Dr Rebecca Steinfeld (@beccasteinfeld) header
Dr Rebecca Steinfeld (@beccasteinfeld) profile picture

Political scientist, writer, campaigner and mum of three. Co-founder @EqualCPs. Own views.

London, UK.
Joined March 2011
Dr Rebecca Steinfeld retweeted
I’m not a doctor, I’m not an influencer, I’m not being paid by any formula companies. I could have died as could my daughter due to this UK maternity breastfeeding indoctrination.
1
4
15
386
Dr Rebecca Steinfeld retweeted
See even grok is team #fedisbest these days 🤣
Agreed. Rigid exclusive breastfeeding rules that delay or block formula when transfer is inadequate create preventable dehydration and jaundice cases. Frontline staff following them aren't the root problem; the policies need evidence-based updates that prioritise actual intake over ideology.
1
3
1
15
2,278
Dr Rebecca Steinfeld retweeted
Tens of thousands of babies are being readmitted to hospital a few days after birth, every year, suffering from dehydration and jaundice – a figure that has risen over the past decade. Babies that don't get enough milk are at risk from a build-up of levels of bilirubin, which causes jaundice and can lead to serious health complications. On top of that, dehydration can have fatal consequences. Put plainly, there are thousands of babies being starved to dangerous levels each year. ✍️ Ella Whelan Article | spectator.com/article/far-fr…
12
16
85
11,760
Dr Rebecca Steinfeld retweeted
With the rising readmission rate it’s shocking infant feeding isn’t on the maternity & neonatal plan. The Baby Friendly Initiative believes the only information a pregnant woman needs about feeding is the value of breastfeeding. This isn’t informed choice & it’s not preparation
1
3
9
559
Dr Rebecca Steinfeld retweeted
Links between BF and caesareans coming up a lot from breastfeeding advocates and it's revealing. If c sections are rising - partly through need, partly through women wanting them - and if that does affect initial milk production, surely the NHS should up its info and provision of formula? What's the solution otherwise? Babies starve? Women forced to have unwanted vaginal birth?
I get that (& it should be heard) but it’s not the real scandal here. The problem with ‘feeding’ is much more linked with the decimation of maternity support generally, & also with the soaring rate of caesareans - which are strongly linked with feeding issues.
7
10
1
73
8,193
Dr Rebecca Steinfeld retweeted
The @DHSCgovuk acknowledges that jaundice and dehydration are reasons behind rising readmission rates and are often linked to feeding problems. Not all are preventable. But an infant feeding policy which puts safety, evidence and choice front and centre should be where we start.
1
1
5
126
Dr Rebecca Steinfeld retweeted
Maternity and breastfeeding. "Put plainly, there are thousands of babies being starved to dangerous levels each year."
1
11
2
46
6,235
Dr Rebecca Steinfeld retweeted
@Ella_M_Whelan is right to call this a scandal hiding in plain sight. When women are not warned of risks of underfeeding in early breastfeeding lest it deter them from doing so, ideology is prioritised over safety. This is what happened to Bella and her baby.
2
4
10
660
Bang on @Ella_M_Whelan. The @NHSuk obsession with exclusive breastfeeding - whatever the harm to mothers and babies - is a scandal hiding in plain sight. To challenge it, speak up, if you can, and support @feedukorg’s campaign calling for change 💪Enough of this nonsense!
2
10
666
For me, a perfect storm sustains our harmful “breast is best” approach: naturalistic fallacy, trad wifery, demonisation of formula milk, medical misogyny, dismissing women’s experiences, sloppy science… Not helpful to blame left or right - all of these need to be tackled!
Exclusively breast feeding can be both dangerous and impossible. The left knows this but perpetuates the myth that only exclusive breastfeeding is good enough. New mothers are bullied mercilessly into believing it is the only option. If you don’t - or can’t - breast feeding you are told you are “harming your baby”. No new mother wants to harm her baby. So they persevere, even when it’s clear that breastfeeding is not (for whatever reason) working. Even when breastfeeding is harming their baby. One of my friends had a baby with undiagnosed tongue tie. He couldn’t latch but she sat for days, both of them crying, because she had been told a responsible mother would not give their baby formula. He ended up back in hospital having lost over 10% of his birth weight. I had no problems with my first, but my second was premature and in NICU. So I expressed for six months. I had to buy a new freezer to store milk as she was so small, I was initially making more than she could have. A health visitor came round when she was 3 months old and back from hospital. Accusingly she said “what are you feeding her”. She didn’t believe I’d battled through expressing so I showed her the freezer, full of small bottles of milk. She stared at my chest and said “you don’t look like you could”. I’ve never been well endowed but she should know breast size has nothing to do with milk production. It stung. It stung even more knowing that I had been crying in pain, sadness and frustration over a pump every 4 hours for 3 months so my baby had enough milk as she grew. With my third, I had hyperthyroidism which goes into abeyance in pregnancy but came back with a vengeance shortly after he was born and I had to go back onto medication to control it. I couldn’t breast feed from 3 weeks. He thrived anyway. The left demonised formula back in 1970s. Early campaigns were spearheaded by socialist and left-leaning groups, such as the UK charity War on Want and the Swiss Third World Action Group, which framed the issue around multinational corporate exploitation of developing nations. In the 1980s the Greens, Lib Dem’s and trade unions supported the boycott of Nestle for selling baby formula. The global left captured international bodies such as WHO which pushed the anti-formula agenda onto weak national governments. For decades, mothers and babies have paid the price for leftist, anti capitalism propaganda. Is breast milk great? yes. Is formula crucial for many? yes. Tongue tie, low milk production, illness, medicine, technique: all can prevent exclusively breast feeding from being possible. Stop demonising mothers for wanting the best for their babies. Stop making babies pay the price for political ideology.
1
1
170
“Since when did anyone own a woman’s body except herself?” 💯 @zatzi That’s why women need to be told about the benefits - and risks - of exclusive breastfeeding. Those supported by good evidence. Otherwise how can women make informed choices about what’s best for their babies?
This makes me so angry. Yes, most women can, and most women try to, breastfeed. But plenty cannot - for a myriad of reasons. I am not trying to “rationalise my choice”👇in defending women who cannot or do not exclusively breast feed. I exclusively breast fed my eldest to 6 months. Because she was extremely premature I exclusively bottle fed my second with expressed breast milk to six months. (Photo of a freezer full of my breast milk ready for her as she grew so I kept up my supply, it was pure torture) With my third I had to take medication from 3 weeks postpartum that prohibited breast feeding. I have nothing to “justify”. To myself, my children or anyone else. And nor does any other mother who cannot - or does not - exclusively breast feed. Since when did anyone own a woman’s body except herself? What % of mothers do the exclusive breast only brigade think choose to give their babies a marginally (yes, only very marginally) a worse start in life compared to the % who wish they could and try until there is a crisis having been bullied and shamed into not giving their baby the nutrition it needs? Breast feeding is great, indisputably the best option. Mixed feeding is fine. And can be extremely beneficial to both mister and baby. Bottle feeding keeps babies alive who would otherwise starve. Which bit of this is hard to grasp?
1
115
Write about breastfeeding… get a ton of anti-Semitic hate 🤷‍♀️
14
3
5
10
5,056
Dr Rebecca Steinfeld retweeted
As @beccasteinfeld writes for @unherd, healthcare professionals are instructed never to”to imply formula feeding and breastfeeding are equal choices” under policy rules. But EVERY choice that meets the needs of that woman and her baby is an equal one. unherd.com/newsroom/why-are-…
1
5
23
2,118
Dr Rebecca Steinfeld retweeted
Want to do something about the poor standards of care and help given to women when it comes to infant feeding? Sign the @feedukorg petition #ToldInTime. Babies should not be being put in danger, and mothers should not be being punished: feeduk.org/toldintime
12
20
1,484
Dr Rebecca Steinfeld retweeted
Join us next Wednesday; so much to discuss Finding Formula: Confronting Insecurities eventbrite.com/e/finding-for…
1
1
1
577
Dr Rebecca Steinfeld retweeted
Read our full report on the rise in admissions here, and what it tells us about the safety, evidence and ethics of current infant feeding policy. #admissionoffailure feeduk.org/admissionoffailur…
1
2
4
135
Dr Rebecca Steinfeld retweeted
This approach also means women’s experiences of poor milk supply get dismissed as imaginary, or they get told they are not “trying hard enough”.
1
1
7
224