pia massaro🫒 (@syncretic_) header
pia massaro🫒 (@syncretic_) profile picture

Apulian person, mediterronea. Morphology, syntax @ Roma Tre. زبان شناس 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈 ally. Academic proletariat. 🍉 🍉 🍉

Rome, Italy
Joined January 2014
Photo by pia massaro🫒 (@syncretic_)Photo by pia massaro🫒 (@syncretic_)Photo by pia massaro🫒 (@syncretic_)Photo by pia massaro🫒 (@syncretic_)Photo by pia massaro🫒 (@syncretic_)Photo by pia massaro🫒 (@syncretic_)Photo by pia massaro🫒 (@syncretic_)Photo by pia massaro🫒 (@syncretic_)Photo by pia massaro🫒 (@syncretic_)Photo by pia massaro🫒 (@syncretic_)
pia massaro🫒 retweeted
Wow. I woke up to an impressive number of upset people who apparently don’t understand how LLMs work and can’t cope well with me pointing it out. An LLM is a statistical next-token prediction model. That’s how it works. It’s an extraordinarily sophisticated calculator performing math you could theoretically do by hand (if you were sufficiently masochistic). Math doesn’t know what it’s calculating. Pi doesn’t spend its evenings contemplating the nature of circles, and c doesn’t ponder the relationship between matter and energy. That doesn’t make the results any less accurate, impressive, or useful. Between inference requests, an LLM isn’t sitting around thinking. It isn’t reconsidering its answers, wondering whether it made a mistake, contemplating its existence, or questioning whether it’s conscious. Its weights remain fixed (it doesn’t learn), and computation resumes when it receives input. We know this because we designed these systems. The architectures, mathematics, implementations, and research are extensively documented. You can study them yourself. Of course, some people immediately lean into comparisons of biological intelligence or philosophical debates over consciousness because that is what they know. But biological intelligence and artificial neural networks are fundamentally different systems. Similar outputs don’t establish equivalent internal experiences. I experience consciousness directly. I infer that other humans do too because we share biological structures and processes. We don’t have equivalent evidence for an LLM, and nothing about its known operation gives evidence of conscious experience. Which brings me back to my original point. To me, understanding is conscious comprehension. It means being aware of information, recognizing its meaning, and experiencing that comprehension. If I wasn’t conscious I could not understand. We can perform actions unconsciously. We can produce correct results without knowing why they’re correct. But I distinguish those capabilities from consciously understanding what we’re doing. An LLM can solve complex problems, explain difficult concepts, and produce remarkably accurate information. I give it full credit for those capabilities. But producing an answer that we rationalize as understanding isn’t the same as experiencing understanding. You don’t have to agree with my definitions. We can debate functional understanding versus conscious comprehension all day, but that won’t establish whether an LLM actually experiences anything. The right debate is this… Could machines exhibit something different from human consciousness, something measurable, meaningful, and worth studying? I think so, absolutely! I’m entirely open to discussing “machine consciousness” in terms of observable, testable computational properties. We built these systems, we can instrument them, examine their internal mechanisms, and investigate what they’re capable of. That seems far more productive than endlessly arguing over whether a machine experiences life the way humans do. So here’s my question: How would you define machine consciousness, and more importantly, how would you measure it?
Not sure who needs to hear this but.... An LLM doesn't "understand" anything. It is a statistical model that spews out tokens based on probabilities calculated through massive matrix operations and context, not an understanding of the subject matter.
595
911
176
6,324
568,430
pia massaro🫒 retweeted
get in loser we’re going to risk embarrassment in pursuit of human connection
126
7,443
234
48,968
651,883
pia massaro🫒 retweeted
The #Meloni government is putting our country, #Italy, in an unprecedentedly dangerous situation through its military collaborationism with the #UnitedStates Not only are we helping to destroy 100s of 1000s of human lives, but it’s only a matter of time before we pay the price
7
191
10
359
4,586
pia massaro🫒 retweeted
7 volte dai carabinieri, ad aprile aveva già cercato di strangolarla ed era libero ma aveva “ricevuto un ammonimento”. Siamo una vergogna, un cesso di paese.
Uccide la ex che lo aveva denunciato. La madre della donna: 'Siamo andate 7 volte dai carabinieri' #ANSA ow.ly/jsQf50ZAELN
9
12
2
96
2,961
Help me out linguistics Twitter: do you know of a language where the verbal root in a predicate can be left out while the verbal inflection remains? I seem to remember Comrie talking about this back when I was a student, and now I wish I'd paid more attention.
11
10
1
62
5,665
pia massaro🫒 retweeted
only an italian could look at a radiator and think “this would hold sauce well” and be correct
69
1,215
82
23,062
452,987
pia massaro🫒 retweeted
Chi continua a dire che la guerra a Gaza finirebbe se solo venissero rilasciati gli ostaggi o non ci ha capito nulla o è in malafede
229
218
15
2,082
47,461
Embarrassing the Israeli president
46
693
27
2,330
42,496
pia massaro🫒 retweeted
—L'attacco a Doha elimina il “pericolo” dei negoziati. —I "regimi arabi" hanno la conferma che l’“ombrello🇺🇸” è un’illusione. —Nel Paese (il Qatar) che ospita la più grande base militare🇺🇸del Medioriente non entra uno spillo/razzo senza l’avallo di Washington. —Se vuoi la pace..
3
148
10
367
30,423
One of the last photos taken by Mariam Dagga, before Israel murdered her.
76
14,652
52
49,176
1,243,779
pia massaro🫒 retweeted
Last photos taken by Gaza journalists before they were killed in Israeli strikes haaretz.com/israel-news/2025…
135
1,834
62
4,099
1,343,454
pia massaro🫒 retweeted
La Regione Sicilia vieterà qualsiasi tipo di recinzione nelle spiagge a pagamento, dopo le polemiche sul tornello installato in uno stabilimento balneare a Mondello, accusato di limitare l'accesso al mare e al lido, nonostante sia per legge libero per tutti @ultimoranet
31
116
13
1,687
94,385
BREAKING: Five Al-Jazeera staff confirmed dead in Israeli strike on Al-Jazeera journalist tent in Gaza.
369
3,655
236
13,058
868,084
pia massaro🫒 retweeted
Sorry sorry I was just trying to buy a book from Cambridge University Press.
57
677
21
9,936
444,843
pia massaro🫒 retweeted
Conosco @FranceskAlbs da vent’anni. Ci incontrammo a Hebron, insieme camminammo nel mercato palestinese, con sulla testa una rete, che i coloni buttavano giu di sotto di tutto, dalle vecchie lavatrici ai w.c. Oggi la ringrazio per la passione che impiega nel suo necessario lavoro
430
8
2,039
23,805
Un 23 in linguistica generale è un 35 niente mi convincerà del contrario
Un 23 è un 23. C'è chi lo accetta e chi no. È inutile metterla su "per certe materie vale come un 30L" perché si scade nell'inutile polemica che alcune materie (e da lì a dire alcune facoltà il passo è molto breve) sono più facili di altre e non la si finisce più
18
73
30
1,047
46,555
1995, 1996, 2006, 2012, 2015, 2018, 2025. Tutte le volte che Netanyahu ha dichiarato che l'Iran era a poche settimane dall'avere la bomba atomica
112
974
86
3,717
137,530
pia massaro🫒 retweeted
Usano pretesti+narrazioni simili a quelli per l'Iraq: 1 milione di morti dopo siamo ancora qui. In Iran—che ospitò la 1a rivoluzione costituzionale dell'intera Asia—è al potere 1 regime dispotico grazie in primis ai risvolti dei colpi di stato promossi da🇬🇧&🇺🇸nel 1921 e nel '53.
#Netanyahu 2002, testimony to Congress: "There is no question whatsoever that Saddam is seeking, working, advancing towards to the development of nuclear weapons[..]If you take out Saddam's regime, I guarantee you that it will have enormous positive reverberations on the region"
1
209
9
409
35,048
pia massaro🫒 retweeted
28
485
27
3,198
139,759