Max Lee (@genomelee) header
Max Lee (@genomelee) profile picture

Love science; Hate overstatements

Boston, MA
Joined May 2016
Photo by Max Lee (@genomelee)Photo by Max Lee (@genomelee)Photo by Max Lee (@genomelee)
Max Lee retweeted
Science – debatably the #1 journal in the world – published a paper on a "virtual biotech" AI system this week but the authors never even test if it works well! all the evidence for its performance is 3 anecdotes the paper has no benchmark scores, no baselines, no replicates
21
42
10
335
40,223
If it's isn't obvious already, it is the end of papers as a measure of productivity, expertise or accomplishment. The odds of publishing in "glam" conferences & journals also very quickly approaches random & the time for gate keeping review increasing exponentially. 1/
31
78
20
748
109,677
In my latest column, I explain some of my reasons for being deeply skeptical about AI models that claim to understand DNA, genes, and genomes: stevensalzberg.substack.com/…
5
31
4
153
16,651
bro...
Repeat after me. FUCK citation counts. Just do meaningful work that you enjoy, do a great job making it accessible and present it honestly so folks can use it and build on it optimally. That's it.
88
461
81
7,568
1,066,071
Max Lee retweeted
no thank you but we will buy twitter for $9.74 billion if you want
11,388
16,783
6,026
216,750
33,775,801
Is this real, or is it excessive AI hype? New paper claims that an AI foundation model achieves experimental-level accuracy in predicting gene expression even in previously unseen cell types." I'll read the paper, but don't believe it for a second nature.com/articles/s41586-0…
13
60
2
415
62,788
I don't really see the point in bragging about total citation counts. They're largely a measure of how well-connected you are: how many of other people's high-profile papers you can get onto as a middle author. Brag about what you've done, not your metrics.
phew! after a dip last year, my citations in 2024 surpassed my previous high year, 2022, by just a bit (and maybe more as Google Scholar updates during the first month of 2025).
1
4
366
Replying to @pmddomingos
Your online rhetoric has been utterly offensive and violates the ethical standards of academic institutions and professional associations. I hope @AAAS and @RealAAAI take action to revoke your fellowship.
1
3
268
The #NobelPrize in Physics 2024 for Hopfield & Hinton turns out to be a Nobel Prize for plagiarism. They republished methodologies developed in #Ukraine and #Japan by Ivakhnenko and Amari in the 1960s & 1970s, as well as other techniques, without citing the original inventors. None of the important algorithms for modern AI were created by Hopfield & Hinton. Today I am releasing a detailed tech report on this [NOB]: people.idsia.ch/~juergen/phy… Of course, I had it checked by neural network pioneers and AI experts to make sure it was unassailable. Is it now acceptable for me to direct young Ph.D. students to read old papers and rewrite and resubmit them as if they were their own works? Whatever the intention, this award says that, yes, that is perfectly fine. Some people have lost their titles or jobs due to plagiarism, e.g., Harvard's former president [PLAG7]. But after this Nobel Prize, how can advisors now continue to tell their students that they should avoid plagiarism at all costs? It is well known that plagiarism can be either "unintentional" or "intentional or reckless" [PLAG1-6], and the more innocent of the two may very well be partially the case here. But science has a well-established way of dealing with "multiple discovery" and plagiarism - be it unintentional [PLAG1-6][CONN21] or not [FAKE,FAKE2] - based on facts such as time stamps of publications and patents. The deontology of science requires that unintentional plagiarists correct their publications through errata and then credit the original sources properly in the future. The awardees didn't; instead the awardees kept collecting citations for inventions of other researchers [NOB][DLP]. Doesn't this behaviour turn even unintentional plagiarism [PLAG1-6] into an intentional form [FAKE2]? I am really concerned about the message this sends to all these young students out there. REFERENCES [NOB] J. Schmidhuber (2024). A Nobel Prize for Plagiarism. Technical Report IDSIA-24-24. people.idsia.ch/~juergen/phy… [NOB+] Tweet: the #NobelPrize in Physics 2024 for Hopfield & Hinton rewards plagiarism and incorrect attribution in computer science. It's mostly about Amari's "Hopfield network" and the "Boltzmann Machine." nitter.cf/SchmidhuberAI/status/1… (1/7th as popular as the original announcement by the Nobel Foundation) [DLP] J. Schmidhuber (2023). How 3 Turing awardees republished key methods and ideas whose creators they failed to credit. Technical Report IDSIA-23-23, Swiss AI Lab IDSIA, 14 Dec 2023. people.idsia.ch/~juergen/ai-… [DLP+] Tweet for [DLP]: nitter.cf/SchmidhuberAI/status/1… [PLAG1] Oxford's guide to types of plagiarism (2021). Quote: "Plagiarism may be intentional or reckless, or unintentional." web.archive.org/web/20211227… [PLAG2] Jackson State Community College (2022). Unintentional Plagiarism. [PLAG3] R. L. Foster. Avoiding Unintentional Plagiarism. Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing; Hoboken Vol. 12, Iss. 1, 2007. [PLAG4] N. Das. Intentional or unintentional, it is never alright to plagiarize: A note on how Indian universities are advised to handle plagiarism. Perspect Clin Res 9:56-7, 2018. [PLAG5] InfoSci-OnDemand (2023). What is Unintentional Plagiarism? [PLAG6] Copyrighted.com (2022). How to Avoid Accidental and Unintentional Plagiarism (2023). Copy in the Internet Archive. Quote: "May it be accidental or intentional, plagiarism is still plagiarism." [PLAG7] Cornell Review, 2024. Harvard president resigns in plagiarism scandal. 6 January 2024. [FAKE] H. Hopf, A. Krief, G. Mehta, S. A. Matlin. Fake science and the knowledge crisis: ignorance can be fatal. Royal Society Open Science, May 2019. Quote: "Scientists must be willing to speak out when they see false information being presented in social media, traditional print or broadcast press" and "must speak out against false information and fake science in circulation and forcefully contradict public figures who promote it." [FAKE2] L. Stenflo. Intelligent plagiarists are the most dangerous. Nature, vol. 427, p. 777 (Feb 2004). Quote: "What is worse, in my opinion, ..., are cases where scientists rewrite previous findings in different words, purposely hiding the sources of their ideas, and then during subsequent years forcefully claim that they have discovered new phenomena."
How 3 Turing awardees republished key methods and ideas whose creators they failed to credit. More than a dozen concrete AI priority disputes under people.idsia.ch/~juergen/ai-…
104
395
128
2,703
1,003,010
Winning the @NobelPrize is the honour of a lifetime and the realisation of a lifelong dream - it still hasn’t really sunk in yet. With AlphaFold2 we cracked the 50-year grand challenge of protein structure prediction: predicting the 3D structure of a protein purely from its amino acid sequence. Proteins are the building blocks of life, and knowing the structure of a protein is crucial for understanding the function it performs. We then folded all 200 million proteins known to science and made those structures freely available for anyone in the world to use, with the help of our wonderful collaborators at @emblebi. Over 2 million researchers have already used AlphaFold2 and its predictions to advance a huge range of important work - everything from enzyme design, to disease understanding, to drug discovery. But this is only the beginning. Over the next few years AI will help us make great strides towards developing new and more effective therapies for today's most prevalent diseases, and the fantastic team at @IsomorphicLabs are making rapid progress on this mission. I can’t think of a more important or beneficial use of AI. Then of course there is advancing AGI itself, the original and enduring goal, and the vision behind the founding of DeepMind nearly 15 years ago. If AI is built safely and responsibly, I believe it will be one of the most transformative and beneficial technologies ever. I’ve always thought of AI as the ultimate tool to help us accelerate scientific discovery. Congratulations to John Jumper (and David Baker!), the amazing AlphaFold team, and all our incredible colleagues at @GoogleDeepMind and @Google that supported and encouraged us along the way - this award is for all of us! It’s been such an honour and privilege to work with all of you to advance the frontiers of AI and science, and there is so much more to come!
BREAKING NEWS The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2024 #NobelPrize in Chemistry with one half to David Baker “for computational protein design” and the other half jointly to Demis Hassabis and John M. Jumper “for protein structure prediction.”
372
885
95
8,696
952,784
In science you can be a complete, ruinous asshole one day and then show up at a conference and everyone acts like nothing happened.
19
31
11
474
96,448
As a former journal EIC, I want to take issues with this claim by Science's EIC that negative interactions between scientists and editors are driven by a lack of respect for people who don't run research labs.
5
41
4
300
123,897
Now Online Transcription regulation by long non-coding RNAs: mechanisms and disease relevance dlvr.it/T1c6rD
81
4
228
50,942
Just published @ScienceMagazine A #LongCovid underpinning & potential biomarker Impressive multicenter, prospective study demonstrates persistent complement activation, pro-clotting + inflammation; severity of symptoms associated with virus reactivation (CMV, EBV) @carlo_cervia
2
393
17
1,064
163,086
Some of these consortia are great; but this one seems to be a waste of taxpayer's $$$. Multiomic integration has been done widely already, and it's unclear what the innovations are here with all these established assays.
Today I had the pleasure to give opening remarks at NHGRI’s Multiomics Kickoff Meeting! This is part of a new program in multi-omics that aims to study how use multiple types of “omics” data (e.g., genomics, epigenomics, transcriptomics, proteomics and metabolomics) in research.
1
77
So senior male scientists here back to ad hominems and publicly disparaging what is perfectly fine science. Imperfect? Sure. Do they deserve public insults? No especially for the trainee. Shameful.
2
3
30
13,546
If you’re interested in how #AI will reshape healthcare in the large language model era 🧵
Our @Nature paper on Foundation models (aka Large Language, Generative #AI, such as #GPT4) for medicine was just published nature.com/articles/s41586-0… @Michael_D_Moor @pranavrajpurkar @ZahraShakerii @jure @hmkyale
4
32
2
94
62,029
For the "it's a cold" and "the pandemic is over" folks
671
1,467
166
4,645
1,566,211
No one deserves that much funding for one grant. This is absurd on so many levels. It's a policy failure and a waste of taxpayers money!!! Think about how many R01s can be funded with that number and how much real science can be advanced! @NIH @USBrainAlliance