
Writer, reader, music, arts & film fan. Rooted in education - lifelong teacher now a trustee, interested in most things. Own views here, + @mhamlin1.bsky.social
Nottingham
Joined March 2009
- Tweets12.7K
- Following751
- Followers610
- Likes70.4K
Mike Hamlin retweeted
This is disgusting.
One of the biggest welfare scroungers in the country, doesn't have a single disability except being a Tory.
But that doesn't affect her, only us who have to put up with her scrounging and her screams of 'benefit cheats'.
Yes we know, it's you.
Effort without equal reward - a new study of British Muslims by the Runnymede Trust shows a very different picture to that pushed by the far right.
🚨 The national data paint a very different picture of British Muslims from the one pushed by the far right.
Young Muslims are more likely to get degrees than peers from similar backgrounds, despite growing up far poorer. Yet they earn less for the same qualifications and pay more for worse housing. The Muslim share of London is less than half what the public imagines.
Those are the findings of a new @RunnymedeTrust report, “Systemic and Silent”, and recent KCL polling.
Here are the clearest figures, with the caveats.
Start with education. Young Muslims in the national Next Steps study grew up far poorer than their peers. 64.6% had a main parent with no qualifications, against 15.5% of non-Muslims. In 22.1% of their households, the household’s representative had never worked or was long-term unemployed, against 2.9%.
Yet by the age of 32, after accounting for background, Muslims had more than double the odds of holding a degree (2.44 times). As teenagers they also had fewer recorded risk factors, on an index covering truancy, smoking and drinking.
So when you’re told Muslims “don’t value education” or “won’t integrate”, the national data point firmly the other way.
The problems start after that. Muslim graduates were less likely to get a first: 19.7% against 29.3% in 2024/25, and there was a gap in every year of the data. The report is clear that this figure hasn’t been adjusted for prior grades or background. After accounting for gender, Muslim graduates earned about £45/week less.
Across the workforce, median hourly pay was £15.25 for Muslims and £17.26 for non-Muslims. Comparing people of similar age, gender, region and sector, the gap was still 8.1%.
Housing shows the same pattern. Muslims were twice as likely to live in households spending 30% or more of their income on housing (18% against 9%). The 2021 Census found them nearly four times as likely to live in overcrowded homes.
We often hear that Muslims are a drain on the country or get special treatment. Earning less for the same qualifications while paying more for worse housing hardly looks like favouritism.
The Muslim employment rate is lower: 51.4% against 70.9% in the 2021 Census. Part of the reason is that the Muslim population is much younger and far more likely to be in full-time education (12.9% against 2.2% in the Annual Population Survey). Muslims in work are slightly more likely than others to be in public administration, education and health, at 36% against 34.8%. Many work in our schools, hospitals and public services.
Then there’s the “takeover” claim. Muslims are 15% of London’s population. A KCL study with YouGov found the public’s median guess was 35%. Among Reform UK supporters it was 50%: they think half the capital was Muslim!
Yet the same public guessed London’s Christian population almost exactly (40% against a true 41%). The overestimate is specific to Muslims.
And those who thought 70% or more of Londoners were Muslim were almost twice as likely as the public overall to mistakenly believe London has Sharia-run “no-go” areas (62% against 34%).
We all know which media they get information from and which politicians they listen to.
Some caveats. The Runnymede report was funded by Islamic Relief UK, but its core figures come from public datasets anyone can check: the Annual Population Survey, Understanding Society, Next Steps, HESA and the Census.
It compares Muslims with non-Muslims as a whole, so it can’t fully separate religion from ethnicity, migration or class; half of the Muslims in the APS sample were born abroad.
And it says nothing about crime or terrorism, so it shouldn’t be stretched to settle those debates.
On the questions it does answer, though, the picture is clear: effort without equal reward. Britain prides itself on fair play. Equal qualifications should bring equal pay, and families who do everything asked of them shouldn’t be nearly four times as likely to end up in overcrowded homes.
runnymedetrust.org/publicati…
Mike Hamlin retweeted
This is brilliant by @ameliagentleman, who decided to cover another rape case down the road, alongside Brand’s packed out trial
theguardian.com/news/2026/no…
Mike Hamlin retweeted
Worth reading this assessment of the Huang-Nvidia-Trump-CIA & the US🇺🇸 anti-China hawk machinations. Conclusion: they got rid of the #Nvidia President-CEO, but 🇨🇳China's Huawei & its tech advances continue.
THINK ABOUT IT.
- Bill Gates had lots of illicit girlfriends—no problem.
- Elon Musk has multiple children with multiple women—no problem.
- Dario Amodei dated a Chinese woman, Jade Wang, before marrying Cami Clark, who pitched a pornography business to none other than Jeffrey Epstein—no problem.
- But Jensen Huang commits old-fashioned infidelity—and this is such a big problem that he has to resign?
Doesn’t make sense.
Here’s the real story.
.
CHAPTER ONE: BIDEN’S CHIP WAR
Jensen Huang of Nvidia was puzzled. It was 2022, and his video-graphics processors had become globally popular as the heart of high-end computing across the planet.
But that autumn, Biden violated the World Trade Organization’s most fundamental principles. He ordered the world’s makers of advanced semiconductor chips and chipmaking equipment (in the Netherlands, Taiwan and Japan) to stop sales to China.
Biden’s administration implied that the chips were for China’s military gear, but this was a lie. The US’s own security establishment admitted that 99.9 per cent were used for civilian purposes, like medical technology and AI computing.
Huang was dismayed. He could no longer sell Nvidia’s A100 and H100 to China.
.
CHAPTER TWO: SOLVING A PROBLEM
Jensen Huang was a problem-solver. In February of 2024, Nvidia launched the H20, a made-for-China AI chip less powerful than its US-only top model.
That way he could keep the US government happy but also have something to sell to the Chinese.
Not everyone in the US was happy about this, and export rules fluctuated.
.
CHAPTER THREE: THE DEEPSEEK MOMENT
In January 2025, a nerdy young man from the Chinese finance industry announced that his firm Deepseek had quickly and cheaply created a high-efficiency open-weight AI.
The implication was huge: the Chinese were finding ways to develop top level AI functionality without massive clusters of top-tier Nvidia GPUs.
Jensen Huang knew he had to respond urgently to keep his place in the China market. He flew to meet trade officials in Beijing in the middle of April and vowed to make "every effort" to serve the Chinese.
The US anti-China hawks had been quietly mobilizing—and made an announcement. In April of 2025, the US banned all export of Jensen Huang’s H20s to China.
Unbelievable! The Nvidia CEO was furious. "Anybody who thought that one chess move to ban China from H20s would cut off their AI ability is deeply uninformed," Huang told an interviewer at a trade meeting in Taipei.
.
CHAPTER FOUR: HUANG’S SPECIAL SKILL
Then came some rare good news. The Nvidia CEO started lobbying Trump behind the scenes. Huang was a master negotiator – and his efforts proved successful.
In the middle of July, 2025, Huang was back in China—his third trip in 12 months.
Huang appeared without his signature black leather jacket. Instead, he wore a traditional Chinese tang suit, and made some of his speech in Mandarin.
Washington had cleared the way for Nvidia to export the H20 to China, he said. We’re back!
Trump had demanded a cash cut of H20 sales in return for approving the exports—US government policy appeared to be literally for sale.
.
CHAPTER FIVE: SPOOKS WERE NOT HAPPY
Huang was moving chips to China again, and the anti-China hawks in the US government were unhappy—and so were the spooks.
There’s a widespread tendency to visualize the US intelligence community as right-leaning hard men, Trumpites in black suits.
This was the opposite of the truth. The CIA leadership greatly preferred the simple, blanket negativity towards “the enemy” characteristic of the Democratic Party. With Russians, Chinese, and North Koreans portrayed as cartoon villains, black ops were justifiable.
But for all his bluster, Trump had a propensity towards treating the leaders of Russia, China and even North Korea, as actual humans who could be negotiated with.
This transactional approach was enormously problematic for the CIA, which needed cartoon villains to justify their annual budget of more than US$15 billion.
And Trump’s habit of parachuting unsuitable new leaders in to command the intelligence community—such as the widely disliked Mike Pompeo—crystalized the negativity, as CIA chroniclers have written.
.
CHAPTER SIX: A TWIST IN THE TALE
Jensen Huang’s celebrations were short-lived. In an unexpected twist, China in September 2025 said it did not want Nvidia chips and would no longer buy them.
- US$15 billion in sales projections vanished.
- Nvidia had to write off a reported $5.5 billion in inventory losses.
- The company had now completely lost access to China's AI market, estimated at US$50 billion.
- And hard evidence was emerging that Chinese companies were building alternatives even for CUDA (a unique element in Nvidia chips).
Huang wanted more positivity from the US. Nvidia was a US firm, and it went from having a 95% market share in China to 0%. “I can’t imagine any policymaker thinking that that’s a good idea,” he told reporters.
.
CHAPTER SEVEN: AGAIN, HE SOLVES THE PROBLEM
But Huang’s extraordinary skill in dealing with Trump paid off again, and by mid-2026, the Nvidia business found a complex equilibrium had emerged in its China business.
Huang had (in December 2025) persuaded the US President to allow Nvidia to sell even the high-powered H200 chip to China, as long as the US government got 25% of the take. So a range of Nvidia chips could again be sold in China.
- Other Nvidia chips were arriving in China via the black market.
- There were suspicions that companies in Singapore and Malaysia, such as Megaspeed, were flouting export restrictions, also delivering chips.
- Some Nvidia chips were stuck in Hong Kong, trapped by the confusing, ever-changing rules, but were expected to be released eventually.
- On the downside (from Huang’s point of view), new China-origin chips, notably Huawei’s Ascend 950, were catching up with advanced capabilities that mimicked those of Nvidia.
In short, China was back in the game.
.
CHAPTER EIGHT: TAKING HIM DOWN
Something had to be done. China had to be dealt with. But first, Huang had to be taken down.
The US anti-China hawks saw Huang’s success in making deals with Trump as a key part of the problem. It was an element which had to be surgically removed.
The CIA and their partners in the western mainstream media sprang into action.
In October 2026, the US intelligence community told New York Times reporters that there were suspicions that Huang’s mistress, Alice Huang Le, was a Chinese spy.
It provided no evidence.
The allegation was plainly ridiculous—the flow of legitimate and illegitimate chips across the border was no secret, and the idea that discussions about the detailed minutiae of nano-level semiconductor engineering could be exchanged during pillow talk was ridiculous, even comedic.
But when the US intelligence community and the mainstream media join forces, they’re virtually invincible.
At this moment in the process, the complicit media are playing its role. A typical headline was that in the Economist yesterday:
“Jensen Huang must resign.”
.
EPILOGUE
Jensen Huang resigned.
Trump has been weakened.
The world’s public has been fooled with the “honeypot” story.
China’s Huawei is pressing ahead—with new, powerful versions of its Ascend chips slated to come out in 2027 and 2028.
.
.
Mike Hamlin retweeted
In 2025, Ofwat blocked £4m of bonuses for water company CEOs.
The year before, those companies paid their CEOs >£24m and their shareholders £1.2bn.
Banning bonuses alone won't stop the money from leaking out of our water system. Public ownership will.
theguardian.com/business/202…
Mike Hamlin retweeted
Serious questions for the BBC - this is not a trivial issue but how the national broadcaster covered a genocide
The BBC Israel Would Say Files. The full results are in for both broadcast and articles.
Analysis of 267 broadcast interviews between October 2023 and October 2026:
- BBC presenters put Israel's case, in Israel's name, to guests criticising Israel's conduct in Gaza in 252 separate interviews.
- They put the Palestinian case, in its name, to guests defending Israel's conduct in 15.
- To better portray this disparity, our compilation of the BBC defending Israel in their own words now runs at 48 mins 12 secs. Our compilation of the BBC defending Palestinians in their own words runs at 2 mins 38 secs.
- The plainest form, “Israel would say”, was put to critics in 75 interviews. “Palestinians [or any Palestinian group] would say” was put to defenders in 4.
- 10 of the 15 Palestinian cases came in the first six weeks after 7 October 2023, and 5 in the three years after. Presenters were still putting Israel's case to critics in 2026.
- The above point suggests an editorial shift to stop conveying what Palestinians are saying, but to continue conveying what "Israel would say".
Analysis of 1,618 written articles, from October 2023 to October 2026:
- When an article reported criticism of Israel's conduct in Gaza, the BBC added Israel's position 49% of the time (1,771 of 3,648 claims).
- When an article reported Israel's claims, the BBC added a Palestinian or UN position 38% of the time (914 of 2,431). A Palestinian position alone: 25%.
- Put the two official sides side by side. When the authorities in Gaza made a claim against Israel, the BBC added Israel's position 58% of the time (334 of 575). When Israel's government or army made a claim, the BBC added a Palestinian or UN position 39% of the time (855 of 2,165).
- Article by article: 71% of the articles reporting criticism of Israel gave Israel's position at least once. 53% of the articles reporting Israel's claims gave a Palestinian or UN position.
- In other words, in almost half of the articles where Israel makes a claim, it goes completely uncontested.
The full report, including every single broadcast and article in the corpus, can be found here, completely free of charge: newscord.org/editorials/bbc-…
Mike Hamlin retweeted
Pity no frontline reporting from Gaza. A great reporter like Beale in Gaza could change hearts and minds even of cowardly politicians. Would BBC like to remind us why it has not challenged day in day out Israel’s illegal ban on foreign press entry to Gaza?
Excellent from @bealejonathan & BBC team. Quality frontline reporting based on committed editorial investment. Not the same as podcast polemic.
A lasting tribute…….
Stuart Holland, 1940-2026
Stuart was a great friend of the Russell Foundation and we are proud to publish his books …
spokesmanbooks.org/stuart-ho…
1
32
Mike Hamlin retweeted
This crook's ethical meter is so broken, he's convinced himself that 40,000 stock trades worth billions is no big deal for a President who has insider info.
Meanwhile:
Biden - 0 trades
Obama - 0 trades
Bush - 0 trades
Clinton - 0 trades
Mike Hamlin retweeted
Sensible, moderate politics for the common good.
Mike Hamlin retweeted
This is why Jon Ossoff won in a landslide in Georgia. He took the gloves off and didn’t pussyfoot around the truth.
Putting aside the fact I wrote about what he said here when many were silent, he’s making the case for why Democrats MUST now hold these monsters accountable.
This isn’t about retribution, it’s about ensuring what Trump and his puppet masters have done NEVER happens again THAT is what the American people voted for.
Of course legislation is a priority it was a priority they didn’t address in 2024, when they failed hard pressed American families who were screaming for help, while they were chasing upper middle class voters who were NEVER going to vote for them.
Then, when they were punished for it at the ballot box, they blamed the American people for rejecting them, and then stayed silent for almost a year while Trump dismantled democracy and tore down the government.
If Democratic leadership can’t walk and chew gum at the same time, then step the fuck aside and let someone who can deliver justice to the American people get the job done. I’d go even further and suggest they step down anyway, because they don’t have the integrity or the trust required for this mission critical moment.
This is NOT the time for more of the same old same old, and that’s what this current leadership represents I’m afraid. It’s why they went into this election with popularity ratings underwater.
This landslide was NOT about a ringing endorsement of the Democratic Party, it was a repudiation of a broken political system.
It’s time for a PEOPLE FIRST REVOLUTION. This is a once in a generation opportunity to deliver transformative change. GET IT DONE.
Oh and before I finish, why does Hakeem Jeffries put full stops in the most odd places in his totally irritating sentences? An orator he is not I’m afraid, yet in a comedic twist of irony, he’s about to become Speaker of the House. Democrats can and MUST do better.
They need to listen and READ THE ROOM, otherwise 2028 will be a repeat of 2024. It’s hard to hear I know, but sometimes the truth hurts and someone has to say it.
🎥 TikTok - vm.tiktok.com/ZGdXhb6VE/
Mike Hamlin retweeted
Rapists of a feather...
Every MAGAt in this picture has been accused, indicted, convicted of, or found civilly liable for sex crimes. Three are currently in jail.
Andrew Tate @Cobratate - Indicted/Charged with multiple counts or rape and human trafficking
Russell Brand @rustyrockets - Convicted of Rape
Donald Trump @DonaldTrump - Civilly Liable / A federal Judge stated he raped E. Jean Caroll
Mike Tyson @MikeTyson - Convicted of Rape
Conor McGregor @TheNotoriousMMA - Civilly liable for Sexual Assault
Lawrence Taylor @LT_56 - Registered Sex Offender. Arrest for sex with a minor.
Tristan Tate @TateTheTalisman - Indicted/Charged with multiple counts or rape and human trafficking
Mike Hamlin retweeted
I had running battles with this vile shit
He led the protest against landing migrants in Portsmouth
Caused our RNLI station to close
Besieged a hotel mistaking a Pakistan cricket team for migrants
Losing us our City of Culture bid
& now this 👇
Mike Hamlin retweeted
The indomitable girl who captured him was waiting for him thirty years later
On September 21, 1965, a 17-year-old Vietnamese girl named Nguyễn Thị Kim Lai was photographed escorting an enormous American airman through the countryside. His hands were tied behind his back. His head was bowed. She was carrying a rifle.
His name was William Andrew Robinson. He was 22, a helicopter mechanic and flight engineer in the US Air Force. The previous day his helicopter had been shot down during a mission to rescue another American airman.
Kim Lai was tiny. She weighed 37 kilograms. She had only finished seventh grade before joining the local militia. Her home province, Hà Tĩnh, was being bombed relentlessly by American aircraft.
According to her recollection, she discovered Robinson hiding among the rocks in a forest. Frightened by his enormous size, she fired three warning shots. He surrendered. Other militia members arrived and tied his hands.
A photographer named Phan Thoan captured the extraordinary contrast between the two.
The photograph became famous throughout Vietnam. It appeared on postage stamps. A celebrated Vietnamese poet wrote a poem about it. The image travelled around the world, becoming a symbol of a small country resisting a superpower.
Robinson was taken to prison.
He spent 2,703 days in captivity. Seven years, four months and twenty-three days. Much of it in isolation, enduring brutal conditions and torture. He was finally released on February 12, 1973.
Kim Lai became a nurse. She married, had three children and eventually became a grandmother.
Thirty years after their first encounter, in September 1995, she was playing with her grandchildren at a neighbour's house when someone came to tell her that foreigners were looking for her.
She returned home.
Standing there was William Andrew Robinson.
He had come back to Vietnam with a Japanese documentary crew. He had apparently wanted to find her for years but had never been able to afford the journey.
She recognised him immediately.
According to her recollection, he approached and embraced her before she could greet him.
They talked about their lives. Their families. Everything that had happened since those few minutes in a Vietnamese forest.
They even returned to the place where he had been captured.
Robinson reportedly expressed the hope that there would never be another photograph like theirs.
There is another photograph of them, taken during that reunion.
She is looking up at him. Smiling. He is standing beside her, still towering over her. No handcuffs. No rifle.
With no US government throwing away the youth of its own citizens to forcefully decide the future of Vietnam both can stand tall side by side.
Mike Hamlin retweeted
Chevron, Exxon and Shell made over $36 billion in profit this quarter.
As I told @NPR, the worst of times for most of us are the best of times for the oil companies.
That’s why we need a permanent windfall tax.
🔗 Read more at the link below.
Mike Hamlin retweeted
This is what global subservience to Trump has brought us to. Robust opposition from Europe to his disastrous course is way overdue. Why do UK and France sit on the Security Council if not to block madness like this?
Under pressure from Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu, the Trump administration may be within days of launching a nuclear strike on Iran. The target would be Pickax Mountain in central Iran, where Israeli intelligence claims the Iranian government has restarted its nuclear enrichment program. No conventional weapon in the American arsenal can penetrate 300 feet of solid granite to destroy the tunnels where enrichment is supposedly taking place. The only military option is a nuclear strike. Netanyahu has been pushing hard for one. “Bibi calls Trump about it every day,” says an informed observer.
Netanyahu is cornered and desperate. After last week’s election results, he can’t form a government unless Trump intervenes directly in Israeli politics and brokers a deal with other parties that gives Netanyahu 61 seats in the Knesset. Otherwise, he is out as prime minister and on his way to ignominy, investigations and possibly jail. Netanyahu must stay close to Trump. He needs this war.
To that end, he’s applied maximum pressure to his closest allies in the administration, including Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth and CENTCOM commander Brad Cooper. Both oppose a negotiated settlement to the war they’ve so grievously mismanaged; both are pushing to restart major combat operations. Secretary of State Marco Rubio and CIA director John Ratcliffe are also following Netanyahu’s lead, as are leaders of the Democratic Party. In a recent meeting on the subject, former president Barack Obama said he opposes the current Iran peace deal being drafted in Doha.
The rest of America’s longtime allies in the Middle East are terrified by the prospect of more war. On September 27th, Netanyahu flew secretly to Abu Dhabi to enlist the UAE in his lobbying effort for a final attack on Iran. The Emiratis refused. After eight months of conflict, Gulf economies are teetering. So are global energy and fertilizer markets. They won’t recover soon. Globally, there are a total of about 850 supertankers used to transport oil from producers to the rest of the world. In October alone, 11 of them were badly damaged in Hormuz. At this pace, a global depression is imminent. A nuclear strike would radically accelerate the destruction. Fallout from a ground explosion at Pickax Mountain would contaminate the Persian Gulf, poisoning the water supply for 100 million people.
And those are just some of the immediate consequences for the region. The rest of the world is every bit as exposed. No country other than the United States has ever used a nuclear weapon in war. Some would like to. An American nuclear attack on Iran would set a new precedent. The Russians have already told at least two other governments that an American nuclear strike on Iran would free them to use nuclear weapons against Ukraine. Pakistan and India would be tempted to do the same against each other, as would North Korea against Seoul. After the first nuclear strike, World War Three is inevitable. That war would be short and final.
We’ve been sleepwalking toward this moment for months. Since February, the administration has quietly rewritten America’s nuclear doctrine to make first use of so-called “battlefield nukes” easier and therefore more likely. No one in Washington in either party seems bothered by this. Now we’re on the brink of it.
Close observers say Trump is likely to decide by next weekend whether or not to use nuclear weapons. That would be November 7, six days from now. To his credit, he’s hesitating. At the moment, Trump is listening to his vice president, JD Vance, and to his envoy and friend Steve Witkoff, both of whom argue a deal with Iran can be made.
They’re right, though it won’t be simple. The Iranians are famously frustrating to negotiate with under any circumstances, and elements of that government have become more radical since Ayatollah Ali Khamenei and his family were killed in February. After decades of isolation, even relatively moderate Iranian leaders seem confused by how decisions are made in the West. (There is a widespread belief in Tehran, for example, that the United States government controls Israel.) But overall, people who have spoken to decision-makers in Iran say there is consensus there that more war is bad for everyone and a deal is worth making.
One group that hasn’t been consulted so far is the global population — the hundreds of millions of people who will be killed along with their children if Trump is pushed by Netanyahu into launching a nuclear strike next week. Now would be the time for them to speak up.
On the evidence of his own words, it is fair to call Rupert Lowe an unapologetic racist. He has told us, repeatedly, that he really doesn’t care…….
🧵
Rupert Lowe is an unapologetic racist.
His post below replies to Andy Burnham, who wrote in the Guardian the evening before that he was “open” to calls for a formal state apology for the slave trade, while ruling out reparations. Lowe was free to oppose that, and others did.
Tory leader Kemi Badenoch objected the same weekend, saying there was “no reason British taxpayers today should be held financially responsible for things that happened generations before any of us were born.” Her quoted objection rests on taxpayers and historical distance.
Lowe’s is framed around race, and is very different. In just 41 words it casts the injured nation as white, recasts the acknowledgement of slavery as an attack on white people, and essentially tells Caribbean and African people, as groups, to fuck off.
Below, I show how his rhetoric does that, and why the charge of racism rests on the words themselves.
Three tools from Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA) help here. The first is Teun van Dijk’s ideological square.
Ideological talk, van Dijk argues, polarises in four moves: it emphasises OUR good qualities and THEIR bad ones, and plays down OUR bad qualities and THEIR good ones.
The second is also van Dijk’s. In his work on the denial of racism, he identifies reversal as one of its strongest forms. The in-group is recast as the real victim of prejudice, so that talk of racism against the majority displaces talk of racism by it.
The third comes from Martin Reisigl and Ruth Wodak’s discourse-historical approach.
They separate referential strategies (which are how a text names and groups people), from predicational strategies (which are the qualities it attaches to them). Asking who is named, and what they are called, shows where a text draws its boundaries. In Lowe’s post, the boundary is race.
The post opens with mock agreement. “I agree. The British establishment should apologise over slavery” echoes Burnham, and the next two words, “To us”, turn him round. The apology is still owed, but the injured party has changed.
Who is “us”? Lowe does not say directly, but the next sentence answers for him. What the establishment has allowed is “anti-white”, so the British people owed an apology are defined by being white. This is the central referential move in the post, and its consequence is easy to miss.
Britain has a large Black British population, many descended from people enslaved on British plantations in the Caribbean. Lowe never names them, but pairing “us” with “anti-white” builds an implicitly white national in-group.
The frame places Black Britons outside the injured party, and gives their claims on this history no standing in Lowe’s version of the debate.
“Anti-white” performs exactly the kind of reversal van Dijk identifies in the denial of racism. Nothing in Burnham’s article is framed in terms of white people. The debate concerns a state, its institutions and what they did. By calling it “anti-white”, Lowe turns a question about Britain’s conduct into an accusation of racism against white Britons. The enslaved vanish from the sentence, and white Britons take their place as the wronged party.
Lowe is not answering anything said about white people. The injury he names is that the debate exists at all. The question on the table was what, if anything, Britain owes for its part in slavery. Lowe swaps it for another, which might be paraphrased as: why should white Britons put up with being reminded?
The second question displaces the first, and the position of victim moves with it.
The remaining predicates reinforce the reversal. “Pathetic” presents acknowledgement as weakness.
Placed next to “anti-white”, “self-loathing” implies that white Britons who support an apology hate their own race.
“Bullshit” dismisses the whole subject as beneath argument.
In the terms of the ideological square, the in-group’s bad deeds are erased, and simply remembering them becomes the offence.
Continued...


































