Grabbing for straws. And again, questions aren't answers.
In 1965, doctors at St Mary's Hospital in London tried to treat heart disease with corn oil.
It went badly.
They took 80 heart patients and split them into three groups.
One group carried on eating normally.
The other two were told to cut out fatty meat, sausages, pastry, cheese and fried food. Butter, eggs and milk were cut back too.
Instead, they had to take oil. 80 grams a day, three times a day with their meals.
One group got olive oil. The other got corn oil.
Corn oil was the big hope because it lowers cholesterol. And it did.
The corn oil group's cholesterol dropped.
So they should have done best, shouldn't they?
After two years, 75% of the people eating normally were still alive and free of another heart attack.
The olive oil group? 57%.
The corn oil group? 52%.
Lower cholesterol. Worse hearts.
The ones who ate their butter and sausages did best of all.
There was one man whose blood sugar shot up after he started the oil. They stopped it and it settled. They started him on it again and it shot straight back up.
The lead doctor, Geoffrey Rose, wrote that corn oil was most unlikely to help and possibly harmful.
That was published in the British Medical Journal in June 1965.
Over 60 years ago.
Now look in any supermarket. Corn oil, sunflower oil, rapeseed oil. Aisles of the stuff. Sold as the healthy choice for your heart.
Has anyone ever told you about this trial?
They had the answer in 1965.
So why did they keep selling us the oil?
9
More grumpy carnivore truthiness.
In 1966, doctors in Sydney gave a group of heart patients a margarine called Miracle.
You couldn't make it up.
458 men, aged 30 to 59, who'd all recently had heart trouble.
Half of them carried on eating as normal.
The other half were told to get rid of the butter and animal fat. Instead they got safflower oil and a safflower margarine. The "heart healthy" swap.
The same swap we've all been told to make for the last 50 years.
The trial ran until 1973.
So what happened to the men on the Miracle margarine?
More of them died.
When the results came out in 1978, the extra deaths were mentioned. But the deaths from heart disease were never broken down by group.
And then the full data just sat there. On an old reel of magnetic tape.
For over 30 years.
In 2013, American researchers tracked the tape down, got the numbers off it and published them in the BMJ.
Among the men told to eat butter and animal fat as normal, 10.1% died of heart disease.
Among the men on the safflower oil and Miracle margarine, it was 16.3%.
Deaths from all causes? 11.8% against 17.6%.
The men who did exactly what they were told did worse.
Did anyone tell you that when you were handed a leaflet about swapping butter for spread?
Because nothing changed. The advice stayed the same. The spreads stayed on the shelves. The seed oils went into everything.
I put real butter on my food and I cook in dripping, just like my nan did.
Miracle margarine.
The only miracle is that anyone still believes it.
Who decided we'd never need to know about this trial?
10
Questions aren't answers and this looks like a grumpy carnivore's truthiness.
Ask Grok or whatever:
A doctor working at Macclesfield hospital helped publish a study the cholesterol industry would rather you never read.
His name is Dr Malcolm Kendrick.
In 2016 he and 16 other doctors and scientists from Britain, Sweden, Japan, Ireland and America asked one simple question.
If LDL, the so-called "bad" cholesterol, really causes heart disease, then older people with the highest LDL should be dying first.
So they went looking.
They found 19 studies. 30 separate groups of people. 68,094 men and women, all over 60.
And the results were published in BMJ Open, a British Medical Journal title.
In the groups covering 92% of those people, the ones with the HIGHEST LDL lived the longest.
Not the shortest. The longest.
In some of the studies, deaths over four years were up to 36% lower among people with the highest LDL than among those with the lowest.
In the rest, there was no link at all.
Not one single group showed what we've all been told. That high LDL in older age kills you.
The authors wrote that older people with high LDL "live as long or longer" than those with low LDL. They called for the guidelines on cholesterol-lowering drugs in older people to be looked at again.
That was nearly ten years ago.
Has your GP mentioned it?
Because right now millions of people over 60 in this country are being told their cholesterol is "too high". They're being frightened off butter, eggs and red meat. They're being handed a prescription and told it's for life.
All to push down the very number that, in these studies, went hand in hand with living longer.
I'm 59. I eat butter, eggs, dripping and red meat. I don't lose a minute's sleep over my cholesterol.
Your body makes it for a reason. Every cell you have needs it. Your brain is full of it.
They told us to fear the one thing that might be keeping us alive.
So why has nobody in charge told the over-60s?
7
The finding that stands out is how ridiculously you managed the understanding of the experiment.
Talk to Grok.
3 months on a vegan diet and they lost 5 years worth of muscle!
Imagine 72 healthy, independent-living adults over 65 who had been eating normally their whole lives. Researchers at Wageningen and Maastricht randomly assigned them to one of three paths for 12 weeks: keep eating the way they always had (omnivorous), switch to a fully self-selected vegan diet, or switch to that same vegan diet while doing supervised resistance training twice a week.
They weren’t handed rigid meal plans. They got guidance, recipes, and some products, but they chose their own food—the way people actually do in real life. Protein intake in the vegan groups promptly fell from about 1.0 g per kg of body weight down to roughly 0.7 g/kg. Essential amino acids dropped with it.
MRI scans told the rest of the story. The self-selected vegan group lost about 0.61 liters of thigh muscle volume—roughly 5% of their muscle in just three months. That’s roughly the amount of muscle most people over 50 lose across five ordinary years. Appendicular lean mass fell by more than a kilogram. Muscle protein synthesis rates, measured with deuterium oxide over the first 10 days, were also lower.
The omnivorous group stayed essentially flat.
Adding resistance training twice a week helped, but it didn’t fully protect them. That group still lost about 0.35 liters of thigh muscle. The lead author later said she was shocked—she hadn’t expected the exercise group to lose any muscle at all.
There were other changes. Visceral fat and liver fat dropped in the vegan groups, and body weight fell by a couple of kilograms. Energy intake didn’t clearly crash; the researchers noted the diets simply weren’t matched for protein or energy the way a controlled feeding trial would be.
This sits in interesting contrast to earlier work from the same team. When older adults were given carefully planned, higher-protein vegan meals (around 1.3 g/kg) in a controlled setting for 10 days, their muscle protein synthesis matched the omnivorous diet. Real-world self-selection, especially in people with the anabolic resistance of aging, appears to be a different story.
The paper’s own conclusion is straightforward: a self-selected vegan diet reduced protein intake, skeletal muscle mass, and muscle protein synthesis in these older adults. Resistance exercise attenuated the loss but did not erase it.
In three months, one dietary shift produced muscle loss that normally takes years. That’s the finding that stands out.
11
Carnivore Commandment # 9: Don't bore people with the whole truth.
Grok:
At the age of four, a human brain is burning two thirds of all the energy the child's body uses at rest. No other animal has ever attempted anything like it.
It was measured in 2014, from brain scans of children at every age. The brain's appetite does not peak at birth. It climbs through the toddler years and tops out at around four or five, when it is using twice what an adult brain uses, inside a body a quarter of the size.
To pay for it, the body stops growing. Growth in those years slows to a pace the researchers compared to a reptile's. A chimp of that age is well on the way to adolescence. A horse is racing at two. A human four-year-old is small, slow and soft on purpose, because everything is being sent upstairs.
That is the most expensive project in the animal kingdom, and it runs for years on whatever is put in front of the child.
For two million years, what was put in front of the child was the richest food the adults could get. Marrow, brain, egg, the soft fat of the kill. Bone marrow is the oldest baby food there is, and it is nearly pure fat.
Now look at the tray. Breadsticks. Rice cakes. A fruit pouch. Low-fat yoghurt in a tube, because the official guidance starts moving children onto lower-fat milk from the age of two. The fat comes out of the diet in the very years the brain's bill is highest.
No parent chose that. It is printed on the chart they were handed.
A lion cub at that age gets first go at the kill. A human child, running the hungriest organ in nature, gets a rice cake and a sticker.
8
Tripping over multi-factorial again.
Sugar is what made the cigarette deadly.
For most of history tobacco was a pipe, a cigar or a plug in the cheek, and almost nobody drew the smoke into their lungs, because they could not. Smoke from tobacco dried in the open air is alkaline. It hits the throat like a wire brush and the body refuses it. People puffed and held it in the mouth. Lung cancer was a curiosity a doctor might see once in a career.
Sugar changed the chemistry. Tobacco cured over heat keeps its natural sugar, up to a fifth of its weight, and sugar burns to an acid smoke that is mild, sweet and goes down without a cough. In 1913 Reynolds launched Camel, a blend that took the harsh, nicotine-heavy leaf and soaked it in sugar sauce until it behaved. Every rival copied it. By 1929 American cigarette makers were getting through 50 million pounds of sugar a year.
A smoke you can inhale reaches a surface the size of a tennis court instead of the inside of a mouth. The nicotine arrives in seconds. So does everything else.
A government tobacco chemist wrote it down in 1950, in a report the sugar trade paid for and was pleased with: without sugar there would have been no American cigarette.
Lung cancer in the United States went from a few hundred cases a year when Camel launched to more than 150,000 deaths.
Sugar has a talent for this. It rarely does the killing in person. It makes the thing that kills you go down easily enough to have another.
9
The problem was that we didn't respect the ecosystems and plowed up the land without considering consequences.
In 1883 a Sioux man watched a settler in Dakota turn over the prairie with a plough, looked at the furrow and said, wrong side up. It took fifty years and the worst man-made disaster in American history to prove him right.
The grass he was looking at had held the plains together for 10,000 years. Its roots went deeper than a man is tall. Around 30 million bison had grazed it, and it had come through droughts far worse than anything the settlers would see.
Then wheat hit $2 a bushel in the First World War. Washington told farmers that wheat would win the war, and speculators told them that rain follows the plough. Millions of acres of sod were ripped up in a decade. When the price collapsed, they ploughed more to make up the difference.
The rain stopped in 1931. There was nothing left to hold the soil down.
On 14 April 1935 a black wall two miles high rolled across Oklahoma and turned the afternoon into night. Cattle suffocated standing up. Children died of dust in the lungs. An earlier storm had dropped the Great Plains on Chicago and New York, and on ships 300 miles out in the Atlantic.
That spring a soil scientist called Hugh Bennett was giving evidence to senators when the sky over Washington went dark. He told them it was Oklahoma arriving.
It has been taught as a drought ever since.
The government knew better. It bought back nearly four million acres of the ruined farms and sowed them with grass. They are called the National Grasslands now, and they have never blown since. The government keeps cattle on them.
9
Not all humans lived on blocks of ice during the ice ages. That tends to be ignored by carnivore promoters. We are omnivores and as such we do eat meat.
From Grok:
Long before farms or cities, small bands of humans moved across the landscape following herds.
They left behind bones, scraps, and the lingering scent of cooked or raw meat around their camps. Wolves, already skilled hunters and scavengers, began lingering at the edges—not as enemies, but as opportunistic neighbors.
The boldest or least fearful of those wolves stayed closer. Over generations, the ones that tolerated human presence better gained a reliable source of leftover meat and fat. Humans, in turn, gained something useful: animals that could help track game, warn of predators, and, in some cases, assist in the hunt.
What began as scavenging gradually became a partnership. The wolves that thrived nearest humans slowly became dogs.
Both species were built for animal foods. Early humans were adept hunters and scavengers of large game, relying heavily on meat, organs, and fat for energy and nutrition. Wolves were pure carnivores by nature.
In those early days of domestication, the overlap was clear—dogs ate what humans left behind or shared from successful hunts. The relationship formed around the same core resource: animal protein and fat from the landscape.
Only much later, after agriculture spread, did some dog lineages develop a greater ability to digest starch. The original bond, however, was forged in a world of hunting and scavenging, where humans and their emerging canine companions thrived on a diet centered on meat.
That ancient overlap still shows in how many dogs prefer and perform well on animal-based foods, and in the enduring partnership between the two species.
10
Don't take medical advice from a grumpy carnivore who needs to be reminded daily about multifactorial realities. Maybe someone can help him understand?
Cancer used to be something a doctor could go looking for and fail to find, and the doctors who looked wrote it down.
A mission doctor spent 11 years among the Labrador Inuit and found no cancer.
A hospital doctor spent 36 years among the Alaskan natives living the old way and found no cancer.
A British army surgeon spent 7 years among 11,000 Hunza and found no cancer.
A district surgeon spent 6 years among 14,000 people in the Orange Free State and found no cancer.
A physician spent 25 years examining 60,000 people in Brazil and Ecuador and found no cancer.
Albert Schweitzer spent his first years in Gabon examining thousands of patients and found no cancer.
Six doctors on four continents, and not one of them was short of patients.
Every one of them wrote the second half too. The trading post arrived, with flour, sugar and tinned fat, and within a generation there was cancer on the ward. Schweitzer watched it walk into his own hospital and put it down to his patients living like Europeans.
The grandchildren of those Inuit now have some of the highest cancer rates measured anywhere.
Medicine files it under bad luck and old age. It arrived by boat.
9
OMG! We bred the sheep to have to be sheered. We bred the cow to be a milk machine. Controlling and abusing animal lives is a peculiar kind of love. It's selfishness with no gratitude. And a reminder too, we "loved" the aurochs out of existence.
It's carnivore cockamamy!
The vegan plan for the cow, the sheep and the pig is that there should not be any.
Nobody puts it that way, but it follows. If nobody eats them, milks them or shears them, nobody keeps them. A dairy cow costs thousands a year to feed, house and treat. A flock needs a shepherd, a vet, fencing and a winter of hay. Nobody is going to fund a billion and a half cattle as a hobby.
So in the world where the campaign succeeds, the last generation is simply not bred. The Hereford, the Herdwick, the Gloucester Old Spot and every other breed your ancestors spent a thousand years making go the way of the dodo, humanely, on a spreadsheet. A few hundred see out their days in sanctuaries until the donations dry up.
They cannot be turned loose. A sheep that is not shorn dies under its own fleece. A dairy cow that is not milked is in agony by the second day. They are our animals. We made them and they made us, and neither side can walk away.
That is the compassionate outcome: an empty hill.
It is a peculiar kind of love that wants its object never to be born.
A lamb in April, up on its back legs, bouncing for no reason at all, exists because somebody is going to eat it. That is the bargain, and the lamb's side of it is being alive.
The alternative on offer is that it never bounced.
18



























