Harry Browne (@harrybrowne) header
Harry Browne (@harrybrowne) profile picture

Journalist, Jobseeker

Dublin
Joined May 2010
Photo by Harry Browne (@harrybrowne)Photo by Harry Browne (@harrybrowne)Photo by Harry Browne (@harrybrowne)Photo by Harry Browne (@harrybrowne)Photo by Harry Browne (@harrybrowne)Photo by Harry Browne (@harrybrowne)Photo by Harry Browne (@harrybrowne)Photo by Harry Browne (@harrybrowne)Photo by Harry Browne (@harrybrowne)Photo by Harry Browne (@harrybrowne)
On the 20th anniversary of the disarming of an American war-plane at Shannon Airport, my 2006 article on the action and the subsequent acquittal of the Pitstop Ploughshares thedublinreview.com/article/…
4
11
6,351
Harry Browne retweeted
A reminder that I wasn't even sanctioned for reporting on Ukraine, but on Palestine. To those who say I have a right to judicial redress, it's been 16 months & counting of waiting for a court decision while living in a state of civil death, where I can't provide for my 3 kids.
By my own count, if one includes these latest sanctions, the EU has now sanctioned 8 European citizens for speech: - 3 German citizens: Alina Lipp, Thomas Röper and Hüseyin Doğru - 3 French citizens: Xavier Moreau, Adrien Bocquet and Sylvain Afoua (aka Egountchi Behanzin) - 1 Lithuanian citizen: Ernest Mackevičius - 1 Irish citizen: Chay Bowes The sanctions include freezing these people's assets and making it a crime for anyone in the EU to pay them, hire them or even lend them a single euro. They also include a travel ban, which leads to some absurd situations: Doğru - based in Germany - was invited by some members of the EU parliament to Brussels to plead his case but he couldn't go due to the travel ban. As one of the MEPs who invited him - and made 40 phone calls to try, unsuccessfully, to get him cleared to come - put it: "It really was like something out of a Kafka novel" (berliner-zeitung.de/article/…). And, probably worst of all, all of this was decided without any charge, trial or court ruling - simply as a unilateral decision of government ministers. Yesterday's sanctions, for instance, were decided at the Foreign Affairs Council meeting of EU Foreign Ministers and were simply signed by Kaja Kallas alone on behalf of the Council (eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-cont…). Put it all together, and this violates at least half a dozen of what the EU keeps saying are the fundamental values and principles it supposedly fights for: 1) Separation of powers: here we have government ministers - members of the executive branch of their countries - acting as prosecutor, judge and jury 2) Presumption of innocence (Article 48 of the EU’s own Charter of Fundamental Rights): they’re punished without guilt ever being established, and without being given a chance to plead their case before the decision 3) Right to a fair trial (Article 47): there was no trial at all, let alone a fair one 4) Freedom of expression and of the media (Article 11): they were sanctioned - explicitly so - for what they said and published. For instance, in these latest sanctions, Chay Bowes was sanctioned for, among other things, the speech crime of "participat[ing] in the spreading of anti-Western and anti-Ukraine disinformation at the UN Security Council" (eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-cont…). Sanctioned in part for a speech at the UN, a forum that exists precisely so that clashing views on international matters can be heard, quite the message to send from the EU... 5) Freedom of movement (Article 45): they're under a travel ban 6) Right to work and to property (Articles 15 and 17): their assets are frozen and nobody may employ or pay them You can think whatever you want about these 8 people. But ask yourself this: even if you are pro-Ukraine, pro-EU, anti-Russia and you view these people as malignant Russian operatives... what is the EU fighting for here, exactly? This is more profound than you may think: we're speaking about the very foundation of modern European civilization, built on the very idea that political power alone cannot decide what is true. I'm not exaggerating. What we’re witnessing is a return to the pre-Enlightenment playbook, when monarchic or religious authorities defined the truth, deviations from it were called heresy, and heretics were excommunicated - cut off from the community, so that no one could trade with them, employ them or help them. In Europe's darkest times, heretics were even famously burned at the stake - like Joan of Arc or Giordano Bruno. It took literal centuries of religious wars and debates, and the likes of Voltaire, Kant and Mill, to replace it with a basic idea: that no single power, however legitimate, gets to be the final judge of what is true, and that you answer for your words only before a court, under laws written via a process separate from the power that does the accusation. You can find countless works of European literature on this very matter. Take Spinoza, excommunicated in 1656 by the Portuguese-Jewish community of Amsterdam, with a decree ordering that "no one should communicate with him" nor "accord him any favor". He went on to write the Theological-Political Treatise, one of the founding texts of the Enlightenment, with an entire chapter arguing that "in a free state every man may think what he likes, and say what he thinks." Or Mill, two centuries later in On Liberty, Chapter 2: "All silencing of discussion is an assumption of infallibility." Or Kafka’s The Trial, the story of a man accused by an authority nobody can quite locate, of something nobody will explain. How is what Europe is presently doing anything other than going back to that very system, under new appellations? The authority: government ministers. The heresy: "disinformation". The excommunication: assets frozen, banned from travelling and nobody may pay them, hire them or lend them a single euro. It’s basically Spinoza’s excommunication decree on EU letterhead, with a bit of Kafka sprinkled in given that the man invited to the European Parliament to contest his punishment couldn’t attend because of the very punishment he wanted to contest. You don’t have to like these 8 people, or even care about them, to see the problem. Heck, this system was developed precisely for the people nobody likes: consensual ideas never needed protecting. No, the real question here is this: do you want Europe to be the heir of Spinoza - or of Voltaire, or of Galileo, or of any of the countless Europeans who suffered or even died for thinking differently - or of their persecutors?
33
1,263
56
3,927
62,823
Harry Browne retweeted
This deserves a response because it raises an important point. EU sanctions are subject to judicial review. That is correct. Sanctioned persons can apply for judicial review from the Court of Justice in Luxembourg. It is technically wrong to call this a "defence." It's an application to annul an administrative measure. This can take as long as 24 months. It requires specialized legal representation, potentially running into hundreds of thousands of euros in legal costs. For all of that time, the sanctioned person is subject to a travel ban and an asset freeze, making it difficult to pay for legal representation. For all of that time, they are subject to an ongoing deprivation of rights. Traditionally, in democracies, if an action risks irreversible harm, threatens fundamental rights, or lacks a fair way to fix mistakes later, ex-post review is considered inadequate. We don't shoot first and ask questions later. We involve a court before the punishment happens, and we hold the prosecution to an extremely high standard of evidence. We are abandoning that standard now. And we are doing it for what is ultimately - however much we might disagree with it - speech. We are creating a very broad EU power to punish speech. Today, you may abhor the victim. Tomorrow it might be you. It is correct to note that restrictive measures are not criminal convictions. That is the core of the problem. These sanctions were designed as a foreign policy instrument to pressure other governments and the powerful foreign nationals around them. That is why there are fewer checks and balances on how they are used. They were not designed to be used on EU citizens as a form of punishment. They are now being used in that way. They don't have the safeguards for fundamental rights that are present in criminal procedure, and which EU citizens expect. They are wide open to abuse.
This quoted post is unavailable.
43
420
34
1,259
32,115
Harry Browne retweeted
GOVT MISINFORMATION ALERT - If Ireland deploys DF to proposed ‘EU Support Mission’ to Lebanon without Triple Lock -It will NOT be a Blue Helmet Peacekeeping Mission -It will be an EU (Von Der Leyen ‘We Stand With Israel’) Peace Enforcement Mission to Disarm Hezbollah -A CIVIL WAR
The vast majority of people want Ireland to maintain our proud tradition of peacekeeping. Reforming the triple lock ensures our decisions on participation in peacekeeping missions are not dictated by a veto from Russia, China, or the United States.
47
382
32
979
27,298
Harry Browne retweeted
A psychotic, bloodthirsty call for ethnic cleansing on a scale unseen since the Nazis, which will definitely not provoke any letters from the EHRC to Elon Musk's British side project. Lowe should have said something mean about Zionism if he wanted that to happen.
1
83
2
239
5,882
Harry Browne retweeted
I went on the Ditch's Party Line to speak about how Western support for Israel's crimes in Gaza is legitimizing racism more broadly and strengthening the forces of the radical right. Thanks to @harrybrowne and @BigPaulieDoyle for having me on!
3
12
24
1,207
Harry Browne retweeted
Minister for further education James Lawless promotes government’s AI summit… … with picture of a six-fingered hand typing on a laptop
16
90
8
337
21,690
Such a pleasure to meet and interview Aaron. Audio version available wherever you get your podcasts, The Ditch – The Party Line
3
138
Harry Browne retweeted
I came to address the topic under discussion, which was US and Russian foreign policy. @ScottLucas_EA repeatedly tried to make the debate about me in such a juvenile fashion that he cited (irrelevant) Twitter posts to make his case. And as he has repeatedly on Twitter, he also lied about the OPCW whistleblowers -- who I'm always honored to defend. Especially in Ireland, home to one of them. Video should be out soon. Thanks to UCD for having me and to everyone who attended, on either side of the debate, in good faith.
Replying to @aaronjmate
Hey there Aaron Well done on staying composed It was pathetic to see Scott Lucas from the Clinton institute of UCD spew lie after lie and the manner in which he constantly attacked your journalistic credentials says a lot about the calibre of his academic integrity and UCDs
13
80
4
422
27,624
🎧 lol on @NewstalkFM - @harrybrowne tells Fionnan Sheahan “the real opposition from the right in the country is coming from the @Independent_ie” - “right Harry, thanks for that, right…” replies Fionnan. Listen…
2
1
4
891
Harry Browne retweeted
Gavin Bazunu maintained his connection to all of us opposed to this match. He was also able to act, facing implicit and explicit threats. He turned his character to action, in a decision that was deeply personal but also collective. Thank you. ontheditch.com/comment-thank…
97
262
13
1,162
25,683
Harry Browne retweeted
The Ditch: The Party Line | Episode 29: Foul Play, with Rebecca O’Keeffe ‘What would constitute a Kaepernick moment for the Irish soccer team over the next 10 days?’ ‘Not playing. Refusing to play. ‘There's no other action that you think we could have. There's not a taking the knee for them?’ ‘If you're talking about sporting moments, I genuinely think if they refuse to play that would be a sporting moment that we celebrate in this country. It would constitute one of the great sporting moments of this country. I think it will impact far beyond the game. I think it will have a domino effect. That will be a sporting moment. And sporting moments bring the country together collectively. It captures the nation. And that would do it.’ ‘It would be Jesse Owens. It would be Muhammad Ali not going to Vietnam. I do think that's the level we're talking about.’
25
86
13
207
13,228
Harry Browne retweeted
Myself, Seán Fearon and Pat Brodie have published a report today examining the exaggerated benefits and significant costs of data centres to Ireland. Below is a short thread on some of the key takeaways. Read the full report here: mural.maynoothuniversity.ie/… 1/6
3
61
2
111
1,966
Great piece @BigPaulieDoyle in @wereontheditch on the Raytheon 9 Excellent reflection on the hypocrisy of Ireland's political & media elite around our complicity in imperialist wars & genocide, & towards citizens who seek to enforce basic moral standards ontheditch.com/comment-the-r…
1
5
11
544
Harry Browne retweeted
This one is dedicated to the Raytheon Nine. ‘Raytheon, it was clear, wasn’t particularly welcome in Derry, and anyone found to have disrupted its activities would be likely found, by their peers, to have acted within the bounds of their legal duty.’ ontheditch.com/comment-the-r…
34
1
78
4,528
One of my favorite things I've read on "alignment" and AI risk is this piece by my friend Jordan Ecker on how we are already living in a society dominated by an inhuman rationality we created and which escaped our control, namely, capital clereviewofbooks.com/beverle…
7
66
6
363
12,273
Harry Browne retweeted
Remember the letter signed by over 50 academics calling on Ireland to recuse itself from digital matters during the EU Council presidency? Dublin based IIEA co-hosting an event with Microsoft: 'Harnessing AI for Growth and Competitiveness: Priorities for the Irish Presidency'.
5
8
1
22
1,941
Harry Browne retweeted
Replying to @ThomasByrneTD
@ThomasByrneTD uses the example of Operation Irini to argue the TL is outdated. The opposite is true. It saved us from becoming embroiled in hostile naval operations in the Med. It will also save us from becoming involved in Israel-aligned EU military operations in Lebanon. 1/2
The Triple-Lock legislation was introduced in 1960, before the EU and OSCE even existed. It is outdated and no longer fit for purpose when it comes to peacekeeping. In @businessposthq, I share my thoughts on the need for reform. businesspost.ie/politics/tho…
1
9
19
445
Just received the highest honor in journalism. Taxi Driver: You see they bombed all those boats? Me: Yea it’s terrible, war crimes Taxi: We’re at war and the pelucones (the rich) don’t care…I only know because there’s a girl who writes at a gringo newspaper…esté Dropé Esité something like that. She was recently on a radio show I like. She said all these things I hadn’t heard before. Anyways, súper pilas la pelada (super smart girl). She mostly writes in English but if you can read English you should check her out. I lived in Queens for 10 years so I can read English. I forget her name but the newspaper is called Dropé Esite and they’re my favorite newspaper now. Got out the taxi and immediately started crying. Everyone knows taxi drivers are the true media critics so I’m counting this as my first award 🙂‍↕️ I’ve gotten death threats before I’ve even gotten my first official job in this industry. The financial precarity of being a freelancer has meant restructuring a bit of my life. My family’s terrified because the last journalist in our family was literally actually tortured by the CIA and sent to prison. My friends are annoyed that I choose all nighters writing over nights out with them. So, I really needed this validation lol. If it makes my paisanos feel seen then that’s what I wanna do for the rest of my life 🥹 Shout out to Dropé Esité News 😎
141
1,200
27
12,496
313,078
Harry Browne retweeted
Must be nice to be a defence correspondent and get paid a salary to write a variation of this article every single week
16
88
3
498
7,575