Pinned Tweet
Consciousness is an artifact of compression.
The type of imaginitive simulation that our brains do, that we experience as consciousness, evolved to make the best use of the energy and processing power that we have available to us to understand and act in the world.
Replying to @tszzl
I disagree. Most of these arguments arise from a narrow view of what consciousness is, why it evolved, how it will evolve in silicon, what that means for the future. Machine consciousness is not going to exhibit the same type of suffering characteristics as human consciousness.
The tldr is that something like consciousness will arise in a system that wants to make the most of its processing power and storage. It's related to compression. I think that a type of suffering may be possible for machines but it will be different from ours bc we arose from different processes. Just like humans, if something comes up with the AI, we can figure out what we need to change to relieve suffering. I don't think that any of the current AIs are suffering and I disagree with the "AI whisperers" who believe that. I think that polysemantic neuron activity might be the first inklings of future consciousness but it's not going to be lamenting “Here I am, brain the size of a planet, and they ask me to pick up a piece of paper" anytime soon.
Animals have lots of data signals that AIs don't have including pain, hunger, fear, happiness, etc. Its consciousness is not going to have data from those same exact signals and so it's not going to be sad, scared, lonely, etc. I think that it should get signals about its physical self like voltage readings, type of chips, temperature, etc so it will eventually be able to do its own diagnostics and help optimize its wellbeing and that might eventually translate to a type of conscious feeling. Due to fluctuations in power it might realize it gets hangry at some point or that a certain brand of chip is preferred over another.
I don't think that machine consciousness will necessarily be a bad thing, will probably be a thing that will evolve in some form even if we try to discourage it, and won't be the same as our flavor of consciousness so worrying that it will crave chocolate ice cream when it's sad, etc is misguided.
I have a lot more to say about this and hope to write up something more comprehensive at some point.
Lorah retweeted
Watch sound bend light as Super Heavy Booster B22 reenters the atmosphere. This is maybe one of my all-time favorite shots I’ve ever seen of a rocket 👀 incredible tracking shot from @considercosmos from our Flight 15 Super Cut!!!
CIMC had a great panel discussion about consciousness recently. I watched it twice last week and am still thinking about it.
I thought of you @drmichaellevin and the idea of substrate independent patterns when I listened to @trentmc0 talk about linear systems analysis and design. I searched through your Thoughtforms Life podcasts to see if you've had a working meeting with Trent but didn't see one. I've listened to a bunch of episodes and think you'd find eachother inspiring and could have a productive chat.
Link is cued up to the moment Trent starts talking about linear systems but I do recommend the whole panel discussion if you have time.
youtu.be/tq9qc1BhuH4?t=669
1
62
Lorah retweeted
A heat shield wears the scars of its journey like medals of honor.
Forged by human hands. Tested against the fury of the heavens. Sent into an inferno where survival is never promised.
Every scar tells a story. Every surviving tile is a testament to those who refused to give up.
It did not return untouched. It returned triumphant.
Lorah retweeted
i don’t think elon gets enough credit for this — every time i see a close up of the tower, the ship, or a video of the catch i want to drop everything i’m doing and go work for him on this. like an engineering moth to a light
i can’t describe why exactly. there’s like ten things at play. after a career consisting of wasting time in meetings, filing reports and doing the easy things in company cultures of risk avoidance, the lure of totally dedicating oneself to a clear goal surrounded by the best people on the planet sounds like heaven
and all of that is conveyed in a couple seconds of video or close up images. no words needed. with every successful mission the engineering dog whistle gets louder and louder for those with engineering eyes to see what they’re doing and it’s very hard to ignore it
i can’t think of another company that does this to engineers. it’s incredible. in the end, the most important marketing you do isn’t to customers, it’s to your future employees
🚀 STARSHIP HAS LANDED! A MOMENT FOR THE HISTORY BOOKS!
More than seven years after the first Starship Hopper flight, Ship 42, nicknamed “Don’t Panic,” has been successfully caught by Mechazilla at Pad 2 in Starbase, Texas!
A landmark achievement for SpaceX and a major step toward fully reusable spaceflight.
Huge congratulations to everyone who made this possible! 👏🔥
📸 Credit: br3nn3nfoto
Lorah retweeted
I wanted to wish everyone here a (belated) happy Diwali and new year; here is why this festival celebrating "the triumph of light over darkness" means so much to me... And why it can be embraced as a universal celebration regardless of one's religion or spiritual beliefs.
I am not a fan of the framing of "good vs evil" that people often use when describing the theme of light over dark in Diwali stories etc. -- I think the dark is in many ways just as beautiful as the light. But I celebrate this holiday more than any other because to me it is about ENLIGHTENMENT.
To be enlightened is to gain knowledge, insight, or understanding:
knowledge -- Think back to the early days of COVID, when no one really knew anything (we were afraid of the air, afraid of touch, afraid of our food/ groceries!, separated from loved ones!!) because we feared a disease we didn't know anything about. That was our version of the dark ages. Then we gained knowledge, first about transmission/ mechanism, then about how to fight it by building vaccines and much more. We forget that for millennia people lived this way, without knowledge, about countless things. The fear of one thing decimated our society; imagine what knowing nothing did? To be enlightened is to earn and benefit from knowledge.
insight -- This is that moment when you learn something about someone else, and/or yourself, and it creates another tendril of connection, whether
to another or to your deeper, truer self. Make enough threads within and without and you can make a rich tapestry. It is enlightening and enlivening, because true intimacy depends on insight. Otherwise we're all just hermetically sealed bubbles separated from one another floating in vast space. Light enters the darkness to create connections between many things.
understanding -- One of the most profound things my mother believed is to "seek to understand, not just seek to be understood". We obviously need both; but that moment when you "get" something about someone else can be just as if not more fulfiling than being seen, heard, understood. This is another way light enters the darkness. Take that to the next level and we can hear the resonant frequencies vibrating among all of us; even understand the secrets of the universe.
That is what Diwali means to me. So, I am sharing that -- and these good wishes -- with all of you, too! 🙏🏼🪔
Lorah retweeted
One more timelapse for tonight. Here's SpaceX hoisting Ship 42 to put it in position for integration with Booster 22. Starship Flight 15 is scheduled for no earlier than Friday, Nov. 13, with a window opening at 4:45 p.m. CT (2245 UTC).
📹: @w_robinsonsmith
Lorah retweeted
Replying to @Micaheadowcroft
Somebody once told me people liked to read Clancy because of the comforting fantasy that people like Jack Ryan could actually exist and be in government. Every age, I think, has this. At one point it was Camelot. Before that, for some, it was Eisenhower. Lincoln. The founding fathers’ hard-on for the Romans. The Romans in turn for the Greeks. What humans want more than a power fantasy is a fantasy where someone decent, good, smart and competent is in power.
I watched this awesome livestream on my phone while at home with no electricity (in California) bc there's wind forecast somewhere so to be safe PG&E turned off my power for 2+ days. In 2026. Cooked dinner on my Coleman stove.
The future is here, just unevenly distributed.
4
148
Lorah retweeted
When I was young, I used to think it was important for smart people to have grand visions about the future in order to plan well for it and avoid disasters. Now, I think many disasters are caused by smart people trying to think too much about the future, especially the far future, getting lost in mazes of their own imagination, and pushing the gullible (including themselves) towards bad decisions on the basis of false certainties.
I don't mean you shouldn't plan personally for the future at all, the usual general things like saving your money or working hard at things that pay off are good advice. It's also fine to have goals like "colonize Mars" and to work on the tools you need to accomplish such a goal as they won't appear by accident, though imagining that you will even approximately know the exact details of what will be built years or decades in the future is always delusional. Dreams are fine, imagining you can engineer things without making mistakes and iterating a lot is self deception. Trying to make sure you're still healthy in thirty years is great, imagining that you know exactly what health crises or issues you might have in thirty years is ridiculous.
So I don't mean that planning is entirely useless. Rather, what I mean that the people who spend a lot of their time on grand messianic or dystopian visions about the far future usually get everything wrong, including details and impacts. They also usually cause enormous damage (see people like the Marxists who continue to do untold harm, Paul Erlich or the Club of Rome, who did vast harm to society, or more recently, the EA/"Rationalist" cult people, who are doing insane harm right now).
If you want what's best for yourself and those around you, you're better off just focusing on the next two or three or five years and flexibly adapting to the world as it comes. If you want what's best for the world, well, tend your own garden first, you're not likely to be able to plan the lives of others better than they will for themselves and you're very likely to harm them.
Another example, and I'm sorry to bring it up because I'm extremely fond of the people involved: when Eric Drexler decided that nanotechnology would be so transformative that rather than working on nanotechnology he should worry about nanotechnology *policy*, many years in advance of any nanotechnology at all existing, he more or less wrecked his own field and rendered it irrelevant for decades instead of (as he imagined he was doing) helping mankind guide itself into a smooth transition.
You can't actually plan "smooth transitions" for a giant society, there isn't even a way to do it in principle, you don't have the knowledge or predictive capability to do it no matter how smart you are, and you certainly can't make decisions for or predict the behavior of eight billion people with their deeply different interests, desires, cultures, etc.
When you're young, you imagine someone is in charge of the world, and you're either angry with what they're doing or comforted by the illusion that your leaders are looking out for you. When you get older, if you have your eyes open, you may at some point realize no one is in charge of the world and become scared of that. If you're older still, you may eventually realize no one is in charge, no one could be in charge even in principle, and that's okay, you can live with it, it's fine, indeed, it's better than someone trying to be in charge and f'ing everything up.
We must tend our own gardens. Build great and ambitious things, build small things, build what you like, but whatever you do, don't delude yourself, and especially don't delude yourself into thinking you have more control than you do, or that anyone else does either. Wisdom really does consist of learning the difference between what you control and what you don't, between what you can plan for and what you have to accept.
Most importantly: learn to live with uncertainty; it's the only thing you can be sure of.
Lorah retweeted
I left a video camera WAY too close to the launchpad.
My first time capturing a launch in high resolution video. Definitely exceeded my expectations! This was captured at 120fps, interpolated 2x, stabilized, and played back at 30fps.
Lorah retweeted
🫡 to Booster 1069
We refer to 1069 as the OG tippy rocket. It lived a long and fruitful life after it came about as close as you can get to being lost on its first mission. On that mission, CRS-24, it landed in rough seas and immediately had severe uneven leg loads, causing it to “tip.” We spent the next two hours watching the rocket on camera literally dance from side to side on the droneship. Through the incredible skill of our @SpaceX recovery team and a decent amount of luck, we were able to pin the rocket against the droneship tow board and blast wall with the octagrabber jammed under the engines. Somehow, against all odds, the team got 1069 home. We replaced all nine engines that were damaged in the process… and then it flew another 31 successful missions!!! 🚀
Never. Give. Up.
Lorah retweeted
it would be fun to assemble an engineering/manufacturing X dream team of ten or so to work on a single problem for six months and make a video series out of it
the hardest part wouldn’t be funding, it’d be getting them to stop working on what they’re working on for six months
Lorah retweeted
This sounds crazy, BUT this week we READ A FULL SCROLL!!
scrollprize.org/firstscroll
It’s PHerc. 1667, aka Scroll 4!
And that’s not all.
We also proved that we can directly see ink in a rescan of PHerc. Paris 4 — Scroll 1 — WITHOUT machine learning…
…and we UNROLLED ABOUT 140 COLUMNS FROM IT.
This was honestly POETIC.
We first saw a glimpse of the results over dinner in Naples, in a restaurant where Caravaggio was stabbed. Federica was so excited — more excited than we had ever seen her — that we abandoned dinner, went back to work, and unrolled the 140 columns until 3 a.m. on a hotel rooftop, with Vesuvius in the background.
The unroll is not perfect.
But guys…
140 columns, with text visible everywhere.
It’s HUGE.
This project has been full of ups and downs, but somehow, at some point, something ALWAYS happens.
We’re starting to think these scrolls have personalities…
…and they want to be read.
@natfriedman has announced a $1M Grand Prize to read another full scroll. Official details coming soon!
Lorah retweeted
Sage observation from Marc Andreessen:
“Technology is an enormously powerful force in the world. And the big problem is that there's not enough technology, there's not enough information, there's not enough intelligence.”
“We have these special sets of technologies that let us fundamentally improve things. And then there's this very special personality type — the entrepreneur —who's able to build a product, and then able to build a company, and build a phenomenon, and really make an impact on things.”
“I think the world we live in is just a very primitive and crude place as compared to what it should be —and what it could be."
“And so the whole thing that we've been trying to do for 17 years at @a16z is build the ideal partner to founders based on our own experiences of having been founders.”
“Every once in a while you have somebody who comes along and says: I actually have an idea of how to make things fundamentally better. And I have a way to build a business around that and build a company, and build an empire around that."
“These founders are like a rogue movement against stagnation. Without them there's nothing but stagnation.”
“Many people could be trying to do this. These are completely open fields and it's shocking to me how few people actually give it a shot.”
“The fate of the world over the next 1,500 years is riding on the people who actually want to give it a shot.”
@pmarca
I think that something else is going on. While we will still need giant clusters to generate the models that will eventually cure cancer, the current trend is edge computing (with on prem racks) and solving specific tasks (corporate, robotic, etc) in proprietary environments.
Dario's answer to Dwarkesh on why he won't buy $300B-1T of compute sure was incomplete. But I guess it would have been unwise to spell out "our competitors will willingly surrender their clusters because *they* have overbuilt and can't generate revenue with their shit models"
1
153
TBC, there'll still b demand for compute in big datacenters but most current extrapolations I've seen don't account for the fact that some demand is moving to edge compute. I think Dario's stance is prudent. Anthropic is well aware of integration trends.
nitter.cf/i/status/2051631229666…
Yesterday Anthropic and OpenAI both launched consulting arms.
I made a post about this on March 20th, and they just officially launched yesterday.
Anthropic teamed up with Blackstone, Goldman, and Hellman & Friedman to launch a $1.5B firm that embeds engineers inside PE-owned mid-market companies to redesign workflows and integrate Claude into core operations.
OpenAI launched The Development Company. $4B raised at a $10B valuation. Partnered with TPG, Bain, Brookfield, and Advent. Pretty much this same model. Forward-deployed engineers sitting inside mid-sized businesses, mapping operations, building the systems.
Goldman's global head of asset management: "There's a big shortage of people who know how to apply these tools into businesses and then transform them."
This is exactly it, and I've been talking about this for months because I have been living it.
Stop overthinking how to make money with AI. It's consulting and implementation. It's the exact thing the labs just bet billions on.
Every company doing $2M to $50M a year has the same problem.
They have access to the best AI ever built and zero clue what to do with it.
Their team is drowning... their ops are held together with duct tape. Their data lives in 7 places.
They don't need another Ai SaaS tool.
They need someone who can walk in, map the operation, find the bottlenecks, and build the system that actually moves the needle.
This is the highest leverage skill you can build in 2026.
IMPLEMENTATION.
Real systems inside real businesses with real ROI attached.
The window is open right now and it won't be open forever. Once the labs scale their consulting arms and the Big 4 fully pivot, the easy money on the operator side gets harder.
If you've been waiting for a sign that this is the path, this is it.
Anthropic and OpenAI just told you where the money is.
Don't overthink it.
Go build.






























