Behavioral Science the truth retweeted
As recorded in Hansard & by the National Audit Office, HMRC were sending letters to one specific group to pilot an approach to "encourage users to withdraw from the scheme". HMRC split the 1,500 users into 5 groups to 'assess which letter creates the greatest behavioural impact.
Replying to @4x4RoadRunner01 @hmtreasury
Promoters have deeper pockets to defend themselves! We are the easy targets, the 'low hanging fruit' so to speak. At what cost? Multiple suicides & referrals for self harm. Surely this proves that the policy is not fit for purpose & the risk assessment was flawed! @hmtreasury
Behavioral Science the truth retweeted
Replying to @4x4RoadRunner01 @hmtreasury
However. HMRC only seem to treat the promoters victims this way, NOT the actual promoters themselves. The government, @hmtreasury and #HMRC could have made the #LoanCharge policy go after the promoters retrospectively, but decided to change the policy to go after the victims
Behavioral Science the truth retweeted
Replying to @journomadeleine @Telegraph
HMRC are out of control and need proper oversight. And taxpayers need a #taxpayersbillofrights.
Death and taxes.
Now the taxes outlive you.
Right now, HMRC can't demand information about a dead person's tax more than 4 years after they die.
Labour's draft Finance Bill SCRAPS that cap 🤬
After 4 years HMRC just needs a tribunal to sign it off. It can apply without telling the family.
HMRC says "very low" numbers will be affected.
Sure 🙄
In @Telegraph tonight:
HMRC is expanding its powers to investigate the dead.
Read the full story here:
telegraph.co.uk/money/tax/ne…
Behavioral Science the truth retweeted
Replying to @keithmgordon
The Loan Charge sets a very dangerous precedent. Parliament waived through legislation to bypass longstanding statutory protections around enquiry windows, because HMRC failed to do their job. What next after this? There’s a tonne of people who ignored IR35 for 20 years.
Replying to @HCsick @TheRising_Moon @Stephen41792571 @4x4RoadRunner01 @lionheart_jon @HMRCVictim @DanNeidle @Cestrian2203 @HMRobbinCs @rexgold @HMRCgovuk @CIOTNews @ICAEW_Tax
I was certainly sold it on the basis that ex HMRC worked there and that they worked closely with HMRC to remain within the laws
Replying to @4x4RoadRunner01 @DanNeidle @HMRCVictim @Cestrian2203 @TheRising_Moon @HMRobbinCs @rexgold @Ray_McCann55
HMRC knew & failed to act. See working paper from 2009 quoting 2004 Legislation. It's quite clear that HMRC knew & failed to follow their own directive, resulting in 1000's of additional victims being dragged into this mess! They failed their duty of care!!
Behavioral Science the truth retweeted
Loan Charge & Taypayer Fairness APPG member @libdemdaisy asked how many people liable for the #LoanCharge have taken their own lives.
The answer is that there are 8 suicides that HMRC are aware of. Each one a tragedy.
A resolution is urgently needed.
questions-statements.parliam…
Behavioral Science the truth retweeted
The remarkably powerful @BBCRadio4 #Fileon4 documentary featured #LoanChargeAPPG member @CMonaghanSNP’s very powerful & harrowing @hmtreasury question on the #LoanCharge on the tragedy of the seven #LoanChargeSuicides & the #LoanChargeScandal.
We need a full, independent inquiry
Behavioral Science the truth retweeted
“The #LoanCharge took my brother’s life - he was a father, a son, an uncle, a partner: it has essentially destroyed our family”
The appalling reality of this immoral dangerous policy. 7 known #LoanChargeSuicides.
@Jesse_Norman @sajidjavid suspend activity NOW #LoanChargeScandal
BuzzFeed News has spoken to devastated families of two men who took their own lives after facing loan charge demands from HMRC
buzzfeed.com/emilyashton/loa…
Behavioral Science the truth retweeted
The deliberate misinformation about the #LoanCharge by @HMRCgovuk is a key part of the #LoanChargeScandal. Part of it has been the false impression given about who it affects, this is our report that exposes this. We are sharing this with Sir Amyas Morse. loanchargeappg.co.uk/wp-cont…
Behavioral Science the truth retweeted
We’ve been sent more evidence to show the intransigence & unreasonableness of @HMRCgovuk regarding ‘settlements’ (demands) to people facing the #LoanCharge It’s clear the impression being given by senior officials/Ministers about how “helpful” they are is false #LoanChargeScandal
Behavioral Science the truth retweeted
Another heartbreaking email we have received, from the husband of someone facing the draconian #LoanCharge. “he has already contemplated taking his life numerous times thankfully he was talked out of it the last time by the @samaritans”
Pls listen & act @RishiSunak @Jesse_Norman
Behavioral Science the truth retweeted
Replying to @HCsick @ContractorCalc
Exactly, read Trevor Price article
The #RangersFC vs #HMRC "Big Case" - "Inconvenient Win", the birth of the #LoanCharge Policy and Scandal.
#LoanChargeScandal
linkedin.com/pulse/rangers-f…
Replying to @ContractorCalc
HMRC only claimed loans weren't loans as PAYE income tax and NIs hadn't been deducted by employers, before contract income distribution. Wrong legal argument, as they eventually found out, switching argument in Rangers FC case, but subsequently pivoting from employer liability.
Behavioral Science the truth retweeted
The thing that politicians should learn from today's election results in the USA is that it is their voters and not large corporations that hold their future in their hands. A vote is on loan, never promised and promises matter.
#loancharge #loanchargescandal #loanchargesuicides
Behavioral Science the truth retweeted
We have written again to Rachel Watson, Director General of @policeconduct about the #IOPC wilfully ignoring the #LoanCharge as a common factor in 41 #HMRC referrals for suicide & serious self harm.
We will continue to pursue this IOPC failure of duty.
loanchargeappg.co.uk/wp-cont…
Behavioral Science the truth retweeted
Our letter to @jamesmurray_ldn requesting an independent review of the #LoanCharge and the desired scope of that review, plus a suggested legislative framework for resolving the #LoanChargeScandal
With thanks to @keithmgordon and @GregMulholland1
loanchargeresolution.co.uk/w…


















