Bringing sanity to research.
40.7% of citations to retracted papers still treat them as support (21,037 of 51,626, pending human review).
Citations live: sanecite.com/checker
Calculations and conclusions are Beta. Help us build this: send feedback or contribute on GitHub.
1
70
Agreed, really important stuff @PaulLitvak is working on here! I hope to be able to contribute in my small way however I can. This brings up a larger point I've been thinking about: What I observe in this field is due to how new it is everyone is moving fast and trying to be first. Which is fine but in my opinion the resulting fragmentation is a curse. It's like we have hundreds of people shooting BB guns at a brick wall. We could all use the same effort in a unified way and blast a hole through the bunker doors of Science big enough for everyone to walk through! I'm determined to be helpful and supportive to anyone I think is doing great work.
I imagine people are nervous to open source and share their ideas freely because of a fear that resources to fund their work is scarce. Worse perhaps they fear someone will steal their ideas and they won't have another idea. That is not true.
Be excellent, be intense, be endlessly generous and helpful. Above all be continually zealous for truth and everything you need will follow. Scarcity is a lie. There is more work than could be done in a hundred lifetimes. There are endless ideas in you yet to be discovered. There are more people interested in truth than you might imagine that are willing to fund the pursuit of it.
I am living proof of this. I am no one from nowheresville. Yet someone as eminent and respected as @tylercowen found my work valuable and honored me with initial funding through @emergent_vc
There are adventures to be had, dragons to be slain and much fellowship along the way!
I end with one of my favorite quotes:
"It is amazing what you can accomplish if you do not care who gets the credit."- Harry S Truman
Paul is building a repository to house all the issues in papers that are being found thru AI paper auditing!
I believe this project will be a core piece of infrastructure! Websites, AIs, & humans will query the API.
Apply to submit your findings here: evidence.guide/signup
I just subscribed to @JoshuaH29403304 . Sign up here: joshuaharris357232.substack.…
22
Yeyyy! I’m so happy people are discovering the games I made for memorizing the quotes of the church fathers!
Fragment #48 · Epiphanius of Salamis
Restored in 2 tries
⬛🟨🟨🟨
🟨🟨🟨🟨
play.viapatrum.org/daily
1
36
Thing is about human nature is it’s never about the sex it’s about power. Married people give and take that dynamic in a harmonic resonance. Polycule etc is more like a Darwinian malevolence.
People are being hurt we just aren’t hearing from them yet.
Replying to @Dan_Schwartz
Oh, polycules are only scratching the surface of the depravity of the EA movement. @MrAndyNgo ‘s new Zizians book explains just how far it goes. The Zizians simply took EA to its logical ends.
20
Uhh guys? Can you please stop freaking out the normal people? Go to church or something.
This is getting weird man.
NEW: An AI researcher at Anthropic runs a business that hosts "consensual non-consent" orgies in the Bay Area. The orgies have been the subject of sexual assault allegations and sparked debate about the AI industry's attitudes toward women, some of whom report feeling pressured to attend the orgies in order to advance their careers.
Paul Crowley, a cybersecurity researcher at Anthropic, is listed as a manager of Red Means No LLC, which says that its parties are "designed to be spaces to … ignore the 'nos' of others." Participants can use a safe word, "red," to end an encounter but give "default consent" to "spanking," "wrestling," and "light pain" by entering the orgy, according to Red Means No's website. More extreme actions, including "light electricity" and "moderate beatings," are "permitted with negotiation," though "body-shaming and race-shaming … are disallowed entirely."
The orgies have been known to attract a disproportionate number of employees at Anthropic and OpenAI, a dynamic critics say creates professional pressure for women in AI to attend. The criticism spilled into public view last month after an independent AI researcher, John Wentworth, said that he "absolutely [does] upgrade" his assessment of AI safety experts "if I find out they go to [Red Means No]," adding that attendance was a "strong signal" of free thought.
"Want to get ahead in your AI career? Go to the rape orgy," Substacker Ivy Asterix quipped. At least one woman claims to have been sexually assaulted at Red Means No, which the group describes as a "safe space" to have "your resistance ignored."🧵
freebeacon.com/america/horri…
27
SaneCite retweeted
A clinical trial was retracted in 2010. Three medical reviews published 7–16 years later still counted it as supporting evidence.
@SaneCite, a project that tracks research still relying on retracted papers, found this case by hand and let us test it with YuCe, our open-source tool that makes AI agents record exactly which source each claim rests on.
Three AI agents read the reviews. Every claim they wrote down had to carry an exact quote from the text, checked against the source. When a claim relied on the trial, the agent recorded that too.
Then we told YuCe the trial was retracted. All 35 claims resting on it lost their support at once. The other 655 of 690 stayed untouched. The agents found 15 of the 16 passages SaneCite had found by hand. This run took 10 minutes and cost $0.26.
Not everything flagged was useful. Of the 28 flags we sent SaneCite, our own AI first pass found only 11 were claims that truly relied on the trial; 3 were just reference mentions, 14 were the agents' working notes. No human has checked this yet.
A claim losing support does not mean it is wrong: a review's overall result may still hold. YuCe does not judge the science. It shows what rests on what.
Thanks to @SaneCite for the case and for permission to share it.
That’s because it’s not biological it’s first spiritual. Materialist views of the world hollow out everything and answer nothing.
It’s not like all our ancestors were dummies until Darwin stumbled along. He sees a mechanism but not the agent that made the mechanism nor the telos for which it was made.
Man without meaning dissolves.
I'm glad somebody finally brought this up. I've been noticing it for about 20 years, at least, increasingly.
37
The paper said US growth was faster in 1950-90 than in 1910-50.
SaneCite found: if you count the years the standard way, the same as for every other country, US growth was slower, 1.84% a year versus 2.13%.
Across the 63 method choices we could compare in this body of work, the authors break from the standard method 89% of the time.
sanecite.com/saez-zucman-che…
19
The report said the global minimum tax on big companies was weakened by a factor of 2.
SaneCite found: if you measure it against the 2021 deal the standard way, the report's own spreadsheet gives 1.6.
Across the 63 method choices we could compare in this body of work, the authors break from the standard method 89% of the time.
sanecite.com/saez-zucman-che…
25
Clinton SHOULD have resigned he did this while in office and it was a breach of trust of ones most sacred vows. It wasn't in his past everyone has a past. That's the salient point. It's not good to look past stuff like this. It ignores the massive psychological and spiritual toll that adultery has on a person. It's worse than tax fraud. Marriage is more sacred than money.
No. Bill Clinton did not resign.
Jensen Huang shouldn’t either.
And the Nvidia board shouldn’t fire him.
Particularly in the heat of the moment.
Ride it out and ignore the journos.
Clinton did. And then no one cared.
1
27
I'm hardly a fan of Elizabeth Warrens policies in a lot of areas but I don't get why this is a bad thing. If someone is unable to pay their bills or even unwilling (depending) why would charging them 30%+ help anything? Just issue lower credit amounts in general to people. Credit cards hurt far more people than they help.
JUST IN: Sen. Elizabeth Warren reveals Democrats have legislation ready to cap credit card rates at 10%.
17
The paper said the top income tax rate should be 83%.
SaneCite found: if you run the paper's numbers through the standard formula, you get 57%.
Across the 63 method choices we could compare in this body of work, the authors break from the standard method 89% of the time.
sanecite.com/saez-zucman-che…
1
13
Excellent project, excellent people. Worth follows.
Replying to @NathanpmYoung @stuartbuck1
I'm very thankful to @stuartbuck1 for his support! I'll try my best not to let him down. The donation thru Lightcone allows me to go to fulltime at @MetascienceObs and scale up forensic metascience work, paying at least a yr of my salary plus compute and help from contractors.
1
27



















