Replying to @HCsick @loanchargeprey @TheRising_Moon @CheltenhamJump1 @DanNeidle @HMRCVictim @4x4RoadRunner01 @Cestrian2203 @HMRobbinCs @rexgold
And until their argument changed in the Rangers case the courts were consistently saying loans weren’t taxable - we later found out those decisions were in fact wrong however nobody had time machines to go back and take different decisions based on later facts
Replying to @HCsick @TheRising_Moon @CheltenhamJump1 @DanNeidle @HMRCVictim @4x4RoadRunner01 @Cestrian2203 @HMRobbinCs @rexgold
HMRC mistakenly lthought they would win in court on a "loans = taxable PAYE income" legal argument. 1000's of unactioned open enquiries left pending a result for years. Which also explains the mess of accumulated unaffordable interest on top of the eventual #LoanCharge for many
Hypocrite Hammond retweeted
@DanNeidle The primary blame for #LoanCharge debacle should always be the promoters. But #HMRC are not blameless either. Even Ray McCann recognised that in the latest government review and in a X post.
Replying to @HCsick @Mylerdoo @HMRobbinCs @loanchargeprey @TheRising_Moon @DanNeidle @CheltenhamJump1 @HMRCVictim @4x4RoadRunner01 @Cestrian2203 @rexgold @loanchargeAPPG @LordsEconCom
Not forgetting HMRC "always clear" loan schemes "never worked" but SAs signed off year on year. Loan schemes were variously evasion, illegal avoidance, "evoidance", or apparently "disguised" remuneration, but contractors were dishonest, fools or both. The narrative kept shifting
Replying to @HCsick @HMRobbinCs @loanchargeprey @TheRising_Moon @DanNeidle @CheltenhamJump1 @HMRCVictim @4x4RoadRunner01 @Cestrian2203 @rexgold
Absolutely - on preferred supplier lists of major recruitment players in the market at the time - all the mood music was saying all above board
Replying to @Mylerdoo @HMRobbinCs @loanchargeprey @TheRising_Moon @DanNeidle @CheltenhamJump1 @HMRCVictim @4x4RoadRunner01 @Cestrian2203 @rexgold
LCAG reported on this to @loanchargeAPPG and at least one mainstream MSM covered the story. However, large end-clients organisations - even HMRC, have been able to claim plausible deniability by arms length 'unawareness' of supply chain. @LordsEconCom repeatedly queried HMRC.
Replying to @HCsick @HMRobbinCs @loanchargeprey @TheRising_Moon @DanNeidle @Mylerdoo @CheltenhamJump1 @HMRCVictim @4x4RoadRunner01 @Cestrian2203 @rexgold
Exactly my scenario. When I was offered my first contractor gig, I wanted to set up a Ltd Co. All I could hear was horrified cries of "what?? are you CRAZY?? haven't you heard of IR35?!!" (I hadn't). Then I found literally all were on a "scheme". Same return as Ltd, no IR35 woes.
Replying to @HMRobbinCs @loanchargeprey @TheRising_Moon @DanNeidle @Mylerdoo @CheltenhamJump1 @HMRCVictim @4x4RoadRunner01 @Cestrian2203 @rexgold
Imagine starting a contracting career amid #IR35 warnings and so following peer and preferred supplier pro advice to use loan scheme as the safe option. Comparative remuneration to Ltd Co, with a market salary PAYE element. No HMRC warning. Why some felt like grooming...
Hypocrite Hammond retweeted
The United Kingdom’s 2017 #LoanChargeScandal remains one of the most contentious measures in modern #tax history.
The Retrospective Dilemma: Why the #LoanCharge Targeted Individuals Over Promoters
linkedin.com/pulse/retrospec…
Hypocrite Hammond retweeted
Replying to @Stephen41792571 @HCsick @CheltenhamJump1 @DanNeidle @HMRCVictim @4x4RoadRunner01 @Cestrian2203 @HMRobbinCs @rexgold @HMRCgovuk @loanchargeAPPG
HMRC says loan schemes "never worked" - the law was always clear.
If so, winning in court didn't matter because it could have warned the public of the eventual demise of the schemes on moral grounds. Instead: a 2009 note for tax advisers and not the public.
Hypocrite Hammond retweeted
Replying to @TheRising_Moon @HCsick @CheltenhamJump1 @DanNeidle @HMRCVictim @4x4RoadRunner01 @Cestrian2203 @HMRobbinCs @rexgold @HMRCgovuk @loanchargeAPPG
Admitting that and accepting their role in contributing to this mess would have been the right thing to do. That's clearly not in their DNA, as you know from your own experience. The lengths they then went to to cover this up and pursue a punishment strategy? Unforgivable
Hypocrite Hammond retweeted
Replying to @TheRising_Moon @HCsick @CheltenhamJump1 @DanNeidle @HMRCVictim @4x4RoadRunner01 @Cestrian2203 @HMRobbinCs @rexgold
One could almost call it entrapment or tax grooming 🤨 @HMRCgovuk published a note targeted at advisors in 2009. Mentioned in #loancharge review as attached and viewed by a handful of tax nerds at the time. Why no serious attempt to intervene at that time? Never explained
Replying to @CheltenhamJump1 @DanNeidle @HMRCVictim @4x4RoadRunner01 @Cestrian2203 @TheRising_Moon @HMRobbinCs @rexgold
Or should have HMRC done more to target loan promoters much earlier - but didn't, for fear it would weaken their claim against workers involved (per FOI HMRC internal correspondence)? Which had the unintended consequence of exposing far more unwitting taxpayers to #LoanCharge...
Hypocrite Hammond retweeted
My advice is all #LoanchargeScandal victims is to collect 1000£ each, donate it to any party @Conservatives @UKLabour @LibDems even @reformparty_uk with promise and delivery of abolishment of loan charge and retro tax.
That is how promoters did.
innit @MelJStride?
Hypocrite Hammond retweeted
Always a pleasure to take the stage at @yorkshirepost Business Awards! Congratulations to our magnificent winners. Great images from Allan McKenzie.
Hypocrite Hammond retweeted
Replying to @PhilipHammondUK
You are doing a tax grab on 100k contractors by retrospectively changing tax laws. Taxing loans as income and at the same time as loans, then taxing us on the fees that the promoters charged. While you let the promoters walk away as they are Tory donors.
#LoanChargeScandal
Hypocrite Hammond retweeted
Replying to @Ray_McCann55
@Ray_McCann55 you had the chance to right this. What stopped you?
Replying to @HuddlestonNigel
@HuddlestonNigel It is almost 7 years since I first highlighted the coming catastrophe that would be the loan charge. @HMRCgovuk has largely alienated many who supported the policy of closing these schemes. The lack of consistent, fair, humane settlement terms has been shameful.
Hypocrite Hammond retweeted
How many times will risk of more #LoanCharge suicides be ignored by this heartless Government?
Cross party MP's, Lords & press all predicted loss of lives, but @BorisJohnson failed to stop retrospective tax.
Thousands crying out #STOPtheLoanCharge
nitter.cf/loanchargeAPPG/status/…
The suicide risk from the #LoanCharge has been raised many times in Parliament inc by #LoanChargeAPPG officers/members, yet so far Ministers won’t acknowledge this in their replies & @hmtreasury & @HMRCgovuk refuse to call a halt to the #LoanChargeScandal m.youtube.com/watch?v=jtfnVS…
















![Loan Charge Action Group [LCAG] (@LCAG_2019) profile picture](https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/993517859354619905/lIfW2JQm_400x400.jpg)
![Image from Loan Charge Action Group [LCAG] (@LCAG_2019)](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Ea_gY8KXQAIZAv2.jpg?name=small&format=webp)

