
ALT IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF MISSISSIPPI ) UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ) v. ) MISSISSIPPI STATE SENATE, ) COMPLAINT Plaintiff, the United States of America, respectfully alleges: 1. The United States brings this action against Defendant Mississippi State Senate to enforce Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, as amended, 42 U.S.C. §§ 2000e, et seq. (“Title VII”). Defendant discriminated against attorney Kristie Metcalfe based on her race (Black), in violation of Title VII, by paying her a much lower salary than her white colleagues during her eight years as a staff attorney for the Senate’s Legislative Services Office. Defendant consistently paid Metcalfe $40,000 to $60,000 less than its lowest-salaried white attorney (at times, paying her less than half of what it paid any of her other white colleagues) even though she and the white attorneys were doing the same jobs with the same levels of responsibility.

ALT 13. When Defendant hired Metcalfe in 2011, she was the LSO’s only Black attorney. The other four full-time staff attorneys and the LSO Office Director were white. 14. For at least 34 years before Metcalfe’s hire in 2011, Defendant employed only white attorneys in the LSO, and, during Metcalfe’s entire eight-year LSO tenure (2011-2019), all of the other LSO attorneys were white. 15. Defendant set Metcalfe’s starting salary at $55,000. 16. Metcalfe’s starting salary was significantly lower than what Defendant paid all of its white incumbent attorneys at that time. Defendant paid Jeff Rosamond and Caryn Quilter $95,550 each, Larry Richardson $113,322, Bubba Neely $114,768, and Bob Davidson $121,800. Defendant’s starting salary for Metcalfe was thus less than 60% of what it paid the next closest white attorneys even though the work Metcalfe was being hired to do was substantially the same as that of her white colleagues.

ALT A quote from New Yorker staff writer Jelani Cobb, that says: “The difficult lesson in that history is that, while further progress is possible, we should not underestimate how arduous it will be to achieve, or how long it will take. We believed that we had broken with history, but it is apparent that history has, in fact, broken some part of us.”





























