Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
To update my slide decks for my course “The Political Economy of Early America,” I picked up the latest edition of a mainstream U.S. college history textbook I had used before as source material. (I have no wish to start a fight, so no names; suffice it to say the book is as mainstream as mainstream gets.) I wanted to check whether I was missing any recent developments in scholarship or shifts in coverage.
I was struck by how much the prose and content had been dumbed down. In places, it truly read like a middle-school textbook. I went back to the older editions I had kept, and a side-by-side comparison from 2000 forward shows a clear deterioration with each revision. In 2000, students were reading a serious work. The current edition is not.
As an economist, I suppose I should not be surprised. Four rational agents shape the outcome, and not one of them has any reason to defend quality.
The publisher maximizes revenue per student, not learning. Simpler prose and lighter material may reduce what students learn, but they raise adoption rates: instructors find the book “easier to teach with” and students complain less. Learning outcomes are an externality.
The instructor worries about teaching evaluations and grade inflation. Assign an easy textbook, and students are content; you hand out A’s to most of them, and your workload drops. The instructor who assigns the harder book and earns lower evaluations bears a private cost for a public good. A textbook collective action problem.
The student, given limited information, optimizes for the grade rather than for human capital accumulation. If the exam tests recall from a simplified textbook, the simplified textbook is the rational choice. The cost of shallow learning surfaces only years later, too distant and diffuse to weigh much on today’s decision.
The university cares about retention and graduation rates, not about what anyone learns. A textbook that cuts the failure rate in introductory courses looks good on those metrics, even when it achieves the cut by lowering the bar.
The result is what one would predict: a steady decline in textbook quality that no rational agent in the chain has any motive to reverse.
The only way forward is to break the collective action problem: get universities to curb grade inflation (I am open to suggestions on how; caps on A’s bring their own troubles) and to care about what students learn, rather than about some inane comment on a teaching evaluation.
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
Very happy that our paper received the DFA Prize for Best Paper in the Journal of Finance.
The literature on wealth inequality has been highly influential in public debates, yet it largely ignores a key way households save over the life cycle: Social Security.
We show that including the fair value of accrued benefits in wealth substantially mutes the rise in wealth inequality since 1989.
Its importance has grown dramatically over the past three decades. In 1989, Social Security represented only 26.0% of the wealth of the bottom 90%. In 2019, this percentage rose to 49.8%. We cannot understand household balance sheets without paying attention to Social Security.
🧵🚨Accepted paper🧪
with @mjmill611 (Harvard) and @NatashaRSarin (Yale)
Existing studies paint an incomplete picture of trends in wealth inequality in the US. When Social Security is properly accounted for, wealth inequality has not really increased over the past three decades.
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
Our excellent conversation with @ben_golub is dropping tomorrow in all fine podcast players. Here's Ben discussing the implications of economic theory slop, and why some economists are reacting like artists rather than scientists.
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
After the excitement of last week, I have decided to change the background photo of my profile to a screenshot of the definition of recursive competitive equilibrium with Arrow securities from Section 12.9, page 495 of Recursive Macroeconomic Theory, by Lars Ljungqvist and Thomas J. Sargent, fourth edition (the yellow one).
I picked this equilibrium because I have always fancied recursive equilibria more than sequential competitive or Arrow–Debreu equilibria, even if in this economy all three of them are equivalent. Nothing deeper than personal taste.
Also, it is a great way to illustrate the “Big K, little k” device, which I often use in my papers.
Obviously, this equilibrium is dynamic and stochastic, and, depending on the specifications of preferences and technology, may or may not be unique, stable, efficient, or have a steady state.
You define an equilibrium like Lars Ljungqvist and Thomas J. Sargent do. Period.
That settles it, and there is no further debate to be had.
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
A guide for students of economics: Ten statements that demonstrate that someone does not understand modern economics or what an equilibrium is, and that you can safely ignore everything else they say.
1. “Equilibrium means the economy is stable or at rest.”
Many assume that an equilibrium is a peaceful state with no forces at play. Instead, an equilibrium is just an arrangement of actions and expectations over time that are mutually consistent. It can be locally unstable, explosive, or fragile. Nothing in the definition of equilibrium implies stability.
2. “Equilibrium implies optimality or social efficiency.”
Equilibrium is often conflated with efficiency, but equilibrium merely reflects decentralized consistency, not welfare maximization. Market power, externalities, incomplete markets, nominal rigidities, and frictions routinely produce inefficient equilibria. I often teach a first-year macro graduate course, and not a single one of the equilibria I define is efficient.
3. “Equilibrium is a unique outcome.”
Many often expect models to have one equilibrium. In reality, multiple equilibria arise naturally in dynamic, strategic, and incomplete-market environments. Models of coordination failures, self-fulfilling expectations, bubbles, overlapping generations, and liquidity traps all hinge on the existence of equilibrium multiplicity.
4. “Equilibrium requires perfect foresight or perfect information.”
Equilibrium does not assume agents know the future. In fact, equilibria are often stochastic. The definition of equilibrium only requires that beliefs are consistent with the (perceived) stochastic laws of motion implied by the model. Bayesian learning, noisy signals, ambiguity, and subjective uncertainty all fit well within an equilibrium framework, provided beliefs converge to an internally consistent (but possibly incorrect) distribution.
Bonus point: equilibria are compatible with agents having diverging beliefs that never converge to a single Dirac distribution.
5. “Real economies are rarely in equilibrium, so the concept is unrealistic.”
Equilibrium is not meant to describe the daily state of the world. It is a conceptual device used to understand the outcome of our models under the assumptions we make. Also, see point 1 above.
6. “Equilibrium requires agents to be fully rational in a psychological sense.”
Equilibrium only assumes internal consistency: agents optimize given preferences and constraints. It does not assume realism about human cognition. We can and do define equilibria in models with behavioral biases, bounded rationality, inattention, or rule-of-thumb behavior. We only need to ensure that the resulting actions and beliefs are mutually compatible.
7. “Equilibrium eliminates dynamics or learning.”
Equilibrium is sometimes misinterpreted as a static state in which nothing evolves. In fact, many equilibria are sequences of probability distributions over states driven by shocks, policy rules, and endogenous responses. Learning dynamics (Bayesian updating, adaptive rules, experience-based expectations) can occur within equilibrium if the evolution of beliefs is self-consistent.
8. “Equilibrium renders expectations unimportant.”
A common misconception is that equilibrium mechanically determines outcomes. In reality, expectations are often central: they determine investment, consumption, asset prices, and policy responses. Many equilibria differ only in their expectations. This is why communication, credibility, and forward guidance matter even in fully rational models.
9. “Equilibrium excludes policy intervention.”
Some interpret equilibrium as a laissez-faire concept. In fact, equilibrium analysis is the foundation of modern policy evaluation. Fiscal, monetary, and regulatory interventions work through equilibrium responses (prices, wages, interest rates, quantities) and must satisfy equilibrium conditions to be credible. Equilibrium is a tool for policy design, not a barrier to it.
10. “Equilibriums…”
Aequilibrium is a Latin neuter noun of the second declension, which forms a nominative plural in “a”. It is composed of aequus (equal; the same root as equality or equity) and libra (balance or scales or the name of several currencies over history).
A final thought: “equilibrium” is a term of art. Its meaning in economics differs from its use in the natural sciences or in everyday language. Terms of art are ubiquitous across academic disciplines, and the first act of intellectual diligence when one starts studying a discipline is to learn what they mean.
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
"Our population is increasing approximately 7 times the EU average"
Jim O'Callaghan says foreign student visas could be reduced as part of an overall reduction in the crazy number of foreigners arriving here every year
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
If the assumptions are too restrictive, relax them.
If you cannot relax them bc the model becomes too difficult - by dropping the model you just think you understand but you do not - what you are doing is you are relaxing the logical consistency requirement so that you can reach conclusions which you do not know follow from assumptions.
Honestly, this post is an example of this, the argument is in effect logically faulty. It assumes the existence of a superior level of understanding as a self-evident fact without the need of any justification. In fact it assumes that this level of understanding is reachable just by loosening the logical constraints. But then by construction this is a lower level of understanding.
My main issue with the way economics is taught today is the obsession with understanding all aspects of the economy through mathematical models.
The result is that we're training economists who can build models but don’t properly understand the economy. It’s also isolating economics from other social sciences.
Don’t get me wrong — maths is very useful, but not when it comes at the expense of understanding the real economy. And, of course, it doesn't help that many of the models being taught are grounded in assumptions that aren't empirically verified.
I did a bachelor’s degree in (mainstream) economics. I learned a lot of statistics, econometrics, linear algebra, and calculus. It has served me well in many ways, but the degree was quite detached from what's happening in the real world.
It should be perfectly possible to teach maths alongside non-quantitative approaches to economics and adjacent social sciences.
Check out my newsletter if you want to read more about this (link in replies).
Research Ireland, on behalf of @DeptofFHed, has launched Global Talent Ireland, a prestigious programme to attract exceptional mid-career &established researchers to Ireland.
We at @SmurfitSchool are delighted to host applicants pursuing ambitious research.
#GlobalTalentIreland
Research Ireland, on behalf of @DeptofFHed, have launched Global Talent Ireland - a new initiative to attract exceptional mid-career and established researchers from across the globe to Ireland.
For more information visit:
researchireland.ie/funding/g…
1
129
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
Texting with a colleague at another uni who is mired in the AEA replication process. Wasting > month getting all in order so that some RA can just push one button and get all the data merges right so that the results are perfect to the 3rd decimal place.
1/5
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
👇Important thread. I agree with Toni.
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
📢 Can a single personal communication impact monetary policy uncertainty?
My research joint with @jarismen and @manoskyp and now published in Annals of Operation Research says yes!
📷 Read the full article here
link.springer.com/article/10…
📷 Listen sum
notebooklm.google.com/notebo…
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
We churn out more & more papers *per scientist*, at an increasing pace, in a rapidly changing publication landscape.
Why? How? Want to make sense of this?
In a new paper just published in Quantitative Science Studies we dive in & look for answers.
direct.mit.edu/qss/article/d…
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
Delighted that @ucddublin has been awarded the @Athena_SWAN institutional Silver Award in recognition of our work towards gender equality. Thanks to all who contribute to this effort across UCD, and in particular to @ColizScott, Emma Sokell, Marcellina Fogarty and all in @UCD_EDI
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
It was a pleasure to welcome Minister @CarrollJennifer to @ucddublin today and to hear her incisive and informed opening address at our Dignity and Respect Conference. @UCD_EDI
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
Please consider submitting your work to the 2024 workshop on Empirical Monetary Economics at @ofceparis in Paris on the 9th of December 2024
Keynote speaker: Jonathan Wright (Johns Hopkins)
Deadline: 15 September
@RefetGurkaynak @AnnaRogantiniPi
sites.google.com/site/worksh…
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
In my field, all of this harshness goes into producing top X% papers that are little better than data mining. arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10317. 🙁😢
This quoted post is unavailable.
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
Delighted to see this support from An Taoiseach @SimonHarrisTD and Minister @podonovan that will allow us to provide accommodation at below market rate @ucddublin. This will greatly benefit students that need it most.
Thanks to all in @dfheris who worked with us to achieve this.
Today, Minister @podonovan and I announced the funding to allow 493 new beds proceed in @ucddublin.
The State is now investing €100 million in student housing to deliver 1,000 beds.
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
This morning, Minister @mmcgrathtd met with @SpeakerPelosi, former Speaker of the US House of Representatives, and U.S. Ambassador to Ireland, Claire Cronin, where they discussed the US-Ireland economic and trade relationship, as well as broader geopolitical developments. 🇮🇪🇺🇸
Juan Arismendi-Zambrano retweeted
One of the many incredible things about Danny Kahneman: He was a joyful coauthor. Look at how many coauthors he had? His ideas often came from discussions. (When I was struggling to keep with the flood of ideas, all oral, he exclaimed, "Cass, you think by writing. I think by talking!")



































