MCheshireAgainstHS2 (@mcahs2) header
MCheshireAgainstHS2 (@mcahs2) profile picture

Mid Cheshire action group against #HS2 £107 billion Gravy Train for vested interests. CO2 +ve for 120 years Undeniably environmentally harmful according to DfT

Joined October 2013
Photo by MCheshireAgainstHS2 (@mcahs2)Photo by MCheshireAgainstHS2 (@mcahs2)Photo by MCheshireAgainstHS2 (@mcahs2)Photo by MCheshireAgainstHS2 (@mcahs2)Photo by MCheshireAgainstHS2 (@mcahs2)Photo by MCheshireAgainstHS2 (@mcahs2)Photo by MCheshireAgainstHS2 (@mcahs2)Photo by MCheshireAgainstHS2 (@mcahs2)Photo by MCheshireAgainstHS2 (@mcahs2)Photo by MCheshireAgainstHS2 (@mcahs2)
This is from 2017. We've done 3 reports on the "challenging" geology #HS2 route through Mid Cheshire. Expert work by geologists internal and external. It's why the M6 avoided this area (notice how it bends?) not ok for 70mph motorway but 250mph train? mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/hs…
16
73
5
88
Tunnels that's why HS2 is expensive
2
1
75
MCheshireAgainstHS2 retweeted
This, from DfT annual report, shows capital spending on roads, rail and HS2. Spending on HS2 is, year after year, higher than on the whole of the rest of the rail network, and nearly twice total spending on national highways. Just think what could have been done instead.
58
112
25
300
51,364
MCheshireAgainstHS2 retweeted
Why does #HS2 cost £100 bn? Becuz the tree planting, obvs #HS2CostsMysterySolved nitter.cf/tomhfh/status/20916108…
Some more reasons why HS2 is cripplingly expensive: It's not just a railway, it's also a 140 mile long nature reserve. 7 million trees and shrubs. Net biodiversity gains. Rare fauna planting. Chalk hill reshaping. Wetland creation. Cycle paths and bridleways. Reptile habitats. Public viewing points. River realignment with new bends, pools, and riffles. "Alongside the construction of Britain's new high speed railway, HS2 is delivering one of the largest environmental programmes ever undertaken in the UK". You'd think that a new railway would be environmentally beneficial enough. But no. Because this is a government project it can't just be a railway. It has to be a nature reserve too, and a jobs creator, plus a view protector, forest creator, and the most expensive bat protection project in the world. Thanks to all these expensive boondoggles, the railway itself has been cut and cut and cut, and no longer goes to Leeds or Manchester - it's been slashed from 330 miles to 140. It would obviously be better for the environment to have forgone the nature slop and just built the sodding railway in full, on time, and within budget. The Victorians weren't magically better at building than we seemingly are today. When private companies build a railway they care about costs, profit, and efficiency. When a government builds a railway they care about creating a camel to appeal to all people. It can't just be a railway. It has to be so much more. And that's when we see costs spiral to destruction.
1
1
119
MCheshireAgainstHS2 retweeted
Andy Burnham wants to throw taxpayers' money around like confetti. His latest proposal is to extend the failed HS2 project to Manchester. A realistic HS2-spec Birmingham–Manchester extension would be a £80bn–£90bn project with Manchester station/tunnel complexity, weak cost control, and further delay. Let's remember that by May 2026 the government’s reset estimate for Phase 1 had become £87.7bn–£102.7bn, excluding future inflation, with Old Oak Common–Birmingham not opening until May 2036–October 2039 and the Euston/Handsacre full scope not until 2040–2043 Burnham's HS2 proposal confirms either that he is not a serious politician or that he thinks people are idiots or both.
11
47
6
120
12,831
Burnham’s #HS2 promise is dead on arrival – here’s how to really fix Britain’s railways msn.com/en-gb/news/other/bur…
3
8
114
MCheshireAgainstHS2 retweeted
Great work @AJPendleton and team @NEF. I was a fan of #HS2 but have been converted by strength of the evidence in report. If rebalancing is an imperative, why are we spending billions on a scheme where 40% of the benefits go to London. Time for a rethink!
3
13
2
20
MCheshireAgainstHS2 retweeted
If you are wondering if #HS2 is worth £106bn have a look at this @NEF report. Spoiler alert... it really isn’t! 40% of the benefits go to the London but only 10% to York & Humber & 12% to the Midlands. Time to scrap the scheme and devolve £100 bn to local areas to invest.
The cost of HS2 could rise to £106bn or more, the original max budget for the project was £56bn🤯 NEF report looked at alternatives and sets out how the investment could be better used to improve journeys and ease overcrowding 🚄 https://nitter.cf/t.co/ilLfFJPOHj
2
17
2
31
MCheshireAgainstHS2 retweeted
Manchester suffers steepest fall in living standards in England. The scrutiny will now come. telegraph.co.uk/gift/2531a98…
200
1,719
124
4,764
89,980
Factual reasons for #HS2 cost increases #mythbusting
2
5
9
285
In the offices of a vested interest no doubt. #HS2 Watch this space for who is providing office space.
🚨 WATCH: Andy Burnham says No 10 North will be close to Manchester Piccadilly
5
2
134
MCheshireAgainstHS2 retweeted
Watch this for everything you need to know about Burnham and his economics…..it’s beyond embarrassing! Honestly if this is the scale of Westminster capabilities we are expected to accept Im out! It’s like asking 4 year olds to run government!
8
1
75
14,525
MCheshireAgainstHS2 retweeted
I have mentioned the Ajax fighting vehicle fiasco many times — on Twitter, on my TV show and in a direct confrontation with the defence secretary. As for HS2 it’s clear it should never have been started and was an all-too predictable fiasco. But it might be too late to pull stumps. Open to persuasion either way.
82
12
5
171
313,545