
Former Information Commissioner, Punjab. IDS, QAU & GC Alumnus. #CPDI, #Human Rights, #Development, #Governance. Retweets not endorsements.
Islamabad
Joined March 2010
- Tweets36.8K
- Following1.2K
- Followers3.8K
- Likes8.6K
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
مرلی دھرن گوپال نامی صارف لکھتے ہیں کہ ورلڈ ایئر فورس ڈائریکٹری کے مطابق انڈین فضائیہ کے زیرِ استعمال فعال رفال طیاروں کی تعداد 32 ہے جبکہ انڈیا نے 36 رفال طیارے خریدے تھے۔
bbc.in/4CgA1L6
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
سوال یہ ہے کہ اشرافیہ یہ دروازہ کیوں کھولے؟ اِس لیے کہ امارت کی دیوار اُتنی اونچی نہیں جتنی دکھائی دیتی ہے۔ پیسہ فارم ہاؤس اور جنریٹر خرید لیتا ہے، مگر نلکے کا صاف پانی اور لاہور کے نومبر کی وہ ہوا نہیں خرید سکتا جو پھیپھڑوں میں اُترنے سے پہلے بینک بیلنس نہیں پوچھتی۔ مچھر پھاٹک پر دستک نہیں دیتا، اور وبا شجرہ نہیں دیکھتی۔ دیوار گلی کو روک لیتی ہے، شہر کے جملہ عیوب کو نہیں روک پاتی۔ ہوا اور پانی سانجھے ہیں، اور دانائی اِسی میں ہے کہ اشرافیہ یہ بات وقت پر مان لے۔
آج کا کالم
jang.com.pk/news/1635266
India's trade deficit with China is likely to hit a record $150 billion in 2026-27. When Modi took over in 2014 it was $36 billion. When Modi govt declined to join the 15 member Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) block comprising Asean plus 5 nations, the reason given was RCEP will be used by China to push its exports disproportionately into India. India's trade deficit with China was roughly $52 billion in 2018-19 when RCEP was signed. It has balooned to $150 billion(nearly 3 times) in just 7 years inspite of India not joining RCEP. So question is did India achieve its objective of preventing large Chinese imports by not joining RCEP? Counterfactual : since India has not succeeded in preventing a flood of imports from China, it would have had atleast privileged access to the large Asean plus 5 economies if it had been part of RCEP. Food for thought?
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
A lingua franca is not meant to be anyone’s first language and does not ask to replace one. It has only to let two strangers who share no mother tongue finish a piece of business, carry what is held in common, and be learnable by people not born to it. It is a roof, not a floor. Nobody in Lahore speaks less Punjabi at home for having spoken Urdu at the bank.
Across four provinces and four peoples, that is what has happened. In Punjab 7.2 per cent were born to Urdu and 42.8 per cent reach it. In Sindh, 22.9 and 44.6. In Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, 0.7 and 27.8. In Balochistan, 0.5 and 19.4. No other language here is taken up by anyone not born to it. Punjabi, Pashto, Sindhi and Balochi are received and handed on, and that is the whole of their range.
The Federation promoted Urdu, and it was right to. The school taught in it and the broadcast spoke in it, and what came of that is not an official formality but a living market. Every television channel Gallup names, in news and entertainment alike, broadcasts in Urdu, taking 93.9 per cent of all entertainment viewing and 78.5 per cent of news. Nobody watches a drama in a language out of duty.
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
REER alone does not determine whether the PKR is overvalued. Devaluation offers no lasting export advantage, beyond a one-time gain. However, an overvalued rupee undermines export competitiveness. The govt must choose between containing inflation through a managed strong rupee and protecting exports through gradual exchange rate adjustment
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
RAFALE COUNT AT 32?
A report by Cirium Aviation Analytics and Flight International says the Indian Air Force has 32 Rafale aircraft in its fleet.
Questions are being raised over the report, as it does not explain the basis for counting only 32 aircraft instead of 36.
The report states: “The information contained in this report was prepared using Cirium fleets data. While reasonable care has been taken to ensure accuracy, the information is supplied on the understanding that no legal liability whatsoever shall attach to FlightGlobal, its officers or employees in respect of any error or omission that may have occurred.”
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
It did not remind you of the genocide of shia Hazaras by Amir Abdur Rehman involving massacres, enslavement, confiscation of ancestral lands and forced displacement. A totally unrelated Aurangzaib story fits the narrative, continuing persecution of minorities in Afghanistan does not.
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
A Tale of Two Calendars
On a November night outside Lahore, a farmhouse glows like a small city. Chandeliers in a marquee, flowers flown in that morning, a dhol on the lawn. The groom’s friends from New York walk around wide-eyed. We had Pakistan all wrong, one says.
At the gate, a rickshaw driver drops off two waiters and heads home to a katchi abadi by the railway line. One room for seven, a curtain for a door, a rented rickshaw, a son who left school at twelve.
Same city, same night. Not the same year.
Measured against France, our richest 40,000 households are ahead of the average French family today. The next 400,000 live in the France of 1979. The average Pakistani lives on what a Frenchman earned in 1912. The rickshaw driver lives in the 1860s.
The friends were right about the lawn. Lahore was simply larger than the lawn.
In Europe the order is reversed. Houses are modest, but the park is mown, the pavement wide, the square clean enough to sit in. The family is ordinary. The street is rich. Here everything beautiful sits behind a wall, and even a middle class family pours a lifetime’s savings into a house that turns its back on an open drain.
Yet one row joins the calendars. Even in those 40,000 homes, children die before five at France’s rate of 1968. Money buys a farmhouse and a foreign degree. It cannot buy clean water, a working hospital or breathable air. The wall keeps the street out. It does not keep the city out.
Private wealth carries a family only so far. Beyond that, progress lives outside the gate, or it does not live at all.
In the end, every society reveals itself in what it puts a premium on. The private lawn, or the public square.
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
دو سو برس کا انکار
1493ء میں قسطنطنیہ کے دو یہودی بھائیوں نے چھاپہ خانہ لگایا۔ اُسی شہر کے حاکم مسلمانوں نے پہلی کتاب 1729ء میں چھاپی، یہودیوں سے دو سو چھتیس برس بعد اور وہ بھی اِس فتوے کیساتھ کہ دین کی کتاب نہیں چھپے گی۔
چھاپہ خانے سے ضد کی قیمت علم و حکمت کے میدان میں تہزیبی شکست کا موجب بنی۔ یورپ کا عالم ایک برس میں ہزار ہاتھوں تک پہنچتا اور دس برس میں اُس پر دس جواب چھپتے۔ ہمارا عالم زندگی بھر بیس نسخوں سے آگے نہ جاتا، اور اُس کے بعد شاگرد شرح لکھتے، شرح پر حاشیہ، حاشیے پر تعلیقات۔ ہر شاگرد کے ہاتھ میں کتاب آئی تو یورپ کی جامعہ میں اُستاد کا کام پڑھانا نہیں، بحث کرانا رہ گیا۔ ہمارا مدرسہ وہیں رہا جہاں کتاب کی قلت علم پر اجارہ داری کا ہتھیار بنی رہی۔ پڑھنے کا شعور عامیوں تک نہ پہنچا تو پرکھنے کی عادت بھی نہ بنی۔
jang.com.pk/news/1633199
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
A Tale of Two Cities
In 1881 Amritsar had about 1.52 lakh people and Lahore 1.49 lakh. By 1901 Lahore had 2 lakh and Amritsar 1.6 lakh. Today Lahore has nearly twelve million, and Amritsar about one.
The map shows how Lahore grew. In 1901 it was three separate places: the walled city, the Civil Lines along the Mall, and Mian Mir cantonment standing apart to the southeast. By the 1940s the railway workshops at Mughalpura had joined them, and Model Town, a garden suburb founded in 1920s, sat alone in open fields to the south. By 1975 all of them had merged into one city. Today that city runs south past Model Town toward Raiwind, along the Ferozepur road, and across the Ravi to Shahdara.
The towns around them followed. Muridke, a roadside halt with under 7,000 people in 1961, now has a quarter of a million. Jandiala Guru near Amritsar went from 7,750 to about 29,000 in a century.
Amritsar grew as a trading city before the advent of railways. Its merchants dealt in shawls, grain and dry fruit on routes that ran west to Kabul, north to Kashmir and to Gangetic plains. Lahore grew as a capital, with roads, rail and canals tying western Punjab to it.
Two cities a short ride apart, with the same soil, the same canals and similar people. Why did one become a metropolis and the other stay a city?
What becomes of a trading city when the routes that fed it run elsewhere? How large can a city grow beyond the hinterland it serves? And do its towns rise or wait with it?
Perhaps a city is less its buildings than what flows through it.
Here I discuss the questionable police encounters in Pakistan’s #Punjab province, and the adverse implications for #RuleOfLaw, #HumanRights & even #PublicSafety that are often ignored. Our endemic #Corruption problem worsens the situation. youtu.be/AWXDV7m4s9Y?si=6jBA… via @YouTube
2
122
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
Surreal Evening at Pakistan's oldest Irrigated Forest Plantation, Changa Manga (Estb 1862)
It is a unique closed canopy two-storyed forest comprising Mulberry, Siris, Sagwan, Semal, Bohrr, Mahogany, Jaman
I totally love it's century old jungle tracks along mini canals
Here I discuss adverse implications of incidents in #Punjab where police apparently enabled victims of violence to slap the accused, filmed it & then let the video go viral.
Disturbing Trend: Accused Slapped by the Victim in Police Stations youtu.be/ks2XVomDHTs?si=bgTP… via @YouTube
3
79
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
Replying to @imbehroz
KP dimmed by about a fifth since 2012, while Hazara, whose feeders pay their bills, got brighter. Rural Sindh tells the same story: Kashmore, Dadu, Naushehro Feroze and Shikarpur lost 30 to 60% of their light, and the only new glow is at Thar coal, Dhabeji and the Sanghar gas fields. Balochistan grew overall, but the light moved to Gwadar, Hub and Quetta. Light follows payment of bills.
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
Pakistan from space at night, 2012 and 2026. In fourteen years our lit-up land grew by about a quarter, and our urban population by about 60%.
Growth has been uneven. Faisalabad, Multan and Sialkot have doubled their lit footprint. Islamabad-Rawalpindi grew 1.8 times and the Lahore belt 1.5 times, while Karachi grew 1.4 times and Peshawar 1.2.
Lahore, Gujranwala and Kasur were once separate pools of light. They have now fused, with Sheikhupura, Muridke and Kamoke, into one lit belt larger than Karachi’s. A megacity is taking shape along the GT Road.
But the state still governs the old map. The Lahore belt spans four districts and has no single government. Karachi is divided among a dozen land-owning agencies. Punjab’s cities have been run by appointed administrators for most of a decade.
The lights have merged. The state has not. Cities grow on their own. Whether they grow well depends on whether we govern them as the places they have become.
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
With respect till second WW the idea of complete independence was alien to Indian leadership, Jawarlal Nehru did demand Swaraj at Lahore Congress session in 1930 but his own father MotiLal publically distanced from the idea, it was basically a Dominion Status everyone thought but WW changed everything ,British empire collapsed and USA replaced Britishers as new Super power and 1941 Atlantic Accord clearly demanded independence of India, the game changed then not before…. @iamthedrifter
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
ایک خیال جو کب سے پک رہا تھا اور کل ایک نظم میں ڈھل گیا
کوئی ہے ؟
کوئی ہے جو مجھ کو بھی زیرِ لب کبھی روک لے، کبھی اذن دے
کوئی ہے جو میری ہی چاپ کی کبھی بیڑیاں ، کبھی پَر بنے
کوئی ہے جو میرے ہی شہر میں مرے حال سے رہے باخبر
جسے فکر ہو میں کہاں گیا ، جو خیال میں مجھے ڈھونڈ لے
رہے منتظر پسِ خواب بھی ، کہ میں لوٹ کر اُسے آ ملوں
کوئی ہے کبھی جو دمِ سحر ، کبھی وقتِ شام نوید دے
کہ جو رات ہے وہ گزر چلی ، کہ نئی سحر ہے قریب تر
کہ ابھی وہ کس کی پلک پہ ہے، کہ ابھی وہ کس کے خیال میں
وہ کمال ہے ، وہ جمال ہے، جو کسی نے دیکھا نہ آج تک
کوئی ہے جو میرے بھی دل کی تال سے تال دے، مری لے بنے
کبھی یہ کہے، کبھی وہ کہے، کبھی چپ رہے، کبھی بول دے
جو مرے سخن میں بسے تو یوں کہ وہ شعر ہو، میں غزل بنوں
مرے حرف حرف میں سانس لے، مری سطر سطر میں لَو جلے
کوئی ہے جو میری راہ میں سبھی سورجوں کا چراغ ہو
جو اُنھیں بھی جا کے سراغ دے کہ کہاں ہے نور کا آستاں
کسی دشت میں، کسی رات میں، جو قدم سے ایسے قدم ملے
کہ نہ چاپ دو، نہ قدم جدا، جو صدا اٹھے تو وہ ایک ہو
جو زمیں پہ میرے قریب ہو، مری آس ہو سرِ آسماں
کوئی ہے، میں جس کی دعا میں ہوں کوئی حرف سا، جو کبھی مجھے
کسی شام چھو کے جو پھونک دے، تو بدن میں روح سی چل پڑے
مری نبض نبض میں جاں پڑے، مرے انگ انگ میں رس بھرے
میں جو راکھ تھا، سو گلاب ہوں، میں جو خشک تھا، سو بہار ہوں
کوئی ہے جو میرے دیارِ دل میں اذان دے ترے اسم کی
وہ اذاں کہ جس سے میں جی اٹھوں، کہ سکوت ٹوٹے فصیل کا
کہ دریچے وا ہوں مکاں مکاں، کہ گلی گلی میں ہو روشنی
کہ مرے بجھے ہوئے طاق میں کوئی لَو جلے ترے ہاتھ سے
کبھی لوٹ آ، کہ اُجاڑ ہے ترے بِن نگر، مرے چارہ گر
کبھی سامنے سے صدا تو دے، مرے اَن کہے کو زباں تو دے
مجھے اپنی آپ خبر نہیں، کہ میں کون ہوں، کہ کہاں ہوں میں
کوئی ہے؟ کوئی تو کہیں پہ ہے جو مجھے مجھی سے ملا سکے
٭٭٭
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
Since 1950 Pakistan’s population has grown 7.2 times, and income per person has still risen more than fivefold. That is no small achievement. But imagine what we could have been.
Across the border, Indian Punjab has 70 people of working age for every 100. Our Punjab has 58. In facing districts that share the same soil and the same language, a woman on our side has about 3.4 children and on theirs about 1.6. The biggest reason is that they put their girls in school two decades before we did.
Had we controlled our population, every Pakistani would be richer by at least $400 a year. That is some $90 billion of income, and $9 to 11 billion of taxes, foregone every year. It is enough to nearly double what all our governments spend on education.
Few rupees work harder than those spent on women. An educated woman earns more, marries later, has fewer and healthier children, and sends every one of them to school. Her returns do not stop with her. They pass to the next generation and to the national budget. No highway or subsidy pays back like that.
We have done well against the odds. We can do far better. Every girl in school brings that day closer.
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
A Resilient Pakistan
Since 1950 Pakistan's population has multiplied more than seven times, from 36 million to 259 million. Had the whole world grown at that pace, it would hold 18 billion people today, not 8.3 billion. China would have 4 billion people instead of 1.4 billion, Europe 2.8 billion instead of 541 million, and Japan 625 million instead of 122 million.
Pakistan carried that weight in one of the world's hardest neighbourhoods. To the east is a hostile neighbour with nearly six times its population and nearly nine times its economy. To the west is Afghanistan, the playground of the Great Game, through four decades of Soviet and American wars and more than three million refugees.
Few societies have carried such a weight. Of the large economies that grew this fast, most fell into civil war or state collapse, and the rest mostly stayed poor. Only Saudi Arabia and Iraq, both carried by oil, did better.
Pakistan had no oil windfall yet it multiplied real income per head 5.4 times, faster than the world.
Those who call it a failed state should look at the record: it is the most resilient state of the last 75 years.
Mukhtar Ahmad Ali مختار retweeted
کسان سے محبت؟
راشد لنگڑیال
jang.com.pk/news/1631121


















