Pinned Tweet
7 signs you’ve exchanged Young, Restless and Reformed for Young, Restless, and Redacted:
1. You went from someone who cringebrags on his smoking hot wife, to someone who cringebrags on his submissive tradwife
2. You went from a 6’2 former jock who bought some glasses to cosplay as a nerd, to a 5’6 former fantasy nerd who discovered barbells and cosplays as a jock
3. You went from a suburbanite who cosplays as an urban city boy to a suburbanite who cosplays as an agrarian hunter-gatherer
4. You went from unsingable sad soyboy hipster music to unsingable old music (in 4 parts!)
5. You went from a coward who hides behind nuance to a coward who hides behind controversy
6. You went from someone who, as a matter of principle, aspires to 10K+ followers on Twitter and a church of 500+ to someone who, as a matter of principle, aspires to 10K+ followers on Twitter and a church of <120
7. You traded the power of narrative for…the power of…story? Yeah, that part never changed – at Newburgh, IN
Jake Mentzel retweeted
I had some good years in my 30's, reinvested money, built out businesses, and then cancel culture hit. (People have no idea what it was like on the back end, you couldn't even get payment processing.) I was living off of credit cards and trying to find a way to pull a rabbit from a hat. All I could do was run the math of when I'd have to tell my wife and kids we officially had nothing. Meanwhile you don't say these things because you want your kids to have a normal childhood, you don't want to stress out your wife, and you can hide a lot of financial troubles from them, but I look back and my face is beet red and swollen. I still exercised hard but you can't escape the cortisol bomb of obsessing over whether this is the month you're wiped out. That's what people are going through now. We are all the Red Baron pizza man and nobody next to Trump gives a shit. Trump 47 is all a get rich quick scheme for them as they take foreign trips, sell pardons, and do God knows what else. I have no remaining patience for the neocons, chickenhawks, World Liberty Financial, buying private islands, and taking money from Gulf country for your "investment fund." All of these people are repulsive, which in politics doesn't matter if they can deliver wins for the great good of the country. Now we see - they can't even do that.
I remember making 40k with a wife and two babies and having nothing left at the end of the month after rent and groceries, and I think about it still every day. If you’re struggling to make ends meet and keep your family fed with a roof over their heads, that struggle is simply the most pressing and urgent matter in your life and nothing else really comes close. This is something that many Republican politicians and conservative “thought leaders” still do not understand and maybe never will.
Jake Mentzel retweeted
The divorce rate for white, ideologically conservative, Christian-attending-church-weekly, first-marriage couples who have multiple biological children is less than 1%.
We have the data; people looked at the data. Sociology isn’t a mystery.
The divorce rate for college educated people is nearly half as those without. For white people it’s about 30%. For Christians it’s about half of non-Christians, for non-boomers it’s a fraction.
If you’re a white christian college educated millennial, your divorce rate is about 15%. Don’t listen to doomers.
If you can’t beat em, buy em.
Dodgers Announce Purchase Of Milwaukee Brewers buff.ly/jsFEx7V
Proposal: opponents are allowed to turn off the DH for one AB/game and force pitchers into the box. Problem solved.
3
211
I’m not a big conference goer, but this was exceptionally good. I was blessed and helped and strengthened and encouraged.
The first Evergreen Summit has come and gone. It was, in many ways, an experiment. We had ideas about what might help pastors and their wives, but until people actually experienced it, we didn’t know whether those ideas would work.
The comment I heard over and over was that this was unlike any pastors’ conference people had attended before. Thankfully, they meant that as a compliment. We didn’t do anything revolutionary, but we made a handful of deliberate decisions that seemed to produce exactly what we hoped they would.
First, we didn’t record anything.
That wasn’t because we were trying to hide something. It was because we wanted people to know that one thing everyone would say about the Evergreen Summit was, “You had to be there.” The Summit isn’t primarily about consuming content. It’s about working through real ministry with peers.
Not recording also created a freedom that is increasingly rare. Men knew they could be honest about what was actually happening in their churches, their marriages, and their own hearts without wondering whether a clip would live online forever. That simple decision set the tone for the entire conference. People were open, and that openness carried into every discussion.
Second, we intentionally structured the teaching differently.
Rather than hour-long lectures, we grouped three sessions of roughly twenty-five minutes together. One speaker would finish, the next would step up immediately, then the third. The goal wasn’t to exhaust a subject but to get everyone thinking. The sessions existed to feed the discussions, not replace them.
After each block, all of the speakers returned for an open Q&A panel where attendees could ask whatever was on their minds. Then we broke into facilitated roundtables of about seven pastors each.
Each man identified one of the significant challenges facing his church. The group worked to define the issue carefully before jumping to solutions. Once everyone had laid their cards on the table, each roundtable selected a handful of those issues and worked through them together so that men left with practical next steps instead of merely taking home another notebook full of conference notes.
We repeated that pattern three times over the course of the Summit.
Just as important were the unstructured moments. Thursday and Friday evenings were designed simply to let pastors and their wives get to know one another. We encouraged everyone to exchange phone numbers and build friendships with like-minded couples. Ministry can be lonely. It doesn’t have to be.
The women’s track followed a more traditional format, but it shared the same goal. Rosaria Butterfield taught two sessions, Emily taught one, and after each teaching block we held panel discussions with Rosaria, Emily, and two seasoned pastors’ wives. There were also prayer groups, fellowship, and plenty of time simply to talk. If there’s one area we’ll refine for next year, it will probably be the women’s track, but even there we heard very positive feedback.
Overall, I wouldn’t change much.
It was a privilege to spend a few days helping strengthen pastors, their wives, and ultimately their churches. If the Lord is pleased to use the Evergreen Summit in even a small way to help faithful men endure for the long haul, then it has accomplished exactly what we hoped.
One thing has become clear, however: this is never going to be a massive conference.
We had roughly one hundred attendees this year. We may make room for another fifty couples next year, but not much beyond that. The Summit isn’t infinitely scalable because one of its greatest strengths is intimacy. The more you chase size, the more you risk losing the very thing that makes the event valuable.
So we’ll grow carefully, if at all.
Lord willing, we’ll gather again next year and do what we set out to do from the beginning: equip pastors, elders, and their wives for a lifetime of faithful ministry.
More info on next year’s Summit will be coming soon.
10
409
Jake Mentzel retweeted
"Five Types of Men Who Should Never Be Elders" - Men who look qualified for eldership but eventually become dangerous once they have it.
A session by @jacobmentzel at:
This quoted post is unavailable.
“Before you die, let the world see the best you that you knew how to become. Give that gift to your wife and kids and grandkids.”
From an interview I just did where we talked about godly ambition. Give it a listen: youtu.be/hkb7c_SNYPI?si=0EhA…
“The process is the punishment.”
I’m not the only one who has been warning about this kind of lawfare being deployed in the PCA, but these recent cases are exactly what many of us have been talking about.
Consider two examples: Burke Parsons and @ZacharyGarris.
I would be surprised if either suspension ultimately stands if appealed all the way through the process. But that is exactly the problem.
The process is long. In the meantime, these men are suspended from office. They are sidelined from pastoral ministry. Their churches are disrupted. Their people are left without their shepherd. Even if the suspension is eventually overturned, the process itself becomes the punishment.
That creates a dangerous incentive structure. Men can use the courts of the church to temporarily remove pastors over charges they likely know will not hold up under final review. The accusations are often tied to elastic applications of ninth commandment violations, claims of “harshness,” or other highly subjective standards.
Take Garris. He was suspended for poking fun at Dr. Anthony Bradley by saying there are some things so complex that even a PhD cannot understand them. Frankly, that is funny. Dr. Bradley regularly invokes his credentials in ways that invite that kind of jab. To have a church lose its pastor, even temporarily, over something like that is absurd.
This kind of judicial maneuvering does real damage.
It chills ordinary pastoral speech. It rewards strategic accusations. It destabilizes local churches. And it sends a clear message to younger men: enter this denomination, and you may find yourself sidelined for months over charges that will eventually be overturned.
If the older conservatives in the PCA do not step up and use their authority to stop this sort of procedural abuse, younger men are going to ask a very reasonable question:
Why would I come into, or remain in, a denomination where the process itself can be weaponized against faithful pastors?
This is not mainly about whether these particular men win on appeal.
It is about whether constitutional process in the PCA will be used to secure justice or to exercise ideological control by other means.
#SavethePCA
Jake Mentzel retweeted
The rise of the “church planter” can be explained by this.
Most churches are managerial. Many men who aspire to lead have no future in these churches.
Therefore, they start a new church where it’s success or failure is very much dependent on his charisma and leadership.
This quoted post is unavailable.
Jake Mentzel retweeted
I'm not a charismatic. You're just a hyper-cessationist.
Why the popular, hard-line/hyper-cessationism doesn’t do justice to the Reformed tradition.
***Primary sources:
Puritan John Trapp: “Actually, supernatural dreams are sent to people by God and his angels, and they are done so either to comfort us, as in Matt 2:19, or to chasten us, as in Job 7:13-14. And God usually repeats them until they are regarded.”
Vermigli: “a good and lawful attention to dreams is not to be forbidden. The godly are permitted to pray that they may be instructed even in their dreams.”
John Owen: “To say God does not or may not send his angels to any of his saints, to communicate his mind to them as to some particulars of their duty according to his word or to foreshadow to them his own approaching work, seems to unwarrantably limit the Holy One of Israel.” Exposition on the Book of Hebrews
John Calvin: “Still, I do not deny that the Lord has sometimes at a later period raised up apostles, or evangelists in their place, as has happened in our own day.” Commentary on 1 Cor. 12:28
William Bridge, Westminster divine: “But, you will say, may not God speak by extraordinary visions and revelations, in these days of ours? Yes, without all doubt he may: God is not to be limited, he may speak in what way he pleases.” The Works of the Rev. Bridge, vol. 1
Richard Baxter: “It is possible that God may make new Revelations to particular persons about their duties, events, or matters of fact, in subordination to the Scripture, either by inspiration, vision, apparition or voice.” Christian Directory
Samuel Rutherford: “There is a revelation of some particular men, who have foretold things to come, even since the ceasing of the Canon, as John Huss, Wycliffe, Luther, have foretold things to come and they certainly fell out, and in our nation of Scotland, M. George Wishart and John Knox.”
“Mr. Flavel replied, That he expected much trouble because of his dream the night before, adding, that when he had such representations made to him in his sleep, they seldom or never failed. Accordingly they were overtaken by a dreadful tempest.” The Life of John Flavel
Luther: “I do, indeed, have dreams from time to time, which move me somewhat....” Commentary on Gen 37:10
Also Luther: “The Spirit and the gifts are ours through Him Who with us sideth.”
“Increase Mather did no less than three Times as the Year, 1678, was coming on, very Publickly Declare, That he was verily Perswaded, a very Mortal Disease would shortly break in, and the Slain of the Lord would be many. Some of his Friends were troubled at him for it. But when the Year 1678. was come on, we saw the Mortal Disease. The Small-Pox broke in.“ Cotton Mather, Parentator
George Gillespie: John Knox, John Welsh, and others were “holy prophets receiving extraordinary revelations from God, and foretelling strange & remarkable things, which did accordingly come to pass punctually.” Works, vol. 2
etc. etc.
****Secondary sources:
“Some of the later ‘cessationist’ ideas should not be read back into the Reformation era. While the Reformers were quite clearly not modern charismatics, they were also not so suspicious of the supernatural.” Nick Needham, 2000 Years of Christ's Power
“Personal informative revelation…was the standard Puritan view, as I have observed it—they weren’t cessationists in the Richard Gaffin sense.” J.I. Packer
“Without a doubt, the Westminster Confession of Faith teaches cessationism, but it is a cessationism which requires considerable nuance and allows for supernatural surprises so long as they are working with and through the Word of God.” Kevin DeYoung
“The divines did not intend to deny that God could still speak through special providences that might involve dreams or the ministry of angels, for example, but such revelation was always to be considered ‘mediate.’ Garnet Howard Milne
“However, many of the authors of the WCF accepted that “prophecy” continued in their time, and a number of them apparently believed that disclosure of God’s will through dreams, visions, and angelic communication remained possible.” Garnet Howard Milne
"Where the contemporary continuationist claims that God may still reveal hidden and future events to the church, he or she stands in line with Reformed orthodoxy as represented at the Westminster Assembly. Where the modern cessationist denies any God-given ability to discern such matters, he or she is at odds with the pneumatology and the doctrine of Scripture of the Westminster Assembly." Milne
"The strict cessationist perspective of Warfield and others is a limited perspective on what the reformers and their descendants believed and practiced. If Knox, the Scottish Presbyterians, and the Covenanters were living today in the same manner that they did in the 1500s and 1600s, we would be forced to classify them more with the continuationists than the cessationists.” Dean Smith, Westminster Theological Journal
“The Reformed tradition repeatedly stress the completeness and sufficiency of Scripture. They show an appreciation for discursive processes for deriving conclusions from Scripture. Yet we also find testimony to extraordinary works of the Spirit of a nondiscursive kind.” Vern Poythress
etc. etc.
****Conclusion:
Popular treatments of cessationism have swung to an extreme that the divines didn’t intend. The Reformers, Puritans, and Westminster Divines clearly believed that dreams, angelic visits & prophetic impulses/motions can still have a role in the ordinary lives of Christians. Popular treatments of cessationism rarely (never?) nuance this.
The Divines who gave us WCF 1.1 also wrote 5.3: “God, in his ordinary providence, maketh use of means, yet is free to work without, above, and against them, at his pleasure.”
Can the SEC beat non-SEC teams in anything? Wait wait wait I get it. They spend all season beating each other up that they don’t have any gas in the tank for the post season right? 😆😆😆
Or maybe it’s just the era of Big Ten supremacy.
1
2
238
When my kids turn 13, they get a fun trip of their choice with mom or dad.
Abe picked Spring Training in Arizona. So we spent a few days in Scottsdale.
His top three highlights:
1. Watching Cal Raleigh, J Rod, and Randy Arozarena take BP for 30 minutes while Ichiro shagged balls at second.
2. Blake Snell stopping to sign every kid’s ball — including his. (Still hate the Dodgers. Snell for life.)
3. Real Men with @PastorMark and the guys at Trinity Church.
When your Tuesday night men’s ministry cracks the top three Spring Training moments of a 13-year-old baseball addict, you’re doing something right.
Strong, masculine Kingdom culture. Open-handed. Hospitable. Just good men who love Jesus and build each other up.
6
438
This is the way.
BREAKING: 1st Detransitioner to Take a Medical-Malpractice Lawsuit to Trial Wins $2 Million Judgement
Fox Varian sued her Westchester, NY, area psychologist and plastic surgeon for the gender-transition mastectomy she got at 16.
I was the only reporter to attend the entire 3-week, historic trial. Subscribe to my Substack to receive an alert about the feature article I have coming out next week in a major publication out about the trial: benryan.substack.com. I cover pediatric gender medicine as a specialty on my Substack.
Sorry to just give just a teaser for now about the case! But I wanted to get the word out about the verdict promptly, the slower pace of feature-article publishing notwithstanding.
The entire case file was put under seal when the trial started (although I obtained all those documents before they was sealed), and all the transcripts from the trial are also under seal. The riveting trial was sparsely attended and there was only one other reporter at the trial; and he only attended for part of it and, as I observed, took few notes. So my own hundreds of pages of notes from the trial will likely remain the only way for the public to learn about the all finer details of what transpired, possibly ever (or until an appeal, should that happen).
In addition to my article coming out in the media outlet soon, I intend to write a lot about what I observed and learned on my Substack over the coming weeks. Stay tuned…
I’d love to be able to do something like this for my kids and/or grandkids.
I came up with an idea.
A “Legacy Loan.”
Parents could buy a home for their kids while they’re young, or build a tax-free housing fund, like a 529 plan but for real estate.
The home transfers when the kid marries or turns 30.
We have 529s for college.
Why not for housing?
3
1,182
Jake Mentzel retweeted
Calvin's spirit towards Luther: honor the Reformer, forgive the man, preserve the Gospel.
John Calvin's private letter to Heinrich Bullinger (November 25, 1544)
"I hear that Luther has at length broken forth in fierce invective, not so much against you as against the whole of us. On the present occasion, I dare scarce venture to ask you to keep silence, because it is neither just that innocent persons should thus be harassed, nor that they should be denied the opportunity of clearing themselves; neither, on the other hand, is it easy to determine whether it would be prudent for them to do so.
But of this I do earnestly desire to put you in mind, in the first place, that you would consider how eminent a man Luther is, and the excellent endowments wherewith he is gifted, with what strength of mind and resolute constancy, with how great skill, with what efficiency and power of doctrinal statement, he hath hitherto devoted his whole energy to overthrow the reign of Antichrist, and at the same time to diffuse far and near the doctrine of salvation.
Often have I been wont to declare, that even although he were to call me a devil, I should still not the less hold him in such honour that I must acknowledge him to be an illustrious servant of God.
But while he is endued with rare and excellent virtues, he labours at the same time under serious faults. Would that he had rather studied to curb this restless, uneasy temperament which is so apt to boil over in every direction.
I wish, moreover, that he had always bestowed the fruits of that vehemence of natural temperament upon the enemies of the truth, and that he had not flash his lightning sometimes also upon the servants of the Lord. Would that he had been more observant and careful in the acknowledgement of his own vices.
Flatterers have done him much mischief, since he is naturally too prone to be over-indulgent to himself.
It is our part, however, so to reprove whatsoever evil qualities may beset him, as that we may make some allowance for him at the same time on the score of these remarkable endowments with which he has been gifted.
This, therefore, I would beseech you to consider first of all, along with your colleagues, that you have to do with a most distinguished servant of Christ, to whom we are all of us largely indebted.
Besides, you will do yourselves no good by quarrelling, except that you may afford some sport to the wicked, so that they may triumph not so much over us as over the Evangel. If they see us rending each other asunder, they then give full credit to what we say, but when with one consent and with one voice we preach Christ, they avail themselves unwarrantably of our inherent weakness to cast reproach upon our faith.
I wish, therefore, that you would consider and reflect on these things rather than on what Luther has deserved by his violence, lest that happen to you which Paul threatens, that by biting and devouring one another, ye be consumed one of another.
Even should he have provoked us, we ought rather to decline the contest, than to increase the wound by the general shipwreck of the Church."























