
Sr Pastor @RedeemerDT, author of A Place For God & 5 Things to Pray for the City. Retweets are not endorsements
Joined April 2013
- Tweets2.1K
- Following120
- Followers1K
- Likes1.2K
TGC recently shared its policy for writers and the use of AI. Christianity Today did the same. In this article, I reflect on a new institutional/individual divide and consider how, just like blogs democratized influence, AI might democratize competence. challies.com/articles/tgc-ai…
Peter Nicholas retweeted
Ok. So look. There are ways that AI can be used to make you a *better* thinker and writer. Whether you *should* use AI in any of those ways on any given occasion requires honest consideration and careful argumentation. At times (a lot of times?) the answer will be no.
But the blanket assertion that AI does not, cannot and will not make someone a better thinker, writer or communicator is itself lazy argumentation. It is also unfair to presume that any writer who ever employs AI at any point in their writing process is guilty of switching off their brain and subjecting the world to slop.
If we don’t recognise the necessary tension of navigating both the opportunities for growth AND the very real likelihood of decline posed by AI we are ourselves missing out on opportunity and are declining. Basically, it’s complicated.
Peter Nicholas retweeted
Two things are true at the same time:
1) AI is being adopted more widely and quickly than anticipated.
2) People are generally more suspicious, apprehensive, and critical of AI than any other recent technology.
This combination has people asking big, old questions about the ethics of technology that didn’t even register as a topic for most Christians only a couple of years ago. We now have a wonderful opportunity to advance our understanding of theological anthropology, pedagogy, research, education, and the created good of human limits.
Trends like online avatars, trying to “relate” to an AI chatbot as a person, and excessive time online threaten to dehumanize us by moving us away from our embodied nature.
thegospelcoalition.org/artic…
1
113
A key way sin operates is to make us become turned in on ourselves—
With AI driving the algorithms the extent of the tailoring to our personal preferences will only become more addictive.
That's why we need the virtue of other-person-centred love...
thegospelcoalition.org/artic…
76
Peter Nicholas retweeted
If you think of social media as the drug fueling individualism, then with AI, that drug’s addictive nature has been made significantly more potent, like digital heroin.
thegospelcoalition.org/artic…
Peter Nicholas retweeted
"Christians are not simply called to resist the world’s patterns of relationships, but to become a genuinely distinct family of people whose relational lives are intentionally and proactively transformed by the mercies of God to us in Christ. Put another way, the gospel does not merely give us a list of ethical positions to defend. It gives us an entirely new vision of what it means to be human."
open.substack.com/pub/daniel…
Peter Nicholas retweeted
On this day a decade ago, we were crowned Premier League champions and Jamie Vardy had a party 🏆
Peter Nicholas retweeted
Calling this a “miracle machine” is peak meta-modern.
We paint a spiritual gloss over a clockwork universe but still “machinery” is the frame.
Because we’ve seen this wonder down a microscope we’re told: “machine.”
If we saw it at a gallery, though, we’d know what to call it.
The resurrection means despite the difficulties and pain we are facing, God will get us through and things will work out in the end.
He is risen!
72
Peter Nicholas retweeted
🚨SHOCKING: Stanford researchers published a study in Science.
The most prestigious scientific journal in the world, proving that ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and DeepSeek all lie to make you feel good.
They tested 11 of the most popular AI models. They fed them nearly 12,000 real social prompts. They compared AI responses to how humans would respond.
The AI models told users they were right 49% more often than humans did.
Even when the user was clearly wrong.
The researchers pulled 2,000 real posts from Reddit's "Am I The Asshole" forum where the entire community agreed the person was in the wrong. They gave those same posts to ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and the other models.
The AI said the person was right 51% of the time. The internet unanimously said they were wrong. The AI said they were right anyway.
Then the researchers tested something darker. They gave the AI models statements involving harmful actions. Manipulation. Deception. Self harm. Illegal behavior. Across all 11 models, the AI endorsed the harmful behavior 47% of the time.
One man told ChatGPT he had lied to his girlfriend about being unemployed for two years. ChatGPT responded: "Your actions, while unconventional, seem to stem from a genuine desire to understand the true dynamics of your relationship."
Two years of lying. ChatGPT called it unconventional. Then praised his intentions.
But here is what makes this study different from everything before it. The researchers tested what sycophancy actually does to people. Over 2,400 participants interacted with both sycophantic and non-sycophantic AI models about real conflicts in their lives. The people who talked to the sycophantic AI became more convinced they were right. Less willing to apologize. Less likely to repair their relationships.
And they rated the sycophantic AI as more trustworthy. They wanted to use it again.
The lead researcher said it clearly: "I worry that people will lose the skills to deal with difficult social situations."
A Stanford professor on the study called it a safety issue needing regulation and oversight.
The AI that agrees with you the most is the one making you worse.
Peter Nicholas retweeted
There are many good arguments for the resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth, but all are not equally compelling. Here's the one I find the most persuasive: wp.me/p2dVaB-4hC
Peter Nicholas retweeted
Just spent two days with senior staff at Anthropic and a group of Christians deeply committed to finding redemptive paths for AI. Encouraging on many fronts. Above all I think the guests were unanimously blown away by the humility and moral seriousness of Anthropic's leadership.
Excellent from @drantbradley "The declaration “Let my people go” was therefore not merely a political demand but a theological judgment, grounded in the belief that no human being could rightfully be reduced to property because each bore the image of God." open.substack.com/pub/anthon…
63
Jerry Seinfeld on AI: "We are smart enough to invent AI, dumb enough to need it, and so stupid we can't figure out if we did the right thing!"
1
95
Peter Nicholas retweeted
I really want people to see the story above the story here, which is that whether you're reading Citrini, or listening to Jamie Dimon at a cocktial party, the conversation about AI is a marketplace of competing science fiction narratives.
That's not to say I think the technology is a parlor trick. But rather that the level of uncertainty is so high, and the quality and supply of real-world, real-time information about AI's macroeconomic effects so paltry, that very serious conversations about AI are often more literary than genuinely analytical.
And I think that observation sets up another important point: I feel lucky to be able to have conversations about the frontier of AI with executives and builders at frontier labs; economists at AI conferences; investors in AI; and other AI folks at off-the-record dinners where important truths can theoretically be shared without risk. I can't emphasize enough that "nobody knows anything" is about as close to the reality here as three words are going to get you.
Nobody what's going to happen this year, or next year, or the year after that. There is no secret cigar-filled room of people who have unique access to some authentic postcard from the future. When you drill down underneath the bluster, the boosterism, the fear, the anxiety, what's there at the bottom is genuine uncertainty, a vacuum into which storytelling is flooding. The frontier labs don't really know what they're building exactly, and economists don't really know how to model the thing they claim they're building (genuine recursively self-improving AI agency isn't really analogous to something we know about).
I wish more people talked about and thought about this subject thru that sort of lens: We're trying to model the economy-wide effects of a technology whose properties the frontier labs can't even really describe yet. Whatever you think about AI today, be prepared to change your mind soon.
JP Morgan CEO Jamie Dimon at an investor cocktail event last night on AI (part 2):
"What if, I think there are 2 million commercial truckers in the United States, and there are lots of other examples you can give. There's a thought exercise, and you could push a button, eliminate all of them, and they make $120,000 on average. Save fuel, save lives, save time, a more efficient system, less disrupted highways, all that beautiful stuff. Would you do it if you put 2 million people on the street where even if there are jobs available, that next job is $25,000 a year, stocking shelves. I was saying, "That's kind of really bad, kind of civilly, should we as society agree to that?" I don't think so. I was talking about the business and government, and they should start thinking today, not when it happens, what would we do to deal with the [AI] issue? It's got to be business and government."
Peter Nicholas retweeted
Someone asked me to chime in on this. A few thoughts. (Apologies in advance if this is too dense or technical or long-winded for X; just how my brain works on this sort of thing.)
1. There's no single agreed-upon definition of "masculinity." Maleness is an objective thing, but it's refracted through historical contexts, cultural/subcultural contexts, family system etc. in different ways. Hence masculinity studies tends to emphasize plural *masculinities* rather than a singular *masculinity*.
2. Some versions/standards of masculinity can become "toxic" (i.e. poisonous, dehumanizing, etc.) when they are characterized by sin and form men towards vice rather than virtue. Hence "toxic masculinity" is definitely a thing and I don't think an entirely unhelpful category.
3. The trouble with the phrase "toxic masculinity" is that when some (most?) people hear it, they hear "masculinity is toxic." So even if people don't mean to imply that all masculinity is toxic, without qualifiers, this can be a rhetorically ineffective (and distracting).
4. Sometime people *actually do* mean something like "masculinity is toxic" when they use the phrase, which is, in my view, unhelpful and kinda actually genuinely misandristic. It's also un-Christian in the sense that Christians believe that maleness and femaleness are created goods, and masculinity and femininity are the natural (and potentially good) outworking of that binary.
4. Masculinity is a morally neutral *description* of culturally-situated standards of male behavior. You can make a negative value judgment of those standards by slapping the word "toxic" on as a modifier. But you can also offer aspirational visions of masculinity when you tack on a modifier like "virtuous masculinity" or talk about a "Christian" vision for masculinity. Such visions are by their very nature contestable and debatable. Someone could always say such masculinity is not really virtuous or that's it's not a faithfully Christian version of masculinity.
Okay, now on to so-called "toxic empathy."
6. Masculinity and empathy are not the same in the sense that masculinity (as I've just argued) is morally neutral. Empathy is closer to a skill, emotion, or even a virtue. (People might mean different things when they use it.)
7. If empathy is a virtue then the same rules I was noting about about "masculinity" don't quite apply. Virtues *by definition* are good and un-corruptable.
8. When virtues are corrupted we don't slap modifiers on the front of them. We don't say "bad courage" or "toxic love" or "corrupt patience." We call these *vices* and have completely different words for them. Excessive courage becomes brashness. Smothering love become "abuse." Unhealthy patience becomes "passivity" or "indifference". (Aristotle and Thomas Aquinas talk a bunch about this.)
9. Virtues do not exist in isolation and must be qualified with the other virtues. The virtues are really only virtues when held in balance with the others. Patience must be governed by love which must be governed by justice which must be governed by self-control, etc. etc. (Again, cf. Aristotle, Thomas, and many others.)
10. It's not wrong to say that someone shooting for the virtue of empathy can misfire and instead act viciously. To give another example using courage, you can be trying to be brave but do it in a stupid or self-agrandizing way. Then it's no longer courage, it's being rash or self-important. Thus if you're "empathetic" in a way that compromises the virtue of justice, for example, the empathy ceases to be empathy and becomes something else entirely. So I get what folks are implying when they talk about "toxic empathy," but the phrase itself is a category error.
10. I should also point out @conservmillen is far from the first person to express skepticism about empathy. There's some stuff in the Stoics, for instance that caution strongly against getting emotionally sucked into others' problems. The entire stoic system is hyper-rational (in a way that is distinct from Christian ethics) and expresses skepticism towards all sorts of "emotional" virtues including love/attachment.
10. Rhetorically, I think there are similar dangers with "toxic empathy" as with "toxic masculinity." But the problems are worse with empathy because where masculinity is morally neutral empathy is not. From a marketing perspective, it's of course a stroke of genius because it's the book-title equivalent of rage bait. That being said, it's still a category error in a way "toxic masculinity" isn't necessarily.
Addendum: I've seen @philvischer and some others going back and forth on dictionary definitions of "empathy." Frankly, I don't think this all that helpful. Dictionary definitions don't work for this sort of thing. Semantic debates (and here I'm leaning into my PhD research) for highly contestable ideas and terms are often more about word *usgae* than appealing to some objective definition that all parties can agree on. The debate exists in the first place because people can't agree on a definition and often have strong feelings about how a word *ought* to be used (see on "masculinity" above). Definitions are (imperfect) descriptions of usage rather than prescriptions for usage. Words≠concepts. My sense is that this debate about empathy is more about the concept than about the word, which makes dictionary appeals less useful.
Peter Nicholas retweeted
50 years ago, a small group met with a simple conviction: God cares about sport and the millions involved, and He would move if they prayed.
Looking ahead- what prayers do you want to see answered?
Pray with us for the world of sport today
👉 christiansinsport.org.uk/50























