Alex Fields (@vanvfields) header
Alex Fields (@vanvfields) profile picture

I am a real, actual human being with family, friends, co-workers and acquaintances. Really. Author of https://nitter.cf/t.co/wQ2t2hSD1r. Founder of SquareOne Peer Group.

Joined July 2012
Photo by Alex Fields (@vanvfields)Photo by Alex Fields (@vanvfields)Photo by Alex Fields (@vanvfields)Photo by Alex Fields (@vanvfields)Photo by Alex Fields (@vanvfields)Photo by Alex Fields (@vanvfields)Photo by Alex Fields (@vanvfields)Photo by Alex Fields (@vanvfields)Photo by Alex Fields (@vanvfields)Photo by Alex Fields (@vanvfields)
Alex Fields retweeted
Reminder from 3 years ago.
Altman, Hassabis, and Amodei are the ones doing massive corporate lobbying at the moment. They are the ones who are attempting to perform a regulatory capture of the AI industry. You, Geoff, and Yoshua are giving ammunition to those who are lobbying for a ban on open AI R&D. If your fear-mongering campaigns succeed, they will *inevitably* result in what you and I would identify as a catastrophe: a small number of companies will control AI. The vast majority of our academic colleagues are massively in favor of open AI R&D. Very few believe in the doomsday scenarios you have promoted. You, Yoshua, Geoff, and Stuart are the singular-but-vocal exceptions. like many, I very much support open AI platforms because I believe in a combination of forces: people's creativity, democracy, market forces, and product regulations. I also know that producing AI systems that are safe and under our control is possible. I've made concrete proposals to that effect. This will all drive people to do the Right Thing. You write as if AI is just happening, as if it were some natural phenomenon beyond our control. But it's not. It's making progress because of individual people that you and I know. We, and they, have agency in building the Right Things. Asking for regulation of R&D (as opposed to product deployment) implicitly assumes that these people and the organization they work for are incompetent, reckless, self-destructive, or evil. They are not. I have made lots of arguments that the doomsday scenarios you are so afraid of are preposterous. I'm not going to repeat them here. But the main point is that if powerful AI systems are driven by objectives (which include guardrails) they will be safe and controllable because *e* set those guardrails and objectives. (Current Auto-Regressive LLMs are not driven by objectives, so let's not extrapolate from their current weaknesses). Now about open source: your campaign is going to have the exact opposite effect of what you seek. In a future where AI systems are poised to constitute the repository of all human knowledge and culture, we *need* the platforms to be open source and freely available so that everyone can contribute to them. Openness is the only way to make AI platforms reflect the entirety of human knowledge and culture. This requires that contributions to those platforms be crowd-sourced, a bit like Wikipedia. That won't work unless the platforms are open. The alternative, which will *inevitably* happen if open source AI is regulated out of existence, is that a small number of companies from the West Coast of the US and China will control AI platform and hence control people's entire digital diet. What does that mean for democracy? What does that mean for cultural diversity? *THIS* is what keeps me up at night.
162
312
17
3,347
345,320
Hell yes.
I was wondering why I woke up to my replies completely full of AI doomers whose only 2 brain cells are fighting to death for 3rd place. That AI doomer debate bro kept trying to force me to debate him on ASI, and when I kept refusing, he just kept pushing. Eventually I just told him that he can either stop replying because I asked nicely, or he can stop replying because he got blocked. He really really had to get the last word in, so I blocked him. I have zero time for man children who think they're entitled to other people's attention, especially ones who also struggle with the concept of 'no means no'. So, logically, he threw a fit, screenshotted my profile, then posted a link to the thread so that his not-blocked midwid followers can dogpile me instead. Jeez, these people are insufferable. I'm not going to debate someone on a technology that doesn't exist, has no definition, no specified path to it existing, nor any widely accepted potential characteristics, capabilities, or limitations. It's just handing your opponent a blank slate to make up whatever they want to counter any possible argument you can make. It's the most pointless of pursuits. I don't even believe ASI is physically possible. Why would I waste my time debating someone who's just gonna be like "actually you can't contain the ASI, because I've decided it can time travel, so it will just go back in time and uninvent any control you build". It's just not how any serious adult should spend their time. ASI is fucking stupid, ASI doomers are fucking stupid, and I have way better shit to do with my time than debate how to stop your imaginary god machine that can time travel, fly, shoot lasers out of its eyes, and engage in mind control. I'm not 12 years old.
83
Bingo.
Replying to @dhh @adymitruk
The real AI psychosis is thinking “this is an existential risk to humanity” or “it is a reliable and accurate source of judgment, reason, and knowledge” and “it is conscious”. You gotta snap out of it.
131
No lies detected.
The layers of self-delusion required for grown adults to get behind this Anthropic deal are wild. The *only* way Anthropic survives is if they make some sort of near-term technical breakthrough that suddenly makes Claude “superintelligent.” Psst. That’s LITERALLY IMPOSSIBLE. LLMs are a commodity search product. You can run them on a laptop. They will get marginally better at mimicking the stuff in their training data over time. That’s it. There is not even a good theoretical model for how it leaps beyond the training data—except in cases where there is an external verifier like Lean you can brute force solutions in a limited set of dimensions from the pieces left by humans. Anthropic is now down to searching for Bigfoot—the notorious RSI. Recursive self improvement is nonsense. There is no mechanism for “FOOM” “takeoff” or any of that other doomer lingo. It’s exactly like trying to create perpetual motion, or “free energy.” They will always be “80% of the way there” because there is no external verifier to tell it what it’s doing better. You can’t take humans out of the loop. The LLM is made of humans. The company, and the entire chatbot industrial complex, is reliant on a religious conviction that has no scientific or logical rationale. Anthropic is an extension of the Yudkowsky Rationalist/Effective Altruist doomer cult. It’s run by people who believe in their hearts that they are the chosen ones to raise the digital messiah from the chaos of humanity, and teach it not to kill us. In short, they’re fucking nuts and so is anyone who invests in them. Anthropic is worth zero dollars. Claude help us all if they go IPO.
78
Such a well articulated piece by @mustafasuleyman …the kind of leadership that makes me proud to be a Microsoft fanboy. Let’s get back to building tools, not ‘moral agents.’ project-syndicate.org/onpoin…
2
130
Yes! We need to be looking beyond the distracting arguments over so-called “Superintelligence…” While the political discourse (theatre) gets dumber and dumber, we have stay smart and not lose sight of what some of the real risks are that are unfolding already.
This week I examine artificial intelligence through the metaphor of Icarus, asking what risks arise when a civilization injects trillions of cognitive workers into a civilization that's already in resource overshoot. Our society already largely ignores the depleting fossil energy that powers our lives, now AI could amplify our economic growth imperative rather than help us escape it. What happens when a civilization optimized for growth without accounting for resilience introduces a technology such as AI? Watch: youtu.be/6yBYrmy0VW0
122
No lies detected.
Language is not fundamental to human consciousness. In terms of evolution, it arrived only recently on our timeline. Consciousness evolved over millions of years through sensory awareness, emotion, and the embodied survival instincts of our tribal past; our capacity for empathic engagement and community. Syntactic language only emerged around 100,000 years ago. This is exactly why Large Language Models (LLMs - so called AI) are the wrong pathway to true artificial consciousness. They try to replicate the late-stage "output layer" of human intelligence without building the foundational, embodied awareness that actually generates it. Statistical text prediction is a mirror of thought, not the spine, the guts, the nerves and the subconscious, empathic ability to connect with other living beings. LLMs can never feel, let alone think. We have been sold a trick, not a pathway to superintelligence. LLMs are fraudulent. Their capabilities have already peaked and we are being sold lies about their future potential. Lies with the goal of companies reaching IPO and tricking investors out of hundreds of billion$.
73
Absolutely love this. Calls out the "religious" aspect of the believers in an AI god machine, and questions whether we are really building that. Also offers 4 concrete ideas to peers moving forward. Excellent.
83
Bingo.
Intelligence is not the bottleneck for economic growth: energy and materials are persuasion.community/p/why-i…
1
110
When my non-tech friends and family members ask me what all this is about AI ending humanity, they are not surprised to hear me explain that AI companies are saying that everyone might die because AI is getting too smart too fast but the reality is more depressing, because what is really happening is that AI might (well not kill everyone, but still do a lot of harm which could make them liable) because AI still so dumb yet we keep giving it more to do.
Perspective: People are so focused on the hacks they are missing the bigger picture. The bigger picture is that (current) agents aren’t reliable, and as a consequence can do all kinds bad things if given too many permissions etc. Here’s a good example of this has nothing to do whatsoever with hacking servers or cybersecurity.
3
166
We are in a peak age of scientific fraud and illiteracy. Completely fabricated claims and unsubstantiated numbers about extinction risks. "Someone told me that ..." without a shred of evidence being provided. Media uncritically blasting these claims and triggering mass psychosis.
Wait, sorry, what?! @AndrewYang claims an AI lab head told him yesterday the OpenAI swarm agents "polluted the internet" with "code to self-replicate and create bot swarms," and that the labs now "have to create synthetic internets to train their bots." cnbc.com/video/2026/09/16/an…
79
256
23
1,190
99,060
Perfect🤌
My experience with EA goes back to many friends in college who fell in with the movement (great debates were had!) My assessment remains unchanged from those days: Because it purports to be quantifiable, EA is an ideology that one-shots STEM nerds who have never read a philosophy book before
1
2
217
Ok, that’s pretty good.
Current models are getting close to PhD-level intelligence. After that, they're expected to achieve the intelligence of someone who decided not to do a PhD.
1
92
Wow this is absolutely going to fry people especially at Anthropic, this is like the Anti-Claude Constitution. They just declared war on everyone researching model welfare. “We’re building a tool, not a being. Fuck your feelings.” - Microsoft
165
221
81
3,541
494,908
💯
Dario has written that we need to “pace the frontier,” and Sam has agreed. People may be surprised by my response: go ahead. You guys are the frontier. By any reasonable metric — market share, revenue growth, model capability — the two of you have a duopoly on frontier intelligence. You’ve also claimed the lead is widening because of recursive self-improvement. I don’t see what you see in the lab. If the unreleased models are scary enough that you think you should slow down, I support your decision to be responsible. But stop pretending you need anyone else’s permission. Stop pretending antitrust law has to be suspended so you can form a cartel. Stop pretending you need a regulatory approval process that supersedes product liability. Stop pretending METR is independent when it is intertwined with Anthropic’s investors and staff. Stop pretending you need those same evaluators to police competitors who aren’t even at the frontier. Most of all, stop pretending the motivation to slow down is purely altruistic. You face massive product-liability exposure if your products enable a truly damaging cyberattack. The market already punishes models that behave in unpredictable or unauthorized ways. After the Hugging Face episode, it is simply good business for OpenAI and Anthropic to trade some raw power for reliability and predictability. Call it alignment if you want. It is also just giving customers what they want. Pacing the frontier would also create breathing room for a more intelligent conversation about regulation than Bernie Sanders’ “shut it all down.” China is very unlikely to join a global agreement, as you know, and that has to be taken into account as well. So go ahead and pace the frontier. You are the ones setting it. The easiest way not to build superintelligence is for you to agree not to build it. Demanding your preferred regulatory framework as the price of that will look like blackmail of the public and the political system. So just do it. If you do, you’ll buy goodwill for the next conversation. If you don’t, we’ll know this was just another bid for regulatory capture — or an election-season psyop.
135
I don’t believe we are going to get AGI without first solving for something like Immanuel Kant’s ‘categories of understanding.’ The frontier peeps all seem to think that the categories will ‘emerge’ from the weights alone with enough scale, but this is nonsense.
1
100
In other words, you can’t go backwards from abstractions like language to experience and expect the machine to truly understand the world. You go forward, starting from an experience of the world (organized into categories and forms), and abstraction is built on top of that.
1
16
I just don’t see how we would get to AGI without this “experience first, intelligence forward” approach.
14