Tennessee, where TVA aims to begin construction with a design more than 95% complete and benefit directly from lessons learned at Darlington. Ontario is thus absorbing the risks of pioneering the first BWRX-300 while the vendor prepares to deliver its successors. Having committed billions to pioneering an American reactor design, Ontario now depends on a foreign vendor whose scarce engineering resources are being pulled in competing directions. Ontario’s immediate priority must be getting Darlington back on track. GE Hitachi needs to hear an unequivocal message from Queen’s Park and Ottawa: completing the engineering required to deliver Canada’s first BWRX-300 must take precedence over the company’s expanding international ambitions. Canada is hardly powerless. OPG’s Integrated Project Agreement provides broad audit rights, performance-based financial incentives and contractual protections where project partners fail to meet the required standard of care. Ontario also retains substantial commercial leverage through three additional planned BWRX-300 reactors that have yet to reach final investment decision. The province should use this leverage to demand an independently verified engineering recovery plan, backed by dedicated senior personnel, binding delivery milestones and transparent reporting. Where contractual obligations have been breached, OPG should pursue the remedies available under its agreements. The larger lesson concerns the next generation of Canadian nuclear construction. Canada has deployed the full weight of its public balance sheets to establish the BWRX-300, an American reactor design, as an international commercial product. We cannot afford to repeat this naive arrangement with the Westinghouse Electric Company AP1000, committing billions of dollars and decades of energy planning to another foreign vendor whose scarce engineering resources and strategic priorities ultimately lie elsewhere. It is time to be Maîtres chez nous. Canada’s next reactors must be CANDU.
17
25
10
146
12,062
Dan Wrightman retweeted
I was involved in proofreading this doc for Edgardo. As is typical for him, this is top-shelf work, well worth the read! 👏
Nova Scotia’s proposed Wind West offshore energy project promises to transform the province into a major electricity exporter, yet its enormous scale, uncertain buyers, and rising costs raise serious questions about its economic viability “Atlantic Canada has seen this pattern before: large wind-powered visions, public money up front, and a pivot when buyers fail to materialize. Wind West deserves scrutiny in that light. It is a first-of-its-kind offshore wind project in Canada, built with other people’s money, with no guaranteed buyer, producing electricity for export at more than $200/MWh, plus about $70/MWh for new transmission to reach buyers. Each of those features is a risk, and federal taxpayers are being asked to carry it ….” In “Wind West: Nova Scotia’s offshore wind gamble with Ottawa’s money,” economist Edgardo Sepulveda (@E_R_Sepulveda) examines the project’s underlying assumptions, arguing that its projected costs are too optimistic, its export market too uncertain, and the electricity it generates will struggle to compete with cheaper, more reliable alternatives. Read full commentary here⬇️ macdonaldlaurier.ca/wind-wes…
3
6
23
785
Dan Wrightman retweeted
"The new federal plan acknowledges that electricity bills will still go up, maybe by a lot, but promises that increase will be more than cancelled out by lower costs for things like gasoline, natural gas and propane."
The Liberals pledge $52B more to double Canada’s electricity capacity by 2050. #Budget2026 thelogic.co/news/federal-bud…
5
2
1
14
434
Nuclear power? Hydro storage? What are Nova Scotia’s options for new 'cost-effective' electricity when the grid is maxed out? saltwire.com/nova-scotia/nuc…
5
3
7
1,876
Dan Wrightman retweeted
Very pleased to see @MLInstitute publish my data-intensive essay on Wind West, Nova Scotia's proposed offshore wind project.
Nova Scotia’s proposed Wind West offshore energy project promises to transform the province into a major electricity exporter, yet its enormous scale, uncertain buyers, and rising costs raise serious questions about its economic viability “Atlantic Canada has seen this pattern before: large wind-powered visions, public money up front, and a pivot when buyers fail to materialize. Wind West deserves scrutiny in that light. It is a first-of-its-kind offshore wind project in Canada, built with other people’s money, with no guaranteed buyer, producing electricity for export at more than $200/MWh, plus about $70/MWh for new transmission to reach buyers. Each of those features is a risk, and federal taxpayers are being asked to carry it ….” In “Wind West: Nova Scotia’s offshore wind gamble with Ottawa’s money,” economist Edgardo Sepulveda (@E_R_Sepulveda) examines the project’s underlying assumptions, arguing that its projected costs are too optimistic, its export market too uncertain, and the electricity it generates will struggle to compete with cheaper, more reliable alternatives. Read full commentary here⬇️ macdonaldlaurier.ca/wind-wes…
1
6
1
22
688
Dan Wrightman retweeted
“Atlantic Canada has seen this pattern before: large wind-powered visions, public money up front, and a pivot when buyers fail to materialize. Wind West deserves scrutiny in that light. It is a first-of-its-kind offshore wind project in Canada, built with other people’s money, with no guaranteed buyer, producing electricity for export at more than $200/MWh, plus about $70/MWh for new transmission to reach buyers. Each of those features is a risk, and federal taxpayers are being asked to carry it ….”
Nova Scotia’s proposed Wind West offshore energy project promises to transform the province into a major electricity exporter, yet its enormous scale, uncertain buyers, and rising costs raise serious questions about its economic viability “Atlantic Canada has seen this pattern before: large wind-powered visions, public money up front, and a pivot when buyers fail to materialize. Wind West deserves scrutiny in that light. It is a first-of-its-kind offshore wind project in Canada, built with other people’s money, with no guaranteed buyer, producing electricity for export at more than $200/MWh, plus about $70/MWh for new transmission to reach buyers. Each of those features is a risk, and federal taxpayers are being asked to carry it ….” In “Wind West: Nova Scotia’s offshore wind gamble with Ottawa’s money,” economist Edgardo Sepulveda (@E_R_Sepulveda) examines the project’s underlying assumptions, arguing that its projected costs are too optimistic, its export market too uncertain, and the electricity it generates will struggle to compete with cheaper, more reliable alternatives. Read full commentary here⬇️ macdonaldlaurier.ca/wind-wes…
6
19
2
61
3,262
Nova Scotia’s proposed Wind West offshore energy project promises to transform the province into a major electricity exporter, yet its enormous scale, uncertain buyers, and rising costs raise serious questions about its economic viability “Atlantic Canada has seen this pattern before: large wind-powered visions, public money up front, and a pivot when buyers fail to materialize. Wind West deserves scrutiny in that light. It is a first-of-its-kind offshore wind project in Canada, built with other people’s money, with no guaranteed buyer, producing electricity for export at more than $200/MWh, plus about $70/MWh for new transmission to reach buyers. Each of those features is a risk, and federal taxpayers are being asked to carry it ….” In “Wind West: Nova Scotia’s offshore wind gamble with Ottawa’s money,” economist Edgardo Sepulveda (@E_R_Sepulveda) examines the project’s underlying assumptions, arguing that its projected costs are too optimistic, its export market too uncertain, and the electricity it generates will struggle to compete with cheaper, more reliable alternatives. Read full commentary here⬇️ macdonaldlaurier.ca/wind-wes…
5
17
11
30
5,263
Dan Wrightman retweeted
Wind West has been advanced with almost no public discussion on the costs and benefits. Economist @E_R_Sepulveda lays out the facts, costs and regulatory pitfalls that await this ill-conceived project: “Wind West power at more than $200/MWh could only be resold at a loss.” macdonaldlaurier.ca/wind-wes…
43
87
13
200
7,763
Canada is one of only six countries in the world that can design, build and export its own nuclear reactor technology. At the heart of that competitive advantage is CANDU, Canada's only homegrown nuclear reactor technology. At a time when countries are racing to build sovereign nuclear capability, the question remains: will we invest in our own or import someone else's? In recent testimony before Parliament, @Dr_Keefer argues that choosing a reactor technology is about more than energy generation. It's a choice about retaining Canadian ownership, Canadian jobs, Canadian supply chains, and whether the economic benefits of nuclear investment stay here in Canada. As governments consider the next generation of nuclear projects, the opportunity is not simply to deploy nuclear power, but to reinforce a Canadian industry that can compete at global scale for decades to come. #ChooseCanadian #ChooseCANDU
Yesterday I appeared before the House of Commons Natural Resources committee to make the case for a Canadian nuclear industrial strategy centred on CANDU. As Washington mobilizes behind Westinghouse and the AP1000, Canada faces a defining choice: will we champion our own reactor technology or help build an American industrial enterprise with Canadian shareholders? My five-minute testimony is below. For the full transcript and deeper analysis, visit my Subst@ck, Decouple Media. Link in the comments.
12
20
416
Dan Wrightman retweeted
We’re giving new life to our 106-year-old Cameron Falls Generating Station, located near Thunder Bay. Happening now: The facility’s G7 unit is undergoing a major refurbishment, including the installation of new generator windings, a new runner, and rehabilitation of the existing turbine shaft – its first overhaul in more than 30 years. These upgrades will ensure about 25 more years of clean, reliable generation. Unit by unit, OPG continues to breathe new life into Ontario’s long-serving hydroelectric stations – an investment that will ensure clean power keeps flowing for our future. Learn more: bit.ly/4z3lOOT
2
5
14
627
Dan Wrightman retweeted
imo this is some quality reporting by Matthew McClearn, and exemplary tanking of actual thought from the ignorant yet pious Pembina [subscription: theglobeandmail.com/business… ]
1
8
1
15
1,289