KProuty retweeted
Today in Shenzhen, Washington, Beijing and Moscow sat down at the same table. For the first time in history.
Not a single European in the room.
I think we're watching the beginning of the end of an era. Not the end of cooperation between nations. The end of global governance.
Let's start from the beginning.
Since 1945, and especially since 1990, we've stacked a layer of power on top of nations. The UN and its agencies. The European Commission. The IMF, the World Bank, the WTO, the OECD. The European Court of Human Rights. Then frameworks imposed without ever facing a single voter: Agenda 2030, the Marrakech migration pact, ESG standards, the global minimum tax. Around them, the forums where these elites talk to each other, Davos first among them. And the big foundations funding the whole ecosystem, from the Open Society to the Gates Foundation, one of the largest funders of the WHO.
You don't need a conspiracy to explain this system. You just need to read the mechanics.
Problem one: knowledge. Hayek wrote it in 1945. Useful information is scattered across millions of minds. The further from the ground a rule is made, the more wrong it is. A rule designed in Brussels for 450 million people, or in Geneva for 8 billion, is doomed to fail.
Problem two: exit. Why did Europe overtake imperial China? Walter Scheidel answers in Escape from Rome: because it was fragmented. An inventor driven out of one kingdom moved to the next. States had to compete to keep their talent. Unified governance removes the exit door. And power without competition has no reason left to govern well.
Problem three: accountability. A government that fails gets voted out. A European commissioner, a WHO official, a foundation board, never. Covid, the AI Act, the tech gap laid out in black and white by the Draghi report: they get it wrong, and you pay for it.
Problem four: capture. Stigler showed it in 1971. Regulation ends up serving the people it claims to oversee. The more complex the rules, the more they protect entrenched giants with armies of lawyers to comply. Innovation comes from new entrants. They're the ones being suffocated.
To be clear, I'm not talking about globalization.
Free exchange between peoples lifted more than a billion humans out of misery. Extreme poverty fell from about 38% of humanity in 1990 to under 10% before Covid. That's the market. People building and trading.
Globalism is something else. It's the bureaucracy that shows up afterwards to plan what the market built.
Trade connects people. Global governance manages them.
And it's losing.
My read: the war in Ukraine will be settled between great powers, not in Brussels. The European Union is discovering it's no longer invited. Legacy media and Hollywood have lost their monopoly on the narrative. And AI will finish the job: when anyone can verify, create and speak without asking permission, the gatekeepers are guarding nothing.
Then comes the only project worth having: a renaissance.
Treating poverty as an engineering problem, not a moral rent. Building abundance instead of rationing it. Going to Mars instead of holding one more COP.
Humanity doesn't need a world government.
It needs to be left alone to build.
End of Ukraine war.
End of EU.
End of globalism.
End of lies empire (legacy media / Hollywood / supranational entities).
Nuremberg 2.0 about Marxist ideas.
And then, humanity renaissance and space colonization and abundance as humanity project and see poverty like an engineering problem.
That’s the way.
KProuty retweeted
There is a reason New York City has not experienced the kind of violent riots we have witnessed in Paris and other major cities around the world.
We had the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group (SRG), a specialized unit of highly trained officers prepared to confront violence before it spiraled out of control.
Let me make something absolutely clear.
Peaceful protest is a constitutional right. Violent rioting is a crime. And confusing the two is a dangerous failure of leadership.
The SRG was not created to silence peaceful protesters. It was created to protect New Yorkers when demonstrations crossed the line into violence, to protect businesses from destruction, peaceful demonstrators from violent agitators, and police officers from being assaulted.
Now City Hall is dismantling that specialized unit, introducing unarmed civilian de-escalation teams, and restricting the tools available to police.
I support de-escalation. Every responsible police officer does. But de-escalation is a strategy, not a substitute for the ability to confront violence.
You cannot reason with a brick flying through a storefront. You cannot negotiate with a Molotov cocktail. And you cannot send a social worker to do the job of a specially trained police officer confronting a violent mob.
The NYPD will still have officers responding to protests. But the question City Hall has failed to answer is why New Yorkers will be safer without a dedicated unit specifically trained for these dangerous situations.
What happens when peaceful protesters are attacked? When businesses are being destroyed? When police officers are surrounded and assaulted?
Who responds? How quickly? With what training? And with what tools?
These are not hypothetical questions. These are the decisions that determine whether a dangerous situation is contained or an entire neighborhood descends into chaos.
I spent four years as mayor and 22 years as an NYPD officer. I know the difference between protecting someone’s right to protest and allowing someone to use that protest as cover for violence.
The right to protest does not include the right to terrorize. And protecting civil liberties should never require surrendering public safety.
City Hall may believe dismantling the SRG is a political victory.
But if violence erupts, the people paying the price won’t be the activists applauding this announcement or the politicians celebrating it at City Hall.
It will be the police officer who gets assaulted. The small-business owner whose livelihood is destroyed. The peaceful protester who gets caught in the violence. The innocent New Yorker who simply wants to get home safely.
New York City’s Public Safety is not a laboratory for ideological experiments. Our police officers are not expendable. And public safety is not something you gamble with to score political points.
City Hall should reverse this decision before New Yorkers discover the consequences the hard way.
KProuty retweeted
Christianity is a great moral system for internal use – not so much for external relations.
Being soft and benevolent works beautifully inside a society where everyone plays by the same code: it produces the most trusting, generous and peaceful communities in history. Applied indiscriminately to those who play by different rules, it becomes a self-defeating strategy. That is not cynicism. It is game theory: unconditional cooperation feeds the cheaters, and cooperation survives only when it can recognize cheating and answer it.
Other, more predatory civilizations are simply being rational within their own moral approach, which is a bit different from ours. They respect strength and read softness as weakness. Then they resent us for being both richer and weaker – and they act on it.
The Church knew this once. Augustine and Aquinas did not preach a defenseless Christendom; they wrote the doctrine of just war.
If we want to keep our nice, soft, benevolent societies internally – and we do – then we need to learn a bit from the others, especially in external relations. Kindness inside requires firmness at the border.
A soft interior needs a hard shell. That is not a betrayal of Christian civilization. It is the only way it survives.
What Is Christianity at Its Deepest?
It is the reflex of caring about every other person: their suffering hurts you, and you want to help.
That is what we call the dignity of every human being – even our enemies. This is a revolutionary idea. Christ put it in three words: love your enemies.
Sometimes we even overdo it. At home, I am laughed at because I try to rescue every fruit fly I see in trouble – which is indeed excessive :)
But what we have to understand is that this is not the natural default setting of the ruthless, territorial, tribal killer apes that we are. And so not every civilization shares this reflex. We acquire it very young, as little children, as the normal way to behave – and then we project it onto everyone else, assuming that all others work the same way. They do not. It is not the human default. It is Christianity.
The human default is the opposite: to rejoice at the misery and suffering of others – of enemies, of members of other tribes. Or at least indifference. It is quite understandable: it is the natural instinct of predator societies. And it was ours too. In Rome, we filled the Colosseum to watch men kill each other, and we lived off slaves. The opposite had to be learned – it is civilizational – and it took millennia. Tradition says the gladiator games ended when a monk jumped into the arena to separate two fighters, and the crowd killed him for it. The crowd was nature. The monk was Christianity.
Even Nietzsche, Christianity's fiercest enemy, understood this better than many believers. He saw that compassion for the weak was not nature but Christian morality – and attacked it for this very reason. Indeed, taken too far, it is a mistake – it becomes suicidal. We have to restore measure to it. Augustine put it best, teaching that we owe love to all, but since we cannot help everyone, we must first help those whom time and place have brought closest to us – what the Church calls the order of charity.
And this is how different civilizations still operate. Moral obligation stops at the edge of the family, the clan, the tribe; beyond it, people instinctively care only about their own interest – at the expense of others, to varying degrees. Anthropologists who measure it find the West to be the exception, not the rule. We have to understand that, and not project our moral code onto them – that is a mistake. Sometimes a very costly mistake for those who do not understand it.
This is what distinguishes civilizations at the deepest level. We should be conscious of what we are, and where it comes from.
Incidentally, this is what makes envy-based systems like communism a different civilization. Compassion suffers at the suffering of others. Envy suffers at their happiness – and rejoices at their fall. Communism turned that reflex into a system: the class enemy, the show trial, the cheering crowd. It brought back the arena. Today's online mob is the same arena, with likes instead of thumbs.
At the opposite end stands the famous motto of the Polish fighters, who fought for the freedom of others:
For Our Freedom and Yours. 🗽
KProuty retweeted
Here's why we'll have to thank Bill Gates for vaccinating us.
Seriously. I mean it.
In April 2020, Bill explained that life would only return to normal once we had vaccinated more or less the entire population of the planet. Eight billion people. One dose at a time.
Whatever you think that vaccine did against Covid, it worked wonders against something else.
It vaccinated the West against them.
Think about how a vaccine works. You inject a small dose of the threat, so the body learns to recognize it. And next time, it fights back.
That's exactly what happened.
For decades, the technocratic project was invisible. Abstract. Hidden behind committees, reports and forums nobody watched. You can't fight what you can't see.
Then Covid. And for two years, they showed us everything. At full dose.
First dose: people nobody elected deciding whether you could leave your home.
Second dose: a QR code to drink a coffee, see a movie, visit your father in the hospital.
Booster: doctors punished for asking questions, platforms censoring on request, "trust the science" used to end every debate.
Second booster: small businesses wiped out by decree while the biggest fortunes on the planet exploded.
And the same faces on every screen, every day, explaining calmly that they knew better than you what was good for you.
The patient got sick. Very sick.
And then the immune system kicked in.
An entire generation learned to recognize the symptoms. Emergency used as a pretext. Fear used as a delivery system. Freedom suspended "temporarily." Experts who are never wrong and never accountable.
Today, millions of people spot those symptoms in seconds. They read the fine print. They ask who decides, and who pays. They see the playbook before the first page is turned.
And that's a problem for them. Because they're about to go all-in.
Digital ID. Digital currency. Licensed AI. Closed models "for your safety." The last pieces of the project, all arriving at once.
But this time, the population has antibodies.
Every time they say "it's for your safety," millions of people hear "what are you trying to take from me?" Every time they announce a temporary measure, millions of people remember how temporary the last ones were.
That's what's going to save us.
So yes. One day, we'll have to thank Bill.
He spent years warning the world about the next pandemic. He was right. He just got the virus wrong.
It wasn't the one in the vial.
It was the one in the idea.
Thank you, Bill. Herd immunity achieved.
Just not the one you were hoping for.
If you want to understand why Jensen Huang was pushed out by his own board in a matter of days, not for his results but over his personal conduct, and why so much of the media went after him so hard, read this post. And read the ones linked below.
What comes next for them, in the age of AI?
To answer that, you have to stop looking for a plot and start reading a worldview.
Here it is, in one sentence: a small enlightened class knows better than you how you should live, what you should own, and what you're allowed to say.
That's it. Everything else follows.
You'll own nothing, because private property means private decisions. Experts must plan, because free people trading is disorder. Energy, money, information must stay scarce, because whoever manages scarcity manages people.
These people aren't cartoon villains. It's worse. They're convinced. They sincerely believe they're enlightened enough to decide how eight billion people should interact. And what disturbs them most isn't poverty, or crime, or chaos.
It's free will.
And now AI arrives. The one technology that dissolves scarcity. A kid with a laptop gets a doctor, a lawyer, an engineer, a teacher. Intelligence becomes abundant. Nobody needs a middleman to explain the world anymore.
For their worldview, that's an existential threat. So what's the logical next move?
The same one as Covid.
Step 1: the crisis.
They won't need to invent it. AI will bring real shocks. Jobs disappearing faster than any "transition plan." Deepfakes everywhere. Cyberattacks on hospitals and banks. Industrial-scale scams. And a system that never fixes anything won't fix this either.
They don't light the fire. They just don't put it out.
Step 2: the savior.
When the fear peaks, they show up with the solution. "Only we can protect you." A license to train a model. An ID to use one. Closed AI "for your safety." Every chip registered, every computation tracked.
You've seen this movie. In 2020, a QR code to buy a coffee. In 2022, Canada used emergency powers to freeze the bank accounts of protesters. Every emergency power, once tested, stays in the toolbox. They never give it back.
Step 3: the capture.
AI ends up closed, licensed, and controlled by a handful of aligned players. Scarcity is recreated by law. And the one tool that could have freed you becomes the perfect control infrastructure. Plug it into a digital ID and a digital currency, and you have something no regime in history ever had.
That's the protection racket. The oldest mafia method there is. You let the neighborhood burn, then you sell the shopkeeper protection. The price isn't money. It's your freedom.
And that's why this week matters.
Jensen Huang is gone. His mistakes are real, he admitted them himself. But look at what his fall revealed: the company that powers the entire AI world just became a national security file overnight.
And when compute becomes a security question, the people in charge of "security" start deciding who gets compute.
The man who put GPUs in everyone's hands is out. Watch who replaces him. Watch what they say about open models, about export rules, about "responsible" compute. That's where the next battle will be fought.
So how do you not fall into the trap?
Remember Covid. Fear is always the delivery mechanism. When the next crisis comes, the first question isn't "how scary is it?" It's "what are they asking me to give up?"
Never trade freedom for protection. Benjamin Franklin said it in 1755: those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.
Defend open source like your life depends on it. Run your own models. Own your own compute. Keep your cash, your data, your tools.
And build. Faster than they can regulate.
The next crisis is coming. Their solution is already written.
Don't sign it.
KProuty retweeted
The Far Left cannot be won - as you can see below. 👇
In my book, I call them Left Identitarians: lovers of DEI, antiracism and talkers of white supremacy.
But the nuanced centre left and right is who I write for - those of us who know something is wrong with the country and want to understand what is going on.
You cannot understand without knowing schools and children.
If you are on the Left, ignore those who call you racist for questioning the DEI mantra - break out of the cage!
Read my book and see what you think!
Diversity is NOT Our Strength!
leftfootforward.org/2026/11/…
KProuty retweeted
It should tell you something that @elonmusk realized it is easier to catch a flying spaceship than get Congress to cut a dollar of waste.
KProuty retweeted
Back in the 1960s and 1970s, right-wing nutjobs used to claim that the anti-Vietnam movement was funded by the USSR, who used agent provocateurs to whip up our students into demonstrating and rioting.
This was, of course, soundly derided. Eventually even right-wing nutjobs stopped making this claim.
In 1991, after the USSR fell, we got to see the old KGB files. Lo and behold the Soviet Union funded the anti-Vietnam movment and placed agent provocateurs to whip up our students into demonstrating and rioting. They literally flew radicals to Moscow to train them in subversion.
While I'm sure some of the demonstrations were home-grown, by and large it seems to have been a successful Soviet operation. So successful that a large part of the population (including most of my fellow Boomers) still believe the lie.
KProuty retweeted
BREAKING NIUS: Die Antifa hat nun ein Bekennerschreiben zum terroristischen Brandanschlag auf mein Auto veröffentlicht. Darin heißt es unter der Überschrift "Julian Reichelt du Hund":
"Wir haben letzte Nacht anlässlich der Gen-Z-Demo am Samstag in Berlin das Auto des Ex-Bild-Chefs Julian Reichelt angezündet. Pressefreiheit schützt qua Definition journalistische Arbeit vor dem Staat, unser Angriff auf das Auto dieses misogynen, rassistischen, transphoben Arschlochs ist kein Angriff auf sie. Die guten Gründe für unseren Schuss vor den Bug sind nicht an einer Hand abzuzählen."
In dem Schreiben wird auch meine Adresse veröffentlicht und Bezug genommen auf die geplante Gewaltdemo (Gen Z) am 20. November. Das ist natürlich nichts anderes als eine Aufforderung an den Mob.
Und dennoch hat sich seit 48 Stunden kein einziger politisch Verantwortlicher in der Stadt Berlin zu diesem Anschlag geäußert. Die CDU schweigt geschlossen. Auch die Innensenatorin von der SPD interessiert der Anschlag nicht. Wenige Straßen von mir entfernt wohnt ein Mitglied der Bundesregierung. Da wird das Wohnhaus natürlich geschützt, aber wenn man Opfer eines Anschlags wird, nachdem CDU-Ministerin Prien NIUS zu "Feinden der Demokratie" erklärt hat, nachdem CDU-Ministerpräsident Daniel Günther die Antifa zum Kampf gegen uns aufgerufen hat, nachdem Merz-Freund Wolfram Weimer Anschlagsratgeber der Antifa mit Steuergeld finanziert, nachdem immer noch Millionen Euro Steuergeld über das CDU-Familienministerium an die militante Antifa fließen, nachdem Karin Prien bekannt hat, dieser elendige, gewalttätige sogenannte Antifaschismus sei "DNA der CDU", dann interessiert das die Mächtigen nicht. Der linke Straßenterror hat in Berlin keine Gegenwehr zu befürchten, schon gar nicht von der immer noch regierenden CDU. Man ist auf sich allein gestellt.
Wenn die Linken ihre Sturmabteilung losschicken, gucken viel zu viele Konservativen, Bürgerlichen weg. Bis jetzt gibt es auch keine einzige öffentliche Stellungnahme eines deutschen Chefredakteurs oder Verlagshauses. Das ist beschämend. Die komplette Führungsriege der deutschen Medienlandschaft schweigt zu diesem Anschlag (während sich zahlreiche normale Mitarbeiter geäußert haben – danke!).
Für NIUS gibt es auf dieses Totalversagen der Freiheitlichkeit nur eine Antwort: Journalismus. Wir werden uns niemals einschüchtern lassen. Wir brennen – leider im wahrsten Sinne des Wortes – für die Meinungsfreiheit.
KProuty retweeted
Without @JohnCleese’s help, my family might have been killed by Pakistani supporters last night.
He sent 8 security guards to defend Singhs Dining
My husband @kingkapoor72 was arrested yesterday by met police
Aggressive protesters chanted “Pakistan Zindabad”, outside my restaurant
Londonistan is done
KProuty retweeted
Is there anything more Monty Pythonesque than a man being attacked for not serving something?
Chinese man: I'd like Kung Pao Chicken, please.
Italian man: I'm sorry, but we serve only pizza.
Chinese man: So you hate the Chinese people?
Italian man: No, not at all. But this is a pizza restaurant.
Chinese man: You won't serve me Kung Pao Chicken?! You are oppressing me! You are racist!
Italian man: No, I'm not. I run a pizza parlour. I serve pizza!
Chinese man: I'm being oppressed! I'm being oppressed! I must kill you for oppressing!
Policeman: I understand you're oppressing this man.
Italian man: No, I'm not. I'm selling pizza.
Policeman: Alright. You're under arrest! Come with me!
Thanks, @JohnCleese for helping these people.
KProuty retweeted
Abolishing the electoral college would mean not knowing who won the presidency for 4 weeks while California keeps counting. No thanks.
我的乖乖,真的戳心窝子,兄弟们
看完百亿对冲基金大佬 Bill Ackman 谈马斯克的这段切片,最戳心窝子的根本不是 SpaceX 和特斯拉的万亿估值,而是他提到自己女儿时的那半句话,
身家百亿美金的华尔街巨鳄,可以用钱买下这世上99%的顶级资源,唯独买不回女儿重新看见世界、重新开口说话的生理机能,
而今天唯一能给他女儿带来这种物理希望的 Neuralink,
恰恰来自一个二十年前就可以彻底躺平退休、却偏偏选择继续拿命死磕硬科技的疯子。
很多人总喜欢拿世俗的功利算盘去揣测马斯克为什么还不收手,
却忘了如果当年他在把特斯拉做上市后就去买游艇打高尔夫,
今天人类既不会有占全球过半运力的可回收火箭,更不会有让无数失明失语者重获新生的微米级脑机电极丝。
这就相当于一个早就通关了财富游戏的玩家,非但没有退服养老,反而把赢来的全部金币熔铸成手术刀和发动机,孤身一人去撞人类物理与医学边界上最硬的那堵墙,
所以 Ackman 最后那句感慨才显得格外沉重:当一个人明明拥有随时退场享受人生的特权,却依然留在泥泞的工程第一线替全人类蹚雷,这样的人出现在我们的时代,本身就是整个人类文明最不该被辜负的幸运
KProuty retweeted
I was wrong. THIS is as dark as it gets. I’ll warn you I couldn’t finish the video. People wonder how communists could kill 100 million people in the last century…this is why. These are not liberals. These are not democrats. They are demons. God help us.
KProuty retweeted
Haiti just ran the cleanest A/B test of the century.
Option A: the international system. Thirteen years of UN peacekeeping, billions in aid, an army of NGOs. Result: a president assassinated in his own bedroom, a capital run by gangs, more than a million people displaced. The peacekeepers themselves brought cholera to the island and killed nearly 10,000 Haitians. After the 2010 earthquake, the Red Cross raised half a billion dollars and built six permanent homes. Six. Oxfam staff were caught paying for sex workers in the ruins.
Option B: Bukele. A few weeks, 2,000 soldiers, armored vehicles, one clear objective. Result: the gangs are now writing letters to the UN asking for "mediation."
Read that again. The gangs are asking the UN to protect them. They know exactly who is a threat to them and who isn't.
This isn't about Haiti. It's about the operating system the West has been running since the 60s, and it is dying in front of us. Its axioms were wrong.
Axiom one: everyone can be reinserted, the criminal is a victim of the system, punishment is oppression. El Salvador tried truces and soft approaches and became the murder capital of the world. Then it stopped believing it.
Axiom two: force is always illegitimate. But order isn't natural. It's built and maintained, sometimes by force. A state that refuses to use legitimate violence doesn't abolish violence. It hands the monopoly to whoever is willing to use it. In Haiti, that's the gangs.
Axiom three: everything can be steered from the top. Central banks, planners, aid agencies, "development" programs. Decades of money pushed down from above, and the result is always the same: a class that lives off the problem and has zero incentive to solve it. An NGO that fixes Haiti loses its budget. Think about that.
Axiom four: morality is relative and the old norms were just oppression. This one was built by a very specific elite in the 60s and 70s. In 1977, Sartre, Beauvoir, Barthes, Deleuze and others signed a petition in Le Monde defending sex between adults and minors. Those people are the intellectual grandparents of today's ruling class. Epstein isn't an anomaly. He's the tail of that comet: a network of untouchables who believed rules were for other people.
Now the system is cornered, and it has two exits.
Exit one: lock everything down. Digital IDs, programmable money, censorship sold as safety, a technological control state more total than anything Orwell imagined. Keep the bureaucracy, add the surveillance.
Exit two: let it collapse and rebuild on what actually works. Individual responsibility. Freedom. Consent. Clear rules, actually enforced. Decentralized systems that emerge from the bottom instead of central planners who are never accountable for their failures.
Haiti just showed us which one delivers.
The 20th century bet on the bureaucrat. The 21st belongs to builders, and to states that do what they say.
KProuty retweeted
Thomas Sowell – The Man Who Asked for the Evidence 📚
He was born in 1930 in North Carolina, in a house without running water. His father died before he was born. He grew up in Harlem, left school at sixteen, delivered telegrams, worked in a machine shop and served in the Marines. Then he went to Harvard, Columbia and Chicago.
He started as a Marxist. Books did not cure him. A summer job did.
In 1960, at the U.S. Department of Labor, he studied the minimum wage in Puerto Rico's sugar industry. Each time the wage was raised, employment fell. He proposed a simple test to find out why. Nobody in the building wanted it run. The department's budget depended on the law being good; whether the law was good was not its business. That summer, he understood that an institution has interests of its own, and that the truth is rarely among them.
Everything else followed from there. For sixty years, he has asked the three questions that no ideology survives: compared to what, at what cost, and what hard evidence do you have?
He put the whole of economics in one line, observing that there are no solutions, only trade-offs. And he put the whole of politics in another, noting that it is hard to imagine a more dangerous way of making decisions than putting them in the hands of people who pay no price for being wrong.
He gave the planners their true name: the anointed. People who judge themselves by their intentions and everyone else by results, and for whom every failure of their policy is proof that it was not tried hard enough.
He was a black man from Harlem who said that culture matters more than grievance, and that the policies made to help the poor had hurt them most. For that, the people who claim to speak for the poor never forgave him. He kept writing anyway – more than forty books, without a single slogan in them.
He is ninety-six. He has never held power, never led a movement, never raised his voice.
He only asked for the evidence. In the age of the Lie, that turned out to be the most radical thing a man could do.
—
America has one honor that fits: the Presidential Medal of Freedom, its highest civilian award. 🏅🇺🇸
He should receive it now, while he can still walk up and collect it. 🗽
Hayek finished the job of obliterating the entire socialist project in 1945 with one devastating insight: the knowledge needed to run an economy does not exist in any one place.
It is scattered across millions of minds – the farmer who knows his field, the shopkeeper who knows his street, the engineer who knows his machine – and only prices can gather it. No planner can collect it, because most of it cannot even be written down. The socialists spent the next eighty years building bigger ministries to collect it anyway.
And yet here we are, watching politicians explain that this time it will work, because now they have data, experts and algorithms. They cannot tell you how many nurses a single hospital will need next winter – how exactly are they going to know what three hundred million people want, need and can make, every day, in every town?
Every Soviet shop with left shoes only, every empty Venezuelan shelf, every five-year plan fulfilled on paper was just Hayek being proven right. He left the planners one sentence to hang over their desks: "The curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design." But sure, let's give the committee a supercomputer. What could go wrong?
KProuty retweeted
This is another perfect example of somebody saying something that makes sense if you devote three nanoseconds of brain activity to it, but the moment you engage a few functioning neurons and actually THINK about what you're saying, the whole argument collapses into a steaming heap of constitutional illiteracy.
You see, here in the United States of America, we have this peculiar little arrangement called "civilian control of the military."
It's not some obscure technicality buried in the footnotes of a Pentagon personnel manual. It's a fundamental principle upon which this republic was founded.
Let me illustrate this with an example so absurdly simple that even the most determined political imbecile ought to be able to follow it.
Suppose I joined the Army, attained the exalted rank of Private First Class, and never earned another promotion in my entire miserable military career.
Then, years later, I somehow got myself elected President of the United States.
Would a four-star admiral outrank me?
YES! ABSOLUTELY!
Would that same four-star admiral nevertheless be subject to my authority as Commander in Chief?
YOU BET YOUR SWEET ASS.
Because, you see, military rank and constitutional authority are TWO ENTIRELY DIFFERENT THINGS.
Pete Hegseth is the Secretary of Defense. He occupies a civilian office within the executive branch of the federal government, appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate.
That office carries authority over the Department of Defense and the military officers serving within it, regardless of whether those officers have more stars on their shoulders than a goddamned planetarium.
Vice Admiral Nancy Lacore absolutely attained a higher military rank than Pete Hegseth ever did.
AND THAT HAS ABSOLUTELY NOTHING TO DO WITH WHETHER SHE IS SUBJECT TO HIS AUTHORITY AS SECRETARY OF DEFENSE.
In fact, the entire point of civilian control of the military is that civilian leadership exercises authority over military officers, including those holding the highest ranks.
The Vice Admiral understands this.
The Secretary of Defense understands this.
Every military officer who has taken the oath understands this.
But apparently, somewhere out there in the great howling wilderness of American political discourse, people have convinced themselves that a military pay grade is a constitutional chain of command.
They're announcing this revelation to the world with the smug confidence of a man who has just discovered that water is wet.
Congratulations. You've successfully confused military rank with civilian authority, and somehow managed to turn your own ignorance into a political talking point.
Hope this clears things up!




































