Pinned Tweet
The question was unanswerable. They both knew it. Poilievre was the joke.
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
Grabbing for straws. And again, questions aren't answers.
In 1965, doctors at St Mary's Hospital in London tried to treat heart disease with corn oil.
It went badly.
They took 80 heart patients and split them into three groups.
One group carried on eating normally.
The other two were told to cut out fatty meat, sausages, pastry, cheese and fried food. Butter, eggs and milk were cut back too.
Instead, they had to take oil. 80 grams a day, three times a day with their meals.
One group got olive oil. The other got corn oil.
Corn oil was the big hope because it lowers cholesterol. And it did.
The corn oil group's cholesterol dropped.
So they should have done best, shouldn't they?
After two years, 75% of the people eating normally were still alive and free of another heart attack.
The olive oil group? 57%.
The corn oil group? 52%.
Lower cholesterol. Worse hearts.
The ones who ate their butter and sausages did best of all.
There was one man whose blood sugar shot up after he started the oil. They stopped it and it settled. They started him on it again and it shot straight back up.
The lead doctor, Geoffrey Rose, wrote that corn oil was most unlikely to help and possibly harmful.
That was published in the British Medical Journal in June 1965.
Over 60 years ago.
Now look in any supermarket. Corn oil, sunflower oil, rapeseed oil. Aisles of the stuff. Sold as the healthy choice for your heart.
Has anyone ever told you about this trial?
They had the answer in 1965.
So why did they keep selling us the oil?
9
More grumpy carnivore truthiness.
In 1966, doctors in Sydney gave a group of heart patients a margarine called Miracle.
You couldn't make it up.
458 men, aged 30 to 59, who'd all recently had heart trouble.
Half of them carried on eating as normal.
The other half were told to get rid of the butter and animal fat. Instead they got safflower oil and a safflower margarine. The "heart healthy" swap.
The same swap we've all been told to make for the last 50 years.
The trial ran until 1973.
So what happened to the men on the Miracle margarine?
More of them died.
When the results came out in 1978, the extra deaths were mentioned. But the deaths from heart disease were never broken down by group.
And then the full data just sat there. On an old reel of magnetic tape.
For over 30 years.
In 2013, American researchers tracked the tape down, got the numbers off it and published them in the BMJ.
Among the men told to eat butter and animal fat as normal, 10.1% died of heart disease.
Among the men on the safflower oil and Miracle margarine, it was 16.3%.
Deaths from all causes? 11.8% against 17.6%.
The men who did exactly what they were told did worse.
Did anyone tell you that when you were handed a leaflet about swapping butter for spread?
Because nothing changed. The advice stayed the same. The spreads stayed on the shelves. The seed oils went into everything.
I put real butter on my food and I cook in dripping, just like my nan did.
Miracle margarine.
The only miracle is that anyone still believes it.
Who decided we'd never need to know about this trial?
10
Questions aren't answers and this looks like a grumpy carnivore's truthiness.
Ask Grok or whatever:
A doctor working at Macclesfield hospital helped publish a study the cholesterol industry would rather you never read.
His name is Dr Malcolm Kendrick.
In 2016 he and 16 other doctors and scientists from Britain, Sweden, Japan, Ireland and America asked one simple question.
If LDL, the so-called "bad" cholesterol, really causes heart disease, then older people with the highest LDL should be dying first.
So they went looking.
They found 19 studies. 30 separate groups of people. 68,094 men and women, all over 60.
And the results were published in BMJ Open, a British Medical Journal title.
In the groups covering 92% of those people, the ones with the HIGHEST LDL lived the longest.
Not the shortest. The longest.
In some of the studies, deaths over four years were up to 36% lower among people with the highest LDL than among those with the lowest.
In the rest, there was no link at all.
Not one single group showed what we've all been told. That high LDL in older age kills you.
The authors wrote that older people with high LDL "live as long or longer" than those with low LDL. They called for the guidelines on cholesterol-lowering drugs in older people to be looked at again.
That was nearly ten years ago.
Has your GP mentioned it?
Because right now millions of people over 60 in this country are being told their cholesterol is "too high". They're being frightened off butter, eggs and red meat. They're being handed a prescription and told it's for life.
All to push down the very number that, in these studies, went hand in hand with living longer.
I'm 59. I eat butter, eggs, dripping and red meat. I don't lose a minute's sleep over my cholesterol.
Your body makes it for a reason. Every cell you have needs it. Your brain is full of it.
They told us to fear the one thing that might be keeping us alive.
So why has nobody in charge told the over-60s?
7
Carnivore Commandment # 5: Never forget that "they" are out to get you.
The children's menu is 105 years old, and it was invented because American hotels had lost their bar takings.
Before 1920 there was no such thing as children's food. A child old enough to sit at a table ate what the table ate, in a smaller helping. Mutton, kidneys, oysters, game, cheese, whatever was going. Restaurants did not want children at all, because a family lingers and does not drink.
Prohibition changed the sums. With the wine list gone a dining room needed new customers, and in 1921 the Waldorf-Astoria in New York printed a pink and cream card for the under tens with Little Jack Horner on the front.
The star dish on that card was a broiled lamb chop.
The idea spread through every hotel and railway dining car in the country, and with it a notion nobody had held before: that a child is a separate species needing separate food. The leading paediatrician of the day, Emmett Holt, supplied the rules, a long list of things too exciting for a young stomach. The cooking got blander and paler by the decade, until the food industry noticed that a child trained to expect his own menu could be sold his own products.
A century on the card offers nuggets, chips, pasta shapes and a carton of juice, and parents say their children will not eat anything else, as though that were a fact about children.
It took a hundred years to get from a lamb chop to a dinosaur made of breadcrumbs, and it started because Dad could not order a drink.
8
You can't trust the opinion of the one abusing the cow. This isn't activist vs farmer; this is someone who advocates for carnivore absolutism. BS comes with the job.
Activist: "You keep them pregnant their whole lives. It's forced."
Farmer: "How long's a cow in calf?"
Activist: "I don't know. Ages."
Farmer: "Nine months. Same as your mother."
Activist: "And then you do it again, every single year. That's not natural."
Farmer: "Put a bull in that field and go away for ten years. You'll come back to a calf a year. Deer do it. Bison do it. Nobody's stood over them with a clipboard."
Activist: "But you inseminate her. She can't consent."
Farmer: "Have you ever tried to do anything to 600 kilos of cow that she didn't fancy?"
Activist: "No."
Farmer: "She'll stand for it about one day in 21. The other 20 she'll put you through the gate."
Activist: "And if you just left her alone?"
Farmer: "Every three weeks she'd be bellowing at the hedge, riding her mates and trying to get through the fence to next door's bull."
Activist: "That's instinct. It isn't a choice."
Farmer: "It's the loudest opinion on this farm."
Activist: "I still think she'd rather be free of it."
Farmer: "She's over there. Go and ask her. Mind how you go, it's day 21."
1
330
We are omnivores and the grumpy carnivore won't have it; he thinks otherwise and he manufactures pictures.
For about 1,500 years the medical advice was to go easy on raw fruit and vegetables, and nobody found it controversial.
Galen, doctor to Roman emperors and the last word in European medicine until the 1600s, wrote that he had been ill every autumn of his youth until he gave up fresh fruit, and well ever after.
Europe took him at his word. Fruit was cold and wet and bred fevers. In 1569 the sale of fresh fruit was banned in England, because it was held to be causing the plague then raging. In 1603 Lady Anne Clifford put a fever down in her diary to eating too much of it. Children were kept away from it. Salad was a suspect Italian habit, and when John Evelyn wrote a book in its praise in 1699 he had to spend a good part of it arguing that the stuff was safe. Everything else went into the pot for hours or into a pie. During the cholera of 1832, American city health boards were still warning the public off raw fruit and vegetables.
These people had no fridge, no clean water and fields manured with whatever was to hand. They had learned what a bowl of raw greenery did to a household, and they wrote it down.
Five a day dates from 1991. It was launched in California with a foundation set up by the fruit and vegetable trade. The number was chosen because it was easy to remember.
Fifteen centuries of doctors went on what happened to people who ate raw plants. The campaign that overturned them went on who was selling them.
The idea that raw plants are the foundation of health is younger than the Walkman.
13
Carnivore Commandment # 5: Never forget that "they" are out to get you.
Zelda Fitzgerald wrote a novel in six weeks while she was a patient in a psychiatric clinic, and her doctors agreed with her husband that she should not have been allowed to.
She was the original flapper, a judge's daughter from Alabama who married Scott Fitzgerald at 19 and became half of the most famous couple of the 1920s. At 27 she took up ballet and trained eight hours a day. At 29 she was offered a place with a professional company in Naples. A few months later, in 1930, she broke down.
The Swiss clinic diagnosed schizophrenia. The greatest authority on the disease in Europe was brought in for a second opinion, at great expense, and confirmed it. He also reassured Scott that none of it was his fault.
Her treatment was called re-education. The dancing was to stop, since ambition had overtaxed her. So was the competition with her husband. She was to learn to be content as a wife.
In 1932, in a clinic in Baltimore, she wrote Save Me the Waltz. It drew on her own life, which Scott regarded as his material. He was writing Tender Is the Night from the same years, and from her letters. He was furious. Her psychiatrist took his side, and she was made to cut it.
Then came the treatments of the day. She was given insulin, in doses large enough to put her into a coma, dozens of times. At a hospital in North Carolina the director believed in injecting horse serum into the spine. Over 18 years she was in and out of seven institutions.
Most psychiatrists who have read her file since think she had bipolar disorder. That is a different illness, and none of what was done to her would have treated it.
On the night of 10 March 1948 she was sleeping on the top floor of that North Carolina hospital, in a locked ward, waiting for a course of electric shock. A fire started in the kitchen and went up the dumbwaiter shaft. Nine women died. She was identified by a slipper.
Scott is on every school syllabus in America. Zelda's doctors spent 18 years treating her for wanting to be something more than his wife.
10
Somebody park a time machine near the grumpy carnivore and leave the keys in it. He doesn't belong in this time and he's reached a breaking point. Dreams of dead animal fat are no longer enough.
The year is 10,800 BC.
You are lying in wet grass at the edge of the ice, downwind of an animal half as big again as any buffalo your descendants will see, with horns wider than you are tall. You have a spear, a stone point that took you a day to make, and your brothers. By dark the whole camp is eating fat. One of your points stays between its ribs for nearly 13,000 years, until a flood opens the gully and a cowboy rides past.
The year is 3700 BC.
There is no horse and no bow. So you put on a calf skin, walk out in front of a few hundred buffalo and bleat until they follow you towards a cliff. Your whole nation is hidden along the route behind piles of stones. At the bottom the women are waiting with knives. By the next moon the meat is dried, pounded and sealed in hide bags under melted fat, and it will keep for years.
The year is 1730.
An animal arrives from the south, taller than an elk and willing to carry a man. You call it elk dog. Within a generation you are riding into the herd at a gallop, choosing your cow and killing in an afternoon what used to take the village a month of planning. Your lodge doubles in size, because a horse can drag longer poles. You have never been so rich.
The year is 1850.
You are Cheyenne and you stand 5 foot 10. You eat hump, tongue, marrow and back fat, and in winter the bags. The herd that passes your camp takes three days to go by. The soldiers at the fort, raised on bread in Cork and Hamburg, come up to your eyebrows. Nobody has measured you yet. When a scientist finally does, he will find that the men of your nations were the tallest people on earth.
The year is 1871.
A tannery back east works out how to turn buffalo hide into belts for factory machines. A hide is now worth $3.50. Men arrive with heavy rifles, and a good shot can drop a hundred animals before breakfast without shifting his seat. They take the skin and the tongue. You ride for a whole day through what they leave behind, and your horse will not eat the grass.
The year is 1873.
The Secretary of the Interior writes, in his annual report, that he would not seriously regret the total disappearance of the buffalo, since it would make you dependent on the soil. The following year Congress passes a bill to protect the herds. The President leaves it in a drawer.
The year is 1883.
In October, Sitting Bull's people ride out and kill the last thousand of the northern herd. There is nothing behind it. That winter the Blackfeet wait at the agency for ration wagons that somebody counted wrong in an office, and a quarter of the nation starves.
The year is 1886.
You are picking up bones. The railhead pays $8 a ton. Your larder goes east by train, where the skulls are stacked higher than a house, ground into fertiliser and burned into charcoal for filtering sugar white. On ration day you queue for flour, sugar, coffee and lard.
The buffalo is in the sugar.
The year is 1892.
The scientist with the measuring rod has reached your children. They are an inch shorter than you. He writes it in a column.
The year is 2026.
Your great-great-granddaughter drives 40 miles to a dialysis clinic. Her people have the highest rate of diabetes in America. The monthly food box holds cereal, pasta, juice and tinned fruit, and was designed by nutritionists. On another continent, in a conference hall, people in lanyards agree that the world's cattle are unsustainable and that everyone should move to grains and beans, for their health and the planet's.
Nobody in the hall has asked her. Her family already ran that trial. It took one generation, and they still have the measurements.
11
Anybody noticed how grumpy carnivores all repeat one-another? Could it be they work from the same rolodex? Is it their bible? lol
15
Margarine was cheaper than butter and saying it was fear of butter is dishonest. Later fat would become a thing to avoid and that would include butter.
One of the biggest nutrition scams in history was convincing Americans to fear butter.
We threw out a food people ate for thousands of years and replaced it with margarine made in a lab.
Then we got sicker.
Butter was never the villain. Eat real food.
MAHA
8
Spending time with Stockwell Day is about as big a counter-incentive as can be imagined.
Congrats Premier Doerksen! Smaller cabinet (by 22%!) signals fiscal prudence,less bureaucracy and lower taxes. And fewer days huddled under the marbled dome means you and your MLAs will spend more time in the real world. With us.The people.
1
14
You can ask for names until hell freezes over and you'll still never get them.
Fact: Over 500 eyewitnesses saw Jesus after His resurrection.
The entire New Testament was written by eyewitnesses and men who walked closely with Jesus.
There’s more reliable written evidence about the life of Jesus Christ than there is Julius Caesar or Alexander the Great.
11
The grumpy carnivore is determined that what's good for him is what's good for everyone. He's quite judgmental and sees himself as a carnivore lion. But lions don't have his weaknesses and they don't drink coffee, eh. With unpasteurized milk no doubt.
Variety is the most overrated idea in nutrition, and it is how most people end up overeating.
No animal looks for it. A lion has eaten the same four things for a million years. A cow has never asked what else is on.
Hunting peoples ate the same few animals all year and counted themselves lucky.
Variety is the way round feeling full. You can be stuffed with dinner and still have room for pudding, because a new flavour reopens the appetite. Every buffet on earth is built on that.
"Eat the rainbow" is a slogan. It was written to sell produce, and it has been repeated so often that people take it for biology.
A food that is complete does not need a rotation. Fatty ruminant meat carries the protein, the fat, the iron, the zinc and the B12 in one piece.
A diet needs thirty ingredients when no single one of them is doing the job.
I have eaten roughly the same day for six years. Fatty mince, goat butter, raw goat milk. I have never been bored at a meal, and I have never stood in front of a fridge wondering what I fancy.
When dinner gets dull on carnivore, the fix is a fattier cut.
9
"The cow has turned up for work every morning for 10,000 years, and nobody has ever had to recast her."
The cows and their offspring are controlled from birth all the way to the slaughterhouse. They don't "show up". Ergo, the grumpy carnivore is not a serious person.
Joaquin Phoenix says dairy farming is theft from a cow, and he is not a serious person, on evidence he supplied himself.
January 2020. He won a Golden Globe and announced that he would wear one tuxedo for the whole awards season, to cut down on waste. The tuxedo then flew to Washington, to London and back to Los Angeles, with him inside it.
In Washington he joined a climate protest on the Capitol steps and told the crowd that meat and dairy were the third leading cause of climate change. Then, into a live microphone, of his own free will: "I flew a plane out here today, or last night rather." He was arrested minutes later, though sadly only for obstruction.
A month on he collected his Oscar and used the speech to explain that mankind feels entitled to artificially inseminate a cow, take her calf and put her milk in its coffee and cereal. He said this to a ballroom of people who had each arrived in a separate car.
He has been vegan since he was 3, when he saw fish killed on a boat. Most of us have revised at least one opinion since the age of 3.
The Oscar was for Joker, and for Joker he lost 52 pounds on lettuce, steamed green beans and an apple a day. He said the hunger did strange things to his mind. He came out hollow, twitching and unable to stop laughing, and the Academy judged it the most convincing portrait of illness that year. It is the only time he has shown the public honestly what that diet does.
In 2024 he walked off a film five days before shooting and the crew went home.
The cow has turned up for work every morning for 10,000 years, and nobody has ever had to recast her.
12
Another grumpy carnivore who can't digest that health and welfare depend on multi-factorial concerns. Fortunately we live in 2026 and not 10,000 years ago.
The shift from hunting to farming ~10,000 years ago was the biggest lifestyle change in human history. Skeletal evidence shows it came with clear biological costs: people got smaller, their bones got weaker, and cranial/robusticity patterns shifted.
Height: Late Mesolithic hunter-gatherers in Europe were significantly taller and heavier than the Neolithic farmers who followed them. In one Central/Southeast European sample, pre-agricultural men averaged notably larger body size; Neolithic agriculturalists showed reduced stature and body mass relative to both earlier foragers and later farming populations.
Genetic analyses confirm early European farmers were shorter than expected given their polygenic height scores—pointing to nutritional stress, disease, and poorer early-life conditions rather than genetics alone. Similar stature declines appear across many global transitions to agriculture.
Bones and strength: Mobile foragers had denser, stronger skeletons. In Illinois populations, hunter-gatherers from ~7,000 years ago had ~20% higher bone mass in the femoral head (trabecular structure) than later agriculturalists from the same region—comparable to the bone loss seen after months in space.
Broader European data show a clear decline in lower-limb bending strength beginning in the Neolithic as mobility dropped with settled food production. Activity and loading mattered more than body size alone; forager bones overlapped with non-human primates in some metrics, while farmers did not.
Skulls and brains: Softer agricultural diets (less tough, fibrous, or animal-heavy foods) produced measurable reductions in facial and mandibular robusticity. Holocene cranial capacity shows reductions in multiple regional samples (Europe, Africa, and elsewhere) that exceed what body-size changes alone would predict.
Timing and magnitude remain debated—some analyses place a rapid recent drop with complex societies, others find relative stability over the last 300,000 years—but the pattern of gracilization and dietary-driven skull change is consistent across studies.
Why it happened: Narrower diets heavy on grains brought more deficiencies, seasonal hunger, dental disease, enamel hypoplasia, and anemia (porotic hyperostosis).
Sedentism + denser populations raised infectious disease load. Less long-distance mobility and varied physical demand reduced skeletal loading. Animal protein and fat quality declined relative to forager diets in many places.
Farming supported larger populations and eventually complex societies, but early adopters paid in stature, bone strength, and skeletal robusticity. The archaeological record is clear on the individual-level costs of that transition.
16
Grumpy carnivore hasn't even progressed to accepting pasteurized milk, he opposes it, yet he lectures us. Somewhat confusingly too. But things do eat things.
"Milk is for baby cows."
Eggs are for baby chickens.
Honey is for baby bees.
Wheat is for baby wheat. Every grain is a packed lunch for a seedling that you have ground up and baked.
A peanut is for a baby peanut plant.
An almond is for a baby almond tree.
A lentil is for a baby lentil.
Rice is for baby rice.
An apple is a bribe, paid by a tree, to get its children carried somewhere else.
A potato is the plant's own savings account, and you have dug it up.
Wool is for sheep. Leather is for cows. Your house is for trees.
Everything a person has ever eaten was meant for something else, and usually for something's offspring. Eating has always worked that way.
There is one drink on the shelf that was never meant for the young of any species. Nothing in nature has ever raised a baby on it, and no mammal makes it.
It was invented in a factory in the 1990s, out of oats and rapeseed oil, by people who say milk is unnatural.
12
Imaginary beings should stay in the imaginations of the dreamer. It wouldn't mean there'd be peace on earth but it would unblock minds to be more concerned about concerns here and now.
9
Mistaking a falcon for an eagle and something about breakfast and doctors?
Visitor: "Is that an eagle?"
Falconer: "Peregrine. Fastest animal there has ever been. She's been clocked at 240 miles an hour, coming down."
Visitor: "She?"
Falconer: "The females are a third bigger. The male's called a tiercel. It means a third."
Visitor: "Why's she on the scales?"
Falconer: "I weigh her every morning, to the quarter ounce. Half an ounce heavy and she'll sit in a tree and look at me."
Visitor: "She won't fly if she's eaten?"
Falconer: "Why would she? A full falcon has no business in the sky. It's where 'fed up' comes from. A hawk that's fed up won't work."
Visitor: "That's a falconry word?"
Falconer: "So's hoodwinked. That's the hood. Under the thumb, that's the leash. Haggard is a bird caught wild as an adult. Never quite trusts you."
Visitor: "So you starve her."
Falconer: "I keep her keen. There's a weight where she's sharp, fast and wants it. Below it she's weak. Above it she's furniture."
Visitor: "What does she eat?"
Falconer: "Quail and pigeon. Bones, feathers, the lot. Never a seed in her life."
Visitor: "And she's healthy on that?"
Falconer: "She's 14. She hits a pigeon so hard it's dead before it knows there's weather."
Visitor: "My doctor says never skip breakfast."
Falconer: "Has your doctor ever caught anything?"
1
13


























