Shahryar Pasandideh (@shahpas) header
Shahryar Pasandideh (@shahpas) profile picture

Military and technology analyst. Fellow @UofT @BGCCIH. PhD from @GWtweets. Previously @BelferCenter. Press inquiries: send a DM and include your email.

Toronto
Joined August 2013
Photo by Shahryar Pasandideh (@shahpas)Photo by Shahryar Pasandideh (@shahpas)Photo by Shahryar Pasandideh (@shahpas)Photo by Shahryar Pasandideh (@shahpas)Photo by Shahryar Pasandideh (@shahpas)Photo by Shahryar Pasandideh (@shahpas)Photo by Shahryar Pasandideh (@shahpas)Photo by Shahryar Pasandideh (@shahpas)Photo by Shahryar Pasandideh (@shahpas)Photo by Shahryar Pasandideh (@shahpas)
Although I do not plan to delete this account or my threads and posts, I do not anticipate doing much posting or writing here going forward. I will be writing on my website; I am working on finalizing some things. spasconsulting.com/
2
1
14
18,474
Read the FT's reporting closely: Russia's sale of LMUR/Kh-39 launchers to Iran appears in a 2024–25 production schedule, so the order predates the June 2025 war, let alone the current war. It isn't evidence of Russian wartime resupply re Hormuz. Here as elsewhere, headlines...1/
2
2
16
1,406
let alone the current war. Any such arrangements between Iran and Russia are unlikely to have anything to do with the current state of affairs in the Strait of Hormuz. A similar dynamic applies to pre-28 Feb reports of a potential transfer of Chinese CM-302/YJ-12 supersonic 3/
🇨🇳🇮🇷🇺🇸 The reported deal in which China will sell supersonic CM-302 anti-ship missiles (image 1, from Algeria)—CM-302 is the export designation for the missile known as the YJ-12 in PLA service (image 2)— to Iran is interesting and will, if realized, amount to the latest in a long-running series of technology transfers from China to Iran in the area of anti-ship missile technology. Iran's Noor family of subsonic anti-ship cruise missiles are of Chinese origin, although Iran has a domestic production line and has evolved and adapted the design and the underlying components for its own purposes. Iran acquired the export-only Chinese C-802 in the 1990s. The Chinese military/PLA itself uses the related but nevertheless distinct YJ-83 family, which Iran does not operate. The most notable Iranian development of the Noor/C-802 is the extended-range Qader, which has a claimed nominal maximum range of 300 km. The Noor/C-802 is a subsonic turbojet-powered design comparable to certain versions of the French Exocet design and the American AGM/RGM/UGM-84 Harpoon design. Iran also received several smaller and shorter-range Chinese anti-ship missile designs that are powered by a solid-propellant rocket motor. This includes the Nasr, which is the Iranian version of the Chinese C-704, and the Kosar, which is the Iranian version of the Chinese C-701. Such Iranian-built anti-ship missiles have notably exported by Iran to Venezuela, as well as Iran's non-state allies in the Middle East. Ansarallah in Yemen has notably received both shorter-range and longer-range Iranian maritime strike munitions. The ramjet-powered supersonic Chinese CM-302, which is the export version of the YJ-12, is a far more sophisticated anti-ship missile than the aforementioned Chinese-origin designs manufactured in Iran. Iranian interest in supersonic anti-ship missiles, namely of Soviet-Russian origin, has been reported for several decades. There are claims that Iran deployed a supersonic anti-ship missile derived from the air-launched ramjet-powered supersonic Soviet-Russian Kh-31 by the summer of 2024 (images 3-4), although such claims cannot be corroborated with publicly available information. The CM-302/YJ-12 is a much larger and heavier supersonic anti-ship missile, one that can deliver a much larger warhead. China formally exports missiles that are compliant with the Missile Technology Control Regime (MTCR), which entails a maximum range restriction of 300 km. Such restrictions are often formalities, not least in a context in which all maximum range figures are inherently nominal. Supposing that Iran will receive MTCR-compliant CM-302 missiles, the presence of the CM-302/YJ-12 in Iran will further enhance Iran's maritime strike capabilities within the Persian Gulf and Strait of Hormuz, but will have more limited implications beyond that because the fundamental constraint in long-range maritime strike capabilities is not munitions range but maritime intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance (ISR). A supersonic anti-ship missile like the CM-302/YJ-12 amounts to a fairly short time-to-target maritime strike munition, one that is notably slower than an anti-ship ballistic missile of comparable range, but will not in itself address the major open water search challenge that Iran faces vis-a-vis the U.S. Navy in the Arabian Sea. 1/
1
4
372
…anti-ship missiles to Iran. It's a recurring pattern, and worth asking why: careless reading, motivated reasoning, or chasing engagement on a hot story. Either way, check the timelines, take note of a report, and carry on with the often mundane analytical work that is required
2
200
Replying to @matthew_petti
@matthew_petti recently had a post regarding Iran that included a gem of a jest: "my country yearns to be bombed." There appear to be area/country experts who think that bombing or starving a country will lead everyday people to rise up, depose their government, and end a war. 1/
There is a longstanding tendency among American analysts to underestimate how resilient and adaptive other societies can be in times of war. The notion that the average Chinese citizen will protest against a war once pork and cooking oil become expensive parallels the notion...1/
3
1
1
11
1,201
Personally, I try to stick to military and military-technological matters because there is some material basis to reality. Humans are complicated, and human behaviour can be unpredictable. Assuming a simplistic cause-and-effect relationship between the use of military force and
1
1
217
measures including induced food shortages, if not starvation, require some truly heroic beliefs that are well beyond my modest skills and knowledge. The stakes are immensely high, and any military strategy predicated upon such assumptions strikes me as a collapse-prone edifice.
1
195
There is a longstanding tendency among American analysts to underestimate how resilient and adaptive other societies can be in times of war. The notion that the average Chinese citizen will protest against a war once pork and cooking oil become expensive parallels the notion...1/
“Beijing can support a war effort for only as long as the Chinese public could put the People’s Liberation Army’s success above its nutritional needs.” Read @jwuthnow on how China’s food insecurity could shape its decision-making: foreignaffairs.com/china/lim…
7
21
5
210
21,777
That relies on open-water fisheries to source animal protein. If you are going to dive into such analytical waters, one really needs to go about it in a holistic manner. Beijing is unlikely to passively watch its society starve or take to the streets. It can adapt in wartime.
1
1
31
1,418
A final comment. We live in a world of industrial food production, processing, and distribution. You can directly and/or indirectly starve a society through many ways, including strikes against "agri-"industrial facilities up and downstream. We live in a targeter's paradise.
1
1
34
1,263