Ingrid Ozols AM (@ingioz) header
Ingrid Ozols AM (@ingioz) profile picture

An Aussie Latvian #suicideprevention #mentalhealth šŸ’œšŸŒ· ā¤ļø#womanhood. Cautious compassionate evid-base assertiveness is not hate.

Melbourne
Joined March 2010
Ingrid Ozols AM retweeted
So Australia commissioned its own systematic reviews, the results came back (like every other in existence) showing low to very low quality evidence for puberty blockers. Then they went ahead and recommended the drugs anyway, to fulfil the ā€œembodiment goalsā€ of physically healthy adolescents who have been given a nonsense, activist-crafted diagnosis. And now the Health Minister is encouraging the states that have acted to protect kids from this medical scandal to follow the federal government's lead and once again give vulnerable kids these unproven drugs. For years, Canada and Australia have been in close competition for which nation is the most shameful when it comes to all things gender. It's still too close to call, but I think Australia may have just edged into the lead.
43
169
13
633
16,029
Ingrid Ozols AM retweeted
ALERT: Australia’s top medical research body just recommended puberty blockers for minors and starting today is requesting public input for two months. I know Australia’s National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) overlooked some relevant evidence because in June 2023 I published ā€œThe Truth About Puberty Blockersā€ in the Wall Street Journal—one of the first major-media pieces to examine the claims that these drugs were fully reversible and free of long-term consequences for children with gender distress. The drugs, never approved by the FDA for this use, have a documented history of thousands of adverse event reports, including thinning and brittle bones, teeth that shed enamel and cracked, degenerative spinal disks, painful joints, wide mood swings, seizures, migraines and suicidal ideation. Some developed fibromyalgia and others reported fertility problems and cognitive issues. Several countries, including the UK, Sweden and Finland, have restricted or largely ended their routine use for minors. Against that backdrop, NHMRC has now issued a "conditional recommendation" that gonadotropin-releasing hormone agonists can be considered for people under 18 with "gender incongruence." The long technical drug name refers to drugs like AbbVie’s Lupron, powerful medications that are also used off-label for chemical castration of repeat sex offenders. I read the NHMRC 45-page draft and its evidence tables. The recommendation is, not surprisingly, far stronger than the evidence under it. The supporting review included 15 studies. All were non-randomized. None were Australian. Most followed patients for only 6 months to 2 years. What is established at high certainty is simply the pharmacology: the drugs suppress puberty. Periods stop. The reason the drugs are prescribed—"gender dysphoria"—shows ā€œlittle to no change,ā€ rated very low certainty. Poor body image shows the same, and the confidence interval allows for slight worsening. The report tries to make the best of it by saying blockers prevent deterioration rather than produce improvement. But the studies were uncontrolled before-and-after designs. They cannot demonstrate prevention of anything. No eligible studies were found on fertility, fractures, death by suicide, or satisfaction with care. The committee acknowledges the low certainty of the evidence and then states that it ā€œdoes not lessen the importance of making a recommendation.ā€ In ordinary medicine, weaker evidence raises the bar. Here the bar is lowered. The recommendation also drops any requirement of distress. A young person qualifies with "gender incongruence...with or without distress,ā€ because requiring distress ā€œwould be unethical.ā€ The familiar ā€œpause to thinkā€ framing is hard to reconcile with data from Australia’s largest clinic: of 64 young people who started blockers, 81% went on to cross-sex hormones. The plain-language summary prepared for families does not mention the low certainty of the evidence or the absence of data on fertility and bone health. Queensland and the Northern Territory have already rejected the advice for their public systems. Public consultation closes January 18, 2027. Parents in Australia, make yourselves heard. Check the submission information here: consultations.nhmrc.gov.au/c…
22
115
15
335
7,200
Ingrid Ozols AM retweeted
Naz Shah: "do you support this bill as drafted?" Hilary Cass: "No."
16
1
57
2,219
Ingrid Ozols AM retweeted
🚨🚨This is HUGE. In a major blow to the Government, Baroness Cass says the draft Conversion Practices Bill is nowhere ā€œnear tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequencesā€. She also reveals that when she gave a statement welcoming the draft Bill back in June, she hadn’t even had the opportunity to read it. Her comments were based on what had been sold to her by the Bill’s drafter.
4
20
2
90
5,502
Ingrid Ozols AM retweeted
Baroness Prentis asks Baroness Cass and Prof Gillian Leng whether they are concerned that the very act of passing conversion practices legislation will create a chilling effect. An unequivocal YES.
1
6
23
843
Ingrid Ozols AM retweeted
"She said: ā€œAlong with clinicians, Baroness Cass also raised concerns about the impact on parents having difficult conversations with children which may cause alarm and distress."
1
4
39
831
Ingrid Ozols AM retweeted
4/ But it’s wrong to criminalise attempts to change a self-image which is (a) counterfactual, (b) possibly transient and (c) likely to entail harm to the self & others. These are all reasons why it can be reasonable—and sometimes essential—to question & challenge it.>
2
34
214
2,915
Ingrid Ozols AM retweeted
Among Hilary Cass’s bombshells in today’s #ConversionBill committee was this key point: that transgender identity & sexual orientation are different. Lumping them together as if they’re the same kind of thing is one of the aspects of the Bill that makes it a conceptual mess./1>
Replying to @hannahsbee
Cass explains that the Bill treats something treating something - gender identity - as a stable belief, when it is actually something that, for many, is changeable. She points out that it is also something intrinsically very sidfficult and distsressing to discuss for young people and parents alike. It is not the same as sexual orientation.
9
259
18
1,004
20,820
How many generations haven’t had to do the same? Now some think we can just skip it when it gets too hard. @prof_curiosity1 this is when the ā€œvillageā€ is needed to help give loving support, not start lifelong medication journey and potential complex health outcomes.
ā€œThere is only one cure for adolescence, and this is the passage of time and the passing on of the adolescent into the adult state.ā€ Donald Winnicott (1962) explains why there is NO justification for the misuse of puberty blockers on our children. Let the child grow and become adult. Let them develop the tools within themselves to manage their feelings about their own bodies and their sex.
2
106
Ingrid Ozols AM retweeted
šŸšØšŸ“„ BOMBSHELL REPORT: The research that launched ā€œgender-affirming careā€ for kids was broken from day one. A new report reanalyzes the original Dutch studies behind puberty blockers, hormones and surgery for minors. What they found is staggering. 🧵
25
507
35
1,323
19,380
Parents r the villains 2 affirming clinicians, last 2 know about distress & transitioning. We luv, listen, & try 2 comfort. Suicidality holds us hostage if affirmation isnt instant. Compassionate caution is viewed as hate & bigotry. Sad this is a common story. šŸ˜“
Parents’ perspectives of their children’s trans identities, – whether affirming, questioning or outright rejecting their child’s declared transness travel a remarkably similar emotional journey. A tumult of shock, confusion, uncertainty, fear, grief and ambivalence is reported by the majority of parents following their child’s disclosure. In short, they are devastated. Read Kendra's personal account interwoven with her analysis of the expert review of available research by Stella O'Malley and Robin Ion. genspect.org/the-blind-spot-…
1
38
Ingrid Ozols AM retweeted
1/ This really should be the moment this dangerous and tyrannical bill dies. It emerged during this session that the Government's much quoted remark from Baroness Cass in support of this bill was secured only by giving her 15 minutes to respond when she was busy.
ā€œI unfortunately don’t think the definitions are anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences.ā€ A strong opening from Baroness Hilary Cass on the risks posed by the Conversion Practices Bill for healthcare professionals, parents and vulnerable young people. She warns that ā€œmalign actorsā€ may weaponise the Bill, and explains that the approach in the #CassReview has already been described as ā€œconversion practicesā€.
11
114
3
566
16,429
Ingrid Ozols AM retweeted
ā€œNHMRC leaves nation out of step on puberty blockersā€ in The Australian šŸ‡¦šŸ‡ŗ newspaper today. Link to article below ā¬‡ļø
2
6
1
23
1,863
Ingrid Ozols AM retweeted
Lord Hope - gentle but deadly - teases out how unfair and unworkable the Bill would be for medical professionals who may be prosecuted for conversion practices. Witnesses are Mark Swindells, Ass Director for Standards & Ethics, the GMC & Andrew Smith, Deputy CEO, HCPC 2 clips
1
38
1
97
3,726
Ingrid Ozols AM retweeted
Very important intervention today by Baroness Hilary Cass
3
66
1
411
7,314
Ingrid Ozols AM retweeted
Dr Cass warned that there were ā€œmalign actorsā€ who were ā€œlooking to exploit young peopleā€ and use them to ā€œpursueā€ medical professionals in the field. She also sounded the alarm about parents being ā€œcaught upā€ in the legislation. telegraph.co.uk/politics/202…
4
59
2
269
3,700
Ingrid Ozols AM retweeted
"No". One word. This may be the most important intervention in the debate so fare.
@NazShahBfd asks Baroness Cass whether she supports the bill as drafted, given earlier media reports that suggested she backed it.
8
141
2
945
22,219
Will freedom of thought be next? Perhaps we need to fill the prisons?! 🫣🫣🫣🫣🫣
ā€œI have every right to comment when a law is badly drafted and when it’s going to harm people.ā€ See Helen Joyce (@HJoyceGender) answer why as a ā€œcis straight personā€ she thinks she has any right to oppose a ā€˜conversion practices ban’. The Government’s draft Conversion Practices Bill would create a new offence, carrying up to five years in prison, aimed largely at words. Parents, therapists and faith leaders could be prosecuted for a single conversation, and acting in good faith or in a child’s best interest would be no defence. 🚨 TODAY AT 5PM IS YOUR LAST CHANCE TO HAVE YOUR SAY 🚨 The Free Speech Union has built a tool that lets you choose the issues that matter most to you and draft a response to the Joint Committee in your own name. It takes minutes šŸ‘‡
14
Ingrid Ozols AM retweeted
ā° 5 hours to go to STOP the bill! If you haven’t submitted evidence to the parliamentary committee on the draft Conversion Practices Bill, please do so before 5pm today. Everything you need is on our website, including our template, guidance and the link to submit. Every single submission counts ā¬‡ļø sex-matters.org/take-action/…
6
64
7
117
6,146