winston smith retweeted
Dr. Thorp, that’s confirmation bias, not epidemiology.
You claim you’ve never seen SIDS before vaccination? Perhaps you should examine the research on Alaska Native infants, where SIDS has been extensively documented.
SIDS occurs in infants regardless of whether they’ve recently been vaccinated. And large epidemiological studies have found no causal association between routine vaccinations and SIDS.
You remember the deaths that fit your hypothesis and disregard those that don’t.
That’s why we conduct population studies instead of relying on one physician’s recollections.
Anecdotes generate hypotheses. They don’t establish causation.
You should know the difference.
Why is it that I’ve never seen SIDS or severe carnage in infants or toddlers days before vaccinations? Why is it ALWAYS after vaccinations? I’m sure The High Priests & Priestesses of the vaccine death cult, Drs Neil, Hotez, Platkin, Annie Andrews and Offit et al have a brilliant explanation for this.
What do you guess their answers would be?
winston smith retweeted
You are not an infant, Ken - different needs than a growing infant.
Breast milk gets more than half of its calories from fat.
Mature human milk has about 4.4 grams of fat in every 100 grams, which works out to roughly 56% of its calories, and it has cholesterol in it too. The very first food every baby is built to eat is a high-fat food.
Fat is good for your baby and good for you.
fdc.nal.usda.gov/food-detail…
winston smith retweeted
Brian, I notice you’ve added “Dr” to your display name. Congratulations, if you’ve recently earned a doctorate.
Out of curiosity, what is your doctoral degree, and in what field?
Given our lengthy discussion of epidemiology, I’d be interested to know.
Replying to @DJSim22 @drterrysimpson
Correct, how did that massive reduction in deaths happen without a vaccine?
winston smith retweeted
Brian, at last, your calculation! And now we can see the problem.
You've divided 500 deaths by 300 million people. Except America didn't have 300 million people in 1962. It had approximately 187 million.
More importantly, before vaccination, measles infected an estimated 3–4 MILLION Americans annually, hospitalized 48,000, caused 1,000 cases of encephalitis, and killed 400–500.
The relevant question is what happened to those outcomes after vaccination, not what percentage of the entire country died in a single year.
By your reasoning, preventing a disease that hospitalized tens of thousands of children annually is unimpressive because most Americans didn't die from it.
You've demonstrated division, Brian. Now we need to work on epidemiology.
Replying to @drterrysimpson
For all that supposed research you’ve done, you struggle mightily to understand simple math.
500 deaths/300,000,000 = 0.000001 (I am making assumptions in your favor).
So a 100% effective vaccine would save 0.0001% of the population. Wow! 🙄
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
The 500 deaths refers to average annual measles deaths in the US before the 1963 vaccine, when the US population was about 186 million. Measles infected nearly all children prior to vaccination. jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/… history.com/articles/measl…
winston smith retweeted
Brian, your graph ends in 1960. The measles vaccine arrived in 1963.
You're claiming a graph that stops BEFORE vaccination proves vaccination had no effect AFTER its introduction.
Before the vaccine, measles killed 400–500 Americans annually. Following widespread vaccination, deaths fell to nearly zero.
Better medicine helped children survive measles. Vaccination helped children avoid measles altogether.
One reduced the consequences. The other prevented the cause.
Your conclusion isn't in the graph, Brian. You've brought it with you.
winston smith retweeted
You asked for contact tracing. Philadelphia linked three secondary and four tertiary measles cases to one internationally acquired case. Airborne spread is exactly why investigators trace shared spaces and exposure windows. Philadelphia Health Department report - don’t try to explain an epidemiological tool when you’re guessing
winston smith retweeted
Ken, the heart is metabolically flexible. It doesn't run on steak fat.
It uses fatty acids, glucose, lactate and ketones. The proportions change with feeding, fasting, exercise and metabolic state. Fatty acids are often the largest fuel source at rest, but that doesn't mean the heart is burning butter or that saturated fat is cardioprotective.
You are confusing what a cell can use for fuel with what is healthy to put in your diet.
The heart can burn fatty acids while LDL particles are contributing to atherosclerosis in the coronary arteries.
Knowing what fuels the heart is basic physiology. Knowing what causes coronary disease requires a little more study.
Your heart runs mostly on fat.
It never takes a break, and most of the energy it needs to keep beating comes from burning fatty acids, the same kind of fat you get from steak, butter and eggs. It burns ketones easily too.
So why were you told to cut the fat to protect your heart?
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2008…
winston smith retweeted
If you are thinking of coming to the Ashton Pub for the book launch between 1-4 and plan to have lunch, the manager says you should book a reservation because they have a large group coming for lunch at 12:30. I would guess that by 2 or 3, those numbers will have thinned out.
winston smith retweeted
2011 November 18 snow on the ground in Moosonee and ice in the Moose River but boat taxis to Moose Factory island are still running.
winston smith retweeted
You’ve confused fewer deaths with fewer infections. Before vaccination, measles still infected 3–4 million Americans annually, hospitalized 48,000 and killed 400–500. Where is your evidence that hospitalizations had fallen 99%? CDC
And “live” is followed by “attenuated”—weakened. The vaccine virus does not spread person to person. Learning half the terminology is a poor foundation for announcing that an entire argument has collapsed.
Replying to @drterrysimpson
seeing how measles deaths & hospitalizations dropped by 99% prior to the vaccine existing, that shit doesn’t add up lmao
also, you’re self infecting with measles by definition, bc it is a ‘live vaccine’ so the entire argument falls on its face
winston smith retweeted
Got a very nice note from the Ottawa Public Library today inquiring as to what titles I have available: it ended with "Thank you very much, Ottawa readers love Peggy J Blair's mysteries!"
winston smith retweeted
Wayne Ng and I will be on CTV Ottawa Morning at 7:40 to talk about CRIME FOR CHRISTMAS book launch at the Ashton Pub on Saturday, followed by the annual CRIME FOR CHRISTMAS mystery author book fair on November 24th at the Barrhaven Legion!
winston smith retweeted
The mistake here is thinking a vein and an artery are just two pipes carrying the same blood.
They aren’t.
Arteries have different walls, different pressures and different flow. Most importantly, their inner lining and supporting matrix are much better able to trap ApoB-containing particles like LDL.
And we have a rather nice natural experiment. Take a vein from the leg and use it as a coronary bypass graft. Once that vein is exposed to arterial pressure and flow, its wall changes. It thickens. Smooth-muscle cells grow. The matrix changes and becomes richer in material that can trap LDL particles that previously passed through.
Then what happens?
That vein can develop atherosclerotic plaque.
So yes, blood pressure, inflammation and damage matter. Nobody studying atherosclerosis says otherwise. But LDL isn't simply an innocent repairman who happened to show up at the scene. The diseased vessel wall becomes increasingly capable of retaining ApoB particles, and those retained particles help drive the plaque.
The vein isn't a pipe. The artery isn't a pipe. And atherosclerosis isn't bacon grease clogging plumbing.
It is vascular biology.
And for the record, I like my steaks medium rare. Sous vide, followed by a good hard sear.
Understanding LDL does not require giving up steak. It just requires understanding a little more biology.
Your veins carry exactly the same blood as your arteries.
Same cholesterol. Same LDL. Every single drop.
Yet plaque builds up in your arteries, and hardly ever in your veins.
If cholesterol floating in the blood was the whole story, both would clog.
They don't.
Arteries take the pressure. They get damaged. Inflamed. Then they get patched up.
Veins don't.
So is cholesterol really the villain?
Or is it just what turns up to repair the damage?
And who's asking what caused the damage in the first place?
winston smith retweeted
Larry, herd immunity was described scientifically in 1923, decades before the measles vaccine. It wasn't invented to sell vaccines. And vaccination doesn't bypass the immune system. It activates it. That's Immunology 101.
Natural herd immunity is real. We saw population immunity develop after chikungunya outbreaks in 2006 and Zika outbreaks in 2015–2017. We also saw it with measles before vaccination.
But here's the part you conveniently omit.
Before the measles vaccine, nearly every American child eventually contracted measles. Epidemics returned every few years as new children were born, replenishing the susceptible population. An estimated 3–4 million Americans were infected annually, with hundreds dying.
Two doses of MMR are approximately 97% effective at preventing measles.
Herd immunity describes what happens when enough people are immune to interrupt transmission. That immunity can come from infection or vaccination.
The difference is that vaccination allows us to develop population immunity without requiring millions of children to become infected first.
You've managed to misunderstand immunology, epidemiology, and a century of medical history in one paragraph. Remarkable efficiency.
Herd immunity is a fabricated concept designed to confuse people into believing that vaccines only work when everyone gets the toxic shot, without ever explaining that the PROCESS of vaccination bypasses the very things required for ACTUAL IMMUNITY. In other words, because vaccines DO NOT WORK, antivaxxers are blamed.
Got it?
winston smith retweeted
Measles is one of the most infectious diseases known to man with sequela that include severe neurologic injury, immune amnesia, and even death. the vaccine does not cause autism. The immunity from measles is not necessarily life long - and it cannot be cured with vitamins.
winston smith retweeted
Carnivores hate fiber - don't believe in atherosclerosis from LDL
Ken, first we can retire the Victorian image that fiber “scrubs the colon clean.” It doesn’t. Fiber is not a bottle brush. Different fibers affect stool water, bulk, fermentation, microbiota and motility in different ways.
And yes, there are constipated patients who feel worse with more fiber — especially bloating, pelvic-floor dysfunction or slow-transit constipation. That is why constipation is treated as a diagnosis, not a morality tale about bran.
But this 2012 Singapore paper does not prove fiber is useless. It studied 63 highly selected patients with idiopathic constipation, was not randomized to no-fiber versus high-fiber diets, and after the initial intervention, people essentially chose how much fiber they wanted to resume. By six months, there were 41 in the no-fiber group and only six in the high-fiber group. Interesting? Yes. Definitive? Hardly.
Modern AGA/ACG guidelines still suggest fiber supplementation for chronic idiopathic constipation, particularly psyllium, while recognizing that the evidence is not especially strong and that fiber can worsen gas and bloating in some people.
And the bigger sleight of hand is using a tiny constipation study to imply that fiber has no health value. A 2025 umbrella review covering more than 17 million people found higher fiber intake associated with lower risk across numerous chronic diseases, with particularly strong evidence for cardiovascular mortality and diverticular disease.
So if fiber makes your constipation worse, by all means investigate why and adjust it.
But “six people resumed high fiber and remained constipated” is not the scientific obituary for fiber. It is just a small constipation study and now you are asking it toCarnivores carry an enormous carnivore argument.
I used to tell people fiber scrubbed their colon clean. I really believed it.
Then a colorectal surgery group in Singapore took 63 people with chronic constipation off fiber. Six months later, the 41 who stayed completely off it went from one bowel movement every 3.75 days to one a day, and none of them had bloating or straining anymore. The 6 who went back to high fiber didn't improve at all.
If fiber isn't fixing your constipation, try cutting it out.
Study:
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2296…
What the Carnivore Diet did to My POOP (TMI Alert) 2026
youtube.com/watch?v=rcbx7O1K…





























