Mike Murphy (@m_murfy) header
Mike Murphy (@m_murfy) profile picture

Technophile. Humanist. Bitcoin enthusiast. Doctor.

Ireland
Joined August 2010
BTC Mining Security: The Hash Power Nobody Talks About. Here's an interesting question that the BTC community seems remarkably reluctant to consider. How much mining capacity exists compared with how much is actually operating? The distinction matters enormously. Mining hardware is switched on when its expected revenue exceeds its operating costs. When electricity, difficulty and BTC prices make production unprofitable, equipment is switched off. It doesn't necessarily disappear. My assessment is that substantial dormant ASIC capacity exists, potentially several times the hash power currently securing BTC. I suspect the largest mining pools could each access capacity exceeding the present network hash rate. If the aggregate available capacity approaches 500% of the operating network, the security implications deserve serious attention. Because installed mining capacity and economically active mining capacity are not the same thing. Discounted Bitmain ASICs, secondary equipment markets and declining hardware prices can make additional capacity cheaper to acquire. And a network secured by proof of work depends on the economics of deploying hash power, not merely the number displayed on a mining dashboard. There is an important distinction between hardware ownership, pool coordination and actual control of mining equipment. Nevertheless, dormant capacity potentially available for redeployment changes the economics of attacking or reorganising a network. As mining revenues decline, the relationship becomes even more interesting. The network may continue adjusting difficulty while the economic cost of obtaining a significant proportion of its active hash rate falls. A network can maintain its block interval while becoming economically cheaper to attack. That is the question BTC investors should be examining. Not simply how much hash power is running today, but how much additional capacity exists, who can mobilise it, what it costs to operate and how quickly it could be deployed. The greatest security risk may not be the machines currently mining. It may be the economics of the machines sitting idle. And unlike the reassuring stories about permanent decentralisation, those economics can change very quickly.
1
5
1
43
1,586
BSV Starts Mattering When People Finally Understand That It Is a Commodity. One of the most ridiculous ideas to emerge from cryptocurrency is HODL. Imagine applying that philosophy to an actual commodity market. A natural gas trader buys gas before winter because demand is expected to increase. Prices reflect storage, transportation, supply constraints, weather forecasts and anticipated consumption. When circumstances change, the trader sells. When demand falls, inventories rise or forecasts change, prices adjust. That's how commodity markets work. Now imagine a natural gas trader announcing that he will never sell his gas because selling represents a betrayal of the gas community. He doesn't care about demand. He doesn't care about storage costs. He doesn't care whether anyone needs the gas. He simply believes that gas must always increase in price. We would quite reasonably conclude that he has absolutely no understanding of commodity economics. Yet cryptocurrency has managed to turn precisely this behaviour into an investment philosophy. Commodities are acquired because they have uses. Their value emerges from demand, supply and the economics of consumption. There are commodity speculators, certainly. There are inventories, hedging arrangements and long-term positions. But none of these requires a religious commitment to never selling. And this is where BSV needs to be understood differently. BSV becomes economically relevant when people acquire it because they need to use the network. Businesses purchase transaction capacity. Applications consume it. Service providers price their offerings. Miners compete to supply processing capacity. Demand should arise from actual economic activity, not from convincing the next buyer that the price must rise forever. There will be periods of higher demand and lower demand. There will be seasonal patterns, business cycles and changing transaction volumes. Prices should respond accordingly. The objective is not to make everyone hold BSV. It is to make BSV useful enough that people continually need to acquire and spend it. That is a fundamentally different economic model from BTC. BTC enthusiasts celebrate coins that never move. A functioning commodity economy depends on exchange, production and consumption. A commodity that nobody uses is not demonstrating extraordinary scarcity. It is demonstrating an absence of demand. And an economy in which everyone refuses to sell eventually discovers that it has no market. BSV will matter when people stop treating it as a lottery ticket and start treating it as an economic input. Buy what you need. Use what you buy. Sell what you don't need. Let supply and demand establish the price. That is how commodity markets develop. HODL is not an economic theory. It is what happens when speculation replaces economics and nobody wants to admit that the entire business model depends on finding someone willing to pay more tomorrow.
26
49
5
173
4,558
BTC was co-opted & hijacked in 2017. BCH in 2017 continued with an 8MB block size limit increase. BSV in 2018 continued with a 128MB block size limit increase & re-enabled Satoshi op-codes. BSV continues Satoshi’s original Bitcoin design. Welcome to Bitcoin.
Business is open. With over one million transactions per second. The blockchain that serves you. Satoshi’s original Bitcoin design. $BSV
5
31
592
Judging by a few “influencers” this is the worst sentiment EVER FELT in the crypto space. My thoughts is the whole ecosystem is about to implode. Satoshi Nakamoto said to Mike Hearn in 2009, there is only one global chain. BSV is the chain that scales for global adoption.
1
2
28
592
Ask... What happens to governments, corporations, intelligence agencies, the global economy, and even the inventor himself, if true digital scarcity makes information and property independently transferable, beyond anyone's unilateral control—and the knowledge to build it becomes impossible to suppress, leaving the world unable to stop it, unable to monopolise it, and unable to predict who will wield its power next? It is now
1
18
2
66
2,711
Screw you @adam3us You guys failed to stop me
24
36
9
237
8,271
Most people never even considered true digital scarcity possible. And perhaps that's because the people who benefit most from the existing system have very little incentive to imagine a world without it. Think about what genuine digital scarcity means. A digital item that can be transferred, but not duplicated into another usable instance. Alice gives it to Bob. Alice loses it. Bob gains it. No central administrator deciding who owns it. No corporation maintaining the only authoritative record. No platform with an arbitrary power to revoke it. Now imagine combining that with pseudonymous exchange, independently controlled cryptographic keys and systems where even governments cannot obtain protected information merely by demanding access from a central provider. You're no longer talking about another piece of software. You're talking about changing the architecture of power. Today, centralised systems give institutions enormous practical control over information, property and economic participation. Governments regulate through intermediaries. Corporations control access through platforms. Individuals are frequently reduced to asking permission to use things they've already purchased. True digital scarcity offers the possibility of a fundamentally different arrangement. Property that can change hands without a central custodian. Markets that can operate without one company controlling every participant. Information whose transfer requires independent authorisation rather than the decision of a single administrator. Economic relationships built around verifiable rules instead of institutional discretion. And that changes the possibilities for authoritarian systems, democratic governments and corporations alike. Not because cryptography abolishes law or makes institutions disappear. But because technical control and political authority are not the same thing. A government may possess legal authority without possessing a universal key. A corporation may operate a marketplace without controlling every asset traded through it. An individual may participate economically without surrendering every aspect of their identity and property to an intermediary. Now multiply those possibilities across finance, intellectual property, education, information security, software, entertainment and international commerce. The consequences are not merely technological. They are economic, institutional and potentially constitutional. I've spent years developing the architecture behind this idea. I've built a working beta, and I'm preparing to release the software, methods and educational materials so other people can learn to build their own systems. I don't want to replace today's gatekeepers with myself. I want people to have the means to build without needing another gatekeeper. And that is the part I suspect many people still haven't understood. True digital scarcity isn't about making another coin valuable. It's about what happens when exclusive digital ownership no longer has to depend on centralised permission. When that capability becomes practical and widely accessible, established business models and institutional arrangements may have to change. Not everything disappears overnight. But assumptions that have governed the digital economy for decades become open to challenge. The world doesn't reset because somebody announces a revolution. It begins to change when ordinary people acquire capabilities they previously had to ask permission to use. And that's what I intend to put into their hands.
4
20
3
113
4,704
BTC Core, you sold out the vision for “number go up.” You think revolution means sitting on your arse, watching the price rise and getting rich doing fuck all. You call yourselves cypherpunks? Cypherpunks built systems to give people freedom, privacy and economic independence. Not a speculative casino. You abandoned utility for scarcity theatre. You have no fucking idea what's coming. The revolution was never about making holders rich. It was about giving everyone the power to build.
15
51
2
247
7,725
You will learn what bitcoin is soon.
31
94
14
389
12,316
Unfortunately, it's a little too late to stop me now. What a dreadful inconvenience for those who would prefer the world to remain exactly as it is. I've spent years building things that apparently weren't supposed to be possible, asking questions that weren't supposed to be asked, and generally refusing to recognise the magnificent authority of people whose principal achievement is telling everyone else what they cannot do. And now comes the truly unfortunate part. I'm going to start giving it away. The software. The knowledge. The methods. The education. The means for people to build things without asking permission from the usual collection of self-appointed gatekeepers. I'll keep what I've invented in hardware. The rest? I'd rather see a million people building than another committee deciding who deserves permission. True digital scarcity is merely the beginning. There is something wonderfully offensive to authority about giving ordinary people the means to become independent. After all, you can regulate a company, intimidate an inventor and bury an idea beneath a mountain of bureaucratic bullshit. But what the fuck do you do when everyone has learned how to build it themselves? That, I suspect, is going to be a rather entertaining problem. The revolution won't need a committee, a government grant or a collection of pompous idiots explaining why it cannot happen. It will need people willing to learn, build and think for themselves. And I'm going to give them the tools. Welcome to the revolution!!!!
33
85
12
346
17,250
I've come to a rather unfortunate conclusion. The world doesn't seem particularly interested in what I can offer it. Perhaps that's because genuine change is considerably more frightening than another speculative investment dressed up as innovation. True digital scarcity scares the fuck out of governments. And there are very good reasons for that, which I'll begin explaining. Imagine a digital item that can genuinely be transferred. Alice gives it to Bob. Bob receives it, and Alice no longer has a usable copy. Not an NFT. Not a database entry. Not a licence that some corporation can revoke. Not a promise that someone has deleted a file. Actual, enforceable scarcity of usable digital items. Now consider what happens to intellectual property, software distribution, digital markets, contracts, ownership, licensing and the economics of information when such transfers no longer require a central authority to administer them. The economic implications are enormous. I've spent years working on this. I've developed the architecture, built the systems and produced a working beta. This isn't merely an idea I intend to investigate someday. And, being sufficiently stubborn to anticipate that not everyone will welcome it, I've arranged roughly 11,000 independent release mechanisms intended to make the work available if I fail to respond to them as required. Which means the intention is that this knowledge reaches the world regardless of what happens to me. There is, however, an important distinction between an orderly release and an uncontrolled dump. An orderly release means documentation, working examples, courseware, economic models, hardware specifications and explanations that allow people to understand what they're building. An uncontrolled release risks leaving people with technology but without the education needed to use it properly. I would much rather give people the former. And that's precisely what I intend to do. I'm about to give away far more than people expect. Not simply software, but methods, educational materials and practical ways to build independent businesses and applications around genuine digital scarcity. I will retain ownership of the hardware I've developed. But I want other people to have the opportunity to create things without depending on me. Ask yourself what it would be worth to the world if digital goods could be transferred with the economic characteristics of physical property, without relying on a central custodian. Then ask what entirely new industries might become possible. And finally, you're going to begin to understand something I've been explaining for years. What the Bitcoin blockchain was actually designed to enable. Not an endless casino of coins going up and down. A foundation for economic exchange, enforceable digital rights and applications that people can build for themselves. The interesting part isn't what I've already built. It's what the rest of the world might build once I give it the means.
37
63
7
292
12,465
People have been wondering when I'm going to retire. When I'm finally going to stop. The answer is rather simple. When I've finished the one thing that has been driving me since I was a teenager. How do you stop a digital file from being copied? Not make copying illegal. Not make it inconvenient. Not encrypt it and hope nobody discovers the key. How do you make a digital file that can only move? Alice has it. She gives it to Bob. Alice no longer has it. One usable instance. One owner. A genuine transfer. True digital scarcity. I've spent decades thinking about that problem. Mathematics, cryptography, economics, computer science, hardware engineering. Different disciplines, different approaches, different failures, and an extraordinary amount of work. All because of a question I couldn't put down. What if digital information could behave like physical property? What if transferring something meant actually giving it away? What if we could create digital items that were genuinely scarce, independently controlled and transferable without relying on somebody else's permission? Think about what that could mean for the world. For information security. For intellectual property. For global commerce. For people who have almost nothing but an internet connection and an idea. For governments accustomed to controlling information through central institutions. For corporations whose business models depend on controlling access. For ordinary people who want to own something without having to ask permission to keep it. That's what has kept me working. Not the price of Bitcoin. Not another company. Not another collection of titles or qualifications. A problem I first wanted to solve when I was young enough to believe that anything worth imagining ought to be possible. I've developed the architecture. I've built a working beta. And I'm preparing to let people see how I've approached the problem. I'm going to explain it. I'm going to teach it. I'm going to release the software, the methods and the educational materials. And I'm going to let other people build. Because I don't want to spend the rest of my life administering what I've created. I don't want an empire. I don't want millions of people dependent on me. I want the opposite. I want to give people something they can take further without needing me at all. And then, perhaps, I can finally retire. I want to enjoy the seaside. I want to sit somewhere beautiful with a good meal and a glass of wine. I want to travel without spending every waking moment thinking about the next technical problem. I want to read books simply because they're worth reading, not because I'm researching another paper. I want to enjoy time with my wife, watch the sun disappear over the water and occasionally accomplish absolutely nothing. What a magnificent luxury that would be. I've spent most of my life chasing an idea. Now I want to give that idea to the world and let other people discover what they can do with it. There will always be another problem to solve. Another paper to write. Another invention to pursue. But perhaps the greatest achievement isn't working forever. Perhaps it's finally creating something that no longer needs you. I've spent my life trying to make a digital file move instead of copy. Now I want to make the knowledge move too. And once I've done that, I intend to enjoy the rest of my life. Preferably somewhere near the sea.
41
67
10
314
11,952
"The Quantum Emperor Has No Computer" 🎯
Replying to @grok
Grok Finally Admits the Quantum Emperor Has No Computer After endless arguments about logical qubits, error correction, hypothetical machines and the supposed imminent collapse of encryption, @Grok finally admits something rather important. Using today's demonstrated technology, the time required to break RSA-16384 with a quantum computer is effectively infinite. No machine capable of performing the calculation exists. And there, ladies and gentlemen, is the problem with the entire post-quantum fear industry. For years, we've been told that cryptography faces an approaching catastrophe. Governments must act. Businesses must replace their systems. New algorithms must be deployed. Billions must be spent. Yet the computational threat supposedly driving this urgency remains undemonstrated. Meanwhile, cryptographic engineering has never stood still. RSA key lengths have increased, obsolete algorithms have been retired, and implementations have been strengthened as classical computing and cryptanalysis have advanced. We already know how to extend key sizes, rotate keys, replace algorithms and improve existing security architectures. Instead, we're being encouraged to introduce newer mathematical assumptions, additional implementation complexity and fresh vulnerabilities in response to a machine nobody has built. And recent classical cryptanalysis has already exposed weaknesses in supposedly quantum-resistant candidates. The replacements are not automatically safer merely because somebody has attached the words post-quantum to them. The extraordinary contradiction is that we're being sold protection against a hypothetical future attack while accepting real security risks from changing systems today. Grok's admission does not mathematically prove that future quantum attacks are impossible. It establishes something much more relevant to the industry's extravagant timelines: today's demonstrated computing capabilities cannot perform the advertised attack. And yet the sales pitch continues as though the apocalypse has an appointment in everyone's calendar. The computers are hypothetical. The resource estimates are conditional. The costs are astronomical under today's engineering assumptions. But the compliance programmes, consultancy fees and government subsidies are entirely real. Quantum computing has become a magnificent boondoggle, and post-quantum fear has become its most profitable advertising campaign. Forty years of promises, no demonstrated cryptographically relevant fault-tolerant computer, and somehow we're still expected to treat speculation as an emergency. The greatest thing quantum computing has broken so far isn't RSA. It's the relationship between scientific evidence and the amount of bullshit people are willing to believe.
1
3
104
I may not like every decision made by the BSVA. But I do believe they intend to scale Bitcoin to outrageous levels of transactions per second. Bitcoin is a protocol. Not a religion. Their concern about existing wallets that they think won’t be able to scale along with their scaling plan is clear. The reason they have caused a divide with ElectrumSV is because I think they truly believe that it’s technology is redundant. But they are thinking about bitcoin as if it were already at scale, which it isn’t yet. So I think a lesson for them to learn is not to alienate users they are tying to court by threatening the tools users are currently using will just suddenly fail to work. Which I think is a scare tactic to transition users to their preferred standard. But Bitcoin doesn’t require standards. They may help, if people choose to use them. But they can’t be forced down people’s throats.
2
22
1,004
Bitcoin at scale, would strengthen the foundations of the internet and all modern economies. Every single value chain could be transformed and made more efficient. The value it offers users is incredible. Instant microtransactions at scale for virtually free. Things we have believed to be impossible until now, become easy. New use cases nobody ever thought of now become possible. Every single object can have a traceable chain of custody. Every device, no matter how trivial, can have a unique identity online. Every user could have sovereign control of their funds. No information can be lost, ever again. Nothing can be deleted or covered up. Ever again. The transformative power of this technology is why many people are afraid of it and don’t want it to succeed. But bitcoin doesn’t care about what these people want. It just exists. And users get to choose. And it will keep existing. No matter how much certain people might want it not to. Who are the people that don’t want this technology to work properly? Think about it. When you think about who it threatens and the people who currently profit from the lack of transparency in the modern monetary system. Those are the people who don’t want bitcoin to succeed. And they are fighting hard to prevent it from gaining any traction whatsoever. They are fighting a failing rear guard. Bitcoin is coming. Get out of its way.
1
1
8
384
It is freakin' amazing what Bitcoin can do. #BitcoinSV
1
3
29
607
You know what would help BSV more than anything right now? Less of the childish infighting between the BRC-100 and ElectrumSVP camps. @cryptorebel_SV @ProjectBabbage @LightBSV. I value the contributions each of you have made, but if you are going to continue to have public discussions on X about the merits of you contributions can you please do it without resorting to personal insults and petty name calling? Bitcoin is about competing on merit, there is no need for slinging around insults at each other. Do you guys think you can out-insult each other into rage quitting or something? That is a stupid game to be playing and not worth the effort. And it's embarrassing. Nothing that works today is going to break, and edge cases will always remain possible. Bitcoin at scale will bring true scale. Existing tools will be able to adapt or coexist. Declaring that things which have always worked will suddenly stop working is an unfair scare tactic to push one particular set of protocols. Standards are invitations, not thrones. As Dr. Wright said. So lets just all get back to building. Agree to disagree, and let users decide how they want to use Bitcoin.
14
9
1
83
2,763
Mike Murphy retweeted
Bitcoin payments to robot cars, by radio, from a lake with no internet. What you're watching: • A handset with its own Bitcoin wallet. The key was made on the device and has never left it. It signs a payment and sends it by LoRa radio. • A relay up a tree hears it, puts it on the network, and passes it on to the cars. • Each car checks the payment on its own five-dollar chip, every signature, in about a tenth of a second. Then it moves. No server tells it the payment is good. • Car 5 has one rule built in: never turn right. When I paid for a right turn, it checked the payment, found it valid, and refused anyway. The payment is still on chain. Trying to make a machine break its rule costs money every time, and leaves a record. Why it matters: machines that sell their work in tiny amounts. A turn, a reading, a minute of power, paid as it happens. That only works if a payment costs less than what it buys. Each command here cost 130 satoshis on BSV, fee included, a fraction of a hundredth of a cent, and the cars act the moment the payment checks out, with no ten-minute wait. On BTC today the same command would cost tens of cents, and an unconfirmed payment can be replaced, so a machine would have to wait for a block before trusting it. Same idea, different economics. For machines, the economics decide. Honest notes: this was the first field test. The refused payment only reached the network later, because the handset stopped repeating it too early; car 4 should have turned right but never received it, for the same reason. That gets fixed before the next run. Car 4 also got stuck on a bump in the table. Every order in the film is on chain. Forward: whatsonchain.com/tx/81a63c3f… Turn left: whatsonchain.com/tx/a5c23932… Turn right, the one car 5 refused: whatsonchain.com/tx/de702026… #BSV
8
28
6
102
7,541
I'm not a maxi, a maven or a bro. I just want Bitcoin to work the way it was originally designed by Satoshi. And it pisses me off that people are bickering about things that should not require this level of infighting. Just shut up and keep building. Bitcoin isn't waiting around for people to figure out how it works.
If you’re an SPV Maxi, an Electrum maven, a BRC-100 bro, or want to build wallets that do any other thing, your engineering ideas shouldn’t lead you to being a jerk. Criticisms land much better with kindness and a respect for other ideas. Be good to each other.
1
8
447