
I’m a specialist in digital health, information management and service transformation. I'm the owner at @voronoi_au.
Brisbane, Australia
Joined December 2008
- Tweets2K
- Following2.4K
- Followers723
- Likes4K
Pinned Tweet
I'm no longer active on this platform. Find me over at bsky.app/profile/thegilcarte…
1
19
Prof Enrico Coiera launches the national policy roadmap for AI in healthcare at todays AI.care conference.
The framework was developed by @AAAiH_AU, and lays out a series of recommendations over five main areas. Full doc at aihealthalliance.org/wp-cont…
Gil Carter retweeted
Thread of my quick reactions to the AI executive order:
(the full text doesn't appear to be out yet, so this is based on the factsheet for now - but I may add more thoughts later once the full thing is up)
whitehouse.gov/briefing-room…
Lots to consider here for #AI and #digitalhealth
“President Issues Executive Order on Safe, Secure, and Trustworthy Artificial Intelligence”
whitehouse.gov/briefing-room…
•AI Safety and Security Measures:
◦Developers of powerful AI systems must share safety test results with the US government.
◦AI systems posing risks to national security, economy, or public health must notify the government during development.
◦The National Institute of Standards and Technology to set rigorous safety standards.
◦The Department of Homeland Security to establish an AI Safety and Security Board.
◦Address threats to critical infrastructure and cybersecurity risks.
•Biological Risks and AI-Enabled Fraud Protection:
◦Develop standards for biological synthesis screening to counter AI-engineered biological threats.
◦Establish standards for detecting AI-generated content and authenticating official content.
•Advanced Cybersecurity Program:
◦Develop AI tools to identify and fix vulnerabilities in critical software.
•National Security Memorandum on AI:
◦Direct further actions on AI and security for military and intelligence use.
•Privacy Protections:
◦Accelerate development of privacy-preserving techniques.
◦Strengthen research in privacy-preserving technologies.
◦Evaluate agencies' use of commercially available information.
◦Develop guidelines for evaluating privacy-preserving techniques in AI.
•Equity and Civil Rights:
◦Guidance to prevent AI algorithms from exacerbating discrimination.
◦Address algorithmic discrimination in civil rights violations.
◦Develop best practices for AI use in the criminal justice system.
•Consumer, Patient, and Student Protections:
◦Responsible use of AI in healthcare and education.
◦Safety program for reporting harms in healthcare involving AI.
•Support for Workers:
◦Develop principles to mitigate AI harms and maximize benefits for workers.
◦Report on AI's potential labor-market impacts.
•Promoting Innovation and Competition:
◦Catalyze AI research and provide resources for small developers.
◦Encourage FTC to exercise authorities for a competitive AI ecosystem.
◦Streamline visa processes for skilled immigrants in critical areas.
•American Leadership Abroad:
◦Collaborate internationally on AI safety and standards.
◦Promote responsible AI development globally.
•Responsible Government Use of AI:
◦Issue guidance for agencies' AI use, including standards to protect rights and safety.
◦Accelerate hiring of AI professionals and provide AI training in relevant fields.
Every health AI startup will have this battle with purchasers (and operators) of large EMR environments. “Yes your product looks interesting, but the sales team from our current EMR tells us they have similar/better/bundled AI functionality about to ship”
That 10x is vital. – at Brisbane, Queensland
Epic was the reason we got rejected from Y Combinator 👀
I still remember our YC interview in Nov 2014. Sam Altman (now founder/CEO of OpenAI) was on his phone the whole time. Gosh, were we really that boring? 😂
Hours later we figured out what happened: the previous Reddit CEO resigned unexpectedly the week before. Sam had been the temporary CEO and that day he was announcing a new interim CEO. I’m guessing he was dealing with a ton of crap behind the scenes.
Later that evening, we got our rejection email:
“We’re sorry to say we decided not to fund you guys. While we like the idea of helping patients prepare and recover from surgery better, it’s a very difficult business for a startup, because it’s hard to compete with incumbents who already have the doctor, hospital and patient relationships. We predict that existing EHR systems will gradually add richer patient advice, and it will get harder and harder to compete with them over time.”
I thought YC would be the last folks to tell us that startups can’t beat incumbents 🤷♂️
It feels like a rite of passage as a Digital Health entrepreneur to be told “the EHR will build this” or “yours looks way better, but we have to try the EHR version first”
For years it frustrated me to no end. But 10 years into this journey, and having been a customer of many B2B software products myself now, I have a lot more empathy for health systems who feel this way.
Especially as many U.S. health systems are still in financial recovery, it’s just common sense to look to existing vendors for any new solutions. And certainly the EHR is the most expensive existing vendor, so they want to maximize that investment.
I’ve been there now too. For instance I do think Zoom has a superior video call experience to Teams... BUT Teams is bundled into my Office 365 purchase. Is Zoom so much better than Teams that I just have to buy it?
So how the heck do you convince a health system to invest in something outside the EHR?
What I’ve found is that 3rd party solutions have to earn the right to overcome incumbents. And you don’t do that by being just 2x or 3x better.
You have to be 10x better on a differentiator a health system truly cares about:
📈10x better results
📑10x more clinical evidence
👨👨👧10x better professional services and support
💨10x faster implementation
Or some combination of the above that provides an aggregate 10x improvement.
Otherwise, the friction for a health system to look beyond an incumbent is just too much.
You gotta be 10x better so it’s a no brainer decision.
Big group coming along to AI conference hosted by @QLD_AI_Hub today. Lots of great speakers to come, looking forward to the discussions. #ai – at Brisbane, Queensland
3
88
This is a beautiful piece of writing.
Last year, working in Ireland, having a pint in the cold outside a Dalkey pub with some new friends, a woman with purpose strode past us. Puffy parker zipped to the nape and her bowed head covered in a scarf. One of my new friends muttered an exclamation, jumped up
1
161
This is excellent. A short plan that can be easily explained, followed and updated on the go will consistently produce better results than a mammoth "big design up front" approach.
To paraphrase @DieterRams principles for good design, "a good plan is as little plan as possible"
One thing I've learnt over the years is that it's usually a good idea to have a plan for change. The plan gathers people and shows the way. But lasting change is inherently emergent so don’t expect the change to exactly match the plan. The plan needs to be just “good enough” at the start, allowing room for tensions, uncertainties, and learning. Graphic by @lizandmollie
3
269
Gil Carter retweeted
👏👏👏 So fantastic to hear at #MEDINFO23 the Australian govt is not just investing in connected healthcare, but using policy leavers to support. The leadership towards a mantra of sharing by default is very, very welcomed
Picking some transformation endpoints with @helenbevan and a BIG group of digital health people at #medinfo23 lnkd.in/gttB-7Fc
Grahame Grieve notes that although government innovation might seem like an oxymoron, beyond small local innovations at the front-line, systemic step change often relies on infrastructure that is government’s purview.
Good quality conversations between…lnkd.in/gWhSW4HD
55
“Digital” often not part of of broader health service design, notes Elizabeth Koff. People don’t want the tech, they want the outcome - and although that can often be better powered with digital, it’s not always considered.
How to better inform planning…lnkd.in/gKpGbG96
Interesting point from Michael Draheim - big supermarkets know MUCH more about your life than health providers do. So much data in retail, and it is used intensively. How can health services do more and better with our health data? #medinfo23 lnkd.in/ghwKKuEM
Great to get the official start at the opening plenary for Medinfo 2023 last night. Looking forward to getting into the show today - lots of digital health to absorb over the next three days. #medinfo23 Australasian Institute of Digital Health (AIDH) lnkd.in/gZvvuxzH
The FHIR IPA approach already built for enterprise EMR platforms and also consumer devices (ie Apple Health) could accelerate broader patient data access in Australia. Looking forward to seeing health organisations here adopting this tech. #medinfo23 lnkd.in/gyaehHJu
Great point from Grahame Grieve - the fact that FHIR standards are all *free* and unencumbered is a major enabler for adoption. Don’t put paywalls or standards revenue models in the way of encouraging access for adopters. #medinfo23 lnkd.in/gDzY_JbZ
Interesting conversation last night with former High Court Justice Michael Kirby, who is also the patron of the eponymous Kirby Institute.
He recounted how effective the “HIV paradox” was as a policy - emphasizing and supporting those most at risk. Usef…lnkd.in/g7ic_KsE
Gil Carter retweeted
Just 4 weeks to go until #MEDINFO23! Be inspired by leading international experts in the field & connect with a community all driven to advance the digital health agenda. This unique international digital health event is one not to be missed!
medinfo2023.org/register/
Early preview of a national health information exchange shared by Peter O'Halloran JP at #dhf23 He notes that technical details still to be developed (real-time sharing of data sounds promising), but this is the start of the journey. lnkd.in/guX4T29i
3
218













