sandith (@sandith) header
sandith (@sandith) profile picture

Author, Naval Architect. Follow History, Mathematics, Engineering, Hindu Philosophy and Comparative Studies, Indian Art & Drama

Kochi
Joined March 2008
Photo by sandith (@sandith)Photo by sandith (@sandith)Photo by sandith (@sandith)Photo by sandith (@sandith)Photo by sandith (@sandith)Photo by sandith (@sandith)Photo by sandith (@sandith)Photo by sandith (@sandith)Photo by sandith (@sandith)Photo by sandith (@sandith)
Have addressed it umpteen times since 1980's, e,g,(pic1,2,3,4). But it is your birthright to avoid due diligence. Just shoot questions as if I am a coach/chatbot. Save ur time waste mine. This contempt for knowledge sank India and allows such nonsense to flourish. Keep it up!
Replying to @MisraNityanand
@CKRaju14 Please address this issue sir
2
28
1
81
2,482
sandith retweeted
0.0016. That is the worst error of a sine formula from early 600s India. No table, no interpolation. One fraction: sin x = 4x(180 - x) / (40500 - x(180 - x)), x in degrees. It is in Bhaskara I's Mahabhaskariya, chapter 7. Astronomers of the time found sines from a 24 entry table. He states this rule as a way to do it without the sine-differences. Try 30 degrees: 4 x 30 x 150 / (40500 - 4500) = 18000/36000 = exactly 0.5. At 90 it gives exactly 1. At 0, 150 and 180 also exact. Checked against true sines, the worst miss is 0.00163, near 11.5 degrees. In 1967 R.C. Gupta compared it with five figure tables and found 0.00160 at 10 degrees. Gupta wrote 16 pages on this one formula. His last line: how Indians arrived at the rule "may be taken as an open question". The book gives no derivation. The fraction kept being used. Brahmagupta (628) has an equivalent rule. Then Vatesvara (904), Sripati (1039), Bhaskara II, Narayana (1356) and Ganesa Daivajna (1520), who changed 40500 to 40320. 🙏🙏 Sources: Mahabhaskariya vii.17-19, ed. K.S. Shukla, 1960. R.C. Gupta, Indian Journal of History of Science 2.2 (1967), pp. 121-136. Photo 1: Bhaskara I. Plot, the fraction against the true sine. The curves sit on each other. Below, the error x1000: worst miss 0.00163 near 11.5 degrees, exact at the dots. Photo 2: Mahabhaskariya vii.17-19, the Sanskrit rule and the formula as equation (2). From R.C. Gupta, 1967, p. 122. Photo 3: Ganesa Daivajna's 1520 change (40320 for 40500), and Gupta's Table I comparing the formula with true sines. Worst gap 0.00160 at 10 degrees. p. 127. Photo 4: Gupta's abstract. The same rule in Brahmagupta (628), Vatesvara (904), Sripati (1039), Bhaskara II, Narayana (1356) and Ganesa (1520), and "We are not aware of the process by which Bhaskara I himself arrived at the formula." p. 121.
4
54
4
154
10,040
Thanks to Bernard Bel, French translator of Euclid and Jesus, for pointing out several minor errors in the article on "Math and AI: a counter statement". All errors are in the hyperlinks: mostly the final full stop was included in the link, resulting in a 404 error, or the URL was wrongly entered in my database as a DOI, resulting in a malformed DOI. Pls point out any further such errors if you spot them. For axiomatic mathematicians, unable to save themselves from the charge of being cheats and quacks and second-rate theorem provers, promoting a church agenda, such errors would be fertile ground for quibbles.😃
25
64
1,040
Axiomatic mathematics is dead. 1. On one side, AI has shown that human axiomatic mathematicians, even their Fields Medalists, etc., are 2nd-rate theorem-provers, just as human grandmasters are 2nd-rate chess players. Therefore, IF the human axiomatic mathematicians are paid to prove theorems, they should be kicked out of their jobs as incompetent, and more competent AI should be allowed to take over. 2. On the other hand, proving theorems of axiomatic mathematics has nil practical value, whether proved by humans or AI. Thus, the theorems of axiomatic math are NOT true in the real world but are mere "relative truths", i.e., "fantasy truths" relative to fantasy axioms of infinity/eternity which cannot be verified or falsified and must be accepted purely on the Western authority which laid them down. All that axiomatic proof does is to make the simplest math pf 1+1=2 extraordinarily difficult, to create a large mass of mathematically illiterate people terrified of math, hence forced to be obedient to Western authority on the most trivial aspects of math. 3. It was for this political reason, of creating obedience to padreist authority, that axiomatic proof was invented in crusading Christian theology in the 14th c. To hide the fact of its church origins, this method of proof was falsely attributed to a non-existent Euclid, in whose purported book (which first arrived in Europe ca. 1125), axiomatic proofs are NOT found. Because colonial mathematics taught us blind obedience, we foolishly accepted the padreist propaganda without checking whether there really was a Euclid, whether he really gave axiomatic proof or whether such axiomatic proofs originated with the church. On this boast of European "supremacy", we handed over on a platter the minds of our children to the padres for their evil childhood indoctrination. 4. I have repeatedly pointed out that (a) there is no evidence for Euclid, (b) there are no axiomatic proofs in the Euclid book. (c) axiomatic proofs are inferior, not superior, since they prohibit the empirical. etc. However, the sad fact is that nobody in this country of 1.4 billion people can stand up and demand that these stupid lies should be removed from school texts or that the education minister should resign. We are terrified, dead-scared of math, not weapons. 5. It was finally admitted in the 20th c. by Europeans themselves, Hilbert, Russell and Birkhoff, that there are no axiomatic proofs in the Euclid book. But we are too mathematically illiterate even to understand that admission. After this admission, the myth of Euclid changed a bit. 6. The myth that axiomatic proof originated with "Euclid" was shamelessly replaced by the even more false claim that the non-existent "Euclid" "intended" axiomatic proofs, but erred. This is so false! The book is manifestly full of diagrams, irrelevant to axiomatic proof, but deeply relevant to Platonic religious geometry, a connection to be expected of any early Greek or church quadrivium texts. But the church aim is to bury the church origin of axiomatic proof at all costs. The only thing Indians can do in math is to blindly accept whatever Western authority says and we dare not demand any evidence or apply our own mind. Applying one's own mind or checking the evidence would be "fringe", 😃contrary to the blind obedience of the "mainstream". 7. In the same spirit of blind obedience to church dogma planted in Western math, we introduced modern mathematics when the US did so after the Sputnik crisis, even though that axiomatic math is useless for rocket science. 8. Anyway, now there is only one job left for human axiomatic mathematicians. It is to cheat and to fool people. They aim to preserve this web of deceptive myths and lies about the math created by church padres. Manjul Bhargabva did not respond to my exposure of the myths and superstitions of axiomatic math (Western ethnomath) (pic 1) because (a) he had no valid response and (b) he thought the best way to suppress the exposure of church lies is by not responding. 9. What he aims to do for Indian education (and has done) is perfectly clear from the way he has preserved the church quadrivium teaching of invisible points in class 6, as also the mention of Pythagoras-Baudhayan theorem. We deserve this Macaulay 2 for not having learned the lessons from Macaulay 1.`The idea being that a few trifling concessions to Indian names would be enough to pacify the Indian ego, and to continue fooling Indians and justify preserving the fraud of axiomatic mathematics and its theorems. Of course, India never had a Mir Jafar at Plassey, so how can we believe one of our own will ever deceive us? 10. The situation is grim, but all hope is not dead. I am sure there are still a few people in India who recognize such Western racketeers and understand how Bhargav et al merely extend Macaulay. There are still a few people left who will check facts from the original sources and not be deceived by the internet chatter of chatbots or the combined propaganda of ignorant journalists and treacherous mathematicians. I am sure these few people will preserve the truth and carry it forward till the dawn of freedom, when people will marvel at the extraordinary foolishness of the colonized, especially Indians with their ganita, in accepting the silly lies of the colonizer of a "superior" Western math minus negative numbers. 🤣 Eventually axiomatic mathematics ("modern math") has to be kicked out of the syllabus and axiomatic mathematicians too have to be kicked out from all jobs in universities and research institutions. They are a gross liability. I dream that a day will come when we will learn to believe things based on well-researched facts, not duplicitous or internet opinions, especially from invaders, looters, their priests, and axiomatic mathematicians and other agents. Let us see how long it takes. Concluded (26)
So strong was the grip of silly padreist superstitions on the European mind, especially in Western academics, and especially in religious Western math, that these Xtian superstitions dominated the further development of Western math. So, AFTER the lack of axiomatic proofs in the "Euclid" book was exposed in the 20th c., a new effort was made to regain church control of math. This aimed to reimpose axiomatic proof not only in geometry but on all math, without ever acknowledging the origins of this tricky method of proof in the politics of the crusading church. (They just said the non-existent Euclid "intended" axiomatic proofs, and gullible Westerners swallowed it, despite all the manifest diagrams in the "Euclid" book, against axiomatic proof, and linking it to Plato.) This modern-day church effort led to the development of axiomatic set theory on which all axiomatic mathematics is based today. ` Things changed after the 1950s because the Soviets paid more attention to practical mathematics of use to society. Taking off from the successful use of Indian war rockets of the 17th and 18th c., the Soviets built rockets good enough to send a satellite, Sputnik, into space. This also meant that the Soviets acquired the capacity to drop a nuclear bomb over any part of the US. This frightened Americans out of their wits. They now faced the spectre of having nuclear bombs dropped on them the way they had brutally dropped them on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. In response to this extreme fright, the US invested a billion dollars (those days, in 1950's) to improve the teaching of math. However, American thinking was deeply colored by church superstitions, especially the church dogma of progress that whatever is later must be better; the hidden hand of god ensures that there is never any regress. 🤣 Therefore, all the mathematicians in the US wrongly assumed that since axiomatic mathematics of set theory came later, it must be better. Of course, as I have repeatedly pointed out, axiomatic mathematics (or the understanding of calculus using axiomatic real numbers) is NEVER used to calculate rocket trajectories, and can never be used. But we will never understand that because colonial education made us mathematically illiterate. So we will wait till a Western authority confirms it, which will never happen. In fact, what is used to calculate rocket trajectories is the 5th c, Aryabhata's method of finite differences to numerically solve the ordinary differential equations of projectile motion, as I explain in detail in my calculus as ganita course. (pic1) But the other thing colonial education taught Indians was to ape the West. Therefore, after the US Sputnik effort, our math syllabi changed to imitate what was done in the US. We started teaching "modern math" from the late 60s. "Ours not to reason why, ours but to ape and cry." For example, when I studied "Euclidean" geometry in school in the mid 60s, it was on the 19th c., stupid Cambridge syllabus where SAS (Prop;ostion 4) was a theorem (proved empirically). Today we teach that SAS (side-angle-side) is a postulate as Russell et al recommended (since empirical proof is not acceptable in axiomatic math). There, was no need to ask anybody in India. All neta-s, babus and math profs concurred that whatever US did was best and there was no need for us to think about it.think This is the very same superstition promoted by ignorant and idiot journalists like Mohana Basu, of irresponsible media like the Print, that any attempt to think, or to tell us anything contrary to Xtian superstitions in math, is Hindu fanaticism. It is interesting how she got support from a buffoon and a lying math prof, and a scheming parliamentarian like Jawhar Sircar, Our only consolation is that we were not the only ones to be fooled. This scheme of spreading Western political dominance through the trick of axiomatic mathematics was so successful that all Muslim countries accepted it, even those which ban or limit the Bible. They happily accepted axiomatic mathematics without the slightest inkling of its crusading Christian theological origin as a trick against Islam. They not only teach it, but pay extra to Whites to teach it. 😀 Like us, they may stay confused till the end of time because the only way we know to try to undo it is to ask a math prof whose livelihood depends upon axiomatic mathematics. Some hope. This is the evil magic of the padres, contd.../25
3
36
2
81
1,678
So strong was the grip of silly padreist superstitions on the European mind, especially in Western academics, and especially in religious Western math, that these Xtian superstitions dominated the further development of Western math. So, AFTER the lack of axiomatic proofs in the "Euclid" book was exposed in the 20th c., a new effort was made to regain church control of math. This aimed to reimpose axiomatic proof not only in geometry but on all math, without ever acknowledging the origins of this tricky method of proof in the politics of the crusading church. (They just said the non-existent Euclid "intended" axiomatic proofs, and gullible Westerners swallowed it, despite all the manifest diagrams in the "Euclid" book, against axiomatic proof, and linking it to Plato.) This modern-day church effort led to the development of axiomatic set theory on which all axiomatic mathematics is based today. ` Things changed after the 1950s because the Soviets paid more attention to practical mathematics of use to society. Taking off from the successful use of Indian war rockets of the 17th and 18th c., the Soviets built rockets good enough to send a satellite, Sputnik, into space. This also meant that the Soviets acquired the capacity to drop a nuclear bomb over any part of the US. This frightened Americans out of their wits. They now faced the spectre of having nuclear bombs dropped on them the way they had brutally dropped them on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. In response to this extreme fright, the US invested a billion dollars (those days, in 1950's) to improve the teaching of math. However, American thinking was deeply colored by church superstitions, especially the church dogma of progress that whatever is later must be better; the hidden hand of god ensures that there is never any regress. 🤣 Therefore, all the mathematicians in the US wrongly assumed that since axiomatic mathematics of set theory came later, it must be better. Of course, as I have repeatedly pointed out, axiomatic mathematics (or the understanding of calculus using axiomatic real numbers) is NEVER used to calculate rocket trajectories, and can never be used. But we will never understand that because colonial education made us mathematically illiterate. So we will wait till a Western authority confirms it, which will never happen. In fact, what is used to calculate rocket trajectories is the 5th c, Aryabhata's method of finite differences to numerically solve the ordinary differential equations of projectile motion, as I explain in detail in my calculus as ganita course. (pic1) But the other thing colonial education taught Indians was to ape the West. Therefore, after the US Sputnik effort, our math syllabi changed to imitate what was done in the US. We started teaching "modern math" from the late 60s. "Ours not to reason why, ours but to ape and cry." For example, when I studied "Euclidean" geometry in school in the mid 60s, it was on the 19th c., stupid Cambridge syllabus where SAS (Prop;ostion 4) was a theorem (proved empirically). Today we teach that SAS (side-angle-side) is a postulate as Russell et al recommended (since empirical proof is not acceptable in axiomatic math). There, was no need to ask anybody in India. All neta-s, babus and math profs concurred that whatever US did was best and there was no need for us to think about it.think This is the very same superstition promoted by ignorant and idiot journalists like Mohana Basu, of irresponsible media like the Print, that any attempt to think, or to tell us anything contrary to Xtian superstitions in math, is Hindu fanaticism. It is interesting how she got support from a buffoon and a lying math prof, and a scheming parliamentarian like Jawhar Sircar, Our only consolation is that we were not the only ones to be fooled. This scheme of spreading Western political dominance through the trick of axiomatic mathematics was so successful that all Muslim countries accepted it, even those which ban or limit the Bible. They happily accepted axiomatic mathematics without the slightest inkling of its crusading Christian theological origin as a trick against Islam. They not only teach it, but pay extra to Whites to teach it. 😀 Like us, they may stay confused till the end of time because the only way we know to try to undo it is to ask a math prof whose livelihood depends upon axiomatic mathematics. Some hope. This is the evil magic of the padres, contd.../25
To summarize, (1) There was no Euclid (and since 2012, no one has accepted my challenge prize of Rs 2 lakhs to provide primary evidence for Euclid bcoz there is NO EVIDENCE. But we still believe the story all the same! We don't need evidence. We need authority! That is our foolishness. (2) EVERY aspect of the Euclid story is a lie. It is one thing that there was no historical Euclid. but the undeniable fact is there are no axiomatic proofs in the Euclid book. This was finally admitted in the West at the beginning of the 20th c. by Hilbert, Russell, Birkhoff etc. who tried to give the missing axiomatic proofs, completely distorting the book in the process. But this church lie is desperately preserved by axiomatic mathematicians to hide the fact that axiomatic proof originated as a trick of church theology, and to hide the disgrace to Cambridge U for having taught this silly lie for seven centuries. (3) It is a further lie that the "Euclid" book intended axiomatic proofs, but erroneously failed to give them. Axiomatic proofs were NEVER INTENDED in the "Euclid" book which is chock full of diagrams. Russell who wrote a fat book on the history of Western philosophy should have known that diagrams are connected to Plato's religious understanding of geometry linking it to soul arousal literally as in Meno etc. Instead, Russell foolishly poked fun at the non-existent Euclid for not understanding that diagrams are irrelevant to axiomatic proof. Plato's religious and anti practical understanding of mathematics was carried forward for over a thousand years by the church quadrivium, In 1940 Hardy replaced Plato's literal "soul arousal" with the stupid euphemism of aesthetics, well knowing that the vast majority of school children detest the ugliness and uselessness of axiomatic mathematics. (4) Axiomatic mathematics is not superior for any practical value such as transactions in a grocery shop or calculating rocket trajectories, where it is a disadvantage. Axiomatic proof is anti-practical in line with the church belittling of practical mathematics. But we foolishly came to believe that it has superior practical value because we wrongly equated mathematics with ganita based on a completely wrong translation of mathematics as ganita, a foolish mistake made by our Sanskritists which we can never hope to correct now that it is so widespread. (5) Axiomatic mathematics is superior ONLY for political purposes, for Western political domination, not for any epistemic value. Indeed it is epistemically inferior since the axioms are fantasies and mathematical theorems are unreal conclusions derived from these fantasies, just as the Banach-Tarski theorem is derived from the fantasy axioms of set theory. The superior political value of axiomatic mathematics is clear from the fact that nobody in any mathematics department in India has in 7 years accepted my challenge to prove 1+1= 2. They have to rely on authority not only for the axioms but also for the theorems. In other words, having accepted axiomatic mathematics, we are forever the mental slaves of the West for every trivial thing. (6) With extraordinary foolishness, we Indians accepted the padre-Macaulay claim of a "superior" Western ethnomathematics at a time in the 19th c., when the West was grossly INFERIOR and leading British mathematicians such as Augustus de Morgan were stupidly struggling with negative numbers from India and saying that negative numbers are evil and that 10-11 does not exist and that -9 cannot be less than zero, just as we superstitiously accepted the superstition that a white skin is a sign of the Xtian god's favor.(pic1) Wars are fought with deception as much as by arms. We did not understand that padres deceptive way to permanently establish lies in the minds of children by taking over the education system as we so foolishly allowed them to do. Is there any remedy today? Difficult. The present government has clearly stated that it is against Macaulay. But what did it DO? It appointed Munjul Bhagava to advise on math education. On what basis? Other than the silly padreist boast that the West is superior? What is the practical benefit that Manjul Bhagav's axiomatic number has brought to any Indian. But Indians still think that the right thing is to appeal to the neta's and the ministers who know nothing of mathematics. India was looted, reduced from plenty to poverty, using deception and mind control by padres and will continue to suffer forever until such time as it learns to again respects knowledge, reject Western superstitions, and restores the tradition of open debate instead of relying on neta-s and babu-s who have zero knowledge. contd.../24
5
77
2
204
4,502
sandith retweeted
For 55 years, one man in Kerala kept checking the astronomy books of his time against the actual sky. The books lost. This is the story of a man stating the circumradius formula for a cyclic quadrilateral about 350 years before Lhuilier (1782)... In 1393, Vatasseri Paramesvara, a Rigvedi Nambudiri of the Bhrigu (bhargava) gotra living in Alattur village on the northern bank of the Nila (Bharathappuzha), started recording every eclipse he saw, with the place. - Navakshetra, 1422. - Gokarna, 1425. - Gokarna again, 1430. His last recorded observation is from 1445, when he was an old man. The problem he faced was real. The standard planetary tables, descended from Aryabhata's Parahita system, no longer matched the sky. Eclipses were arriving early / late. His student Nilakantha Somayaji writes: परमेश्वराचार्येण ग्रहणग्रहयोगादिकं यन्त्रैः पञ्चपञ्चाशद्वर्षकालं सम्यक् परीक्षितम् Acharya Paramesvara carefully examined eclipses and planetary conjunctions, with instruments, for fifty-five years. So Paramesvara rebuilt the system from observation. In 1431 he brought out his corrected astronomy and named it simply Drgganita, "computed as seen": दृग्गणितं नाम गणितं क्रियते मया (I compose this work called Drgganita). He also wrote a manual devoted only to eclipses, the Grahanamandana (c. 1410). And he was honest about his own results. His computations, he wrote, will agree with the sky only "prayah" - approximately. The small remaining differences come from factors not yet known, and future observers will find the corrections. On a riverbank in 15th century Malabar, that is the scientific method in one shloka. The same Paramesvara stated the circumradius formula for a cyclic quadrilateral, the one textbooks credit to Lhuilier in 1782, about 350 years earlier. His Siddhantadipika carries an iterative scheme that is essentially the modern secant method. His son Damodara went on to teach the great Nilakantha Somayaji. Everyone knows Aryabhata and Bhaskara. The man who taught Indian astronomy to check itself against the sky lives in a handful of research papers. 🙏🙏 P.S. Drgganita = drk (seen) + ganita (computed). The name is the method. Sources: K.V. Sarma (ed.), Grahanamandana, Hoshiarpur 1965, Introduction; Nilakantha Somayaji, Aryabhatiya-bhashya, Golapada, Trivandrum Sanskrit Series 185, pp. 154-155; D. Pingree, JAOS 87 (1967) 337-339; K.V. Sarma (ed.), Drgganita, Hoshiarpur 1963; Kuppanna Sastri (ed.), Mahabhaskariya with Siddhantadipika, Madras 1957; R.C. Gupta, Historia Mathematica 4 (1977) 67-74; K. Plofker, Historia Mathematica 23 (1996) 246-256. Photo 1: The key image. Nilakantha's Aryabhatiya-bhashya, Golapada 48: Paramesvara examined eclipses and conjunctions with instruments for 55 years (left, top). Right page: the Drgganita verse and his own eclipse verses naming Gokarna and Navakshetra. Photo 2: Sarma's introduction p. xii: Rigvedi Brahmin of the Bhrgu gotra, Alattur village, house Vatasseri on the northern bank of the Nila. Top highlight: Drgganita II.46, his "prayah" (more or less) statement. Photo 3: Same introduction p. xiii: teachers Rudra, Narayana, Madhava. Drgganita composed in Saka 1353 (1431 CE). Photo 4: Same introduction p. xiv: the last observation in Kali 4536 (1445 CE), and the 55 years of observation.
22
348
18
1,018
55,806
sandith retweeted
Two Indian police officers, Qazi Azizul Haque and Hem Chandra Bose, developed a fingerprint classification system in the 1890s that revolutionized criminal identification. However, their British boss, Edward Henry, became famous for their work, and the system was named after him.
95
1,029
58
5,537
158,292
"Arabic numerals" (0–9) actually originated in India, were refined in Baghdad, and were brought to Europe by Fibonacci because of his dad’s job in North Africa. Even Fibonacci’s work was directly copied from mathematical concepts that not only originated but were common in India. To his credit, however, he openly acknowledged their Indian origins rather than claiming them as his own or attempting to appropriate them. Zero was invented by a legendary Indian mathematician named Aryabhatta. It was an Indian astronomer who defined zero as a number, but the concept of zero, as in "nothing", was already in known by the Babylonians a few centuries before him who used a placeholder to denote "nothing". But, they never included zero as a number in the timeline. Understanding nothing and giving nothing a value are two very different things. It’s the reason there is no year 0, we go from 1 bc to 1 ad.
41
407
10
1,509
18,467
To summarize, (1) There was no Euclid (and since 2012, no one has accepted my challenge prize of Rs 2 lakhs to provide primary evidence for Euclid bcoz there is NO EVIDENCE. But we still believe the story all the same! We don't need evidence. We need authority! That is our foolishness. (2) EVERY aspect of the Euclid story is a lie. It is one thing that there was no historical Euclid. but the undeniable fact is there are no axiomatic proofs in the Euclid book. This was finally admitted in the West at the beginning of the 20th c. by Hilbert, Russell, Birkhoff etc. who tried to give the missing axiomatic proofs, completely distorting the book in the process. But this church lie is desperately preserved by axiomatic mathematicians to hide the fact that axiomatic proof originated as a trick of church theology, and to hide the disgrace to Cambridge U for having taught this silly lie for seven centuries. (3) It is a further lie that the "Euclid" book intended axiomatic proofs, but erroneously failed to give them. Axiomatic proofs were NEVER INTENDED in the "Euclid" book which is chock full of diagrams. Russell who wrote a fat book on the history of Western philosophy should have known that diagrams are connected to Plato's religious understanding of geometry linking it to soul arousal literally as in Meno etc. Instead, Russell foolishly poked fun at the non-existent Euclid for not understanding that diagrams are irrelevant to axiomatic proof. Plato's religious and anti practical understanding of mathematics was carried forward for over a thousand years by the church quadrivium, In 1940 Hardy replaced Plato's literal "soul arousal" with the stupid euphemism of aesthetics, well knowing that the vast majority of school children detest the ugliness and uselessness of axiomatic mathematics. (4) Axiomatic mathematics is not superior for any practical value such as transactions in a grocery shop or calculating rocket trajectories, where it is a disadvantage. Axiomatic proof is anti-practical in line with the church belittling of practical mathematics. But we foolishly came to believe that it has superior practical value because we wrongly equated mathematics with ganita based on a completely wrong translation of mathematics as ganita, a foolish mistake made by our Sanskritists which we can never hope to correct now that it is so widespread. (5) Axiomatic mathematics is superior ONLY for political purposes, for Western political domination, not for any epistemic value. Indeed it is epistemically inferior since the axioms are fantasies and mathematical theorems are unreal conclusions derived from these fantasies, just as the Banach-Tarski theorem is derived from the fantasy axioms of set theory. The superior political value of axiomatic mathematics is clear from the fact that nobody in any mathematics department in India has in 7 years accepted my challenge to prove 1+1= 2. They have to rely on authority not only for the axioms but also for the theorems. In other words, having accepted axiomatic mathematics, we are forever the mental slaves of the West for every trivial thing. (6) With extraordinary foolishness, we Indians accepted the padre-Macaulay claim of a "superior" Western ethnomathematics at a time in the 19th c., when the West was grossly INFERIOR and leading British mathematicians such as Augustus de Morgan were stupidly struggling with negative numbers from India and saying that negative numbers are evil and that 10-11 does not exist and that -9 cannot be less than zero, just as we superstitiously accepted the superstition that a white skin is a sign of the Xtian god's favor.(pic1) Wars are fought with deception as much as by arms. We did not understand that padres deceptive way to permanently establish lies in the minds of children by taking over the education system as we so foolishly allowed them to do. Is there any remedy today? Difficult. The present government has clearly stated that it is against Macaulay. But what did it DO? It appointed Munjul Bhagava to advise on math education. On what basis? Other than the silly padreist boast that the West is superior? What is the practical benefit that Manjul Bhagav's axiomatic number has brought to any Indian. But Indians still think that the right thing is to appeal to the neta's and the ministers who know nothing of mathematics. India was looted, reduced from plenty to poverty, using deception and mind control by padres and will continue to suffer forever until such time as it learns to again respects knowledge, reject Western superstitions, and restores the tradition of open debate instead of relying on neta-s and babu-s who have zero knowledge. contd.../24
As the Lokayata pointed out over 2500 years ago, deductive proof is INFERIOR and unreliable. Why? For it can only result in RELATIVE "truths", i,e., "truths" relative to the starting assumptions, which may have no relation to any actual truths in the real world. For details and references see my Durban keynote/article in pic1. This was combined with a further inferior axiomatic method of beginning the deductive proof with axioms. Axioms are NOT self-evident truths. That was a church superstition. Axioms are nothing more than assumptions or postulate as even the NCERT class 9 math text under UPA admitted (pic2) Finally, this was combined with a third trick. The axioms of Christian theology (like Aquinas' axiom about angels) are pure metaphysics or rather NON-physics, mere unreal fantasies. The "truth" of theses fantasies cannot be determined by experiment. It can only be decreed by authority just as the "truth" of Harry Potter fantasies can only be decided by the author of the books. Because the church padres owned Western education (=colonial education) from Sunday school to the highest universities, or Xtian madrassas like Oxford, Cambridge and Paris), this religious method of proof crept into their teaching of mathematics as religion (Plato, quadrivium, and through the "Euclid" book). When the completely bogus church myth of axiomatic proofs in the "Euclid" book collapsed in the 20th c. the church padres worked hard to reformulate all mathematics around axiomatic with their usual tactic of declaring it "superior". This involved Hilbert, Birkhoff, the agnostic Russell and his Bourbaki courtiers. All of "modern math" is based on the axioms of set theory, which are a fantasy metaphysics of infinity, closely allied to church dogmas of eternity.(pic3) The fantasy axioms results in fantasy conclusions called theorems, like the nonsense Banach-Tarski theorem that one ball of gold can be mathematically converted to two balls of gold of the same size without stretching or distortion and so on. Worse this kind of axiomatic/fantasy math can be pushed into science at the highest level thus allowing the promotion of Christian creationism as science.(pic4). These people well know they are peddling superstitions as is clear from the attacks by GFR Ellis (Stephen Hawking's co-author), and his church goons on me through the press in South Africa. See also the link in pic4 to the Delhi debate between Roger Penrose and me on singularity theory. contd.../23
1
43
1
77
4,093
sandith retweeted
This story is in 2 parts, and this is the 1st. Aryabhata was the master everyone followed. In 628 CE, a 30 year old in Bhillamala, a town in southern Marwad, said his numbers were as accidental as the marks weevils leave in wood. Brahmagupta's Brahmasphutasiddhanta, written under King Vyaghramukha, is a landmark of world mathematics. It is also a takedown. One entire chapter, the Tantrapariksha, "an examination of other treatises", exists to examine and demolish rival schools of astronomy, above all the school of one man: Aryabhata. Aryabhata (Aryabhatiya, 499 CE) was the towering master. Bhaskara I, the finest astronomer of the next generation, followed him line by line. As Brahmagupta's modern editor puts it: "Bhaskara closely followed Aryabhata, but Brahmagupta had the guts to oppose the views expressed by this great master." Guts is one word for it. Here is what Brahmagupta actually wrote. On Aryabhata's eclipse mathematics: "Aryabhata made the apogee of the Moon as moving more quickly and the node as moving more slowly than their actual motions; if his constants give correct results in relation to the end of tithis or eclipses, they must be considered as accidental as are the letters cut into wood by weevils." Weevils. The greatest astronomer of the age before him had, in Brahmagupta's telling, the predictive power of bug scratches in wood. On his own genius: "On seeing me, who possess the most accurate knowledge of mean motions, men who have learnt from the works of Srisena, Visnucandra and Aryabhata cannot face me in any meeting just like deer on seeing a lion." Deer before a lion. In a mathematics book. About himself. And the verdict on the entire school: "As the apparent planets beginning with Mars as derived from the works of Srisena, Aryabhata and Visnucandra are far deviated from their true places, the works of these authors are therefore not valued among the learned." Now the twist. 37 years later, in 665 CE, Brahmagupta wrote a second, gentler book. He named it Khandakhadyaka, literally "food prepared from sugar-candy". And in its main text, the man who had called Aryabhata's astronomy weevil scratches quietly built his planetary calculations on Aryabhata's own midnight system. His modern editor is openly baffled: "The question why Brahmagupta who was so bitter an opponent of Aryabhata in his younger days (628 CE) climbed down to describe and teach one of the systems of Aryabhata's astronomy in his sixty-seventh year (665 CE) is difficult to explain." And in the sugar candy's appendix, the weevil verse, the lion verse and the verdict are reprinted word for word. The lion came back to graze with the deer. He just never stopped roaring. Part 2 follows: the one attack in that book that went too far, and the scholar who answered it 230 years later. Sources: R.S. Sharma (ed.), Brahmasphutasiddhanta of Brahmagupta, Vol. 1 (INSA, 1966), Introduction, pp. 47, 53-54, 73, 79-81. Verses: BrSpSi I.62-63, II.47 (= Khandakhadyaka Uttara IX.1-3). Photo 1: Brahmagupta on Aryabhata's eclipse constants: "accidental as are the letters cut into wood by weevils" (BrSpSi I.62). On himself: rivals "cannot face me in any meeting just like deer on seeing a lion" (I.63). Verdict: their works "are therefore not valued among the learned" (II.47). From R.S. Sharma's edition of the Brahmasphutasiddhanta, Vol. 1 (INSA 1966), Intro p. 53. Photo 2: The twist, on the page: the Khandakhadyaka is "literally meaning food prepared from sugar-candy", and his modern editor cannot explain why "Brahmagupta who was so bitter an opponent of Aryabhata in his younger days climbed down to describe and teach one of the systems of Aryabhata's astronomy in his 67th year (665 A.D.)". Same edition, Intro p. 80.
4
94
5
221
8,789
As the Lokayata pointed out over 2500 years ago, deductive proof is INFERIOR and unreliable. Why? For it can only result in RELATIVE "truths", i,e., "truths" relative to the starting assumptions, which may have no relation to any actual truths in the real world. For details and references see my Durban keynote/article in pic1. This was combined with a further inferior axiomatic method of beginning the deductive proof with axioms. Axioms are NOT self-evident truths. That was a church superstition. Axioms are nothing more than assumptions or postulate as even the NCERT class 9 math text under UPA admitted (pic2) Finally, this was combined with a third trick. The axioms of Christian theology (like Aquinas' axiom about angels) are pure metaphysics or rather NON-physics, mere unreal fantasies. The "truth" of theses fantasies cannot be determined by experiment. It can only be decreed by authority just as the "truth" of Harry Potter fantasies can only be decided by the author of the books. Because the church padres owned Western education (=colonial education) from Sunday school to the highest universities, or Xtian madrassas like Oxford, Cambridge and Paris), this religious method of proof crept into their teaching of mathematics as religion (Plato, quadrivium, and through the "Euclid" book). When the completely bogus church myth of axiomatic proofs in the "Euclid" book collapsed in the 20th c. the church padres worked hard to reformulate all mathematics around axiomatic with their usual tactic of declaring it "superior". This involved Hilbert, Birkhoff, the agnostic Russell and his Bourbaki courtiers. All of "modern math" is based on the axioms of set theory, which are a fantasy metaphysics of infinity, closely allied to church dogmas of eternity.(pic3) The fantasy axioms results in fantasy conclusions called theorems, like the nonsense Banach-Tarski theorem that one ball of gold can be mathematically converted to two balls of gold of the same size without stretching or distortion and so on. Worse this kind of axiomatic/fantasy math can be pushed into science at the highest level thus allowing the promotion of Christian creationism as science.(pic4). These people well know they are peddling superstitions as is clear from the attacks by GFR Ellis (Stephen Hawking's co-author), and his church goons on me through the press in South Africa. See also the link in pic4 to the Delhi debate between Roger Penrose and me on singularity theory. contd.../23
Since axiomatic proof originates in the superstitions of crusading Christian theology, empirical proof or observation is prohibited in axiomatic proof, also in mathematics. But it is acceptable in ganita as in science. I reiterated these points during a lecture on practical ganita vs religious math. This included (1) the KG method, (2) the method of the Nyaya sutra, and (3) the axiomatic method. (pic1, ALT for detailed links to each) A remarkably stupid and ill-informed "science editor" of the Print, Mohana Basu, reported on my talk. The report was full of grave errors and insinuations which will make it go down in world history as the most laughably ill informed article of all time in all history of science reporting. But let us set that aside for the moment , as also the issues of the intellectual thefts by Einstein and Newton, and focus on a single issue about math: Is the empirical (प्रत्यक्ष प्रमाण) or observation, prohibited or not in axiomatic math? During my talk, I again quoted the class 9 NCERT text that proofs in axiomatic math must use logic alone, and reject observations. These proofs are prohibited from using logic + observation as in ganita or science.(pic2) But this class 9 text (compulsory reading for all) was too far beyond the intellectual capabilities of Mohana Basu to fact check. I am setting aside the issue of fact checking by reading from Plato to Hardy that the West had a religious and anti-practical view of mathematics. Since she could not believe this, due to loads of colonial indoctrination, she "fact checked" the colonial way by asking two mathematicians. One a buffoon and the other a liar. The buffoon, Sitabhra Sinha (pic3), foolishly equated √2 in the sulba sutra with the axiomatic real number √2. He needs no further consideration. The other Amritanshu Prasad lied that the empirical is NOT prohibited in axiomatic mathematics at a higher level. Well, Shri 420 Prasad, is 1+1=2 a very high level of mathematics? Can you follow Russell's axiomatic proof of 1+1=2? Can u show me the empirical in it? Can you meet my Cape Town-JNU challenge to prove 1+1=2 in axiomatic real numbers from first principles without assuming any theorem of axiomatic set theory? In any case, can you point to at least one empirical step in either one of those proof? If not, will you admit u lied to mislead people and preserve ur privileges? Will u resign out of shame (if u have any)? I have expressed the view that you are too incompetent a mathematician to know the proof of 1+1=2. Would you like me to offer you an inducement to disprove me by way of my prize? I will repeat my prize on one condition, that if your proof has one single mistake, you promise to resign from your job and leave mathematics forever. Will you accept the bet? I further bet you will dodge, The parliamentarian Jawhar Sarkar, who probably sponsored Basu, who spreads the poison of Xtian fanaticism (they financed u?) by pretending that anything contrary to Christian chauvinistic history that Newton discovered calculus is mere Hindu fanaticism. No need to read or know anything. That's a new low even by the standards of neta-s in trying to push Indian people back into padreist mental slavery. The moral of the story is simple. If, for everything as simple as 1+1=2, we blindly trust authority, on padreist teaching of faith, we are unable to discern whether the authority in question is competent or honest, i.e., whether a buffoon or a liar. contd.../23
32
2
56
2,449
Since axiomatic proof originates in the superstitions of crusading Christian theology, empirical proof or observation is prohibited in axiomatic proof, also in mathematics. But it is acceptable in ganita as in science. I reiterated these points during a lecture on practical ganita vs religious math. This included (1) the KG method, (2) the method of the Nyaya sutra, and (3) the axiomatic method. (pic1, ALT for detailed links to each) A remarkably stupid and ill-informed "science editor" of the Print, Mohana Basu, reported on my talk. The report was full of grave errors and insinuations which will make it go down in world history as the most laughably ill informed article of all time in all history of science reporting. But let us set that aside for the moment , as also the issues of the intellectual thefts by Einstein and Newton, and focus on a single issue about math: Is the empirical (प्रत्यक्ष प्रमाण) or observation, prohibited or not in axiomatic math? During my talk, I again quoted the class 9 NCERT text that proofs in axiomatic math must use logic alone, and reject observations. These proofs are prohibited from using logic + observation as in ganita or science.(pic2) But this class 9 text (compulsory reading for all) was too far beyond the intellectual capabilities of Mohana Basu to fact check. I am setting aside the issue of fact checking by reading from Plato to Hardy that the West had a religious and anti-practical view of mathematics. Since she could not believe this, due to loads of colonial indoctrination, she "fact checked" the colonial way by asking two mathematicians. One a buffoon and the other a liar. The buffoon, Sitabhra Sinha (pic3), foolishly equated √2 in the sulba sutra with the axiomatic real number √2. He needs no further consideration. The other Amritanshu Prasad lied that the empirical is NOT prohibited in axiomatic mathematics at a higher level. Well, Shri 420 Prasad, is 1+1=2 a very high level of mathematics? Can you follow Russell's axiomatic proof of 1+1=2? Can u show me the empirical in it? Can you meet my Cape Town-JNU challenge to prove 1+1=2 in axiomatic real numbers from first principles without assuming any theorem of axiomatic set theory? In any case, can you point to at least one empirical step in either one of those proof? If not, will you admit u lied to mislead people and preserve ur privileges? Will u resign out of shame (if u have any)? I have expressed the view that you are too incompetent a mathematician to know the proof of 1+1=2. Would you like me to offer you an inducement to disprove me by way of my prize? I will repeat my prize on one condition, that if your proof has one single mistake, you promise to resign from your job and leave mathematics forever. Will you accept the bet? I further bet you will dodge, The parliamentarian Jawhar Sarkar, who probably sponsored Basu, who spreads the poison of Xtian fanaticism (they financed u?) by pretending that anything contrary to Christian chauvinistic history that Newton discovered calculus is mere Hindu fanaticism. No need to read or know anything. That's a new low even by the standards of neta-s in trying to push Indian people back into padreist mental slavery. The moral of the story is simple. If, for everything as simple as 1+1=2, we blindly trust authority, on padreist teaching of faith, we are unable to discern whether the authority in question is competent or honest, i.e., whether a buffoon or a liar. contd.../23
Indian ganita is secular and practical, but is wrongly translated as mathematics by incompetent Sanskritists (pic1) The West had a RELIGIOUS and ANTI-practical understanding of mathematics. The very word mathematics, from mathesis, or learning, was linked to soul arousal (pic2), From Plato and Socrates thru Proclus, the church quadrivium of Beoethius, to Hardy in the 1940's, the practical value of mathematics was despised.(pic3) But colonial/padreist education taught us to NOT trust our eyes or the original sources, We cannot believe that the West was so superstitious for so long, and want confirmation from Western sources (😀) Wikipedia and chatbots. This method of seeking authoritative confirmation from the West is a key aspect of the Xtian superstitions inculcated by colonial/padreist teaching. Perhaps we will take a thousand years to understand this religiosity of Western mathematics just as Europeans took a thousand years to understand that Indian place value arithmetic is superior to their primitive pebble arithmetic. The simplest way to understand this "practical ganit versus religious mathematics" is to note that in mathematics today (=axiomatic mathematics=Western ethnomath) the empirical is prohibited, whereas in ganita it is accepted as in science.(pic4) contd.../22
2
35
1
77
2,612
sandith retweeted
Excellent order passed by Hon'ble Division Bench of the Madras High Court on 04.11.2026 - to protect the extremely valuable lands of Sri Agastheeswarar Sri Prasana Venkatesa Perumal temple in Nungambakkam, in the centre of Chennai City (and just half a kilometer from the headquarters of @tnhrcedept) The total properties of the temple is said to be worth Rs.5000/- Crores and they have been under encroachment for decades with the useless @tnhrcedept doing nothing to recover/protect them. However - the @tnhrcedept shamelessly used the proximity of the temple and its funds to: a. buy news papers, magazines for every section in the Department headquarters (they have more than 20 sections) (about Rs. 1.20 to 1.5 lakhs per annum) b. frequently order meals, tiffin, water cans, etc. for the Department c. Photocopying expenses, A4, Legal size paper supply to the Department's legal wing d. Mosquito bats, dinner plates, plastic wares, etc. for the department and so on Instead of ensuring that the properties of this temple were never encroached or alienated and instead of making sure the due annual income of not less Rs. 60.00 crores is always realized for this temple - the shameless officials of the @tnhrcedept looted this impoverished temple.... again and again!
7
154
5
354
4,998
Which is BETTER ("Pythagorean THEOREM" or sulba-sutra CALCULATION)? Deciding this needs knowledge of axiomatic math which few have. It also needs knowledge of IKS which too few have. (Mere knowledge of Sanskrit is NOT enough.) I explained that the Manav sulbasutra 10.10 (pic1,2,3) states the "Pythagorean" CALCULATION using the square ROOT. Square roots were unknown to early Greeks given INFERIOR early Greek and Roman arithmetic. Nothing like this could have been STATED by any early Greek such as Pythagoras (if he existed). Further, for practical applications such as land measurement (e.g. to pay tax)_ we need calculation, not mere theorem proving. So it is the calculation which is more important. But the new school text under NEP prepared by Manjul Bhargava & Co. emphasizes the importance of theorem-proving as done in Western ethnomath. By calling it the Pythagoras Baudhayan THEOREM the aim is to indoctrinate children that theorem proving as in Xtian theology is "superior", while throwing some misleading crumbs at the Indian contribution by adding Baūdhayan, Use of the Manava sulba sutra would reverse this. But we can't do this. We can't stand up to the West under any circumstances. We still do what the West wants and te West wants that Indian school children must be wrongly taught that mathematics is not for its practical value, of CALCULATIONS (as in ganita) but only for useless theorem proving from some fantasy axioms. Obviously, also, If we teach the importance of practical calculations, Bhargava's Fields medal becomes valueless for it is given ONLY for proving utterly useless theorems. Colonial education taught us to be mental slaves. As mental slaves, Indians must ape what padres do, whether it is the inferior calendar, or Sunday as a holiday, or mathematics of theorem-proving and reciting the silly myth of Pythagoras. contd.../21
The difference is that the NDA textbook deceptively speaks of the Pythagorean-Baudhayan THEOREM. People feel happy that the Indian priority is acknowledged (though there is no evidence to connect Pythagoras to the proposition named after him). And similar results were known to the Egyptians and the Babylonians, recorded from much earlier times, so there is no real priority in acknowledging Baudayana. . Further this deceived us again because it does not matter who did it first. What matters is who did it BETTER, as in this cartoon in my colloquium at IIT Mandi.(pic1) Calling it a theorem (though there is no proof in Bauudhayan) again falsel;y suggests that the "Greeks" did it better, and that padreist axiomatic proof is superior. What is better? I have explained that. contd.../20
1
40
2
84
3,667
The difference is that the NDA textbook deceptively speaks of the Pythagorean-Baudhayan THEOREM. People feel happy that the Indian priority is acknowledged (though there is no evidence to connect Pythagoras to the proposition named after him). And similar results were known to the Egyptians and the Babylonians, recorded from much earlier times, so there is no real priority in acknowledging Baudayana. . Further this deceived us again because it does not matter who did it first. What matters is who did it BETTER, as in this cartoon in my colloquium at IIT Mandi.(pic1) Calling it a theorem (though there is no proof in Bauudhayan) again falsel;y suggests that the "Greeks" did it better, and that padreist axiomatic proof is superior. What is better? I have explained that. contd.../20
It is NOT an issue of NDA versus UPA. Under UPA Pervin Sinclair (then NCERT Director) and Jayant Narlikar (Head of NCERT textbook committee) promoted the silly myth of Euclid and implant edthe related superstitions of this supposedly "superior" axiomatic proofs in minds of Indian school kids (pic1) The NDA government did no better. As we saw, it appointed Manjul Bhargava who quietly sat through my exposure of the myths and superstitions about Euclid in axiomatic math.(pic2) Obviously Bhargava could not object because he knows there are no axiomatic proofs in the Euclid book; it is a bogus myth. But accepting it openly would prove that his Fields medal is just an an investment in superstition. If he has any objections, he should stand up now or keep his peace forever. contd .../19
1
26
2
69
2,938
It is NOT an issue of NDA versus UPA. Under UPA Pervin Sinclair (then NCERT Director) and Jayant Narlikar (Head of NCERT textbook committee) promoted the silly myth of Euclid and implant edthe related superstitions of this supposedly "superior" axiomatic proofs in minds of Indian school kids (pic1) The NDA government did no better. As we saw, it appointed Manjul Bhargava who quietly sat through my exposure of the myths and superstitions about Euclid in axiomatic math.(pic2) Obviously Bhargava could not object because he knows there are no axiomatic proofs in the Euclid book; it is a bogus myth. But accepting it openly would prove that his Fields medal is just an an investment in superstition. If he has any objections, he should stand up now or keep his peace forever. contd .../19
That is, the Crusading church invented a politically convenient but scientifically useless method of proof, axiomatic proof, to prove propositions in Xtian theology. This method used NON-physical axioms based on authority (which axioms are fantasies which don't apply to the real world). The church added "reason" to mislead people that it was all proved by reason and not based on fantasy. Did the church invent this tricky method of axiomatic proof as a crusading scam, to fool Muslims? as used in axiomatic proof of Aquinas' Angel theorem (pic1) in Xtian rational theology. To dodge to charge that it invented a scammy method of proof in Xtian theology, the church used another trick. It invented a false myth to attribute the origin of this axiomatic method of proof to the Euclid book, a book falsely attributed to an early Greek but actually first brought to Europe ca. 1125 by the Crusading spy Adelard of Bath. Church madrasas such as Cambridge U. for centuries, from until 1888, taught the nonsense that Euclid invented this method of axiomatic proof (pic2) That is, just as DeMorgan taught the stupid arithmetic that negative numbers from India are evil, till end 19th c., Cambridge U. taught equally superstitious and inferior geometry till end 19th c. Eventually in 1899 it was exposed by Hilbert and Russell that there are NO AXIOMATIC proofs in the Euclid book.🤣🤣(pic3, 4) contd.../18
1
33
3
68
2,653
That is, the Crusading church invented a politically convenient but scientifically useless method of proof, axiomatic proof, to prove propositions in Xtian theology. This method used NON-physical axioms based on authority (which axioms are fantasies which don't apply to the real world). The church added "reason" to mislead people that it was all proved by reason and not based on fantasy. Did the church invent this tricky method of axiomatic proof as a crusading scam, to fool Muslims? as used in axiomatic proof of Aquinas' Angel theorem (pic1) in Xtian rational theology. To dodge to charge that it invented a scammy method of proof in Xtian theology, the church used another trick. It invented a false myth to attribute the origin of this axiomatic method of proof to the Euclid book, a book falsely attributed to an early Greek but actually first brought to Europe ca. 1125 by the Crusading spy Adelard of Bath. Church madrasas such as Cambridge U. for centuries, from until 1888, taught the nonsense that Euclid invented this method of axiomatic proof (pic2) That is, just as DeMorgan taught the stupid arithmetic that negative numbers from India are evil, till end 19th c., Cambridge U. taught equally superstitious and inferior geometry till end 19th c. Eventually in 1899 it was exposed by Hilbert and Russell that there are NO AXIOMATIC proofs in the Euclid book.🤣🤣(pic3, 4) contd.../18
Axiomatic proof is characterized by two features. 1. The use of reasoning, 2. The prohibition of the empirical or observation or facts. It was a church trick which originated during the crusades which were fought to convert Muslims with a view to grab their wealth. Since force failed (all crusades after the first were military failures) Xtians had to use other means to convert them. But Muslims rejected the Bible as corrupted by the church (as Isaac Newton also did). But Muslims then accepted reason. See quote from the crusading spy Adelaard of Bath, who traveled in Muslim lands, disguised as a Muslim student, and who first brought the "Euclid" book to Europe.(pic1) Therefore, the only way to persuade them was to use reason. For this, it first had to make reason its tool for the word reason is hardly found in the Bible. Accordingly, the church created the Christian theology of reason to oppose the Muslim theology of reason or aql-i-kalam. Namely, that aql [अक्ल =? reason] was meant to be used, as Adelard also stated. (pic2) But to preserve their authority in theological matters, the padres used a dirty trick: they prohibited the empirical, for reason plus empirical as in ganita = science. That the empirical or observation is prohibited also in axiomatic proof in math is clarified also by the previous class 9 NCERT math text. (pic3) Remember that church theology was only interested in the politics of domination by fantasy, not in any practical or scientific applications. It declared this method of axiomatic proof as "superior" to the scientific method of proof used in ganita, and we stupidly believed it and still do. contd.../17
31
1
52
2,244
sandith retweeted
75 passengers. No diesel. Built in Kerala. 🚤☀️ Kochi-based Navalt is using solar panels, batteries, and electric motors to make water transport cleaner. Have you been on one of their boats? Which Kerala startup should we feature next? @sandith
1
7
191
First, Indian calendar-makers used the Surya Siddhant and Aryabhatiya, both of which I cited, They did NOT use the Puranas. Both texts advance a good reason for Saturday as the first day of the week, but NOT the Puranas. Our ancestors correctly preferred the science of the Surya Siddhanta and Aryabhatiya over the mythology of the Puranas, E.g. Lalla in his chp 20 called मिथ्याज्ञाननिराकरणम explains why eclipses are due to shadows of the moon and the earth and NOT due to the demons Rahu and Ketu eating up the sun and the moon as stated in the Puranas. He advances basic common-sense reasons.(pic1) He goes on to refute the mythical belief that the earth is supported by sesh nag etc. (pic2) Vateshwar does likewise in his Gola. I have written on both extensively. Furthermore, the Puranas are late accretrive texts, and even Dayanand Saraswati accepted the Puranas had no canonical authority in Hinduism. So you go ahead and defame Hinduism by passing off its myths of demons, myths rejected long ago by our own ancestors, as if they were science. I will stick to the real science of our ancestors. But don't expect me to take you seriously or to respond any further. As you can see, I'm in the midst of something far more important on math and AI.
13
61
185
3,555
Did you understand the the basics of colonial math (Western ethnomath) why 1+1=2 or why points are invisible in church geometry? If not how can you ever hope to understand that Newton had a confused understanding of Indian calculus with his silly fluxions (pic1). Or that this was replaced by a worse understanding of calculus with real numbers and limits. Regress not progress. The first question to ask is how do YOU benefit? Did the axiomatic proof of 1 +1 = 2 practically benefit you in a grocery shop? (pic2) Did your ignorance of it impede you in any way till today? Or did you just go along with the church superstition that the practical value of math is worthless? Likewise, rocket trajectories are calculated using the 5th c. Aryabhata's finite difference methods and not Newton's fluxions or axiomatic real numbers. Check it out. (Explained again in my forthcoming book, pic3.) Recall the Sputnik crisis when Soviet Russia developed rockets which could drop nuclear bombs anywhere in US. While the frightened US did change its math teaching after that, the fact is that US took the wrong decision. It wrongly assumed that axiomatic math or "modern" math is better math and the rest of the world followed. But axiomatic math is NOT the math used in rocket science. But if you don't know even class 6 math, you are a slave dependent on Western authority to tell you what to do. All you can do is to turn this way and that and ask Google and Wikipedīa and chatbots and axiomatic university mathematicians and other Western echo chambers. Q. Do YOU have any firsthand experience of ANY practical value from axiomatic mathematics? If not, reject it. To escape from mental slavery, you have to rebel against padreist Indoctrination. contd.../16
The church arithmetic of the quadrivium by Boethius was as INFERIOR for practical purposes as the church NONSENSE quadrivium geometry of invisible points.(pic1) Boethius emphasized that the church goal is AGAINST practical value (pic2) and for "spiritual" value which disappeared by the 6th c. Padres converted it to political value. Invisible points are still taught in the new NEP text for class 6 produced by Manjul Bhargava and co. Why? Invisible points have no practical value (for geo-metry) to measure any area. But they puzzle students.(pic3) Therefore, students learn several lessons. The most Important political lesson is that the only way to understand (axiomatic) math (and the behavior of invisible points etc) is by blind obedience to whatever authority says. That is axiomatic mathematical proof is disconnected from experience and based primarily on authority. That greatly suits padres who hence first used this axiomatic method of proof in theology or god-knowledge. Padres proved that Indians as a nation are easily fooled for centuries. We just proved it by falling prey a second time to the padreist rhetoric of superiority, restated by Macaulay, by asking Manjul Bhargava to teach us how to do the "superior" if ūseless mathematics done in Princeton. But this is one case where AI has helped us by demonstrating the utter inferiority of not only of Western ethnomathematics but also of their Fields medals. (pic4) contd. .../15 .
2
40
2
104
3,234